Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any French speakers about?

39 replies

BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 03:51

My French is quite rusty and google translate has translated it but it just doesn't make sense (or maybe my English is no better than my French 😁)

Can someone translate this for me?

La graphie "Surname1 Surname2" est réservée par tradition familiale au porteur du titre de duc Surname2, soit une personne par génération, toutes branches généalogiques confondues, ainsi qu'à son épouse, la duchesse Surname2.

OP posts:
wildseas · 22/09/2022 05:04

I would translate it as:

The family tradition is that the spelling surname 1 surname 2 is only used by the duke surname 2. Ie only one person (and their wife Dutchess surname 2) per generation across all of the branches of the family

BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 05:02

The thing is that I was actually googling someone I used to know (inspired by the thread on the double-barrelled surnames). Except it was a woman and she wasn't married (early 20's when I knew her). There's also a slight discrepancy in how surname2 was spelt, but when I googled, wiki (in French) is all I could come up with.

OP posts:
BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:58

JMoore · 22/09/2022 04:50

I would rather translate it as "all genealogical branches included", which makes more sense to me.

It could be like this, for example, Father Dubois de Haricot, Duke of Haricot, has two sons. Eldest son is gets the full surname Dubois de Haricot, and will one day be Duke of Haricot. In each generation that follows him, the eldest son is a Dubois de Haricot, the younger ones just Dubois. Meanwhile, Father's second son has the surname Dubois and can only pass this on to his offspring, and none of them can use Haricot as their surname. Does this make sense?

that is a better translation I think.

I was thinking it's the equivalent of a title such as the Duke and Duchess of Sussex except the title happens to be two surnames? Does that make sense in French nobility?

OP posts:
Augend23 · 22/09/2022 04:58

JMoore · 22/09/2022 04:50

I would rather translate it as "all genealogical branches included", which makes more sense to me.

It could be like this, for example, Father Dubois de Haricot, Duke of Haricot, has two sons. Eldest son is gets the full surname Dubois de Haricot, and will one day be Duke of Haricot. In each generation that follows him, the eldest son is a Dubois de Haricot, the younger ones just Dubois. Meanwhile, Father's second son has the surname Dubois and can only pass this on to his offspring, and none of them can use Haricot as their surname. Does this make sense?

This is how I would have read it too I think.

JMoore · 22/09/2022 04:50

BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:00

all genealogical branches combined - that's the bit that's confusing me

I would rather translate it as "all genealogical branches included", which makes more sense to me.

It could be like this, for example, Father Dubois de Haricot, Duke of Haricot, has two sons. Eldest son is gets the full surname Dubois de Haricot, and will one day be Duke of Haricot. In each generation that follows him, the eldest son is a Dubois de Haricot, the younger ones just Dubois. Meanwhile, Father's second son has the surname Dubois and can only pass this on to his offspring, and none of them can use Haricot as their surname. Does this make sense?

BillHadersLeftEye · 22/09/2022 04:43

Roughly I read this as the Duke and Duchess would be known by a double-barrelling or combination of their surnames - eg the English Royal equivalent of Mountbatten-Windsor. Not technically for 'one person' but will occur with one union per generation and combine the historical family names of both. (Hence the combining genealogy bit)

It's just the French classic of making a description far more elaborate than needs be.

BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:06

Cakeandcoffee93 · 22/09/2022 03:53

Ja toot de la fruit!

Hee hee, reminds me of this

OP posts:
BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:03

Unglamorousgranny · 22/09/2022 04:02

@BeyondApproach i didn't read your op properly

No worries, I appreciate your help anyway!

OP posts:
BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:02

I think it might be confusing to me because it refers to French nobility and I sometimes find it hard to understand the British royal family and titles and names and stuff.

OP posts:
Unglamorousgranny · 22/09/2022 04:02

@BeyondApproach i didn't read your op properly

BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 04:00

all genealogical branches combined - that's the bit that's confusing me

OP posts:
BeyondApproach · 22/09/2022 03:59

Unglamorousgranny · 22/09/2022 03:57

The spelling "Surname1 Surname2" is reserved by family tradition for the bearer of the title of Duke Surname2, i.e. one person per generation, all genealogical branches combined, as well as for his wife, the Duchess Surname2.

This is what comes up if you use Google Translate. Does it mean anything?

As I said, I've already tried google translate and that translation makes little sense to me, but maybe that's more because I can't grasp the concept rather than the translation being incorrect haha.

OP posts:
Unglamorousgranny · 22/09/2022 03:57

The spelling "Surname1 Surname2" is reserved by family tradition for the bearer of the title of Duke Surname2, i.e. one person per generation, all genealogical branches combined, as well as for his wife, the Duchess Surname2.

This is what comes up if you use Google Translate. Does it mean anything?

Cakeandcoffee93 · 22/09/2022 03:53

Ja toot de la fruit!