Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these comments left by my gp were rude

165 replies

Ispy9 · 21/09/2022 21:29

This isn’t really relevant anymore as I am in a much better place now than I was but I’m still quite annoyed about it. A year ago I was suffering quite badly with anxiety and depression so I went and saw my GP about it.

I recently downloaded the NHS App and I thought I’d have a look through my notes. I saw that on the appointment about my mental health my GP had wrote these notes.

‘Examination: Not sleeping, not looking after herself. Unkempt, looking down, shoulders hunched, not wearing a bra, hair not brushed’

aibu to think these comments on my file are quite rude?

OP posts:
Hopeandlove · 21/09/2022 22:19

PinkButtercups · 21/09/2022 21:38

Why on earth would they put about you not wearing a bra. That in itself is so odd.

This is weird and I’m complain about that comment.

the rest of it symptoms of your mental health fine

Wearpantsffs · 21/09/2022 22:18

My GP wrote ‘on examination, she is a pale, thin woman’ on my referral for fertility investigations. I asked my friend who is a GP what that had to do with anything as she said it was code for ‘too thin to conceive!’

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 22:18

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/09/2022 22:17

My hair looks unbrushed 5 minutes after I brush it. I don’t wear bras and for the record I also don’t shave and I mainly wear comfy lounge style clothes. I’m not depressed. I just don’t give a flying fuck about conforming to how men think I should look!

Same.

Sneezesthrice · 21/09/2022 22:17

Unfortunately it IS important they note these factual observations because the medical profession doesn’t seem to think a person can be severely mentally unwell unless they turn up at appointments with dirty unbrushed hair, trackies/T-shirt covered in pot noodle (or other easy to make food of your choice) and smelling unwashed.

This is due to stereotyping typing about what mental illness ‘looks like’ and looking clean and brushed for an appointment even if you haven’t showered in weeks but dragged yourself to do so, just to be able to leave the house for the appointment, will prejudice how unwell they think you are.

I speak from experience.

Although it must be upsetting to read such observations it will have helped your GP form a picture of you clearly not seeming ‘well’ (according to thier expectations of what depressed ‘looks like’ ) and to take how you told them you were feeling seriously.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 21/09/2022 22:17

My hair looks unbrushed 5 minutes after I brush it. I don’t wear bras and for the record I also don’t shave and I mainly wear comfy lounge style clothes. I’m not depressed. I just don’t give a flying fuck about conforming to how men think I should look!

Floweryflora · 21/09/2022 22:15

The GP isn't judging her for not wearing a bra, or being unkempt, you utter pilchard

well said. Some of the stuff posted is batshit.

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 22:14

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 21/09/2022 21:34

'Not wearing a bra' is a bloody weird observation, it's not the law to wear one! The rest I can see is relevant to how you were feeling at the time.

I thought the same, bra comment is unacceptable, rest merely judgemental but possibly informative.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/09/2022 22:14

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 22:01

I know plenty of unkempt women with messy hair, spend a lot of time gardening or working outside. Most women I know hate bras and resent the pressure to wear one. Some even think them unhealthy! Also know a few academics of hunched posture, often looking down ruminating on Shakespeare and the like. So, I would say some of the comments are not only rude, but highly subjective and rather narrow minded. I would prefer a doctor accepted your description of symptoms, without making a judgement on your looks. I suppose it's how they are trained, though, and they mean well. I hope you are feeling better too.

Oh for goodness sake, I have heard it all now.

The GP isn't judging her for not wearing a bra, or being unkempt, you utter pilchard. The GP is concerned that these are outward signs of poor mental health. This is an important part of a mental health examination. Do you really think that everyone suffering from poor mental health gives a perfect description of their symptoms, and that all that doctors have to do to make a diagnosis is to listen to a convenient list of symptoms that the patient recites? You really do not have a clue.

People with severe mental illness may not be able to articulate what is happening, or may be too frightened to do so. They may have delusions that they are being controlled by external forces, or that they will be punished by demons if they disclose what is happening to them (I'm not suggesting that this was the case with the OP, but it certainly is with some mentally ill patients). Any conscientious HCP will pay attention to body language, demeanour, clothing etc. Otherwise you can miss serious, and potentially dangerous, illness.

InfiniteMonkies · 21/09/2022 22:13

I mask struggling a huge amount - five minutes before giving birth to my second child I had to ask if anyone was on hand as I needed to push (I am serious) - they didn't believe me as I wasn't screaming and shouting, I just don't. Not presenting in a 'normal' way is a problem. I appreciate this is for a mental health assessment, so a little different, but it's made me think about a lot of times I've had a judgement or assessment made (without my knowledge of the impact until later). Only you know if they were accurate to give that as a picture of your mental health state at that time though (with our without the weird bra thing), but I have felt judged on the 'normal woman' scale without knowing it.

Han99 · 21/09/2022 22:12

GetOffTheRoof · 21/09/2022 21:57

Nah, you can't see that on the NHS app.

Here's my visible notes from the app for my breast examination 2wks ago (there's a thread on that).

I can see all the notes made by my GP on the app, even answers I gave word for word. Just depends on how much information the GP has chosen to write I think. Other entries are just coded and illegible to me.

MrsFionaCharming · 21/09/2022 22:12

I can always tell when my friend is struggling with her mental health because she stops shaving her armpits. Personally, I never shave mine but she always does when she’s well so it’s a reasonable indicator. It would seem like a strange thing to show up it medical notes, but could also be useful clinically.

Floweryflora · 21/09/2022 22:12

catandcoffee · 21/09/2022 22:10

I'm really interested in how he knew you weren't wearing a bra?

What gender are you ??? Because any woman knows the answer to this.

op don’t answer this.

catandcoffee · 21/09/2022 22:10

I'm really interested in how he knew you weren't wearing a bra?

Carrotzen · 21/09/2022 22:08

They aren't subjective though. Unbrushed hair is not subjective it's a fact. Not wearing a bra is a fact. The OP has gone to the Gp about her low mood. Presumably the GP is using the notes to explain their diagnosis, and essentially justify their treatment. Of course appearance is part of that.

MarmiteCoriander · 21/09/2022 22:07

I realise OP, that seeing a description of yourself at your lowest would feel shocking and invasive. This, however, is part of a regular mental health assessment.

Is the person clean and tidy, or disheveled, filthy and smell? Are there bruises or signs of abuse? Are they wearing weather appropriate clothing? Wearing a T-shirt,shorts and shoeless in the middle of heavy snow for example? These are all subtle clues that clinicians use to check on a patients welfare and mental wellbeing.

Were the observations true from that time? If not- speak to your GP.

I'm glad your mental health has improved and you are in a better place.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/09/2022 22:05

gingertoast · 21/09/2022 21:55

Did he perform any form of physical exam - if so that might explain the comment

What makes you think the GP was a man? A woman would be much more likely to pick up on the potential significance of not wearing a bra if you usually do, in the context of concerns about mental health. It's not the lack of a bra, itself, it's the change from whatever is normal for the individual patient.

Carrotzen · 21/09/2022 22:04

Pretty much the first thing I stop doing when my mental health is declining is stop wearing a bra

It's just that thing that takes effort to do but there's few consequences to not doing, so if I'm struggling to get dressed I'm not bothering with a bra

In itself it's not an indicator, unbrushed hair in itself is not an indicator but as part of the bigger picture it maybe.

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 22:01

I know plenty of unkempt women with messy hair, spend a lot of time gardening or working outside. Most women I know hate bras and resent the pressure to wear one. Some even think them unhealthy! Also know a few academics of hunched posture, often looking down ruminating on Shakespeare and the like. So, I would say some of the comments are not only rude, but highly subjective and rather narrow minded. I would prefer a doctor accepted your description of symptoms, without making a judgement on your looks. I suppose it's how they are trained, though, and they mean well. I hope you are feeling better too.

OfficiallyBroken · 21/09/2022 22:01

I hope you're doing better now.

My sister was denied whatever amounts to sickness benefits with DWP a few years ago because she showered before her assessment and wore smart, ironed clothes (drilled into us by my mother for anything "official").

They specifically noted that her appearance didn't match her symptoms, therefore she was exaggerating her debilitating depression and anxiety.

Your GP was being factual, not rude and probably wrote it that way because of the amount of people that present in genuine distress who are subsequently denied financial support from the government.

ASundayWellSpent · 21/09/2022 22:00

I look like that everyday :D no bra is my standard and the rest is just harassed and tired teacher uniform

Exhaustedmoose · 21/09/2022 22:00

Imo lack of bra suggests you've been in bed or lounging at home and just chucked any old thing on top to be decent enough to leave the house...i.e. you're in a really bad place.

Sleeptightnightlight · 21/09/2022 21:57

The bra thing is odd, but I can see maybe they overall felt there was a lack of care/interest if your appearance and were trying to boil that down factually and briefly.

Sunnyqueen · 21/09/2022 21:57

The bra one is a bit off unless it was very obvious/bordering on inappropriate.. Guess it depends on the top you were wearing at the time. Either way it's nothing to write home about.
I darent look at my mental health notes, between the blank bits I can't remember, all the kick offs and bits I think I remember but probably something completely different happened it's just going to be traumatic af.

GetOffTheRoof · 21/09/2022 21:57

Nah, you can't see that on the NHS app.

Here's my visible notes from the app for my breast examination 2wks ago (there's a thread on that).

To think these comments left by my gp were rude
BirdinaHedge · 21/09/2022 21:56

Good clinical care, I’d have thought. Your GP is recording evidence of your illness, so that colleagues will know if they need to hand over, or if you return. Your GP can see if there’s a pattern in you [lack of] self care etc.

Would you rather that your symptoms were not recorded and your illness potentially mistreated as a result?