Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do parents let their kids take toys to playgroup?

88 replies

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 18:08

Seriously, why?? Toddlers are too young to understand the concept of personal property / ownership, and it makes it really hard to teach them how to share nicely when the other parent turns around and says "Well actually, it is little Felicity's doll..." - I mean, why have you allowed her to bring it to playgroup? Surely it's just asking for trouble? AIBU??

OP posts:
Holidaying7 · 22/09/2022 05:36

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 18:20

Yep, that's fine, but the toy goes in the bag when you arrive at playgroup. Unless everyone else can play with it too, which in my experience is not how it works. It causes unnecessary stress for everyone and is really inconsiderate.

Yep I agree. My rule is, if you don’t want to keep it in the bag, then others may want to play with it. My kids are fine with that. Sometimes the thing stays in the bag, sometimes not and others can play.

WhatILoved · 22/09/2022 05:31

I'm a childminder. I find that when a child brings their own toy it really inhibits their interaction with others and ability to join in. They spend most of the time stressing that another child will take it. Also when we are walking around they don't have both hands free to stop their fall. I let children bring toys as I understand parents can't have the fight when leaving for work. When they come through the door I've taught them to put their toys away for the day. It takes a few weeks (I take the fight! ) but really the change in their behaviour without holding onto teddy all day is remarkable. They see the world more!

lickenchugget · 22/09/2022 05:22

It’s absolutely doable to explain to a three year old that a toy belongs to someone else. Presumably it’s mostly in said child’s possession most of the time, and not lying alone in the pile of playgroup toys?

Destinationdestination · 22/09/2022 04:10

Yes, it’s annoying having to explain to your child they can’t play with another child’s toys but that’s the way it goes and they learn. Child bringing their special toy to playgroup and not wanting to share it is fine. Quite a scary prospect of loosing it amongst all the craziness. Different if they have friends at their house wanting to share. Then they need to get used to that but also friends need to respect sharing and taking turns too.
i get that you want to relax with a cuppa but in reality, if your kid isn’t haven’t a meltdown about not being able to have another kids toy then they will be having a meltdown about something else like wanting another kids biscuit, having a playgroup toy for the whole time without sharing it, not wanting to leave at end of session or wanting to leave and not being able to. There’s always something with some toddlers and it will pass

holidaynightmare · 22/09/2022 00:00

FoxyLoxSox · 21/09/2022 18:13

We have this at mud club. Toddler will bring their own digger/spade/bucket then release it among a sea of other similar items that belong to mud club. So you’re constantly like ooh look this little pick up truck is free, let’s play with it and you get ‘NO THAT BELONGS TO MY SON SORRY’ it annoys me 🤣

Mud club???? What is this I've never heard of it???
If it's some sort of mud based messy play sounds hellish 🤦🏻‍♀️

Anon778833 · 21/09/2022 23:37

Generally, l don’t think you’re BU. We don’t take our own stuff to playgroup. I think there are some situations where it would be understandable if the child has SEN, but the whole point of playgroup is so that the child can play with different stuff. Most kids can manage without an hour or two of clutching toys from home.

It does make it confusing too. My 2 year old picked up a Paw Patrol toy that she likes and a little boy said to me ‘that’s my Chase’. I don’t think it is actually his but at the time it did cause confusion!

Deadringer · 21/09/2022 23:28

We had a high shelf in our setting and any toy or personal item brought in was put up there til home time. That way the child could see it but not play with it and no squabbles ensued. Much worse was when they brought a 'blanky' in with them. One boy used to bring in a filthy piece of fabric smaller than my thumb, he/his parents would sneak it in so we didnt have to put it on the shelf, of course one day he put it down somewhere and then wouldn't leave without it. We had a massive garden, I will never forget searching every inch of it for that tiny, filthy, rag.

Nat6999 · 21/09/2022 23:26

Ds took his cuddly dog everywhere with him at that age, he did right up to being 7 or 8, I even had to take it to meet him from school.

JudgeRindersMinder · 21/09/2022 23:18

user1474315215 · 21/09/2022 18:50

YABU. How are children going to learn about respecting other children's property if they're never put in that situation?

Amd how are they ever going to learn to take no for an answer?

AlwaysLatte · 21/09/2022 23:16

Ours wanted to take their special teddies so we used to take them but leave them in their little backpacks and put a photo of their teddies in their pocket.

lanthanum · 21/09/2022 23:15

With the best will in the world, sometimes the kids smuggle the toy out, or it's the only way of getting out of the house on time. Best of course if it goes in a bag on arrival to keep it safe from other children.

The other annoyance, as a former group leader, is when the toy gets forgotten, and inadvertently packed away with the group toys at the end of the session. On occasion, I was kind enough to bike back and search for it before bedtime, and I did learn that under the seat of the ride-on toys was worth checking before searching the boxes of smaller toys.

jokingfox · 21/09/2022 23:10

Yeah I get what you mean and it is annoying af really. Unnecessary drama. I think toddlers generally have a radar which picks up a signal where the new flashy toy is and of course 17 children jump to it but oh wait, it belongs to Mia who doesn't like to share understandably. My philosophy is, if you're not going to share it, hide it then. Which equally means don't bring it!

Hugasauras · 21/09/2022 23:00

IME the toys from home get abandoned when the playgroup toys come out anyway. Then they can tussle over who gets to play with the best ones of those instead.

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 22:58

sillytrainpeople · 21/09/2022 22:10

I think kids should be allowed to bring their toys to playgroup and not be dictated to by other parents. OP is just arguing with everyone who expresses an opposite opinion and if that's the way they are no doubt the child won't listen to any sense either.

Not arguing, just debating - sharing opinions, thought that was the point of this board?

Anyway, it's late and I'm sleepy. Thanks for the responses. I may not agree with all of them, but food for thought nonetheless 😊

OP posts:
Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 22:55

@takealettermsjones I think you raise some interesting points, and I'll certainly ponder over them.

I suppose where we may differ is that I really like the communal nature of playgroups - the fact that nothing belongs to anyone and the kids all get stuck in together. When kids bring in their own toys from home and won't share them, it really changes the dynamic and I think it results in unnecessary conflict.

I don't think that kids will have a problem learning about respecting personal belongings as they get older - we live in a society which basically revolves around private property, wealth etc. But sharing, being part of collective spaces, being generous - I think they should take priority.

"If it's a confusing concept for your kid at the moment that's fine, but that's what you're there for - to teach them, and reinforce it, not sit at the side with a cuppa or whatever it was you said. Most people send their children to playgroups and such to learn how to socialise with other children."

I think playgroups can have a number of different purposes - helping kids to socialise with others, helping parents to make friends and have a bit of a break - I don't feel like they're mutually exclusive.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 21/09/2022 22:23

To learn to share? Also it's a great what time meet other parents, it was crucial for me in a foreign country with no friends to meet people

takealettermsjones · 21/09/2022 22:16

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 22:03

This is the weirdest response so far.

Basically, my view is that if a child is going to bring a toy to play group, they need to hold on to it, and if not, they need to accept that other children are going to want to play with it. In my experience, this is, understandably, difficult for toddlers and so, inevitably, you end up with a situation where one child is having a tantrum because someone is trying to play with their special toy, and another child is having a tantrum because they've been told that they're not allowed to play with a toy because it belongs to someone else - a concept which, in the context of a playgroup, where all of the other toys are for everyone to play with, is confusing. It's just far easier and fairer if people just leave the special toys at home / in the bag / pushchair - or at the very least, hold on to them.

Your park / mobile phone example is odd - we're adults, so I'm not sure how it's relevant.

I don't see why my response is weird at all. I just disagree with you.

my view is that if a child is going to bring a toy to play group, they need to hold on to it, and if not, they need to accept that other children are going to want to play with it

Okay, and my view is that those 'other children' need to accept that not everything is theirs and they have to ask permission when something belongs to another child.

If it's a confusing concept for your kid at the moment that's fine, but that's what you're there for - to teach them, and reinforce it, not sit at the side with a cuppa or whatever it was you said. Most people send their children to playgroups and such to learn how to socialise with other children. At some point they are going to have to learn that sometimes things belong to others, and they don't have a right to everything just because it's in their space.

Your park / mobile phone example is odd - we're adults, so I'm not sure how it's relevant

It's relevant because it shows how we seem to expect children to readily give up (or "share") everything that's dear to them, while we wouldn't be comfortable sharing certain possessions of our own. I think children should be allowed to retain some choices in the way their belongings are used, and other children need to learn to graciously accept a "no".

sillytrainpeople · 21/09/2022 22:10

I think kids should be allowed to bring their toys to playgroup and not be dictated to by other parents. OP is just arguing with everyone who expresses an opposite opinion and if that's the way they are no doubt the child won't listen to any sense either.

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 22:03

takealettermsjones · 21/09/2022 21:36

You realise you're arguing that other parents should let their children be upset (at not being allowed to take their own toy) ...so that you don't have to deal with your kid being upset (when they're not allowed to play with it).

Incidentally...
If you bring your mobile to the park and I've got no battery, am I allowed to watch YouTube on yours if I want to?

This is the weirdest response so far.

Basically, my view is that if a child is going to bring a toy to play group, they need to hold on to it, and if not, they need to accept that other children are going to want to play with it. In my experience, this is, understandably, difficult for toddlers and so, inevitably, you end up with a situation where one child is having a tantrum because someone is trying to play with their special toy, and another child is having a tantrum because they've been told that they're not allowed to play with a toy because it belongs to someone else - a concept which, in the context of a playgroup, where all of the other toys are for everyone to play with, is confusing. It's just far easier and fairer if people just leave the special toys at home / in the bag / pushchair - or at the very least, hold on to them.

Your park / mobile phone example is odd - we're adults, so I'm not sure how it's relevant.

OP posts:
RobynNora · 21/09/2022 22:02

@NoYouSirName I’m sure you didn’t mean it in a nasty way but the way that was phrased sounds a little like you’re picking on a 3 year old over the internet!

Not all 3 olds understand possession, especially in the excitement of a group setting where everything is seemingly fair game. Toys strewn about are communal and that’s largely the point of a playgroup. Doesn’t mean there is anything wrong with OPs toddler - sounds like fairly normal frustration to me! I can imagine most pre schoolers of that age reacting similarly.

luxxlisbon · 21/09/2022 22:00

Equally, how are children going to learn how to share and take turns if they're allowed to throw a complete wobbly at playgroup when another child wants to play with their special toy? Personally, I think it's unreasonable to expect a barely turned three year old to understand the concept of personal belongings. At this age, it's more about turn taking and sharing, and when another parent allows their child to bring in a toy from home, it makes it really difficult for everyone else and you just end up with a load of angry and confused toddlers.

It really shouldn’t take long for a three year old to understand the concept of belonging.
Your basically saying other parents and kids shouldn’t be able to do what they want because your kid gets jealous. It’s your job to teach him that he can’t always play with everything just because he wants to.
Even in nursery they are allowed their own toys!

cavia · 21/09/2022 21:54

My DD won't go anywhere without her favourite cuddly toy

NoYouSirName · 21/09/2022 21:51

Three! I thought you were going to say he was one! Surely all three year olds without SEN understand ‘that belongs to Olivia’ or ‘that one’s Ethan’s’ and ‘these are the playgroup toys’?! Mine all did at that age. Including the one with SEN.

YABU, lots of children need a transitional object. Or have other reasons why they need their toy. Do you think k adults shouldn’t bring personal belongings into public spaces unless they’re willing to share? Or that they should keep items in their hand at all times otherwise it’s fair game for someone to grab?

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 21/09/2022 21:49

Same reason they let them take toys to school. With no heads-up, and CERTAINLY no name label. Then, when the child inevitably loses the toy, they come in shrieking about it having been 'stolen' 🤦🏻‍♀️ #triggered

takealettermsjones · 21/09/2022 21:36

You realise you're arguing that other parents should let their children be upset (at not being allowed to take their own toy) ...so that you don't have to deal with your kid being upset (when they're not allowed to play with it).

Incidentally...
If you bring your mobile to the park and I've got no battery, am I allowed to watch YouTube on yours if I want to?