Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed that brother is judging DD

61 replies

kirstywursty012 · 21/09/2022 21:07

Hi everyone - it would be great to get some other perspectives so I can stop feeling like I'm going mad!

My brother and his wife are over with their 11 month old baby for 3 weeks (they live in the US) - its been so nice to see my niece and brother. We were very close growing up and since he became a Dad, its been harder to stay in touch.

However, he keeps making backhanded comments and doing side eye to his wife whenever my 3 year old is playing up. It's driving me insane! She's had her odd moment if her cousin is trying to play with one of her toys and because she hasn't had all our attention, she does act up for it. She hasn't really been that bad though - she's said more adorable, funny things over the past couple of weeks than bad and has been really sweet and kind wanting to cuddle her cousin.

The good times seem to go unnoticed though and my brother said something along the lines of "she kicks off a lot, you need to put her on the naughty step" to me in passing. It's starting to stress me out and I can definitely see myself taking it out on her and losing my rag a lot faster.

It also doesn't help that they just have NO interest in leaving the house. We've been cooped up all day together (I would usually take DD out twice to wear her out) - they say its pointless as their daughter is too young to enjoy any kids stuff. I also think DB's DW is a bit of an agoraphobe as she doesn't seem to go out much at home either.

And finally - their daughter is a really quiet chilled baby but she doesn't eat any solids. They have her on the floor during dinner time and I always say "shall I pop some of the food in a bowl for her so she can try it" and they just say "oh she's not really into solid food". I then think to myself "and you judge MY parenting??"

Is this just petty brother sister squabbling or AIBU in thinking he's actually being a bit of a d*ck?

OP posts:
Etive · 21/09/2022 23:46

She's had her odd moment if her cousin is trying to play with one of her toys and because she hasn't had all our attention, she does act up for it. She hasn't really been that bad though - she's said more adorable, funny things over the past couple of weeks than bad and has been really sweet and kind wanting to cuddle her cousin.

Lets face it, I think a lot of people out there with a younger child have come across boisterous toddlers and didn’t like the behaviour they displayed towards their child. Whether that be at playgroup, a toddler class, nursery etc. I read threads most days on MN on the behaviour of other peoples children that others find unacceptable.

Take your child out OP if that’s what you’re used to doing and let your brother parent the way his and his wife want to. Just go out and do what you normally do.

There’s nothing worse than being judged as a parent…

mondaytosunday · 21/09/2022 23:31

You'll have the last laugh when their kid turns three. Smug parents of babies who think they know everything - ha!

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 21/09/2022 23:13

Are they feeding the baby purées?

Mammyloveswine · 21/09/2022 23:06

Ffs... they can judge all they want and you absolutely can be smug as fuck when their perfect firstborn turns into a normal toddler!!

Pollyputthekettleonha · 21/09/2022 23:02

I would take your daughter out anyway, explain to them that she needs stimulation and wearing out, and see if they will come with you. She will play up cooped up all the time. Doesn't sound like she's been that bad.
An 11 month old would enjoy the park or soft play or whatever as well, newborns are too young to enjoy anything, 11 month olds are not, and also need stimulation. She is probably at least crawling so would get something out of going to the park etc.
No solids at 11 months is odd as well, and they are not even encouraging her to try or even sit at the table with everyone? This sounds a bit worrying.
They are far from perfect parents so not sure why they are criticising you. It would be tempting to criticise them back, but would probably get out more like you normally do and rise above it.

Mariposista · 21/09/2022 22:58

Too young to enjoy kids stuff? What a load of rubbish. Babies just enjoy being out in the fresh air and looking around. Get your kid out and leave this lazy lot to their lazy ways. Haha in 2 years they will have the ‘acting up’ 3 year old and you will have a sweet primary age kid - then you can be nice and smug 🤣🤣

Mooda · 21/09/2022 22:54

At 11 months you would expect the baby to be sitting up, crawling, pulling herself up and possibly walking rather than lying on the floor. And definitely eating solids. Does your DB seem aware of this? It's quite concerning.

OrlandointheWilderness · 21/09/2022 22:46

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin
Oh they'll learn. Just wait 2 years. They'll carry a screaming child out of Tesco under one arm like the rest of us.

The solids thing is worrying though.

ImAvingOops · 21/09/2022 22:41

I'd be concerned that their baby isn't sufficiently stimulated if they aren't taking her out. And her diet isn't right - even if they were giving her puréed food that met nutritional needs, babies of that age need introducing to different textures and learn to chew. I'd try to raise this with them in a non confrontational way.
They really shouldn't be criticising you while doing what they are doing

Wouldloveanother · 21/09/2022 22:34

KvotheTheBloodless · 21/09/2022 22:11

At 11 months that baby will be seriously low on iron if she's not eating solids - no wonder she's 'chilled out' Shock That's serious neglect and will cause serious health problems soon.

They need an urgent referral to paediatrics if baby is refusing all solids, there are a few things that could cause this and all need looking into.

This, I’m shocked nobody else seems to have really picked up on that part of the post. No solids at 11 months?? That’s insane! She’s probably undernourished and has no energy to play up. What are they giving her, just milk?

allboysherebutme · 21/09/2022 22:32

Also it's odd they don't feed their child solids very very odd. X

allboysherebutme · 21/09/2022 22:30

I'd still get her out and leave them in. X

shivawn · 21/09/2022 22:19

Honestly, they're in no position to judge you if they have no interest in their daughters nutrition and don't see any reason to take their 11 month outside the house.

My son is 11 months old and he is plenty old enough to enjoy all kinds of things and I would be absolutely stressed off my head if he was eating no solids!

shivawn · 21/09/2022 22:15

she doesn't eat any solids. They have her on the floor during dinner time and I always say "shall I pop some of the food in a bowl for her so she can try it" and they just say "oh she's not really into solid food".

What the.........???

cavia · 21/09/2022 22:15

Similar age gap between my DD1 and DN1. My brother witnessed DD having a tantrum around 2 and was appalled. He soon learnt. Don't let it bother you!

KvotheTheBloodless · 21/09/2022 22:12

Oh, and YANBU re: other stuff, 3-year-olds are hilarious but high energy! They'll learn...

KvotheTheBloodless · 21/09/2022 22:11

At 11 months that baby will be seriously low on iron if she's not eating solids - no wonder she's 'chilled out' Shock That's serious neglect and will cause serious health problems soon.

They need an urgent referral to paediatrics if baby is refusing all solids, there are a few things that could cause this and all need looking into.

Mummyoflittledragon · 21/09/2022 22:08

I know exactly how you feel op. Your dd needs to go out to run off the energy to help her sleep. I would try to ignore their naive comments and behaviour. Or do the mum thing: ‘If you don’t stop telling me what to do, you’ll go on the naughty step. It’s one minute for every year of your life and you’re not allowed any electronics or reading material.’

The kindest thing you can do tbh is to show consistency in your parenting as well as to demonstrate to your brother and sil how littlies need socialisation and to run around.

ExtraJalapenos · 21/09/2022 21:44

They sound like if Sheldon and Leonards mum had a baby on Big Bang Theory
They sound like a right bore. And pretty stupid in my opinion. Why come to the UK from USA just to stay indoors. And don't even start me on the fact that their child isn't even being encouraged onto solids...sounds like their baby is a science experiment!

I think you should carry on as normal with ur DD. She sounds like bags of fun, my DD is the devil incarnate but her uncles and aunties adore her because they love her cheeky personality. I know it can be a handful but laugh it off. DD gets on my tits even now that's shes 4 but I just find her hilarious now. Defo don't keep her indoors either.

Bet you can't wait till Mr and Mrs judgeypants leave!

kirstywursty012 · 21/09/2022 21:44

Thanks everyone! I love Mumsnet! I'll rise above it for now and smugly bank his comments for a later date.

And you're right, I shouldn't be changing DD's routine for visitors. I'll carry on with our usual outings and invite them along at any opportunity.

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 21:42

Laugh and tell them you're recording their comments for in 2 years time.

Then take your dd out for a walk and play as usual.

Bumpsadaisie · 21/09/2022 21:40

Ha ha, 11 months pfb. They're still at the stage where they think they're in total control of how their dD turns out.

Never mind, they'll probably have a classic fireball dc2 soon WHO runs then ragged - and realise they don't have as much control as they thought.

IME DC2s are very good at challenging parental narcissism.

dandelionthistle · 21/09/2022 21:39

Oh - I think you do need to prep a couple of ready lines for brushing off silly nonsense like "she needs the naughty step" or whatever. For me with my DSis I would prob laugh it off with something like "yeah yeah, come back and tell me about it when DN is 3!" but ymmv, you might prefer to say you don't like those methods or you don't want his advice or you'll put him on the naughty step or whatever. It doesn't matter what exactly it is, you just need a way to brush it off so that you don't start absorbing it.

dandelionthistle · 21/09/2022 21:35

Ha. The smug parent of a baby, offering advice to the parent of a toddler, is a cliche for a reason...

That said, I think cousin, sibling, and aunty/uncle relationships are precious, so I'd try to let go and rise above it. There is the same age gap between my DC2 and my DN. Luckily my DSis is fab and has generally always adored my DC and had developmentally appropriate expectations of them, but there were still a few times where I had to bite my tongue. And a few short years later, my DC2 is largely sensible and biddable and DN is the handful, and it's my turn to not make judgmental remarks Grin

Defo carry on your normal life and get DD out and about when she needs it, though. Fine for them to stay at home, but it's not fair to ask a 3yo to compromise that much for visitors IMO.

Pallisers · 21/09/2022 21:27

Take your dd out as usual. Let the rest of it go. I suppose if it was my sibling I'd say something like "get back to me when that gorgeous baby is 3"

And an 11 month old would love to be out, looking at new things, seeing children in the playground, sitting in the sand pit.