Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these comments left by my gp were rude

165 replies

Ispy9 · 21/09/2022 21:29

This isn’t really relevant anymore as I am in a much better place now than I was but I’m still quite annoyed about it. A year ago I was suffering quite badly with anxiety and depression so I went and saw my GP about it.

I recently downloaded the NHS App and I thought I’d have a look through my notes. I saw that on the appointment about my mental health my GP had wrote these notes.

‘Examination: Not sleeping, not looking after herself. Unkempt, looking down, shoulders hunched, not wearing a bra, hair not brushed’

aibu to think these comments on my file are quite rude?

OP posts:
spinduffy · 22/09/2022 03:27

Not wearing a bra is not usually normal in a public setting, so it was just recorded as an observation indicative of a degree of self neglect as part of your mental state examination. You record any visual observations that are not the norm

Marvellousmadness · 22/09/2022 03:25

Why is it rude?
It is true
And valuable information for the state you were in.
You sounded like you were in a bad state

(Or me on a Saturday morning 🤣)
No but seriously. Dont be offended.
It's great the doc was thorough.

Oblomov22 · 22/09/2022 03:20

I can appreciate they are hard to read. But it seems reasonable.

Dred to think what mine might say: Mrs oblomov charged into the room complaining yet again that she hasn't been seen for 18 months...

Ispy9 · 22/09/2022 02:22

thank you everyone for your comments. It was factual at the time yes. I think it was just uncomfortable reading it.

for anybody that wants to access their full records it would be under ‘consultations and events’ under the ‘your health’ section of the app but you need to ask at your GP reception for access to this and also bring ID to prove who you are

www.nhs.uk/using-the-nhs/about-the-nhs/how-to-get-your-medical-records/

OP posts:
LikeAStar1994 · 22/09/2022 02:13

Not wearing a bra? WTF?

I haven't worn a bra for a few months now and my mental health is perfectly fine! In fact I would say it's improved because of the fact my boobs are no longer imprisoned.

gnilliwdog · 22/09/2022 01:13

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 21/09/2022 23:29

I'm shocked that some people think those comments are normal. I would never comment that my client/patient isn't wearing a bra. That's not right. The hair not being brushed comment is a bit off too.. 😳 i would write that you were struggling with self care. End off. The noting down you have no bra on as so out of order. Quite obviously a male doctor OP. I've had people come to speak with me in bad states and would never note down something like that. I find people hardly ever request a copy of their notes but we all know you can so all notes must be professional. That is unprofessional and rude.

Yes, this sounds reasonable. A GP can note concerns without making hurtful or biased comments that the patient may one day read. If it's a habitual practice to always be professional in making notes, it must become second nature.

Mamanyt · 22/09/2022 00:52

Not rude in the least, but uncomfortable reading for you. All of those things, including the bra if he knows you generally wear one, are indicative of depression, and should be noted. He would have been remiss not to.

I am reminded, just a bit, of a patient of ours who just fell apart when he read his chart, and it said, "Patient is SOB." He didn't realize that was "Short Of Breath." So often laymen do not understand contractions, or the importance of physical changes in documenting things like mental/emotional stress.

SpangledShambles · 22/09/2022 00:48

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 22:18

Same.

Same here too! I wear bra at work, or if I really have to. Not wearing a bra is not the social and mental self destruct that some seem to think. I pray for the day when they stop being the norm and women can go round swinging low or high just like blokes do in their boxers and trackies.

milkyaqua · 22/09/2022 00:45

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/09/2022 23:51

It's not about how women should present. It's about noticing that a patient may be expressing distress using non-verbal cues.

I work with homeless people. Many of them sadly have no option but to present without showering and in dirty clothes, and that is to be expected. No one judges them. But if someone who normally looks clean and well-presented comes in, looking dishevelled, I take notice. It might mean mental illness. It might mean substance misuse. It might mean they have been sexually assaulted. It might mean they have been robbed. It might mean they have just had a crap morning and CBA. But it's not something you ignore. If I waited for some of my patients to articulate their symptoms, as you suggest, quite a few of them would now be dead. You are phenomenally naive and ill-informed if you think that that HCPs should overlook non-verbal cues.

Amen.

DillDanding · 22/09/2022 00:45

I think it’s perfectly reasonable.

The bra thing relates to outward appearance as much as unbrushed hair etc.

SpangledShambles · 22/09/2022 00:43

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 23:02

@tectonicplates I agree. There is a set of assumptions at play regarding normal femininity and presentation.

Yep.

milkyaqua · 22/09/2022 00:31

‘Examination: Not sleeping, not looking after herself. Unkempt, looking down, shoulders hunched, not wearing a bra, hair not brushed’

So, the GP is noting signs of poor basic self-care, often associated with some forms of depression.

My depression was picked up at a pap smear once, as I'd reached the point I couldn't face washing my hair and I guess my face and posture also made it apparent.

I don't think it's rude to make clinical notes to back a diagnosis. What is rude is to disbelieve a patient who is suffering from depression and/or anxiety because they look well put together, which has also happened to me with another GP.

Tamworthian · 22/09/2022 00:21

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 21/09/2022 23:29

I'm shocked that some people think those comments are normal. I would never comment that my client/patient isn't wearing a bra. That's not right. The hair not being brushed comment is a bit off too.. 😳 i would write that you were struggling with self care. End off. The noting down you have no bra on as so out of order. Quite obviously a male doctor OP. I've had people come to speak with me in bad states and would never note down something like that. I find people hardly ever request a copy of their notes but we all know you can so all notes must be professional. That is unprofessional and rude.

It comes across a bit ‘patient too depressed to comply with patriarchal societal expectations.’

A friend was talking about a health visitor recently that said she worries as much about people presenting too perfectly, as a sign of depression / not coping, as much as the opposite.

BlindGirlMcSqueaky · 22/09/2022 00:16

This isn't restricted to mental health assessment. I read a comment about a scar on my arm on a letter to the GP from the hospital. Absolutely nothing to do with what I'd gone in for.

It upset me so much that I never ever speak to a medical professional without long sleeves on now and I immediately stopped trying to get treatment for the issue and pretended it was resolved.

It still gives me the creeps now.

Julia234 · 21/09/2022 23:58

No, it’s just a normal examination.

one of the first signs of depression is you start to neglect yourself. He/she was just recording what they noticed to provide a picture.

Aquamarine1029 · 21/09/2022 23:53

Facts aren't rude.

towelhammer · 21/09/2022 23:52

Most women wear a bra or are covered by a coat so for a gp to make that obvs is good. IMO shows the patient is not taking care of self etc in situations like this.

Well the coat depends on the time of year & loads of woman don't wear bras.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/09/2022 23:51

gnilliwdog · 21/09/2022 22:20

Rubbish. You just have a very narrow minded idea of how women should present and behave. Nice name calling, hope you don't work with ill people, you sound like a bully.

It's not about how women should present. It's about noticing that a patient may be expressing distress using non-verbal cues.

I work with homeless people. Many of them sadly have no option but to present without showering and in dirty clothes, and that is to be expected. No one judges them. But if someone who normally looks clean and well-presented comes in, looking dishevelled, I take notice. It might mean mental illness. It might mean substance misuse. It might mean they have been sexually assaulted. It might mean they have been robbed. It might mean they have just had a crap morning and CBA. But it's not something you ignore. If I waited for some of my patients to articulate their symptoms, as you suggest, quite a few of them would now be dead. You are phenomenally naive and ill-informed if you think that that HCPs should overlook non-verbal cues.

towelhammer · 21/09/2022 23:50

I also don't believe if the OP was a man his "unkempt" appearance would be so detailed.

towelhammer · 21/09/2022 23:49

For example, I once had a patient whose nails were always immaculately painted and matched to her outfit. Once she arrived with chipped polish and I knew immediately that she was not in a good way.

I certainly have immaculate nails at the beginning of the week, chipped & messy by the end of it!

octaurpus · 21/09/2022 23:48

'Not wearing a bra'. Blimey, I haven't worn a bra since my teens, not even when I was bf'ing.

keeprunning55 · 21/09/2022 23:46

During my worst mental health breakdown, I probably looked the best i’ve ever looked.. I felt like had to in order for no one to know just how bad i was, including drs. I think it is rude to write in such detail. Looking unkempt, no eye contact is plenty to get the picture..

Jewel1968 · 21/09/2022 23:44

But surely it's only relevant if normally individual is neat and tidy conforming to social norms. I have a friend who regularly presents like that but she is not struggling with anything. Could just suggest a free spirit who is not restricted by social norms

Wilburisagirl · 21/09/2022 23:43

No, they are observations about your presentation which is used (along with what you say and other tests) to form a full and thorough assessment. The care (or lack of) in how we present ourselves can tell people a lot about us, particularly if different than usual. For example, I once had a patient whose nails were always immaculately painted and matched to her outfit. Once she arrived with chipped polish and I knew immediately that she was not in a good way.

tectonicplates · 21/09/2022 23:39

I've logged into the NHS app (you can do this on the website - you don't literally need to download a phone app) and it says that if I want to see details of my GP appointments, I have to agree to share my information with something called Patients Know Best. Is this legit? Otherwise, all I can see is the moment is just stuff I can already see on Patientaccess anyway, so just medication and the dates of past appointments.