Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it time to watch the mud stick with TFG? Watch this space!

984 replies

Roussette · 21/09/2022 21:03

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4396017-Big-Bird-may-be-innocent-but-who-can-vouch-for-Elmo?page=40&reply=120171921

Previous thread!

This thread is now full, here is the link to the new thread www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4912378-trump-gets-gagged-mccarthy-gets-booted-whats-next-in-trumpworld? (added my MNHQ)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
80
DuncinToffee · 20/06/2023 09:03

https://twitter.com/ByDonkeys/status/1670750346396958720?s=20

The Murdoch Succession

BruceAndNosh · 20/06/2023 08:17

Anyone watched clips of Trump's interview with Fox's Brett Baier?
Hard to follow as Trump does his usual talking over the interviewer.

His latest excuse is that he didn't return the documents as he was "too busy" to go through the boxes. And that the documents were all mixed up with personal stuff like trousers and golf shirts and shoes!
Frankly the prosecution just needs to play the interview...

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 19/06/2023 20:45

I vaguely remember reading that Trump was thrown out of at least one school, and was sent to another which was the equivalent of Borstal For The Moneyed Classes. Also that he didn't bother to take his own exams – an accusation which has also been made against one fairly notable OE now resident in America...

AcrossthePond55 · 19/06/2023 17:10

Trump may not be an OE, but he's certainly a product of the elite/upscale private school environment. So as far as mindset I'd put those mentioned in the same bucket. Not the 'all of them are like this' bucket because all privately educated people aren't arseholes . But in the 'I went to an elite school so 'de facto' I am better than you' bucket.

Kew Forest Prep currently $38 - 44k per year
New York Military Academy (boarding) $50k per year.

Above is tuition only, doesn't include 'extras'.

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 08:22

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime

Apologies - Boris remained under the tender loving care of Stanley until the ripe old age of 11 before being shuffled off. And iirc it was a fairly chaotic childhood and his mother had a nervous breakdown before he was sent off, so a combination of events and circumstances that might explain quite a bit.

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 08:16

I look at the Jesuit "give me a child to the age of seven and I will give you the man" phrase, and note that boarding schools in England do not, except in very unusual circumstances indeed, accept pupils under the age of eight.)

But the fact remains that while I don't know for certain if R-M boarded at Westminster Prep, although I would assume he did as the family home is in Somerset, we do know that both Johnson and Cameron were shuffled off to boarding school by 8 (and while fewer people choose that option now, of course plenty of boarding schools here still take kids at 7 or 8) and both have displayed a remarkable ability to land an entire country in the shit and walk away having looked out for themselves and with no apparent remorse.

And, yes, of course it's possible to be an OE and not turn into a pathological liar. As I've said, we have plenty of OE friends who are lovely. But it's a bit like arguing it's possible to be raised by an abusive alcoholic and be just fine. Of course it is, it's not necessarily destiny, but at the same time we understand that many people raised in this situation are more likely than other to have some specific characteristics in common as adults.

Article by the author of Sad Little Men

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/08/public-schoolboys-boris-johnson-sad-little-boys-richard-beard

Why public schoolboys like me and Boris Johnson aren’t fit to run our country

Our elite schools foster emotional austerity and fierce clique loyalty. Here a privately educated writer of the prime minister’s generation reveals the lasting damage public schools do

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2021/aug/08/public-schoolboys-boris-johnson-sad-little-boys-richard-beard

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/06/2023 22:25

Sorry, I now see that you had changed it already to "unwillingness", but I didn't notice before I posted that there was was another page. Apologies.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/06/2023 22:24

Wallaw
but if you're arguing that Cameron, R-M and Johnson don't have in common the willingness or ability to accept responsibility for their actions I will have to disagree with you.

I wasn't. (Did you mean unwillingness, there?) I was suggesting that it is possible to be an Old Etonian and not resemble the nastiest examples of that school's output.

(Or even to have been sent to boarding school at the age of eight and not turned into a waste of space by the experience! I look at the Jesuit "give me a child to the age of seven and I will give you the man" phrase, and note that boarding schools in England do not, except in very unusual circumstances indeed, accept pupils under the age of eight.)

But this thread is about Trump, so I won't derail it further, except to add that his upbringing was not a much better environment!

I think that Trump's general god-awfulness tends to be attributed to his parents, in particular his father, rather than to his schools; and while I know nothing about Cameron's father, it can hardly be argued that Johnson Senior is not just a little shady! Rees-Mogg's father often seemed quite a reasonable person, but he may have been an absolute stinker at home.

Wallaw · 18/06/2023 17:34

*unwillingness

Wallaw · 18/06/2023 17:33

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/06/2023 15:40

I think that people who become unpleasant politicians would have started being unpleasant people before Eton ever saw them, if I am honest. OEs I have known during my lifetime have not been burdened with a sense of privilege, entitlement and omniscience, especially not the last! Most have been faintly apologetic about being associated with the likes of Rees-Mogg, Cameron and Johnson and have not wanted people to know where they were at school – which after all was not in general their choice but that of their parents.

I know plenty of OEs who are lovely, but if you're arguing that Cameron, R-M and Johnson don't have in common the willingness or ability to accept responsibility for their actions I will have to disagree with you. And while Eton isn't specifically to blame, the larger point is that the psychology of people who are sent to boarding school at the age of 7 or 8 (which they all were, albeit not Eton at that age) is warped by the defences necessary to survive in that environment. I can't find it in me to believe that they were destined to become unpleasant people before the age of 8. I really do highly recommend Sad Little Men if you're interested in a deeper, albeit one-sided, discussion.

But this thread is about Trump, so I won't derail it further, except to add that his upbringing was not a much better environment!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/06/2023 15:40

I think that people who become unpleasant politicians would have started being unpleasant people before Eton ever saw them, if I am honest. OEs I have known during my lifetime have not been burdened with a sense of privilege, entitlement and omniscience, especially not the last! Most have been faintly apologetic about being associated with the likes of Rees-Mogg, Cameron and Johnson and have not wanted people to know where they were at school – which after all was not in general their choice but that of their parents.

prettybird · 18/06/2023 13:50

From the years that James Claughton was Master, he wasn't responsible for BJ (I did wonder briefly if he was the one that wrote the very astute assessment of BJ in a school report Wink but realised that the dates didn't match up).

Wallaw · 18/06/2023 13:23

AcrossthePond55 · 18/06/2023 12:48

I think Bannon et al have their own agenda and are using Trump's ego for their own aims. Bannon to push his own brand of fascism, Carlson & Ingraham (and the whole Fox crew) to make money.

We already know that Carlson thinks he's a liar and an idiot, he's been caught saying it. Bannon's kept his actual opinion of Trump to himself. He's made a few comments, but nothing truly 'negative'. Ingraham, who the fuck knows. She just lets loose with verbal diarrhoea that flies every which way.

That clip is exactly what I was saying about BoJo. He knew he was lying and he knew he was doing it very, very badly! He was probably saying silently to himself "FGS Boris, shut UP! You're sounding like an absolute TIT!". Trump would have been absolutely convincing about the cardboard buses. He would have known he was lying but would have believed that he was right to lie and so would have been convincing in his 'rightness'.

Personally, if I'd been the interviewer I'd have said "Go on then, Boris, show me one of your cardboard buses with the painted on people!".

There's a really interesting book called Sad Little Men about the psychological and emotional culture of boarding school and the fact that Johnson, David Cameron, Rees-Mogg, etc. were all sent off at a very young age. Lays out some interesting correlations between that and the UK's current situation. The author went to an all boys boarding school from the age of 8.

In the Boris clip, I see more someone enjoying the feeling that he's clever and charming enough (in his own mind) to get away with the blatant lies - that he'll be forgiven because he's special. As opposed to Trump, who cares deeply whether people believe him.

Interestingly, this letter was published in the (UK) Times last week - screen shotted from Twitter because it will be a cold day in hell before I subscribe to a Murdoch paper, even if it's a decent one.

Is it time to watch the mud stick with TFG?  Watch this space!
AcrossthePond55 · 18/06/2023 12:48

Wallaw · 18/06/2023 12:19

Yes, I think that's a very astute perception of his lying. But what do you make of the people around him? Steve Bannon, Tucker Carlson, Laura Ingraham, etc.?

Have you ever seen this clip? It's clearly not one of his most damaging lies, but one of the most astonishing moments of someone blatantly lying with absolute relish that I've ever seen.

https://twitter.com/brianklaas/status/1143504207640715265?s=20

I think Bannon et al have their own agenda and are using Trump's ego for their own aims. Bannon to push his own brand of fascism, Carlson & Ingraham (and the whole Fox crew) to make money.

We already know that Carlson thinks he's a liar and an idiot, he's been caught saying it. Bannon's kept his actual opinion of Trump to himself. He's made a few comments, but nothing truly 'negative'. Ingraham, who the fuck knows. She just lets loose with verbal diarrhoea that flies every which way.

That clip is exactly what I was saying about BoJo. He knew he was lying and he knew he was doing it very, very badly! He was probably saying silently to himself "FGS Boris, shut UP! You're sounding like an absolute TIT!". Trump would have been absolutely convincing about the cardboard buses. He would have known he was lying but would have believed that he was right to lie and so would have been convincing in his 'rightness'.

Personally, if I'd been the interviewer I'd have said "Go on then, Boris, show me one of your cardboard buses with the painted on people!".

Wallaw · 18/06/2023 12:19

AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2023 14:44

I go back and forth with Trump on whether he believes his own lies or not. I sometimes think his mental illness or deterioration of whatever it is is so extreme that he starts out just saying stuff and then ends up believing it.

@Wallaw

I believe that he believes he has an absolute right to lie. That's not the same as believing one's lies, just that he believes it's not only acceptable, but morally correct to tell those lies in order to accomplish his aims. And because he truly believes he has the right to lie, he can justify the lies to himself and that's what makes him so convincing in his lies. At least, convincing to the Cult.

I think the difference with Boris is that Boris knows that he's lying, but deep down he also knows that he really should tell the truth. I think that's why Boris' lies just seem so blustery and 'insincere sounding', whereas Trump's seem so 'secure in their own rightness'. I think that difference is why Trump has a true 'cult' and Boris doesn't.

I hope that makes sense.

Yes, I think that's a very astute perception of his lying. But what do you make of the people around him? Steve Bannon, Tucker Carlson, Laura Ingraham, etc.?

Have you ever seen this clip? It's clearly not one of his most damaging lies, but one of the most astonishing moments of someone blatantly lying with absolute relish that I've ever seen.

https://twitter.com/brianklaas/status/1143504207640715265?s=20

https://twitter.com/brianklaas/status/1143504207640715265?s=20

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 18/06/2023 00:39

prettybird · 17/06/2023 18:45

....not a "God given right" - a " Trump given right" Shock

He is, after all, more bigly important than God Wink

😆😆😆

Too true!!!!

prettybird · 17/06/2023 18:45

....not a "God given right" - a " Trump given right" Shock

He is, after all, more bigly important than God Wink

Roussette · 17/06/2023 18:41

AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2023 14:44

I go back and forth with Trump on whether he believes his own lies or not. I sometimes think his mental illness or deterioration of whatever it is is so extreme that he starts out just saying stuff and then ends up believing it.

@Wallaw

I believe that he believes he has an absolute right to lie. That's not the same as believing one's lies, just that he believes it's not only acceptable, but morally correct to tell those lies in order to accomplish his aims. And because he truly believes he has the right to lie, he can justify the lies to himself and that's what makes him so convincing in his lies. At least, convincing to the Cult.

I think the difference with Boris is that Boris knows that he's lying, but deep down he also knows that he really should tell the truth. I think that's why Boris' lies just seem so blustery and 'insincere sounding', whereas Trump's seem so 'secure in their own rightness'. I think that difference is why Trump has a true 'cult' and Boris doesn't.

I hope that makes sense.

It really does.

I read somewhere that Johnson is desperate for friends and affirmation all the time, hence his playful nicknames for different Ministers. (Priti Patel AKA "the Pritster")
I think he's hugely insecure hence his shock and horror at being 'found out' for lying

Trumpy thinks he has a God given right

OP posts:
greenacrylicpaint · 17/06/2023 17:41

bj treats anything like a debating club.

draw a side and off you go. no own ideas at all.

borntobequiet · 17/06/2023 16:24

I hope that makes sense.

It does. Trump genuinely believes in himself in a way Johnson doesn’t. This makes the depiction of “good Boris” and “bad Boris” on the British satirical radio show Dead Ringers so convincing. You wouldn’t have “good Trump” and “bad Trump” in the same vein.

AcrossthePond55 · 17/06/2023 14:44

I go back and forth with Trump on whether he believes his own lies or not. I sometimes think his mental illness or deterioration of whatever it is is so extreme that he starts out just saying stuff and then ends up believing it.

@Wallaw

I believe that he believes he has an absolute right to lie. That's not the same as believing one's lies, just that he believes it's not only acceptable, but morally correct to tell those lies in order to accomplish his aims. And because he truly believes he has the right to lie, he can justify the lies to himself and that's what makes him so convincing in his lies. At least, convincing to the Cult.

I think the difference with Boris is that Boris knows that he's lying, but deep down he also knows that he really should tell the truth. I think that's why Boris' lies just seem so blustery and 'insincere sounding', whereas Trump's seem so 'secure in their own rightness'. I think that difference is why Trump has a true 'cult' and Boris doesn't.

I hope that makes sense.

Wallaw · 17/06/2023 14:04

AcrossthePond55 · 15/06/2023 14:46

So that's his 'plan', eh? What a maroon! But just another example of someone who has never truly come up against a brick wall and/or has been able to cheat/payola his way through life.

It would be interesting to know his actual emotions around this. Does he truly believe he's going to skate through all this because of 'who he is' or is he absolutely terrified because he knows he's finally up against adversaries he can't blackmail, bribe, or intimidate? Not that I'd want to poke around in his particular mental sewer, though.

What I DON'T believe for one second is that HE believes it's a 'witch hunt' or that 'the Dems are out to get me'. He knows exactly what he's done and knows it was illegal. He just thought he'd get away with it.

Unlike Boris Johnson, who just flat out knows he's lying, I go back and forth with Trump on whether he believes his own lies or not. I sometimes think his mental illness or deterioration of whatever it is is so extreme that he starts out just saying stuff and then ends up believing it. His allies and the people around him, though, I honestly have no idea. I mean, Tucker Carlson, for example, clearly knows better.

Roussette · 15/06/2023 21:18

AcrossthePond55 · 15/06/2023 14:46

So that's his 'plan', eh? What a maroon! But just another example of someone who has never truly come up against a brick wall and/or has been able to cheat/payola his way through life.

It would be interesting to know his actual emotions around this. Does he truly believe he's going to skate through all this because of 'who he is' or is he absolutely terrified because he knows he's finally up against adversaries he can't blackmail, bribe, or intimidate? Not that I'd want to poke around in his particular mental sewer, though.

What I DON'T believe for one second is that HE believes it's a 'witch hunt' or that 'the Dems are out to get me'. He knows exactly what he's done and knows it was illegal. He just thought he'd get away with it.

I can't believe we are replicating this in the UK with Johnson's privileges Committee report.

Witch Hunt! Kangaroo Court!!

We are echoing you Across in a minor way... so far...

OP posts: