Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think Putin will use nuclear weapons?

507 replies

colddayinhell · 21/09/2022 20:41

I'm getting very nervous about the ramping up of the war and Putin's calling up of 300,000 reservists. It feels like this is a major escalation. I know that any use of nuclear weapons would mean instant retaliation but it no longer feels like a MAD scenario as it almost feels now like he wants a scorched earth and has nothing to lose and doesn't care that it would destroy everything.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 06:59

The UK has been remarkably indifferent to Russia and Russian influence, to our cost.

AhaLynn · 23/09/2022 01:33

Well they have their own repercussions from Stalingrad and when used as a buffer to hold Germany back in WW2.

Celia24 · 23/09/2022 01:00

@LemonSwan I think we can agree and disagree. The Russiaphobic attitude didn't begin with Salisbury. We are culpable as well.

I agree from the point of view that most people are alike rather than different. After all this is coming from oligarchs, not the Russian people themselves on the whole - just look at the footage last few days of Russians trying to flee Moscow.

However, I was a teacher in international schools for years and spent time teaching Russian kids. There were cultural differences between the Russians versus the European kids. Putin has fought quite hard to keep Western culture out of Russia. Interestingly I taught older teens and almost all of them cited Putin as their role model. I had never experienced anything like that

LemonSwan · 23/09/2022 00:28

@Celia24

Well yeah sure Russia has had some bad press. Can’t imagine any other reaction to the Salisbury incident.

Sure they have the dodgy business men / corrupt oligarchs etc.

But really apart from when they are assassinating people and putting them in suitcases or stabbing them with umbrellas; no one really gives a fuck.

You know they are just like us. They are very western. Culturally very similar. A bit fucking crazy too. A normal day in Russia subreddit has given me many a belly laugh and joyful moment. It’s just sad the way this is happening. As the saying goes there is more that unites us than divides us and I am not all fluffy duffy and apply that to all countries. There’s plenty of countries we are more different to than similar. Russia really isn’t one of them.

Hillsmakeyoustrong · 23/09/2022 00:01

No.

Celia24 · 22/09/2022 23:37

LemonSwan · 21/09/2022 23:46

I knew the queens funeral would rattle him. The thought of every country, all these leaders gathering and praising this woman when who will be remembered positively in history and that deep down he knows he won’t be because of what he has done. I thought he might reflect on that and give pause for thought but he’s done the opposite.

What I really can’t get my head around is how much they hate Britain and Europe. Calling us the west. I just don’t understand it because they are the west too. I know they don’t see themselves as that but if I am categorising them they are going in the Europe, USA, Britain box as opposed to the China, Asia or Africa box. It’s bizarre.

Open your eyes - the west hates Russia. Has done for decades. You hear the rhetoric from countless politicians, the public, even our BBC TV shows have been steeped in anti Russian storylines for years.

I can't stand the man but let's not play innocent either.

Queuesarasarah · 22/09/2022 23:32

No I don’t and even if he would I would imagine his generals would disobey the order.

Justanotherlurker · 22/09/2022 23:26

Putin won't use nukes, he didn't even threaten nukes directly he really isn't that stupid.

As for the person who apparently has knowledge from BAE and has tried to say China has tech that the western world should be wary of is really not coming from anything remotely true.

For instance there latest aircraft carrier that they paraded via CCP channels are rebuilds of 70's soviet tech, the poster shows a deep lack of knowledge of China let alone the cha bu duo mentality that is deep routed in all aspects of chinese industry, if the alledged nephew did work for BAE and wasn't just cleaning the toilets they wouldn't have made such a comment. A simple background check would be looking up the elite forces promoting the recent laser scopes which was pushed via chinese gov chanels as just one of many jokes about the strength of the Chinese

I know everyone has been ignoring them, but there is a slight tilt towards a 50 cent army on here to be aware of. But more likely just a useful idiot.

Bus5 · 22/09/2022 22:33

Raddix · 22/09/2022 14:10

I’m terrified. Putin is elderly and supposedly dying of cancer or something. He has nothing to lose. And he’s arrogant enough to take everyone else with him. He doesn’t care if it ends up as scorched earth, he’s no worse off because he’s dying anyway.

Please don't read too much into that. Nothing has been confirmed. I must have read about three or four different ailments he's supposedly dying from and that's ontop of the supposed assassination attempt he had recently.

I've been scared too but trying to keep perspective. When you go outside your door tomorrow you will see that the world is still turning, not to undermine the seriousness of the situation but the hoo-ha you see online isn't representative of the whole picture. Try not to get sucked in to threads like this too much as knowledgeable posters aside there will always be some people who revel in stoking up fear.

People are milling about as they usually would, not clambering to get on planes out of here. I'm only saying this because it's what I needed to hear too.

I had to have a complete media detox back in February when the bald headed little shitbag first started throwing around nuclear threats. It served me well. I'm thinking of reverting back to that. No news and hiding anything on the topic of war.

We are going to be OK.

vera99 · 22/09/2022 20:46

The USSR lost 20 million in WW2 whereas in the Uk we lost 385,000 for a population of 1/3 the size. Misery and death is baked into their souls sadly in a way we could never understand or wish to and a goodly proportion of the male population, in particular, is almost permanently pissed.

TheNinny · 22/09/2022 20:30

Putin has children and I assume people he loves somewhere out there. I’d like to think he won’t start an apocalypse for their sake at the very least. But who knows 😬

Mojitoo · 22/09/2022 20:28

Putin considers himself essential to Russia. Without Putin in charge, there's no point in Russia existing. Without Russia existing, there's no point in the world existing

Chilling, but I concur. Cut him and he bleeds Russia.

Putin has been underestimated time and time again. He has played a long game with the destabilisation of the US and UK (Trump, Brexit). He is politically long-sighted and five moves ahead of everyone else. Putin is intelligent. He's not a 'madman' in an irrational sense.

We've got to stop thinking any of his actions/reactions will be 'normal' (Trump again, actually).

Stationsofthecross · 22/09/2022 20:07

No.

shreddednips · 22/09/2022 20:06

I found this article by Lawrence Freedman in the New Statesman very balanced if anyone is interested:

www.newstatesman.com/world/europe/ukraine/2022/09/using-nuclear-weapons-putin-problems

Isitsixoclockalready · 22/09/2022 18:06

LemonSwan · 22/09/2022 17:55

Thanks @DogInATent

So your saying putin just wants a giant Russia; the land of which he wants being in Europe?

I still don’t understand why they hate the U.K.? Because we gave Ukraine support? Surely they would know we would in the same way we would have helped Russia if someone tried to invade it. Same we would expect others to support us if someone tried to invade us.

I see from online translations of Russian state tv where crazed military people are making speeches about shaking the unshakable island (us) by sending a nuke. In a way it’s a weird back handed compliment. Is this just a show and dance and that they secretly admire us or do they truly hate us. It’s confusing.

I'm not sure whether we would step in automatically to defend Russia from invasion like we have with Ukraine as we have a cooperative relationship with Ukraine but certainly not a good one with Russia although who would invade Russia? The antipathy between Russia and the UK dates back to around the time that they decided to start poisoning people within the UK and put citizens here in danger. Things were good with the Russia/Soviet Union from Gorbachev through Yeltsin to the early Putin years but went downhill after that.

LemonSwan · 22/09/2022 17:55

DogInATent · 22/09/2022 09:05

Russia has a f-cktonne of oil and gas, particularly gas. Most of Europe (including the UK) is dependent on gas for power. Putin has, to an extent, stabilised the former Soviet republics. Russian funding has bankrolled domestic European politics (particularly in the UK). All of which meant that no one was particularly keen on upsetting Putin in case the lights went out or the magic money tree stopped funding pro-Russian conservative political parties. Abuses in Chechnya, Georgia, and the Crimea were frowned at, but sanctions were limited.

Putin is playing a long game. It's based on restoring Greater Russia as his legacy. It's a long-held dream of certain political groupings in Russia (see Foundations of Geopolitics) and several of the steps identified as required to achieve this have already been taken.

Ukraine has been a step too far, and the ROW have been forced to react because Ukraine chose to fight back and not accept Russian annexation.

Most people are just trying to get on, do the school run, not fuck up at work and remember to pick up a pint of milk. Why does he think the world revolves round Russia?
The price of petrol/diesel burned as you do the school run has massively increased because Russia invaded the Ukraine and the ROW has imposed sanctions on Russian oil and gas.

Your job is under threat because the energy price increase is squeezing your employers margins, and you're worried whether or not your wages will increase to keep pace with inflation in the cost of living because Russia invaded the Ukraine and the RWO has imposed sanctions on Russian oil and gas.

Your pint of milk has increased in price because the cereals that go into cattle food, and the energy used to collect, transport and process the milk have all increased in price because Russia invaded the Ukraine and the ROW has imposed sanctions on Russian oil and gas.

We let the world revolve around Russia when we sleep-walked into dependence on Russian oil and gas.

Thanks @DogInATent

So your saying putin just wants a giant Russia; the land of which he wants being in Europe?

I still don’t understand why they hate the U.K.? Because we gave Ukraine support? Surely they would know we would in the same way we would have helped Russia if someone tried to invade it. Same we would expect others to support us if someone tried to invade us.

I see from online translations of Russian state tv where crazed military people are making speeches about shaking the unshakable island (us) by sending a nuke. In a way it’s a weird back handed compliment. Is this just a show and dance and that they secretly admire us or do they truly hate us. It’s confusing.

Theorema · 22/09/2022 14:58

Tactical! Not strategic.

Theorema · 22/09/2022 14:58

Yes I did mean strategic, sorry.

vileta · 22/09/2022 14:51

@illiterato well that's what the west did when Putin took Crimea and things only got worse since

Airymanning · 22/09/2022 14:36

I expect do eventually.

Do I worry? Not really. I just stop reading the news.

notimagain · 22/09/2022 14:31

I know what you're getting at but I think a strike, certainly by multiple warheads on the UK mainland, would be regarded as strategic.

MagicFox · 22/09/2022 14:30

😂😂 @RoachTheHorse

DogInATent · 22/09/2022 14:26

A launch at the US would result in mutual destruction. But a smaller strategic strike on the likes of us, may not.
Are people muddling strategic and tactical?

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 22/09/2022 14:25

Raddix · 22/09/2022 14:10

I’m terrified. Putin is elderly and supposedly dying of cancer or something. He has nothing to lose. And he’s arrogant enough to take everyone else with him. He doesn’t care if it ends up as scorched earth, he’s no worse off because he’s dying anyway.

You know it's not just his call though right? It isn't a question of him pressing a button with no input from elsewhere. It won't happen if the people around him, who are unlikely to all have terminal cancer, don't want it to.

DogInATent · 22/09/2022 14:21

Then there's what he said about having some weapons that are more modern than those of NATO. Doesn't mean those are nuclear weapons.

He has some advanced conventional weapons, but not enough of them to make a difference. Tanks, rifles, etc. that have been seen in parades but have either not been seen at all in Ukraine or only in very small numbers. Laser weapons that have been named in public popularity contests.

But he also has some advanced nuclear weapons at unknown stages of development. And he doesn't need many of those to make an impact.

  • Poseidon/Kanyon - unmanned nuclear-powered, nuclear-armed torpedo drone. This is the 'tsunami' weapon that Russian TV threatened the UK with.
  • Burevestnik/Petrel - nuclear-powered, nuclear-armed cruise missile. Testing of which may have lead to a fatal nuclear accident.