Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?

507 replies

colddayinhell · 21/09/2022 20:41

I'm getting very nervous about the ramping up of the war and Putin's calling up of 300,000 reservists. It feels like this is a major escalation. I know that any use of nuclear weapons would mean instant retaliation but it no longer feels like a MAD scenario as it almost feels now like he wants a scorched earth and has nothing to lose and doesn't care that it would destroy everything.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 07:22

InPraiseOfBacchus · 21/09/2022 22:16

Oh, I agree - my point is that they're entirely not rational - but that they're unlikely to be sentimental types in this kind of situation.

The fact that the people around Putin must be hard headed and ruthless to have got to that rank is exactly why they're not going to be up for using nukes. Starting down that path is almost the ultimate in sentiment, in that it's putting ideology and in this case pride and shame ahead of any sensible considerations. Or indeed self interest.

And that's always the way with nuclear weapons. You launch one, you're risking your own life, those of everyone you love (this is true even for those whose families don't live in Russia) and everything you know and value. There's no General Melchett option in that situation.

Also, for the people talking about the ethics of sacrificing Ukraine to Putin for peace and an easy life, that's moot anyway because it isn't one of the options on the table. We've already tried appeasement. The West let Putin away with two land wars in Europe, interference in domestic politics, various assassinations and attempted assassinations on our soil. It didn't work.

ladydimitrescu · 22/09/2022 07:13

kirstywursty012 · 21/09/2022 20:53

There's a great TikTok account called "countdaedalus" - he's a very rational (albeit a little bit grumpy!) guy and calmly and logically describes the Ukraine war and any potential outcomes. What many people don't realise is that there are satellites constantly watching Putin's rockets. If the hatch was so much to open, the retaliation would be be global. It's also not just up to it Putin - there is a process in launching nuclear weapons and a number of generals need to be on board for it to happen.

Also he really isn't stupid - he has a lot to lose with nuclear war and so does China (his closest ally). For example China has number of cities protected by a HUGE dam - a simple missile attack there could put millions of Chinese people underwater.

Please try not to to worry and don't read the news! You just need a quick daily glance to be well informed - don't obsess over it. Putin is doing really badly in the Ukraine war and is just trying to save face and look tough.

Thank you for this x

GuyMontag · 22/09/2022 07:09

No. No point because no one would 'win' and he being neither stupid nor crazy knows this.

The only country that's ever used nuclear weapons is the USA. Even the USSR (as was) didn't, including when their own systems told them to.

Igotjelly · 22/09/2022 07:07

Cosmos123 · 22/09/2022 07:05

He believes if there is no Putin then there will be no world.

Simple.

Do yes he will use Nuclear weapons.
He does have followers who will do as he instructs just like Hitler had.

The West are very good at winding him up.

What utter bollocks! The West are not ‘winding him up’ 🙄🙄 Gaslighting at its finest.

Cosmos123 · 22/09/2022 07:05

He believes if there is no Putin then there will be no world.

Simple.

Do yes he will use Nuclear weapons.
He does have followers who will do as he instructs just like Hitler had.

The West are very good at winding him up.

SweetLittlePixie · 22/09/2022 06:59

Doubtful. Ukraine is so close to Russia he would be destroying his own country too. They arent very well equipped with bunkers, so it would be really stupid. Then again nobody can say for sure.
i just keep telling myself tht its not gonna happen. No point in being scared of what ifs that you cant change.

VanishingViolet · 22/09/2022 06:55

Wish someone would take Putin out, someone on the inside must be itching to do it! but who would be the next leader?

Muddays · 22/09/2022 03:21

Putin was being used by his so-called allies as a test cattle prod to the west, he failed to destroy and consume, despite momentarily stunning the herd, who are now tougher, stronger and more aware and confident than ever. Watch how quickly his 'allies' queue up to stab him in the back and try to take his place. Putin is finished and nuclear threats just make him look more pathetic. Like a flea riddled starving rat waving a twig in front of a wolf.

Furries · 22/09/2022 02:55

@Bus5 - I’m going to apologise for my above post. I responded before reading the rest of the thread (I should know better by now!).

I’m sorry you’re feeling that way with young children and anxiety - it can’t be easy and it’s understandable. AIBU can be a harsh place to post, so maybe just bear that in mind - that’s not a criticism of your post, just a heads up that you might get jumped on (which I did).

Anyway, there have been a few good posts on here offering views as to why it’s unlikely, hopefully they give a small measure of comfort. Personally, I’m going with the “their kit isn’t up to scratch” approach and ploughing my way through the never-ending stuff that needs to be done in the house/garden etc. I find getting pissed off with endless chores is a good distraction!

kirstywursty012 · 22/09/2022 02:49

Russia will be far more successful playing the long game of rocketing inflation in the west and high energy prices - I’d actually be more concerned about China invading Taiwan where 90% of microchips are made.

That teamed with the current cost of living crisis would make any form of comfortable living completely inaccessible for the majority of people in the west.

I believe Putin is playing the long game - Russia are like Vietnam where they just have so many troops to sacrifice. His military equipment is old so he will just drag this out as long as the rest of the world suffers economically.

Starting nuclear war, creating an everlasting nuclear winter and destroying the lifestyle his oligarch backers enjoy isn’t the plan.

TakeawayManAlan · 22/09/2022 02:46

Bus5 · 21/09/2022 22:38

Sadly, if it meant keeping my children alive then yes I would. My priority is my family first and foremost. I wish we didn't get involved in all of this in the first place.

Naive and quite frankly pathetic post

Give your head a shake

Furries · 22/09/2022 02:34

Bus5 · 21/09/2022 22:38

Sadly, if it meant keeping my children alive then yes I would. My priority is my family first and foremost. I wish we didn't get involved in all of this in the first place.

🤦🏻‍♀️

Ladybyrd · 22/09/2022 02:26

If the US keeps helping Ukraine then yes, I have NO doubt he will. The US needs to back off.

The value of the dollar has shot up again today. Funny that.

Furries · 22/09/2022 02:26

Cosmos123 · 21/09/2022 21:45

He will.

He has nothing to lose.
If he goes down he will make sure the rest go down with him.

🙄

Furries · 22/09/2022 02:22

Hopefully he’s too busy writing condolence letters to the families of people who have fallen out of windows, fallen down stairs, drowned in swimming pools, etc.

Surely there has to come a point where even his most ardent supporters think “wtf”?

Mojitoo · 22/09/2022 02:11

I work on the basis that Putin is usually five moves ahead. An off-ramp is essential.

londonrach · 22/09/2022 02:05

I hope not. I see a mad man cornered and losing and that worries me. I just hope not. We have to stand and support Ukraine in this

Mojitoo · 22/09/2022 02:05

blueshoes · 21/09/2022 23:28

Whataboutery. Yawn

Whatever you think about the post and it's place in this thread, that is one fucking hollow-souled comment.

blueshoes · 22/09/2022 01:22

BlodynGwyn · 22/09/2022 01:04

If the US keeps helping Ukraine then yes, I have NO doubt he will. The US needs to back off.

Just the US? It is not just the US arming Ukraine. The Western world is pretty united on this front. It is not NATO either. It is not US/NATO against Russia. That is Russian rhetoric.

shreddednips · 22/09/2022 01:18

Sixtyfourteen · 22/09/2022 00:38

RTT? A poster said that if Putin uses a (as in one) nuclear weapon, then Russia will be flattened. I don't think that would happen. Flattening Russia wouldn't benefit anyone. The usual thoughtless gung ho rhetoric. We need actual grown- ups holding sensible negotiations.

No, I don't think that is what would happen. It would depend on where he decided to strike, but assuming it was a low-yield strike somewhere unpopulated- the basis of the RAND war games I've looked at- then NATO would have to think strategically about how to respond. In the scenarios described, the responses considered were proportionate, not necessarily lobbing everything we have at Russia in any and all scenarios.

This is not to say that there are any scenarios where the use of nuclear weapons wouldn't be a disaster- it is extremely dangerous for any country to get the idea that 'limited' nuclear use could ever be something to be contemplated to achieve a result.

BlodynGwyn · 22/09/2022 01:04

If the US keeps helping Ukraine then yes, I have NO doubt he will. The US needs to back off.

AuntTwacky · 22/09/2022 01:01

No

blueshoes · 22/09/2022 00:59

notdaddycool · 22/09/2022 00:44

On one level I think there are 1,000,001 different things that could go wrong from it not launching to it being shot down over their territory leaving them to deal with the fall out. Rationally having seen how awful their equipment is he shouldn’t do it, but he’s not exactly rational. I think the chances of him doing it are small, the chances of him doing it ‘successfully’ - in his terms - are tiny.

My last post was meant to quote notdaddycool.

blueshoes · 22/09/2022 00:54

blueshoes · 22/09/2022 00:53

That is the kind of rhetoric I would expect from crazed putin propagandists. I would file all such statements in that box.

See failed launch of Russian air defence missile in Ukraine. Won't fancy a nuclear missle boomeranging back on Russian oil.

blueshoes · 22/09/2022 00:53

Sixtyfourteen · 22/09/2022 00:38

RTT? A poster said that if Putin uses a (as in one) nuclear weapon, then Russia will be flattened. I don't think that would happen. Flattening Russia wouldn't benefit anyone. The usual thoughtless gung ho rhetoric. We need actual grown- ups holding sensible negotiations.

That is the kind of rhetoric I would expect from crazed putin propagandists. I would file all such statements in that box.

Swipe left for the next trending thread