Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Best mouser cat

142 replies

friesandchais · 21/09/2022 21:28

Hello
So I'm petrified of mice and when we moved into this house 10 years ago who we blocked all hole to stop then entering, long story short every so often maybe once or 2 assay they find a way in then we again block any holes check the house and eventually they. But it a cycle and keeps happening. Me and dh and dc are all scared and hate knowing they maybe in the house. Everyone is telling me to get a cat to solve the problem. My friend told me she got a cat and she's now never had a problem since. I would want it to be a indoor cat. I know not all cats are mousers. But what are the best mousers? We really like British short hair cats, are they good, are they good around children? Female or male is better? Will a kitten be a mouser too? And can you train them to be Mousers?
This will be our first pet.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ExHack · 22/09/2022 10:16

@ LBOCS2 How exactly do they kill the frogs and snakes, just out of curiosity? We've never had this with any of our outdoor cats. The mice/moles they bring in are always intact so assume they had broken necks or died from exhaustion.

ExHack · 22/09/2022 10:13

It varies not by breed but by personality. If they get hungry enough I think any cat will become a good mouser.

If they are not hungry they might play with (torment) the mouse for hours and then let it go so they can catch it again (if it hasn't dropped dead from exhaustion).

Mouse traps in the right places would be a more efficient solution.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 22/09/2022 10:13

We had mice in the house last winter. Cat didn't even notice.

Toddlerteaplease · 22/09/2022 10:12

I'm also terrified of mice. It put me off getting a cat, as our childhood cats were mousers. Got two Persians who couldn't catch a cold!

LBOCS2 · 22/09/2022 10:09

We have two killing machines - one ginger, one tabby, both boys. I clear up carcasses daily, and most of them have been brought from outside in; I'm sure of this because I'm 99% certain there are no colonies of slowworms, lizards or frogs living in my house and those are the gifts they have been bringing me recently. A highlight was when the tabby one sauntered past the postie while I was talking to him and the postman asking me in a slightly horrified voice if it was a snake he was carrying.

Get cats if you want them. But don't a) assume you won't be clearing up carrion, and b) assume that all they'll do is catch household mice.

Cleothecat75 · 22/09/2022 10:05

SingingSands · 21/09/2022 21:53

If you want a pet cat, adopt a cat. If you want rid of your mice, call an exterminator!

I agree with this!
Our cat is an excellent mouser, we go through periods of time where she will catch something daily (she eats them on the drive, leaving what I think is the stomach behind so we know she has had a snack). But then also have weeks where she doesn’t appear to catch anything (but she may be consuming them elsewhere).

sometimes she bring them back alive and plays with them and my friend was horrified to see the cat throwing a dead mouse in the air and batting it across the garden. We are used to her doing this kind of thing, so it doesn’t bother us, but if you havent seen a cat do it, I can understand why my friend was so upset about it.

we have also had cats that could not care less about catching anything, all of our cats have been rescue/moggies so I don’t think breed has much to do with it.
I was once told that if a mouse can smell a cat, they won’t make a home there, not sure how true that is though.

TheUntiedShoelace · 22/09/2022 10:01

This is why I'll always be a dog person. Picking up poo twice a day is way less stressful than shovelling mangled rodents and dealing with blood splatter on the curtains.

Cw112 · 22/09/2022 09:53

I have had a few cats, the ones who went outdoors loooved hunting but would bring me half dead mice all the time. The ones who've been indoor only I don't think would know what to do with a mouse if they found one. The Tom I have at the minute is the laziest creature I've ever encountered, he's useless with flies and spiders etc. Also if a mouse has eaten poison etc and then your cat eats it they can become extremely unwell so I would be inclined to just deal with your pest problem through a pest control company so it's done properly. They'll be able to identify any access points that you can block up. At that point you can then just get any cat you want and enjoy them!

Seeingadistance · 22/09/2022 09:52

littlelionroars · 22/09/2022 09:44

We have an Abyssinian, she is the most prolific hunter I have ever experienced.

Honestly I've never had a cat like her. Spring time is awful because she brings in multiple kills a day.

I'm not sure a cat is going to help you with mice though, as quite often they will bring outside mice in and then play with them instead of kill them. Then you are left to catch and release them.

Could you cope with that?

Pic of mad cat attached.

That cat is thinking, why am I wasting time sitting on this cushion when I could be out there slaughtering!

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 09:51

Jack Russells are efficient and clean killers of mice and rats. Plus they have no daft ideas that you might like the kill as a present, and they are too slow to catch birds.

OneTC · 22/09/2022 09:48

littlelionroars · 22/09/2022 09:44

We have an Abyssinian, she is the most prolific hunter I have ever experienced.

Honestly I've never had a cat like her. Spring time is awful because she brings in multiple kills a day.

I'm not sure a cat is going to help you with mice though, as quite often they will bring outside mice in and then play with them instead of kill them. Then you are left to catch and release them.

Could you cope with that?

Pic of mad cat attached.

That looks like a hunter

littlelionroars · 22/09/2022 09:44

We have an Abyssinian, she is the most prolific hunter I have ever experienced.

Honestly I've never had a cat like her. Spring time is awful because she brings in multiple kills a day.

I'm not sure a cat is going to help you with mice though, as quite often they will bring outside mice in and then play with them instead of kill them. Then you are left to catch and release them.

Could you cope with that?

Pic of mad cat attached.

Best mouser cat
elessar · 22/09/2022 09:40

If you want a "mouser" then you cannot have an indoor only cat. Ones with a strong hunting instinct will want to be outside.

If you do want a cat anyway and you're hoping for a general deterrent to the mice (I couldn't say if having them is in itself a deterrent as I've never had mouse problems in a house) then I would get one that needs to be indoor only from a rescue (by far the best choice - so many cats needing homes), or a breed like a rag doll that is bred to be an indoor cat. But accept they may very well not be a good hunter - which to be honest might be best for you as other pp have said - hunting cats will leave them around dead, half eaten or sometimes half alive.

youcantry · 22/09/2022 09:35

Please don't get a cat based on what you think it's 'mouser abilities' might be. Get one because you will love it and make it part of your family. I've had many cats over the years and this never even entered my thinking when I was contemplating getting one. I never had a mouse problem in my houses. Some of mine have been mousers, some went for birds, some brought in live mice but didn't Kill them, just played with them.
Had fun one morning trying to catch a poor blue tit flying around my sons bedroom whilst getting kids ready for school and heading off to work. I did, was late for work but the bird flew off thankfully.
If your chosen cat is not a 'mouser' what do you plan to do with the poor thing?
Get humane traps and only get a cat if you will love it please.

Seeingadistance · 22/09/2022 09:33

The question is really about the best indoor cat.

OP, you could ask local shelters if they have cats with FIV looking for a home. Even with this health condition, these cats can live a long and normal life, but can’t live with other cats and are only rehomed as indoor cats.

That could be an ideal solution as it benefits both you and the cat.

www.rspca.org.uk/adviceandwelfare/pets/cats/health/fiv

OneTC · 22/09/2022 09:31

Having an indoor cat from kitten I'd say it's least likely to develop into a hunter.

They practice alot outside when no one is looking

OneTC · 22/09/2022 09:28

Complete luck of the draw. I've got a giant bsh that has no hunting instinct whatsoever. I had a tiny little black and white bsh that used to kill wild rabbits or anything it could get its paws on

Fizbosshoes · 22/09/2022 09:27

We never had a problem with mice in the house (or never saw them or any evidence of them) until we had cats.
Ours like to catch them, play...then get bored and set the frickin mice free!
I don't mind picking up mice and will get rid of the ones I can catch but we know we've had several that have made homes inside.

TooExtraImmatureCheddar · 22/09/2022 09:26

I used to live in a farm cottage which had a mouse problem - big holes behind the toilet, cooker, boiler etc etc. The landlord blocked some of them up but the mice still came in every winter, and my record was once catching 13 mice in one night (in 6 traps). We had a dog but he couldn't catch them. When the dog died we got a rescue cat, and he exterminated them. His first night he caught two mice and cleared them out. Then we moved and got two new kittens from a farm and they bring mice or birds or frogs in regularly. Most of the mice have been dead but I've tracked down a couple that have run under the sideboard and died and started to smell. The birds are the worst, though - one cat brought a pigeon in our bedroom window, flapping and fighting, and ripped its head off just as it got inside and blood sprayed right over the white curtains and down both the inside and the outside of the window.

I couldn't have kept any of mine in - cat 1 was a stray and accustomed to going out anyway, but the kids let the kittens outside accidentally at least once a day when they were small and we were trying to keep them in until they could be neutered. Luckily they didn't go far at that age!

MyAnacondaMight · 22/09/2022 09:25

The colour of a cat’s fur has no impact on its temperament (genetic abnormalities aside) or ability to hunt. It’s a bit like saying “my kid has blonde hair so is good at maths”. So you can disregard about 50% of the posts on this thread.

Prey drive is, to some extent, breed related. However, the breeds with a strong prey drive are unsuitable as indoor pets. So get an indoor cat if you want, but don’t expect it to solve your mouse problem.

ShinyS1 · 22/09/2022 09:24

My ginger moggie is a killing machine. Mice, rabbits, rats, pheasants, pigeons, frogs. Only squirrels have eluded him so far, though he never gives up.

I keep him in most of the time now, I can't stand it.

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 09:23

It’s perfectly morally fine to get a cat to solve a mouse problem. You don’t have to “love” cats to be decent enough to care for them properly and give them affection. Make sure you can afford the pet health insurance. Many cats prefer to be ‘working pets’ anyway and they tend to live longer and be more fit than cats kept indoors 24/7 with no stimulation.

You’ve a better chance getting a mouser if your cat is an indoor/outdoor cat. They are also more able to keep mice away if they can patrol around your garden and home and catch mice before they chew their way in. They will also scent mark the outside- shrubs, walls, patio furniture and this deters mice as well. Please still train them to use a litter box though, it’s irresponsible to have an indoor/outdoor cat and assume they can just shit in yours or your neighbours gardens.

In the feline kingdom, the female cats are the primary hunters. So although many Tom cats are good mousers, if you want to increase odds your cat will mouse, go for a female one.

Rescue cats will have lived stray for a time and will have had to hunt to eat, so a rescue cat rather than a new fluffy kitten will have a higher chance of having learned the skills of hunting.

Cats do like cat companionship, so one good thing is getting a rescue cat and then once they are settled adding a younger cat/kitten to the family. The older cat will teach the kitten how to hunt and they will have another cat to play with outside and inside.

PicaNewName · 22/09/2022 09:13

ThePuma · 21/09/2022 22:44

She is a registered breeder.

Selling kittens for 200? That's very questionable.

PicaNewName · 22/09/2022 09:12

ThePuma · 21/09/2022 22:34

She is in Newport. I am in Bucks so it was a 2h30 drive each way but it was worth it. She says she is the only longhair breeder in the UK.

i paid £850 each for mine but she has said she will accept £200 each from anyone I introduce to her.

There are lots of longhair breeders in the UK. The long hair gene is recessive so even two shorthair parents who carry th gene can have longhair kittens.

Breed doesn't guarantee hunting instinct. Although if you wanted something high energy, go for a bengal boy.

I breed British, they're essentially quite lazy, although my stud keeps jumping at the window trying to catch my chickens. Grin

LBF2020 · 22/09/2022 09:11

Where I live (rural), people rehome farm cats//feral/semi-feral cats for mousing issues. I think this would only be appropriate if you have a large garden with outbuildings etc.. as the cats like to stay out of the humans way for the most part.