Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Constant comments on blue eyes

145 replies

Janedoe95 · 21/09/2022 22:36

I was wondering if anyone else has experienced the same thing DC has blue eyes and they’re often the first thing people notice. (Which is fine)

but lately people seem to comment every time they look darker (say if I take a photo at night) people constantly comment on whether they’ll stay blue. Even complete strangers will come up and comment several have warned me they’ll change by 2 years rolls eyes

I have brown eyes and I’m not white so I’m not sure if that makes people more inclined to comment

does anyone else have similar experience? Does this happen to all children or all blue eyed children

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 22/09/2022 12:12

Could also be that people seem to just try to think of something to say about babies and toddlers as there’s sometimes not much to say

There is definitely an element of this - I’ve done it myself, regardless of eye colour. “Oh what big beautiful eyes she has!” is just what you say about babies isn’t it? “Cute nose!” or “what dinky ears!” would sound weird.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 22/09/2022 11:38

I think the obsession with blue eyes is insane. To me it's all about a despicable, regressive racist pecking order (subconscious to most, I hope) that has blonde haired blue eyed people at the top, black people at the bottom, and brunettes with brown eyes somewhere in the middle above mixed race people.

10HailMarys · 22/09/2022 11:36

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 21/09/2022 22:41

Mine were blue as a child, people always commented on them.. By the time I was 10 they had started changing, now they're blue/green (differed a lit) with flecks of hazel

when firms ask eye colour I just write 'other' now.

I'm interested to know what forms are you completing all the time that ask you to specify your eye colour.

Tigger85 · 22/09/2022 11:36

Both my ds have blue eyes, eldest has steely blue, youngest ocean blue. They both get commented on for their big blue eyes but one has asked if they will change colour, both me and their dad also have blue eyes as does everyone on my side of the family. Youngest ds was born with a full head of long wavy blonde hair with some coppery bits and that's what gets commented on the most.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 22/09/2022 11:31

Both dh and I are blue eyed so we always knew the kids would be too. (Barring genetic mutation or me bonking the milkman!)

Because I have never witnessed it, I am fascinated by the whole concept of a baby’s eyes changing colour. It just seems so unlikely - like you suddenly
casually said “and tomorrow Timmy is going to grow his extra limb”.

I used to get really excited when my friends’ kids eyes changed.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 22/09/2022 11:22

My son had blue eyes until he was one or so. Then they went green and eventually hazel exactly like mine. His dad has blue eyes and my other son has blue eyes.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/09/2022 11:20

My two have blue and green respectively and I have brown. I guess I probably got a few comments on that (they were also both blond babies whilst I have dark hair and olive skin). So I’m thinking it’s just what people say.

whumpthereitis · 22/09/2022 11:18

I’ve got heterochromia so I get comments on a semi regular basis. People just like to comment on something unusual.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/09/2022 11:18

I think it probably is because you're not white and you've got brown eyes so people feel it's more of a topic. 'oooh mum with dark skin and dark eyes with blue eyed baby'. I can imagine it gets boring for you.

I think it must be this. Otherwise it’s such a non topic! Although blue eyes are rarer than brown, a pretty sizeable proportion of the UK has them.

Could also be that people seem to just try to think of something to say about babies and toddlers as there’s sometimes not much to say.

MooseBreath · 22/09/2022 11:14

Now we get loads of comments on DS's green eyes because apparently people don't often see a blonde child with green eyes.

XelaM · 22/09/2022 11:14

My niece has very beautiful blue/green eyes - they are really extraordinary and everyone used to comment on her eyes when she was younger. She's 19 now and people still mention her eyes sometimes.

My brother also has blue eyes whereas it's unusual in my family and people used to comment on it a lot. He was also very blonde as a child. People used to always say he looks like a little angel.

OceanbreezeSun · 22/09/2022 11:13

I think some people just notice the contrast more & perhaps find it striking but tbh almost all babies will get the comment about big beautiful eyes whether they are blue, brown or green etc. The same for hair colour/ if they have lots of hair etc.

Blue eyes in my family are common, so although beautiful (like green and brown eyes are just as much) they are ‘normal’ to me and not something I would particularly notice straight away or think to comment on.

My dd has dark blue eyes and very blonde hair(almost white in some places)
She is 3 now and friends/family/strangers have always commented on her very fair hair. It’s especially noticeable next to my dark hair and dhs light brown hair. I’ve lost count of the amount of times people have asked questions like ‘where does she get it from?’ ‘Do you think it will go darker as she gets older?’ or ‘wow, she’s very blonde isn’t she?!’
It doesn’t bother me.

MooseBreath · 22/09/2022 11:13

DS used to get comments on his blue eyes because both DH and I have green eyes. At around 1.5, DS's eyes turned green.

FruitPastilleNut · 22/09/2022 11:11

Yes, Ds2 had/has blue eyes and they were the first thing people commented on as a baby.

People still comment on my Dc's eyes now if they see them together - one has brown eyes, one has blue eyes and one has green. People exclaim over it and think it's really odd.

newjobwhodisperhaps · 22/09/2022 11:06

@Alopeciabop That's your view. Personally as much as I have had negative comments, I have also had 'positive'. Such as the examples you give about mixed race people being beautiful. That in itself is rooted in racism and fetishisation of some black features (such a bigger lips and bigger bums) being desirable and others not, and the view that mixed race people get the 'best' of both worlds.

Sadly, there is racism in a lot of encounters whether they seem minor to you or not. I am not saying someone who is ignorant is necessarily an awful person and a hideous racist, but they are just that, ignorant.

LT2 · 22/09/2022 11:03

Yes - the first thing people notice about my 8 month old is his big blue eyes. People have said about them possibly changing. They won't, as both his parents have blue eyes.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 22/09/2022 10:59

my (white Caucasian) son had dark, almost navy, blue eyes for the first few months of his life. They were incredible and lots of people commented on them. However, by a year they had changed to Hazel. Loads of babies have blue eyes at birth but they change to brown.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 22/09/2022 10:26

Most Caucasian babies are born with blue eyes, and their colour often changes. The colour is usually fixed at approximately 2 years old, although can be older in some cases. The reason for this is eye colour is related to the level of melanin in the body, and babies only have low levels at birth, increasing as they age. People with blue eyes have the lowest levels of melanin, and dark brown eyes the highest. These melanin levels are also why some dark skinned children are much paler as babies, and their skin darkens with age.

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 10:25

I didn't know eyes could change colour
My daughter had striking blue eyes as a baby, still does at age 6.

Bootsandcat · 22/09/2022 10:21

I know what you mean. I’m not white either and in my baby group they’re always talking about their ‘blue eyed girl/ boy’ and how it will be a shame if they don’t stay blue…. It’s like… what’s wrong with brown eyes? It’s a strange obsession

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2022 10:16

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2022 10:15

Another assumption.

Also eye colour is not specific to ethnicity. Brown eyes are the most common in the world and about 45% of Caucasians have brown eyes. So I don’t see how this feeds in to your idea that everyone who comments on some random baby having nice blue eyes is struggling with underlying racist tendencies.

Which is not the same thing as me saying colourism doesn’t exist fyi!

But also people have a right to like one eye colour over another! Like how I like brown eyes but have green. But people are just saying a baby has nice eyes! Honestly what do you want them to say?? Oohh look at that fat roll how unique and lovely??

I mean seriously, the amount of comments that are made to mixed race couples about how they’ll have beautiful babies and about how mixed races babies are the most beautiful is crazy. If someone said the same thing about blonde white kids everyone would be aghast.

it’s all ridiculous. Babies are a blessing however they look. We are lucky to have eyes with which to see our differences. And our uniquenesses - different skin tones and eye tones and freckles and noses, leg length, butt size, boob size and waist size, big ears, small ears - all these things literally make each person who they are.

there’s all kinds of racism going on in the world which needs to be dealt with but scattergunning and accusing every situation of having it’s roots in it is just counterproductive and actually causes divides, I feel.

I genuinely am saddened to feel your upset and hurt through your posts. I feel frustrated that because we don’t agree on a point you “call out” colourism. When you know nothing of me. Because you shouldn’t have been put in this mindset by small minded people. You shouldn’t have been forced to see the negatives in people by nastiness, or ignorance, or history, in the first place.

@newjobwhodisperhaps i don’t even know how to work mumsnet 🙄

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2022 10:15

Another assumption.

Also eye colour is not specific to ethnicity. Brown eyes are the most common in the world and about 45% of Caucasians have brown eyes. So I don’t see how this feeds in to your idea that everyone who comments on some random baby having nice blue eyes is struggling with underlying racist tendencies.

Which is not the same thing as me saying colourism doesn’t exist fyi!

But also people have a right to like one eye colour over another! Like how I like brown eyes but have green. But people are just saying a baby has nice eyes! Honestly what do you want them to say?? Oohh look at that fat roll how unique and lovely??

I mean seriously, the amount of comments that are made to mixed race couples about how they’ll have beautiful babies and about how mixed races babies are the most beautiful is crazy. If someone said the same thing about blonde white kids everyone would be aghast.

it’s all ridiculous. Babies are a blessing however they look. We are lucky to have eyes with which to see our differences. And our uniquenesses - different skin tones and eye tones and freckles and noses, leg length, butt size, boob size and waist size, big ears, small ears - all these things literally make each person who they are.

there’s all kinds of racism going on in the world which needs to be dealt with but scattergunning and accusing every situation of having it’s roots in it is just counterproductive and actually causes divides, I feel.

I genuinely am saddened to feel your upset and hurt through your posts. I feel frustrated that because we don’t agree on a point you “call out” colourism. When you know nothing of me. Because you shouldn’t have been put in this mindset by small minded people. You shouldn’t have been forced to see the negatives in people by nastiness, or ignorance, or history, in the first place.

Elsanore · 22/09/2022 08:47

Really interesting points about unconscious racism and the whitening of dark features. I did use to think it was a shame when the young Asian girls I taught used to say "miss I wish I had blue eyes like you". Also when I took my baby into school to show the kids they were thrilled with his blue eyes more than any other feature.

Elsanore · 22/09/2022 08:38

I have bright blue eyes with a dark blue rim around the edge of the Iris. I've had comments about them all my life. Now my dc have the same eyes as me and we get even more comments, always positive, and I like it really especially now it's something in common with dc.

I am white and I used to live in a community that was nearly all Pakistani heritage. That was when I got the most comments about my eyes, and some Pakistani heritage friends would wear blue coloured contacts (not because of me- just because of how prized blue eyes seemed to be).

I think people just notice them and it's a nice inoffensive compliment "oh your eyes are so blue!". I don't read anything into it.

HelloAvocado · 22/09/2022 08:36

LimeTwists · 21/09/2022 22:38

Some people are just dull and look for incredibly dull things to talk about.

Yes, this. Both my children were born with dark brown eyes and people used to comment about it, quite often telling me that all babies are born with blue eyes (um...)

Swipe left for the next trending thread