Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do parents let their kids take toys to playgroup?

88 replies

Peanutbuttermonster · 21/09/2022 18:08

Seriously, why?? Toddlers are too young to understand the concept of personal property / ownership, and it makes it really hard to teach them how to share nicely when the other parent turns around and says "Well actually, it is little Felicity's doll..." - I mean, why have you allowed her to bring it to playgroup? Surely it's just asking for trouble? AIBU??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Goldenbear · 22/09/2022 15:41

Noviembre, talk about overreaction, toddler has attachment toy, is attached to it and the only possible course of action is to take it away from them in a casual, informal playgroup setting as otherwise they will become a brat!?? Load of crap. You should chill out and teach them to not care about stuff that doesn't matter.

Rodion · 22/09/2022 15:06

Perfectly fine if the child keeps the toy but if it ends up in the pile of toys but you get jumped on for touching it that's annoying. Surely they are risking it getting ridied away and lost if they aren't holding onto it. Still, I couldn't get too het up about it.

What gave me the absolute rage in playgroup was when parents would ignore the no food/drink in the equipment rule and send little Jimmy into the ball pool/mini soft play with a juice carton in one hand and a sandwich in the other. Absolute bastards!

Volhhg · 22/09/2022 14:47

YANBU. Yeah kids this age can't be expected to share but equally kids this age can't be expected to know about personal property. So that's why rules exist about parents making sure their kids don't bring in personal property. I guess if you want to join in with a group then you should respect the rules set by those who have made the effort to put on a playgroup. You might have to suffer a tantrum from your child when you make them leave their toy

zingally · 22/09/2022 14:27

I've also been a big shrugger, when kids have gone, "X is playing with the Y! I want to play with it!"
My response has pretty much always been, "Well, X is still playing with it. You'll have to wait until he/she is done. But you could try asking X if you can play together."

I've never been a fan of "you must share!" Why should they?

Autumn2022 · 22/09/2022 14:25

OP I agree. I’ve always made my DS keep his toys in the car for this exact reason. I tell him if he wants to take it in the other children will want to play with it. We now “keep it safe” in the car. It’s taken sometime and tantrums but he understands now why we don’t take them in.

MrsMiddleMother · 22/09/2022 14:22

Yanbu

CousinKrispy · 22/09/2022 14:13

You know what, 3 year olds are going to find something to have the occasional tantrum about anyway, and no outing is going to be a stress-free, sit around and drink a cup of tea without keeping an eye on what little Timmy is up to and possibly intervening kind of situation. Them's the breaks.

Personal toys can create conflict, and the parent who allowed the toy to be brought should be keeping an eye out to try and reduce that potential conflict. But it's really not unreasonable for you to also be keeping an eye on your child and intervening with valuable life lessons about "Sorry, that one is special to someone else, look here's another thing" occasionally.

CatSeany · 22/09/2022 14:06

YANBU - any toy taken into a shared play group needs to be shared - my son probably wouldn't want to share his toy and so he can't take it. He'd also likely be upset if it got lost or broken which is highly likely. It only took one day of explaining to him that he needs to leave his toy/s in the car before he accepted it.

sourgreenplums · 22/09/2022 14:06

I've got late teens so past this stage but honestly, you would like it done one way, because it suits your child and your parenting style, others like it done a different way for the same reasons. There is no right and wrong and one very important thing to remember and teach our child is that in this type of setting everyone is equal and opinions equally valid.
You can't control other people!
Even if you'd like to, and the things they do piss you off you have to find a way to do what pleases you, without trying to change others.
If you continue like this you'll be the parent who is forever complaining that other parents -should- do this or that type of party, invite or not invite on play dates etc.

Mumoblue · 22/09/2022 14:05

YABU.
“Special toy in their hand” becomes “special toy on the floor” very quickly. Luckily when we went to playgroup my son’s special cuddly toy is of very little interest to other kids because he takes it EVERYWHERE and its rather beat-up. I still tucked it away whenever I saw him lose interest in it, but many children are nervous in a group setting and like the comfort of a familiar toy.

Personally I’m not a fan of making toddlers share anyway. They don’t really have the capacity for it, and while we can stress that it’s NICE to share - I think acting like it’s mandatory only causes problems.

Phos · 22/09/2022 13:52

Are we talking about stay and play type things when we say playgroup as opposed to a nursery?

Darkstar4855 · 22/09/2022 13:45

It’s difficult because mine often wants to show his toys to his friends. We have a rule that if it’s out then everyone can have a turn with it but if he doesn’t want to share then it goes away in the bag. That way I’m not forcing him to share but equally we’re not dangling a toy in front of other children that they can’t play with.

Noviembre · 22/09/2022 13:43

God that sounds annoying. Precious parents thinking their special kid can't be separated from a toy nor learn to share. Then they wonder why it grows up a brat. They probably just do it to enjoy smugly telling other toddlers they can't have the toy.

awakenme · 22/09/2022 13:24

Sometimes I wonder about the things people have time to get agitated about.

Countingdowntodecember · 22/09/2022 12:06

I just hate the second hand anxiety when a child inevitably loses their special toy and everyone looks for it.

jokingfox · 22/09/2022 11:46

People expecting 3 yo's to behave like adults because that's not life and they don't have to share. Duh, of course it isn't. We don't see adults snatching gadgets from peoples hands saying "it's mine" unless they are getting mugged which that's done to make quick money. They grow and mature overtime. It's simple steps and stages for children at that age. Pre schools have this day in day out with turn taking, sharing etc slowly nurturing them. Taking toys with you to playgroups etc is like putting a dynamite in that environment where these stages are implemented. I've seen the same kids who don't like to share but then go on to push other children off the slide because they don't like to share the slide and want to be first on it. Some kids are naturally emotionally mature but most 3 yo's I've been with including my little one aren't like that and it takes time and practice. I've stopped seeing a couple of friends because even a 1 hour park meet up would end in tears because I don't feed my child junk and just when everyone is settled, one parent decides to crack open a packet of skittles and chocolate buttons and of course that sets off a dynamite in that environment. I'm not too precious either and if my child is offered a couple I won't take digs and say sorry we don't eat that crap. When I was little I was always taught if you have two ice lollies in the freezer and 5 friends coming over, you eat the ice lolly after your friends have gone and not in front of them. If you have enough, then of course you serve that but I have equally been to play dates where I've sat in the corner watching the host munch on stuff and not offer anything to me which is bad manners in my opinion.

lickenchugget · 22/09/2022 11:03

Peanutbuttermonster · 22/09/2022 07:05

Actually in my experience, it's the other child that throws more of a wobbly - because they don't want to share their toy. Fine, then don't bring it to a room full of other toddlers.

But they shouldn’t HAVE to share their toy?

You seem to ascribed to a system of equity and turn-taking of everything. That’s not life.

And 3yo’s should be able to understand when something is not theirs

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 22/09/2022 09:38

Do you always know when kids have SEN?

maryberryslayers · 22/09/2022 07:32

YABU. My 3yo understands that some toys are for sharing, others belong to people and he may not be able to play with them. If he accidentally picks one up, I just explain that it's another child's special toy so we need to give it back and give him the job of returning it to its owner. It's might be a bit more difficult with my 18m old but her annoyance would last for about 3 seconds until I plonk another toy in her hands.
At 3 most children already have an understanding of sharing/turn taking and special toys. You're there to supervise and play with your child, not drink tea.

Patapouf · 22/09/2022 07:25

namechange881881 · 21/09/2022 18:09

YABU

There might be many reasons they take them. Maybe having their toy was the only way they could get out of the house that morning etc. There's no rule to say you can't take them.

If they won't leave the house without a toy, the parent needs to work on that: not pass the parenting problem onto strangers.

Fucks me off no end when kids bring their own toys and then leave them with communal toys and the parent has the cheek to complain when another child wants to play with it.

I'll tolerate it at a sand pit, but only because there are no communal toys.

KatieKat88 · 22/09/2022 07:14

Personally I think YANBU - keep precious personal toys hidden in a bag etc. There will be a few cases where they have a really good reason for bringing then but a lot of the time the parent just doesn't want to have the battle of telling their child not to bring it/share it - the conversation I've just had to have with my child!

Peanutbuttermonster · 22/09/2022 07:11

cocococococococo · 22/09/2022 06:15

YABU. It isn’t other parents jobs to make your parenting easier.

No, but it would be nice if they didn't make it harder, wouldn't it?

While we're at it - I'm getting slightly irritated by the notion that I should be using situations like this to teach my child about the importance of personal property (as if that isn't something that will be rammed down their throat for the rest of their life...) How about other parents use playgroup as an opportunity to teach their kids that no little Timmy, you can't have your way all the time - the dumper truck / teddy / doll doesn't need to come out with us all the time and actually, if you insist on bringing these things to a communal environment, it's only fair to share them. In the home, in someone else's home, things may be different, and obviously there are exceptions (kids with SEN etc.). But ultimately I stand by my argument that it's just inconsiderate, annoying and creates additional drama.

OP posts:
Peanutbuttermonster · 22/09/2022 07:05

Orphlids · 22/09/2022 05:39

Your belief that play group is an opportunity to teach sharing and turn waiting is no more valid than the other perspective; it is an opportunity to teach that some things are personal belongings and not to be taken. There’s no reason these two situations cannot coexist. I’m surprised your three year old struggles to grasp the latter concept. Sounds like you should focus on that a bit more, as other kids will always bring their own toys and that is never going to change. Other parents aren’t going to stop doing something just so your kid doesn’t throw a wobbler.

Actually in my experience, it's the other child that throws more of a wobbly - because they don't want to share their toy. Fine, then don't bring it to a room full of other toddlers.

OP posts:
cocococococococo · 22/09/2022 06:15

YABU. It isn’t other parents jobs to make your parenting easier.

Orphlids · 22/09/2022 05:39

Your belief that play group is an opportunity to teach sharing and turn waiting is no more valid than the other perspective; it is an opportunity to teach that some things are personal belongings and not to be taken. There’s no reason these two situations cannot coexist. I’m surprised your three year old struggles to grasp the latter concept. Sounds like you should focus on that a bit more, as other kids will always bring their own toys and that is never going to change. Other parents aren’t going to stop doing something just so your kid doesn’t throw a wobbler.