Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?

507 replies

colddayinhell · 21/09/2022 20:41

I'm getting very nervous about the ramping up of the war and Putin's calling up of 300,000 reservists. It feels like this is a major escalation. I know that any use of nuclear weapons would mean instant retaliation but it no longer feels like a MAD scenario as it almost feels now like he wants a scorched earth and has nothing to lose and doesn't care that it would destroy everything.

OP posts:
Igotjelly · 24/09/2022 22:01

Taking Putin out might sound great but what’s waiting in the wings to take over isn’t necessarily any better, in some cases it could be far worse.

userxx · 24/09/2022 22:00

I think he will. Should have taken the fucker out at the start.

LemonSwan · 24/09/2022 21:54

Reassuring they don’t hate us and it’s all propaganda.

It’s made me really sad seeing the young men leaving the last few days. I am glad they are and not fighting but why is he doing this! These are his own people he’s sending to a battlefield he created. They are similar age to me and remind me of my male friends.

I am a new mother recently to a son. It’s just - I have no words really. What on earth is he doing!!!

vera99 · 24/09/2022 12:03

I don't think (hope?) that they will and Harold Wilson very wisely stayed out of the Vietnam War in the 60s - something Blair should have followed and Bush even gave him the option to.

Worryingly the Telegraph is leading with an article about how Putin could be replaced with something even worse.

www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2022/09/24/ultra-nationalists-waiting-vladimir-putin-fall/

Arkady Babchenko, a disillusioned Russian opposition journalist living in exile in Ukraine recently predicted a coup or revolution would only replace Putin with a "cannibal."
Babchenko himself is a divisive figure, considered by some to be as radical in his own way as Girkin. He is infamous for attacking the Russian liberal opposition and believes only Ukrainian or American tanks on Red Square will bring down the regime.

Agrudge · 24/09/2022 12:02

Eddieisadick · 21/09/2022 20:43

Yes he might in Ukraine

This is my thinking.

A small tactical nuke . The more he struggles to win ,the more likely he is to use them I think

InconstantMoon · 24/09/2022 11:55

If the US and China get into a serious fighting war the UK should stay the hell out

vera99 · 24/09/2022 11:31

And anyway we really need to be cranking back from seeing China as an enemy or that we could beat them because their tech is shit or some such argument. If we ever go to a serious fighting war with them then we will all be huge losers at best and all dead at worse.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-59600475

vera99 · 24/09/2022 11:19

Justanotherlurker · 22/09/2022 23:26

Putin won't use nukes, he didn't even threaten nukes directly he really isn't that stupid.

As for the person who apparently has knowledge from BAE and has tried to say China has tech that the western world should be wary of is really not coming from anything remotely true.

For instance there latest aircraft carrier that they paraded via CCP channels are rebuilds of 70's soviet tech, the poster shows a deep lack of knowledge of China let alone the cha bu duo mentality that is deep routed in all aspects of chinese industry, if the alledged nephew did work for BAE and wasn't just cleaning the toilets they wouldn't have made such a comment. A simple background check would be looking up the elite forces promoting the recent laser scopes which was pushed via chinese gov chanels as just one of many jokes about the strength of the Chinese

I know everyone has been ignoring them, but there is a slight tilt towards a 50 cent army on here to be aware of. But more likely just a useful idiot.

Well, I'm quoting my nephew there who tells me they were shocked when India says they won 12-0 in tests between BAE jets and Russian jets. And yes Chinese kit is built on a Russian backbone with much better tech and build. He builds the Eurofighter and it's readily believed amongst the workforce apparently.

www.indiatimes.com/news/india/indian-air-force-leaves-uk-pilots-shellshocked-with-120-victory-in-a-2week-training-exercise-243936.html

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 19:37

Raddix · 23/09/2022 18:58

Truman wasn’t mad because the US was the only country that had nukes, which meant no retaliation and a swift end to the war. In the current scenario where multiple countries have nukes and would retaliate, it’s insane to fire them. Mutually assured destruction. Everyone dies.

Yes, the question with Truman is one of morals and of whether using the nuke cost fewer human lives than an invasion would've. Completely different.

GuyMontag · 23/09/2022 19:22

True. It was only foreign civilians that got nuked, from a USA pov. From the point of view of the other side and, actually Russia, it was horrific and barbaric.

Raddix · 23/09/2022 18:58

Truman wasn’t mad because the US was the only country that had nukes, which meant no retaliation and a swift end to the war. In the current scenario where multiple countries have nukes and would retaliate, it’s insane to fire them. Mutually assured destruction. Everyone dies.

GuyMontag · 23/09/2022 16:46

The only leader so far who's ever given the ok to press the button is Harry S Truman and nobody says he's mad.

Agree that the world looks quite different from the Russian POV.

shreddednips · 23/09/2022 15:38

Raddix · 23/09/2022 14:13

Firstly I don't actually think Putin is a 'nutcase'. He just doesn't view the World from a Western perspective
You think someone who would even consider firing a nuclear weapon is sane? It’s guaranteed to lead to worldwide destruction and the deaths of millions if not billions of people, possibly even the end of the human race. Threatening to press the button is not just “not viewing the world from a western perspective”. It’s madness.

I don't necessarily agree that he's mad either. I can see how Putin may think that threatening nuclear use may give him some kind of advantage by making everyone so scared that they give in to what he wants. I can't see any scenario whereby actually using the weapons gives him an advantage.

Even if Putin is actually fully crackers and willing to trigger Armageddon to go out with a bang if he can't get his way, I can't picture that 'I want to start a full-blown nuclear exchange because I'm very cross' is going to cut it with the people he would need to actually launch the weapons.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 14:22

DoYouRememberDiedreBarlow · 23/09/2022 11:09

Also the fact that we have played around with them when they requested to join NATO. I would call it more than indifference. Also as above say they are tectchy after ww2 and the mass starvation.

I said remarkably indifferent not totally indifferent, ie the UK has given Russia and the Russian state's misdemeanours much less attention than we really should've. They have been let away with far, far too much.

I quite understand Russians still being pissed off with the Germans given WW2. But if they want to talk about the Western Allies not doing enough to assist them during that period, assuming this is what you're getting at, there needs to be acknowledgement of the role that the stupidity and venality of the Soviet leadership and their alliance with Hitler at the start of the war contributed to the suffering of the USSR (and indeed some of said Western Allies). The Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union was partially facilitated by the country's own exports from that period. They sold the Nazis the things that were then used to occupy them. But it was convenient for the role of the USSR in the Nazi war machine pre-June 1941 to not be much talked about afterwards, for various reasons.

Igotjelly · 23/09/2022 14:18

Raddix · 23/09/2022 14:13

Firstly I don't actually think Putin is a 'nutcase'. He just doesn't view the World from a Western perspective
You think someone who would even consider firing a nuclear weapon is sane? It’s guaranteed to lead to worldwide destruction and the deaths of millions if not billions of people, possibly even the end of the human race. Threatening to press the button is not just “not viewing the world from a western perspective”. It’s madness.

He has said it, meaning that he's decided that there is something to be gained from the fear such statements cause. There is a big difference between using fear as a weapon and actually firing a nuclear missile.

Acting 'mad' and being 'mad' are very different things.

Raddix · 23/09/2022 14:13

Firstly I don't actually think Putin is a 'nutcase'. He just doesn't view the World from a Western perspective
You think someone who would even consider firing a nuclear weapon is sane? It’s guaranteed to lead to worldwide destruction and the deaths of millions if not billions of people, possibly even the end of the human race. Threatening to press the button is not just “not viewing the world from a western perspective”. It’s madness.

Igotjelly · 23/09/2022 14:07

Frazzled2207 · 23/09/2022 14:02

I am sure those are the sentiments shared by the vast majority of Russians. But we’re dealing an actual nutcase here. And those in high office who disagree with him risk “accidentally”’falling off the top of a tall building.

Firstly I don't actually think Putin is a 'nutcase'. He just doesn't view the World from a Western perspective, and as such actions that may seem rational to you or I wouldn't to him. He has shown time and time again to be very shrewd. That's not to say he hasn't made a massive miscalculation in starting this war or that he is an evil dictator.

Its also worth reading about the 'mad man theory' of foreign policy, most often associated with Richard Nixon.

Secondly it isn't simply a case of Putin pressing some big red button. Yes he has say over when such weapons would be used but there is a clear chain of command and you only have to look to the Cold War to see examples of that chain being broken and individuals using their initiative and disobeying launch orders.

Frazzled2207 · 23/09/2022 14:02

Igotjelly · 23/09/2022 13:58

To put minds a little at ease (or at least so far as what Russia says can be believed) - Russian deputy foreign minister today:

"Moscow is not threatening anyone with nuclear weapons.....open confrontation with NATO and the US is not in Russia's interests"

Another senior Russian official reiterated that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought".

Finally Russian Ambassador to the US stated that he "wants to believe that the US and Russia are not on the verge of falling into the abyss of nuclear war"

I am sure those are the sentiments shared by the vast majority of Russians. But we’re dealing an actual nutcase here. And those in high office who disagree with him risk “accidentally”’falling off the top of a tall building.

Igotjelly · 23/09/2022 13:58

To put minds a little at ease (or at least so far as what Russia says can be believed) - Russian deputy foreign minister today:

"Moscow is not threatening anyone with nuclear weapons.....open confrontation with NATO and the US is not in Russia's interests"

Another senior Russian official reiterated that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought".

Finally Russian Ambassador to the US stated that he "wants to believe that the US and Russia are not on the verge of falling into the abyss of nuclear war"

Wherearemymarbles · 23/09/2022 11:11

No.
I doesnt care about the west but he does about China.
i imagine Xi has hade some very Frank conversations about what happens if he does.

DoYouRememberDiedreBarlow · 23/09/2022 11:09

Also the fact that we have played around with them when they requested to join NATO. I would call it more than indifference. Also as above say they are tectchy after ww2 and the mass starvation.

DogInATent · 23/09/2022 10:59

LemonSwan · 22/09/2022 17:55

Thanks @DogInATent

So your saying putin just wants a giant Russia; the land of which he wants being in Europe?

I still don’t understand why they hate the U.K.? Because we gave Ukraine support? Surely they would know we would in the same way we would have helped Russia if someone tried to invade it. Same we would expect others to support us if someone tried to invade us.

I see from online translations of Russian state tv where crazed military people are making speeches about shaking the unshakable island (us) by sending a nuke. In a way it’s a weird back handed compliment. Is this just a show and dance and that they secretly admire us or do they truly hate us. It’s confusing.

Russia doesn't "hate the UK".
It just sees us as an easy target for propaganda and buying political influence to disrupt the EU (and potentially NATO).

SnowBall86 · 23/09/2022 09:54

i lived in Russia for a while, so I agree with @DogInATent . In order to see what Putin wants just look at the old USSR map. He hates Gorbachev for what he’s done to once great Russian State. Putin feels it’s his purpose and future legacy to re-build Russia on the basis of mixing USSR territorial ambitions with orthodox Christian ideology. He has no intention whatsoever to go any further than that. Neither does he have any funds or military to do so.

@LemonSwan the west is as much of a collective name as Eastern European. Russia doesn’t hate the west. Russian elite used to speak French (before USSR that is), Russians tend to send their children to study abroad and they are particularly in awe of the Uk (especially the monarchy). When I was in Russia I was told numerous times that “the west” doesn’t want to see Russia prosper but to destabilise it and then break it apart… to take the resources, to weaken its international presence. So it’s not hatred, it’s mainly fear.

TakeawayManAlan · 23/09/2022 07:03

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 06:59

The UK has been remarkably indifferent to Russia and Russian influence, to our cost.

This. Madness to say anything other

Reeks of Russki propaganda

TakeawayManAlan · 23/09/2022 07:02

Celia24 · 22/09/2022 23:37

Open your eyes - the west hates Russia. Has done for decades. You hear the rhetoric from countless politicians, the public, even our BBC TV shows have been steeped in anti Russian storylines for years.

I can't stand the man but let's not play innocent either.

“We” (read - our dodgy elite and leaders) have liked them enough to let them murder our people (the novochok shit and MH17) and accepted their “investments”.

They own half of London and huge chunks or many of our large companies

Swipe left for the next trending thread