Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?

507 replies

colddayinhell · 21/09/2022 20:41

I'm getting very nervous about the ramping up of the war and Putin's calling up of 300,000 reservists. It feels like this is a major escalation. I know that any use of nuclear weapons would mean instant retaliation but it no longer feels like a MAD scenario as it almost feels now like he wants a scorched earth and has nothing to lose and doesn't care that it would destroy everything.

OP posts:
Theorema · 22/09/2022 14:20

Even the most idealistic Putin supporter isn't stupid enough to think that a Russian launch won't result in retaliatory strikes from the US, UK and probably Israel (who won't exactly be keen to see their main supporters be taken off the map)

A launch at the US would result in mutual destruction. But a smaller strategic strike on the likes of us, may not.

The rest of the world will be shocked and terrified that he’s actually gone there.

They won’t actually sacrifice the lives of millions of their own people in retaliation regardless of NATO agreements.

Raddix · 22/09/2022 14:10

I’m terrified. Putin is elderly and supposedly dying of cancer or something. He has nothing to lose. And he’s arrogant enough to take everyone else with him. He doesn’t care if it ends up as scorched earth, he’s no worse off because he’s dying anyway.

VoiceaFromUranus · 22/09/2022 14:08

I don't think Putin is that desperate to get himself assassinated.

Given the number of oligarchs who've had "accidents" recently and the Western sanctions, he can't be keeping too many friends on his side.

Even the most idealistic Putin supporter isn't stupid enough to think that a Russian launch won't result in retaliatory strikes from the US, UK and probably Israel (who won't exactly be keen to see their main supporters be taken off the map)

LoveLarry · 22/09/2022 14:02

StrawberryRed · 22/09/2022 11:24

I could be very wrong but Putin never mentioned Nuclear weapons, it was a western interpretation. Though it was a deliberate case of "saying it without saying it", his team can easily say that they didn't threaten to use Nuclear weapons and its the west frothing up Nuclear talk.

I do understand the need to not let dictators invade and take countries however how important is this if the cultures match? Like England and Scotland - if Scotland had independence and then England took it back, is it worth a war if day to day life looks the same? This is not the same as the Taliban and the Nazis - is it?

Leaving aside the issue of cultures, which you clearly don't know anything about I would say that the russians are very much behaving like nazis.

And the taliban, for that matter

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 13:58

Sixtyfourteen · 22/09/2022 13:39

Every British prime minister wants a war. It makes them popular. It makes them feel important and powerful. Like a real leader. Thatcher, Tony Blair, Cameron. Of course Boris Johnson wanted a war too. Probably more than any of the others. He sees himself as a new Churchill. So he latched onto the war in Ukraine, and did everything he could to make it his war and to milk it for personal popularity. If that puts the UK in danger - so what? It's Boris Johnson who matters.

UK military support for Ukraine was entrenched long before Johnson. It's happened over multiple PMs now, we've been training their troops since 2014. Support for Ukraine is a broad consensus issue in UK politics and there is no PM we could realistically have who wouldn't have responded in the same way.

Johnson has certainly sought to make political capital out of UK support for Ukraine, but the idea that this is something he as an individual dragged us into is actually applying the same bullshit logic that he did when he tried to take personal credit for institutional and consensus based British support. Don't be fooled. It's never been about him, he just wanted to pretend it was.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 22/09/2022 13:58

I think there might be a time window to turn it around from the Russian people and Putins insiders. Where they get wise to what is really going on and actively fight back.
My worry is the propaganda. Putin could literally starve his own people, blame it on us to give them a reason to want to be against us too.
Radicalisation has to start somewhere. Its already happened with his insiders, and now he is radicalising his own people. Suicide bombers mentality doesnt just happen spontaneously, but what if he said fight or starve, and it is the wests fault?
Has he already got a suicide bomber mindset?
The media is to blame for a lot.
I for one thought it very clever the huge show made for Queen Elizabeth. Clever editing, camera angles and deliberate long queues (including shaming individuals) showed the world that we are united despite the shambles of our politics.
Its all media hype on both sides.
If we could only show Russian people the truth. But what country really gets that from the media?

CrunchyCarrot · 22/09/2022 13:49

Maybe the nuclear threat from Putin is just a smokescreen, he may instead use chemical or biological weapons, he seems to like those. So whilst we are all distracted and stressed over nukes, he's got something else up his sleeve. As a PP said, there's a constant watch by the West on all of Putin's missile sites. So it's pretty useless launching one without it being shot down immediately.

Then there's what he said about having some weapons that are more modern than those of NATO. Doesn't mean those are nuclear weapons.

Sixtyfourteen · 22/09/2022 13:39

Every British prime minister wants a war. It makes them popular. It makes them feel important and powerful. Like a real leader. Thatcher, Tony Blair, Cameron. Of course Boris Johnson wanted a war too. Probably more than any of the others. He sees himself as a new Churchill. So he latched onto the war in Ukraine, and did everything he could to make it his war and to milk it for personal popularity. If that puts the UK in danger - so what? It's Boris Johnson who matters.

Heyheyitsanotherday · 22/09/2022 13:18

I needed to read this. Thank you 💗

vera99 · 22/09/2022 13:15

America has now partially lost the Korean War, The Vietnam War, The War in Iraq and the War in Afghanistan if they seriously think they could take on China then they are stark raving mad. China thinks in decades and whilst we were pursuing fringe Islamic nutters in fly-blown countries they were patiently building first-world infrastructure and buying up decades-long mineral contracts with numerous countries. The age of America as the undisputed top of the tree superpower is coming to a close and with have to share that spot with China and to a lesser extent India.

RoachTheHorse · 22/09/2022 13:15

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:58

We have a nuclear response too

I had to share this screenshot. As I was reading your comment this was the image below. Took me a moment to realise it was an ad and you weren't making a random point 🤣

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 13:04

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:52

Yes I think we have to hope against hope that it IS a blow to their Taiwan ambitions because Russia's success - or, more worryingly, successful use of a nuclear weapon - is a green light and a dangerous precedent in more ways than one

Oh, it's definitely a blow. For multiple reasons. It's made clear that the West won't automatically be ok with invasions of neighbours and that there's a line being drawn. Putin was pretty obviously hoping that the Western response to the Taliban retaking Afghanistan would become the new norm, but it hasn't. It has strengthened NATO and also got both the US and Japan talking more about defence of Taiwan. It's made it clear that it's really difficult to conquer a country that has a modern army and weapons, even if you have a lot of resources yourselves. There are people questioning whether that's ever going to be possible again now.

It's also made people question assumptions about large armies in militarised autocracies being difficult to defeat. The Russian military were seen as something to fear because they were good at terrorising defenceless civilians, but this is a different game altogether. So would Taiwan be. The Chinese might have a large and expensive army too, but they haven't engaged in much conventional warfare recently. There can't be many veterans of the Sino Vietnamese war left, not that it was exactly a resounding victory for them anyway, and a few skirmishes and peacekeeping aren't remotely comparable. The mystique of big expensive armies with lots of tanks in authoritarian states has been damaged.

Parkingmoan1 · 22/09/2022 13:00

Theorema · 22/09/2022 12:56

Late to this but YANBU.

i don’t think there will be a nuclear holocaust BUT I do think Putin will use a strategic nuke.

There has been repeated talk in Russia about how easy it would be to wipe the UK off the map.

I think there’s a good chance that Putin will use his strategic nuke on us. Yes we are part of NATO and any nuclear attack on us should mean an instant nuclear retaliation from the USA.

But realistically, that retaliation won’t happen because the USA will not sacrifice millions of American lives on our behalf. Logically, there’s just no way they’d condemn their entire population to certain death because the same thing had been done to us, a small country a long way from them.

The USA has more sense than the UK then.

Fancy putting all of us at risk in this way when we're this irrelevant small little country that should be minding its business.

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:58

Wouldn't have to wait for US

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:58

We have a nuclear response too

Theorema · 22/09/2022 12:56

Late to this but YANBU.

i don’t think there will be a nuclear holocaust BUT I do think Putin will use a strategic nuke.

There has been repeated talk in Russia about how easy it would be to wipe the UK off the map.

I think there’s a good chance that Putin will use his strategic nuke on us. Yes we are part of NATO and any nuclear attack on us should mean an instant nuclear retaliation from the USA.

But realistically, that retaliation won’t happen because the USA will not sacrifice millions of American lives on our behalf. Logically, there’s just no way they’d condemn their entire population to certain death because the same thing had been done to us, a small country a long way from them.

vera99 · 22/09/2022 12:55

The greed of western capitalism that bet huge on investing in China building state-of-the-art factories over decades (Tesla has the world's biggest Gigafactory there as does Boeing amongst countless others !) as is probably the device you are reading this on knew no bounds. China can turn round now and stays thanks for all of that now politely fuck off... which is why the west won't turn on China anytime soon.

Lenin wrote, “When it comes time to hang the capitalists, they will vie with each other for the rope contract.”

Indeed Jacob Rees-Mogg's Hedge Fund has bet big on China - it would seem that morals are for the little people.

www.ft.com/content/0b08fcfa-e0bc-4c9b-8f5d-5c69db2da32c

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:52

Yes I think we have to hope against hope that it IS a blow to their Taiwan ambitions because Russia's success - or, more worryingly, successful use of a nuclear weapon - is a green light and a dangerous precedent in more ways than one

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 12:50

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:43

I don't think China would back nuclear use and agree they'd dissuade but the longer term picture is an alliance there that's against the west

Which isn't new really. One positive thing to come out of this tragic debacle is that the China-Russia pairing are strategically weaker than they were previously. Although I don't discount that China might eventually be able to balance some of the disadvantage and the blow to their Taiwanese ambitions with Russia being more their bitch than previously.

Bearsan · 22/09/2022 12:45

No he's threatening nuclear weapons to try to look tough. He's a failure and the whole world knows it.
A bit like a school bully who's been shown up by a smaller kid and is now going to fetch his dad.

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 12:43

I don't think China would back nuclear use and agree they'd dissuade but the longer term picture is an alliance there that's against the west

colouringindoors · 22/09/2022 12:39

"The Kremlin will allow the Russian military to incur huge losses. The Pentagon estimates that up to 80,000 Russian soldiers have already been killed or wounded in the war. This is more than the Soviets lost in ten years of fighting in Afghanistan. Russia has also sacrificed a colossal amount of equipment, including more than 1,700 tanks (equivalent to 65 per cent of its pre-war inventory); 4,000 armoured vehicles; and 200 aircraft. For example, in a single battle in Bilohorivka in May, Russia lost almost 1,000 soldiers and nearly 100 pieces of equipment while trying to cross the Siverskyi Donets River."

Interesting article about Russian military and weakness of Russian military logistics.

www.google.com/amp/s/ecfr.eu/article/lessons-for-the-west-russias-military-failures-in-ukraine/%3famp

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 12:37

There is not a chance in hell that China would back Russia using a nuclear weapon, any attempt to influence him would go the other way. Their conspicuous failure to offer any public support has, amongst other things, made it quite clear how the Chinese regime feel about this situation. And the Iranian regime have their own problems at present.

vera99 · 22/09/2022 12:36

The first CND march I went on had 500 folks in 1978 I seem to remember but in the next 2 years went from that to 100s of thousands and of course the Greenham Common women's camp. Hopefully, youth will find their voice and soon it's their future after all.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenham_Common_Women%27s_Peace_Camp