Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?

507 replies

colddayinhell · 21/09/2022 20:41

I'm getting very nervous about the ramping up of the war and Putin's calling up of 300,000 reservists. It feels like this is a major escalation. I know that any use of nuclear weapons would mean instant retaliation but it no longer feels like a MAD scenario as it almost feels now like he wants a scorched earth and has nothing to lose and doesn't care that it would destroy everything.

OP posts:
colouringindoors · 22/09/2022 12:35

It is possible, but from everything I've read I believe it's unlikely. As others have said, latest speeches are just as much for the Russian audience as the West. Despite extensive state propoganda there are many in Russia who don't support the war. The very bravest of these have been protesting in Russia (and getting beaten and arrested).

For those who say Let him have Ukraine, sorry you're delusional if you think Putin would stop there.

I take comfort in the fact that the Ukraine offensive has destroyed much of the Russian army's military hardware (which had not been well maintained) and sadly thousands of young Russian men (inc conscripts) have lost their lives as a result of Putin's lust for power. I would be surprised if their nuclear arsenal was in good condition.

ScarlettnotOHara · 22/09/2022 12:32

Isn’t awful we have to live in fear of nuclear war 😞 trying to keep the news off from the kids, I have one particularly anxious teenage son. I bet the ordinary people in Russia are panicking too.

vera99 · 22/09/2022 12:30

TBH China is embarrassed by Russia which has very little high-tech capacity or manufacturing apart from its mineral reserves but is quite happy to have whatever Russia wants to sell at a discount (as does our 'ally' India who also buys Russian arms because they are cheaper). But if the current situation prevails then they will no doubt be happy to have Russia as a servile client state. Business is business after all. My nephew who works at Bae making the Eurofighter says that Russian aviation tech is as good if not better than ours if a little clunky but says that China's military high tech trumps them all.

So it's looking sadly that if climate change or a new pandemic doesn't finish us off then war will be the one to do it. There are multiple flash points between the superpowers all over the place and at some point one of them is going to blow.

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:20

The bigger picture here is the desire for a Russia-China led new world order

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:19

I'm not saying China would be happy about a nuclear exchange but they don't want to see Russia lose

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:18

China certainly haven't spoken out against the war in any vociferous way and their words about not escalating (let the parties talk) is a toothless facade. What is happening with Russia sets a dangerous precedent for the indo-pacific which is also unstable. China's interests are tightly aligned with Russia against the west

notimagain · 22/09/2022 12:13

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 12:01

Yep, exactly this.

Not really exactly this at all...yes the Russian conventional capability is screwed but this thread isn't about that capability and that's not what people seem to be worrying about.

I certainly it's highly misleading to try and give the impression all would be OK for Britain because you " don't see him having the resources to 'drop bombs' on London anytime soon."

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 12:13

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:11

The chance of that happening though is even slimmer than the chance of Puting sending nukes. His equipment, men, morale, weaponry is failing miserably in Ukraine so I don't see him having the resources to 'drop bombs' on London anytime soon.

But what about if China got involved and if the China-Russia-Iran axis consolidated against the West?

China itself has began speaking out against the war/escalation. They certainly don't want a nuclear war or for the war as it stands to go on and on and on.

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:11

The chance of that happening though is even slimmer than the chance of Puting sending nukes. His equipment, men, morale, weaponry is failing miserably in Ukraine so I don't see him having the resources to 'drop bombs' on London anytime soon.

But what about if China got involved and if the China-Russia-Iran axis consolidated against the West?

vera99 · 22/09/2022 12:05

The National Trust is a Nazi Trust smash the National Trust!

(you had to be involved in anti-fascist action in the 70s to get that one!)

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 22/09/2022 12:03

I hope not, I've just renewed our National Trust membership and if there is a nuclear holocaust that'll be money down the drain. Sad

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 12:01

vera99 · 22/09/2022 11:59

Yes but the Nazis had widespread German and Austrian support, some of the best military technology in the world bar none and a country that was late to the western colonial carve-up so wanted a piece of the imperialist action. Russia can't even hold the parts of Ukraine they already have and is expending vast amounts of weaponry and manpower - they have no capability or appetite to widen their horizons of that we can be certain.

Yep, exactly this.

vera99 · 22/09/2022 11:59

Yes but the Nazis had widespread German and Austrian support, some of the best military technology in the world bar none and a country that was late to the western colonial carve-up so wanted a piece of the imperialist action. Russia can't even hold the parts of Ukraine they already have and is expending vast amounts of weaponry and manpower - they have no capability or appetite to widen their horizons of that we can be certain.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 11:57

notimagain · 22/09/2022 11:55

One of the above comments brought to mind a speech from 1938 (before even I was born) and a much more recent Madeline Albright tweet:

"British PM Neville Chamberlain in 1938 called the conflict between Nazi Germany and my native Czechoslovakia a "quarrel in a far away country, between people of whom we know nothing.”

Less than two years later, the Nazis were bombing London."

....

Yes, this is the problem with the argument about choosing our own security now over Ukraine. Those are not actually the options we are picking from.

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 11:57

notimagain · 22/09/2022 11:55

One of the above comments brought to mind a speech from 1938 (before even I was born) and a much more recent Madeline Albright tweet:

"British PM Neville Chamberlain in 1938 called the conflict between Nazi Germany and my native Czechoslovakia a "quarrel in a far away country, between people of whom we know nothing.”

Less than two years later, the Nazis were bombing London."

....

Well I'd sooner cross that bridge if we came to it than encourage a wholly avoidable nuclear war.

The chance of that happening though is even slimmer than the chance of Puting sending nukes. His equipment, men, morale, weaponry is failing miserably in Ukraine so I don't see him having the resources to 'drop bombs' on London anytime soon.

notimagain · 22/09/2022 11:55

One of the above comments brought to mind a speech from 1938 (before even I was born) and a much more recent Madeline Albright tweet:

"British PM Neville Chamberlain in 1938 called the conflict between Nazi Germany and my native Czechoslovakia a "quarrel in a far away country, between people of whom we know nothing.”

Less than two years later, the Nazis were bombing London."

....

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 11:52

Igotjelly · 22/09/2022 11:44

"some unknown people abroad" - Jesus wept!

If Ukraine falls then no one is safe, they are fighting (valiantly) for us all.

Not everyone is a self-centred arsehole, you can't speak for us all.

They are unknown people abroad though, however you wrap it up.

They are fighting valiantly yes, but let's not pretend it's for anybodies sake but their own.

Thinking of your own children before somebody else's isn't being a self centred arsehole. You bring children into the world under the assumption that you'll do everything in your power to protect them. They are not collateral so you can puff out your chest and show people how brave you are for standing up to a a dictator thousands of miles away.

It's just frustrating to read when it isn't the reality of how people feel, not really.

Hypothetically ofc: if Putin turned up at your door and said if you let me blow your children up then I'll leave Ukraine alone, you'd say yes? Come on.

MindYourBeeswax · 22/09/2022 11:48

Thanks for that@Parkingmoan1 Nice for us to have our thoughts referred to as bullshit and something "intrinsically wrong" with us.
Have you ever read about the bravery of ordinary people-including mothers-in wartime or do you think all mothers are appeasers. Even mothers in WW! sent their sons to the front, knowing there was a high risk of death. Mothers let their children join the army and go to dangerous places.
All those who urged Kenndey not to give in during the Cuba Nuclear Crisis-nutter were they?
Must have been something wrong with them I suppose.

Still, your post will give comfort to Putin supporters so job done!

JasonWaterfalls · 22/09/2022 11:45

China did not just buy up the world’s minerals for Putin to fuck this up for them, imo. So no, I think he’d be taken out before nuclear.

Igotjelly · 22/09/2022 11:44

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 11:42

On this thread there have been several posters (with whom I agree) saying that they would rather be dead in a nuclear attack than cede Ukraine or even give an inch of it to Putin

I'm sorry, this isn't intended as a personal attack as you said that several share the sentiment but I'm calling BS on this. This is a site made up largely of women mothers.

No woman/mother I know, or have ever known, would choose to be killed in a nuclear attack and accept that fate for her children, as opposed to accepting that Ukraine may fall to Putin.

If anybody does genuinely feel that way then there's something intrinsically wrong with them. You'd be mad to prioritise some unknown people abroad above your own flesh and blood. Youe own babies, parents. Stop it with the silliness.

"some unknown people abroad" - Jesus wept!

If Ukraine falls then no one is safe, they are fighting (valiantly) for us all.

Not everyone is a self-centred arsehole, you can't speak for us all.

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 11:42

On this thread there have been several posters (with whom I agree) saying that they would rather be dead in a nuclear attack than cede Ukraine or even give an inch of it to Putin

I'm sorry, this isn't intended as a personal attack as you said that several share the sentiment but I'm calling BS on this. This is a site made up largely of women mothers.

No woman/mother I know, or have ever known, would choose to be killed in a nuclear attack and accept that fate for her children, as opposed to accepting that Ukraine may fall to Putin.

If anybody does genuinely feel that way then there's something intrinsically wrong with them. You'd be mad to prioritise some unknown people abroad above your own flesh and blood. Youe own babies, parents. Stop it with the silliness.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 11:41

MindYourBeeswax · 22/09/2022 11:33

On this thread there have been several posters (with whom I agree) saying that they would rather be dead in a nuclear attack than cede Ukraine or even give an inch of it to Putin.
Everyone on our terrace is putting up a Ukraine flag this weekend in a small effort to show that we would rather see that flag on top of rubble, as one neighbour said a sign of courage-than be alive and be cowards.
So, I don't know if Putin is mad or not but it's not beyond the possibility that he would rather die than give in-as several people on Mumsnet and throughout the UK feel the same.

We just have to be brave, hope and have faith in our own courage. Put up our flag and the Ukrainian flag this weekend as a sign that we won't give in no matter what the consequences or the price.

What you are not taking into account is that we already know enough about Putin's mindset and behaviour not to have to base our views on how other people might behave.

We know he's very keen on his own survival because of how he responded to covid. We know there have already been multiple occasions during this war when he's been losing face significantly and still not chosen to use nuclear weapons: the Kiev debacle, for example. It makes sense to interpret his behaviour through what we already know about it.

Certainly agree the West shouldn't be backing down though. Doing so now will only make it more dangerous once he tries this again because this one concession wasn't enough. He isn't the sort of person appeasement is going to work on.

MindYourBeeswax · 22/09/2022 11:37

no doubt, Putin has people monitoring social media sites like this one and it's no bad thing that they get the loud and clear message that Ukraine is a hill we're willing to die on.

GasPanic · 22/09/2022 11:34

Doubt whether he would go for a full nuclear exchange, but he is pretty much cornered, and when you corner people they are likely to react in dangerous and unpredictable ways.

I don't think the idea that he would use a tactical/battlefield nuclear device is entirely out of the question. But if he did, that probably would be it for him.

Atm if he stopped the war quickly and went for peace then within a couple of years the west would be back on speaking terms with him.

If he lets off a tactical nuke then there is no way that would happen, Russia would become a pariah state like North Korea and would only return to the fold if Putin was removed and even then probably only after many years.

The gamble for him is probably whether the consequences in world terms of letting off a nuke are outweighed by the benefits(?) he would get from it in terms of political support on home soil. I have no clue what these (potential) benefits are.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 11:33

The way the Russians have treated the Ukrainians is absolutely Taliban moral territory yes. Bears more than a passing resemblance to the Nazis before they managed to achieve industrialised genocide too. Deliberate massacres of non combatants, stealing children away from their parents, starvation, rape, targeting hospitals... this is a million miles away from day to day life being the same just with a different flag.