Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these comments left by my gp were rude

165 replies

Ispy9 · 21/09/2022 21:29

This isn’t really relevant anymore as I am in a much better place now than I was but I’m still quite annoyed about it. A year ago I was suffering quite badly with anxiety and depression so I went and saw my GP about it.

I recently downloaded the NHS App and I thought I’d have a look through my notes. I saw that on the appointment about my mental health my GP had wrote these notes.

‘Examination: Not sleeping, not looking after herself. Unkempt, looking down, shoulders hunched, not wearing a bra, hair not brushed’

aibu to think these comments on my file are quite rude?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
superplumb · 22/09/2022 20:13

Its standard safeguarding protection type stuff to describe, same with children in some households when police do protection notices. The bra thing is very odd though.

Butchyrestingface · 22/09/2022 19:58

not wearing a bra

I wouldn't be happy about that one. You're not obliged to wear a bra and it doesn't suggest anything about your mental state if you don't.

PuddlesOnFire · 22/09/2022 19:55

Another vote for factual. How you look and how you appear to be looking after yourself are important for diagnosis of depression. It gives an indication of you care about yourself.

I'd rather have a Dr who noticed me as a person when I went to see them and for clues from how I looked than go to one who asked the same rote questions until they figured out what pill to give me.

saleorbouy · 22/09/2022 19:48

Love the way some have assumed GP is a male, it's not mentioned by OP.
Surely these are just observations to assess general health and well being of a patient. I would be impressed with the attention to detail and if the GP knows the patient well from previous appointments then perhaps these were stark changes from their previous appearance.
Personally I wouldn't be angry, if the care prescribed was good.

DisforDarkChocolate · 22/09/2022 19:15

Not all all if they were factual.

Mine must have pages of that.

Stationsofthecross · 22/09/2022 19:13

Factual.

Arenanewbie · 22/09/2022 19:12

Did GP prescribe you anything or refer you to somewhere?
They wouldn’t be able to prescribe you certain things or refer you if you were ok and looked absolutely fine. In a way this description worked as a justification for your diagnosis and treatment.

honeyaubergine · 22/09/2022 19:05

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 18:38

But only because she usually wears a bra. A bra is actually optional, some women choose not to wear one when perfectly OK and not wearing one is not automatically a sign of depression.

Pisses me off when people decree women all have to dress a certain way.

Of course it is ok to not wear a bra. But as this thread shows, for some people it is something that goes when their MH is poor. Commenting on it in a mental state examination means that the next person who assesses the patient can flick back easily to see if it is something normal for that patient or whether it could be a sign that their MH has deteriorated.

Boxofsockss · 22/09/2022 18:53

I don’t think it is rude. I work in healthcare and DRs are quite to the point when it comes to things like that so as to avoid any ambiguity. Don’t take it to heart

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 18:38

Technonan · 22/09/2022 18:34

My late step-daughter had serious MH issues for much of her adult life. A sign she was dipping into depression was that she stopped wearing a bra, and we knew she was heading for a bad patch - it's simply an observation.

But only because she usually wears a bra. A bra is actually optional, some women choose not to wear one when perfectly OK and not wearing one is not automatically a sign of depression.

Pisses me off when people decree women all have to dress a certain way.

Technonan · 22/09/2022 18:34

My late step-daughter had serious MH issues for much of her adult life. A sign she was dipping into depression was that she stopped wearing a bra, and we knew she was heading for a bad patch - it's simply an observation.

BlindGirlMcSqueaky · 22/09/2022 18:30

Flyingbymypants · 22/09/2022 07:08

Ps the exact same is done for men too

Well it's not, is it? They're not expected to be in a bra.

OfficiallyBroken · 22/09/2022 13:53

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 21/09/2022 23:39

Rubbish. The people who do the assessments are often useless and she should have requested a mandatory reconsideration. Of course people that wash can have awful depression. The assessors are randomers used to filter out the applications and shouldn't be allowed to decide. They often make extremely poor choices. Unfortunately they have been given the contract but people can ask for an MR and then appeal the decision and it will be looked at by people who know what they're actually doing.

What's rubbish? How my sister was treated or what I've written?

Fortunately for my sister I was her advocate. I was present in the room for the assessment and the assessor basically wrote a pack of bullshit. Mandatory reconsiderations weren't the process then (which is why I can't remember what the sodding benefit was called, it was a while ago) so I pushed for an appeal. The system banks on people with a tenuous grip on their mental health giving up at the first hurdle. It took the appeal panel less than 15 minutes to decide that my sister was entitled to the financial support she applied for.

My point was that if the GP has been involved in cases like this with DWP they'll know that simple factual observations on a patient can make a difference when it comes to them accessing additional support.

EBearhug · 22/09/2022 07:59

So just to check I've got this right: if you use the NHS app, you can see notes from every GP appointment you've ever had, and what they wrote about you?!

Depends partly on your practice - mine aren't available. I haven't cared enough to ask my GP if I/they need to sign something or do something to allow it. I can do all my repeat prescriptions one, which is usually all I'm interested in.

I can't remember when I last wore a bra, including not at various medical appointments in the last year, nor in the office. My hair doesn't always look immaculate by the time I've walked down to the surgery, especially if it's windy. I don't wear make-up, either. This is normal for me,though, and I think my GP probably knows me well enough by now to know that. I know the signs of when my mental health is starting to slip these days, but I live alone, so it's probably not so clear to others,because they just don't see it. But a lot of things can be subjective, and not everyone is known to their GP, if they don't go often.

Fml1980 · 22/09/2022 07:27

I can sort of see why they would write it down, maybe not so much the bra.
I had PND and apart of mine was to look perfect, and be perfect all the time.
even scrubbing the house all night, it was hell.
My actual HV was brilliant and knew how bad it effected me.
Some health professionals were not and said I couldn't be that bad if I had make up on.

UniversalAunt · 22/09/2022 07:25

It is an observation of physical presentation within a clinical setting.

OP’s appearance at the time is consistent with the presentation & symptoms of depression.

Loads of women don’t particularly like wearing bras, so go without or wear bralettes at home, but climb into one for the day to look ‘dressed’. Particularly so for women with large breasts who I rarely see out & about or in workwear braless.

Not wearing a bra may be an indication in that clinical setting of being indifferent to their appearance or low motivation to change clothes for an appointment. Alongside the observations about being unkempt & unbrushed hair, the bra comment is congruent.

@Ispy9 Good to hear that you are in a better place.

Flyingbymypants · 22/09/2022 07:08

Ps the exact same is done for men too

Flyingbymypants · 22/09/2022 07:07

Saying 'struggling with self care' is completely different to describing your appearance. The latter is a factual, objective part of the psychiatric clinical assessment. I agree the comment about the bra is a bit strange though.

Isaidnoalready · 22/09/2022 07:00

lemonyanus · 21/09/2022 21:43

Oh god I dread to think what my GP notes read like, that's how I look on a normal day Blush

Same but I DO brush my hair it just doesn't look like it

Wilburisagirl · 22/09/2022 06:57

People it's got nothing to do with patriarchy or expectations on women. It's done regularly to gain a sense of what each patient's normal is. Anne is not compared to Susan. Anne is compared to Anne's previous presentations and any deviations from Anne's normal are noted as they might indicate something going on that she needs support with.

Wilburisagirl · 22/09/2022 06:54

LikeAStar1994 · 22/09/2022 02:13

Not wearing a bra? WTF?

I haven't worn a bra for a few months now and my mental health is perfectly fine! In fact I would say it's improved because of the fact my boobs are no longer imprisoned.

Yes and maybe that is normal for you. But the point of the GP noting these things is to be able to pick up on CHANGES to each client's normal. So if it's normal for someone to be wearing a bra, be well groomed and always dressed up etc and then one day they rock up with unbrushed hair and wearing PJs or track pants, you know you might need to dig a bit deeper or monitor a bit more.

Iknowforsure1 · 22/09/2022 06:27

I think the way the GP described you is offensive. Yes, I understand that they need to be factual. But not wearing a bra is not something that should be judged, many choose to do so. Some very mentally well women choose to have messy hair too. Some people choose not to shampoo for long etc etc. That would be enough: “Patient experiences difficulties with self care and the lack of motivation prevents her to look after herself properly” or something along the lines. Not this disgusting way of describing a person.

stayathomer · 22/09/2022 06:19

Somebody said above about not judging men that way but there’d be different indicators. When my brother isn’t at his best we notice he hasn’t had a hair cut, shaved and we always breathe a sigh of relief when mum tells us he’s having a long hot shower and is going to the barber’s later (he has as among other things)

stayathomer · 22/09/2022 06:16

PeloFondo
You we’re probably thinking more about the tee shirt than your back!!! (Love the sound of it btw!!)

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 05:56

spinduffy · 22/09/2022 03:27

Not wearing a bra is not usually normal in a public setting, so it was just recorded as an observation indicative of a degree of self neglect as part of your mental state examination. You record any visual observations that are not the norm

It is completely normal for some not to wear a bra, some people never wear them.