Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Best mouser cat

142 replies

friesandchais · 21/09/2022 21:28

Hello
So I'm petrified of mice and when we moved into this house 10 years ago who we blocked all hole to stop then entering, long story short every so often maybe once or 2 assay they find a way in then we again block any holes check the house and eventually they. But it a cycle and keeps happening. Me and dh and dc are all scared and hate knowing they maybe in the house. Everyone is telling me to get a cat to solve the problem. My friend told me she got a cat and she's now never had a problem since. I would want it to be a indoor cat. I know not all cats are mousers. But what are the best mousers? We really like British short hair cats, are they good, are they good around children? Female or male is better? Will a kitten be a mouser too? And can you train them to be Mousers?
This will be our first pet.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
quitefranklyabsurd · 22/09/2022 22:53

I’m not sure there is a breed that is a good mouser. - some cats are excellent killers though.

We have three cats - two don’t care and have never caught a thing. The third - he’s in a league of his own. An excellent mouser, Alive, dead, decapitated, sometimes we just find a leg or a tail and some guts.

He’s also brought in a love wood pigeon, several more live birds, many dead birds, and then there was the live squirrel!

Be careful what you wish for!

SamanthaVimes · 22/09/2022 22:38

My ginger cat is obviously on mumsnet and took offence to what I posted because he’s just brought home his own mousy friend (alive) to torture FML

HazelBite · 22/09/2022 19:07

I have cats for the last 50 years. All the black cats I've had have been excellent hunters as have any tortishell females. I have only had one who had no interest in hunting and one ginger boy who let himself be intimidated by the larger birds in the garden.
They do bring bodies indoors though OP both alive and dead!

mycatisannoying · 22/09/2022 18:35

My cat brings in more mice than he actually kills outdoors.
I don't mind if he kills it indoors (sorry to sound blasé, but we're in Edinburgh and just so used to them), but it's fucking annoying when he brings it indoors and then just leaves it to escape.

Whatthechicken · 22/09/2022 18:32

Interestingly, my ex feral is a torty. The farm shop next door encouraged her to stick around because she was an excellent mouser. I have a post on the litter tray topic about 2 years ago now on how she came into our lives.

Whatthechicken · 22/09/2022 18:25

Not read the full thread, but as someone said above ‘indoor and best mouser’ don’t go together. My cat catches about four mice a day and generally eats them whole - but she does sometimes leave a head or entrails. But my cat is an ex feral. If I tried to keep her in, she’d just start pissing everywhere in protest. She was used to hunting to survive, even though she has all the home comforts now, she can’t quite shake the habit. If she was inside all the time, I doubt she’d bother. She maybe would torment them instead. She also sometimes bring the cutest baby rabbits home too (already dead). She sometimes eats the rabbits whole or like the other day, she just dropped one in the living room. Dog (beagle) just looked at it, she was sure she was supposed to do something - but she wasn’t quite sure what. My kids have had to get used to death very quickly. If you want a cat get one, but don’t just get one to solve another animal problem - you’ll just end up with an additional problem.

LakieLady · 22/09/2022 18:14

You could try some of those ultrasonic pest repellent devices, OP.

I've never had mice in the house since I got a couple of those.

LakieLady · 22/09/2022 18:13

GiantCheeseMonster · 21/09/2022 21:33

Haha. That’s hilarious. I have three cats. Two are lazy with no interest in catching anything. The third is extremely enthusiastic. She’s female, and a tortoiseshell - anecdotally they are said to be excellent mousers and she fits the stereotype. But since we’ve had her we’ve had many more mice in the house. She brings in live ones and lets them run run round, dead ones and leaves them lying around untouched, and occasionally just a mouse head or liver under my dining table. Honestly, if you have a mouse phobia, get some CBT. Do not, whatever you do, get a cat.

I had a female tortoiseshell and she was a fantastic hunter, too. She was keener on birds than mice though, and once brought it 3 live starlings in a day. She was a tiny little thing, as well.

It crossed my mind that the tortoiseshell markings might make them better camouflaged for outdoor hunting.

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 17:59

'Humane' traps are just a way of moving the problem on and are pretty cruel, as you're removing an animal from its territory / family group and effectively dumping them in a foreign country. They'll die as a result anyway, just not under your nose.

Depends on the mice you have. If you’re rural and these are brown field mice, and you take them to a hedgerow with food, water and shelter they are fine. If you’re in the city and have grey house mice, yes you’re just relocating a house mouse to someone else’s house as they cannot survive outside.

AffIt · 22/09/2022 16:09

MMoon23 · 22/09/2022 15:47

Humane mouse traps. Standard mouse traps /glue traps are awful.
Or seeking the advice of a local wildlife group. My local one has a fb page run by people who are very knowledgeable and well connected to organisations that humanely relocate foxes, mice, squirrels etc

If used properly, snap traps are more humane than anything else, because they (should be) instantaneous. Best to get advice from professionals on their use.

Predators (cats or terriers) are the next best option.

'Humane' traps are just a way of moving the problem on and are pretty cruel, as you're removing an animal from its territory / family group and effectively dumping them in a foreign country. They'll die as a result anyway, just not under your nose.

Glue traps / poison bait are hideous, though.

SweetLittlePixie · 22/09/2022 15:58

We got a kitten from a farm last year. She is great at bringing things home. So far i have found mice, birds, a frog, lots of huge insect and grasshoppers, worms and once even a snake inside my house! All dragged in by the cat. We also have a male burmese and he is absolutely useless. He chases things, but never catches them unles they are already half dead because of the other cat.
We never had animals in our house before, so the cats created this problem rather than solved it.

MarsupiIami · 22/09/2022 15:52

I don't think hunter and indoor cat go together.

ExHack · 22/09/2022 15:51

Has anyone ever tried a pet snake? Or a large bird? (Parrot?) Would a parrot catch them for itself? What about a tarantula?

ExHack · 22/09/2022 15:49

This is definitely the time of year for it.
Last year at my family home (rural) we and the cat caught 70 mice between us in the space of 6 weeks. (We were using traps, for avoidance of any doubt!) I'm not counting the numerous decapitated heads/tails that were found on places like the bedroom carpet.
I woke up in the night hearing a strange thumping sound and opened the cupboard to find a live mouse thrashing around in a trap. My brother in law had to dispatch it with a hammer. So make sure you get the right size traps! Too big and it won't kill the boor little buggers.

MMoon23 · 22/09/2022 15:47

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 22/09/2022 08:26

Some of these posts are so cruel! Why would anyone let/enjoy any cat purposefully tormenting and torturing a mouse. It’s obviously not the cats fault if it happens, but shouldn’t be encouraged surely?!

Out of curiosity, what would be your solution to a rodent infestation?
I certainly wouldn’t inflict poison on any animal - such a slow and painful death!

Humane mouse traps. Standard mouse traps /glue traps are awful.
Or seeking the advice of a local wildlife group. My local one has a fb page run by people who are very knowledgeable and well connected to organisations that humanely relocate foxes, mice, squirrels etc

MMoon23 · 22/09/2022 15:42

SoupDragon · 22/09/2022 08:33

No one is "letting" them do it. They are natural hunters, they just do it. You can't stop them.

If your cat brings in a mouse /bird alive and is continually playing with it and you are just sat there watching then I feel that is ‘letting it’ torment the animal when you could stop it.

of Course they will kill animals though, you can only do so much with bells etc, it’s not that I don’t think cats are natural hunters…

MMoon23 · 22/09/2022 15:38

inappropriateraspberry · 22/09/2022 08:55

That's life I'm afraid. Predators and prey. Better to be food for another animal than poisoned to death.
I'm a vegetarian and accept the 'circle of life,' I'm not taking every field mouse to the vet!

I’m not saying YOU have to take every mouse to the vet, I’m saying they would need to go to the vets in order to survive.
some people who love animals mistakenly let them go thinking they have saved them and would be hurt to realise the outcome, so that’s why I shared that information

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 22/09/2022 14:46

Yeah a dog might do it. We have a street dog rescue and she is really good at finding and catching mice. We usually get some at this time of year as the weather starts to cool snd I guess they are looking for somewhere cosy fir the winter. They don’t hang around long though!

MyAnacondaMight · 22/09/2022 13:06

My cat catches frogs too - agree they must die from internal injuries, from being flung around. I really don’t like that.

He’s a great little assassin (grew up on the street, and knows how to kill), but I definitely have more rodents post-cat than pre-cat. Before him I just had the occasional mouse trying to set up home - now I have regular rats brought in to play with.

TeaAndStrumpets · 22/09/2022 13:06

Another recommendation for a Jack Russell Terrier. My DD lives in the country, and her JRT races alongside the cat hoping for fresh snacks (ugh) They are the best of friends, of course!

LBOCS2 · 22/09/2022 12:15

ExHack · 22/09/2022 10:16

@ LBOCS2 How exactly do they kill the frogs and snakes, just out of curiosity? We've never had this with any of our outdoor cats. The mice/moles they bring in are always intact so assume they had broken necks or died from exhaustion.

I think partially shock and partially internal organ damage. We've had a few half-animals too where they've been chewed at. Poor things; the cats each have two bells on them but still manage to catch wildlife.

thecathaszerobrains · 22/09/2022 10:45

I wouldn't bank on all farm cats being good mousers

I have an ex-farm cat I rehomed as a 12 week old kitten. She's as thick as they come. Put her food in the wrong place and she gets confused and starts howling. Leave the toilet lid up and she's in the toilet drinking. Leave the bathroom door unlocked when you are in the bath and she's in with you. She's also an indoor cat of her own choosing as it's all just a bit scary outside.

My other cat is a mouser if and when she can be bothered. However like most people have said they like to bring their kills back for you to admire. I'll never forget the time I was ill in bed with flu though. I must have crashed out mid afternoon and then woke up the next morning to a bed that looked like a scene from the animals of farthing wood meets Stephen King. She had brought me several get well soon presents and left them on my bed for me.

Have you tried ultrasonic mouse deterrents instead?

Textboxmm · 22/09/2022 10:40

A hungry cat is a good mouser. Don’t over feed them.

Caiti19 · 22/09/2022 10:20

If you are in a rural area, a cat that was born outside and trained by its Mother will be the best mouser. We "support" 2 cats. It's a long story as to how it all happened, but suffice to say they are Mother-Daughter outdoor cats. We feed them twice a day (to discourage them from killing non-vermin small animals and birds), and provide multiple cosy houses for them - but they are both excellent hunters because they learned how as kittens. They are not cats for cuddling, but they are both healthy and happy. They do sometimes present "gifts" to us, but it's always outside as they are outdoor cats. If you spot a cat wandering around your area looking homeless, you can coax it to your garden with food and it will keep coming back for food and will eventually consider your garden to be her territory for killing vermin.

ExHack · 22/09/2022 10:17

@LBOCS2 (see above)