Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 07/10/2022 19:09

Cutted up pear is an old thread on here.
A toddler asked for "cutted up pear" then had a massive tantrum when they got a pear that was cut up.

I think that was it.

Softplayhooray · 07/10/2022 19:05

Blocked · 06/10/2022 16:34

I don't think anyone would dress like this for a stunt. It's totally inappropriate. I know it's not cool to give a shit about children and their well-being but at some point safeguarding has to kick in.

This is either a serious mental health problem, or a sexual kink, or both. Clearly it is ridiculous and totally inexcusable to allow anyone to look like that in a classroom, FGS. Bloody ridiculous.

Snoozer11 · 07/10/2022 18:56

I agree that it's a stunt.

I welcome anything that exposes the insanity of the gender movement.

CatsandFish · 07/10/2022 18:53

*this should be 'just'

CatsandFish · 07/10/2022 18:50

What does "cutted up pear" mean? I googled it but found no meaning, this youtubes and articles about how to cut pears and make fruit salad.

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 18:48

Yeah I get that in terms of the activist, the quote just doesn’t make sense as directed at me

This is my opinion!

"I saw a story that was so ridiculous and disgusting that I decided it could be an elaborate stunt which is legal as a consequence of self ID."

OP posts:
FOJN · 07/10/2022 18:40

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 18:11

I understand that, it’s that particular quote I have issue with, it seems contradictory.

See the reference to cutted up pear. The activists got what they wanted in Canada and are now pissed off that self ID is being exploited by people with motives they don't approve of which exactly what anyone with half a brain cell could have predicted.

This is self ID in action they need to own it but they have a habit of denouncing anyone who take it to the extreme as "not really trans". The whole point of self ID was to remove any gatekeeping so everyone who says they are trans is. Self ID means there is no such thing as "true trans".

I'm sure the tiny number of people with gender dysphoria are delighted about the chancers who are now directing trans rights campaigns.

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 18:11

I understand that, it’s that particular quote I have issue with, it seems contradictory.

OP posts:
Hearthnhome · 07/10/2022 18:03

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 17:56

What are you on about? It is a consequence of self ID! The whole point of the story is a person can be allowed to dress in this way because they identify as a woman. We can still question the motivations behind it and not take everything at face value, what’s wrong with discussing different aspects and angles to things?

That’s the point. Its claimed that it’s transphobic to question the motivation behind it.

He says he is a woman so he is and you can not question what motive is behind it.

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 17:56

GabriellaMontez · 07/10/2022 17:24

"I saw a story that was so ridiculous and disgusting that I decided it was an elaborate stunt. I refuse to accept that this is the consequence of self ID."

What are you on about? It is a consequence of self ID! The whole point of the story is a person can be allowed to dress in this way because they identify as a woman. We can still question the motivations behind it and not take everything at face value, what’s wrong with discussing different aspects and angles to things?

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 07/10/2022 17:26

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 11:57

I’m the Op, no I haven’t disappeared! My first thoughts on seeing the pictures was this must be some kind of stunt, I have seen no evidence that it is or know anything about his motivations, it is purely speculation! I’m finding the discussion really interesting.

Why do you keep misgendering her? Are you a transphobe?

GabriellaMontez · 07/10/2022 17:24

"I saw a story that was so ridiculous and disgusting that I decided it was an elaborate stunt. I refuse to accept that this is the consequence of self ID."

Puddycatfan · 07/10/2022 17:13

nauticant · 07/10/2022 14:02

It's demanding something ("transwomen are women!", "acceptance without exception!"), and when this case comes along saying "here it is, this is what you demanded", there are trantrums about having not wanted that but actually wanted something different.

It's all rather cutted-up pear.

It's EXACTLY cutted-up pear!!!

nauticant · 07/10/2022 14:02

It's demanding something ("transwomen are women!", "acceptance without exception!"), and when this case comes along saying "here it is, this is what you demanded", there are trantrums about having not wanted that but actually wanted something different.

It's all rather cutted-up pear.

IncompleteSenten · 07/10/2022 12:43

Well quite.
Once a person who appears male says they are female, that is the end of the discussion. They are female, no exceptions and to deny that is literal violence because no man would ever claim to be a woman if they weren't.
No platform
No hate
Terfy terf terf and so on

VestofAbsurdity · 07/10/2022 12:09

DdraigGoch · 07/10/2022 06:33

But we must have acceptance without exception, anyone who says that they are trans is trans, according to Stonewall. Why are you gatekeeping? Who gives you the right to deny her lady feels?

Don't forget anyone is who they say they are, therefore we must accept that @robin5810 is non binary because they say so - acceptance without exception - yet robin will not do the same for this person? Hypocritical much? Why would that be? Couldn't possibly be that this person is showing the world exactly what those mantras mean could it?

TempName01 · 07/10/2022 11:57

I’m the Op, no I haven’t disappeared! My first thoughts on seeing the pictures was this must be some kind of stunt, I have seen no evidence that it is or know anything about his motivations, it is purely speculation! I’m finding the discussion really interesting.

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 07/10/2022 09:25

Well this ie exactly what feminists and the more switched on trans people have been warning about for years. Once self id is law then you let in the fetishists and the bad actors as well as the "true" trans people.

If he's able to use the law to exhibit his fetish in front of children in this way then maybe, just maybe the law is bad and some gatekeeping is necessary?

TheKeatingFive · 07/10/2022 09:07

It doesn't really matter if he's a guy with a fetish, a raging narcissistic a-hole, or a pissed off employee pulling a stunt to make a point.

Self ID can/will be taken advantage of by any of those groups and the ultimate result here is a failure of child safe guarding.

The Canadian law on this is a total disaster. They need to wake the fuck up. And everyone else needs to not repeat their dumbass mistakes.

IncompleteSenten · 07/10/2022 09:00

Oh FFS
Highlight the absurdity of self I'd no questions asked and the potential for abuse by individuals who do not actually believe they are of the opposite sex to that indicated by their genitals and chromosomes but want to use that open and unquestionable platform for other reasons (normally sexual) - yes

CatsandFish · 07/10/2022 08:59

Sunnyqueen · 06/10/2022 21:07

Yes it is a deliberate stunt, he is seeing how far he can push them before they dismiss him so he can then sue. The guys spoken out about anti trans before he started this.

@Sunnyqueen There is absolutely no evidence he ever spoke out about anti-trans before this. That lie came from a QANON site, so, consider the source.

IncompleteSenten · 07/10/2022 08:57

Undermine - no.

Highlight the absurdity of se

CatsandFish · 07/10/2022 08:54

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 20:28

Yes, well done. Sex is biological and can’t be changed. What this whole thing is about is gender, a societal construct.

@robin5810 A woman is an adult human female. It is a SEX classification. Not a gender classification. Therefore, a trans woman cannot be a woman. A woman is only based on SEX. Nothing else.

Brefugee · 07/10/2022 08:53

So here's a great idea, let's get rid of the bullshit, sexist, sex role stereotypes and expectations and stop pretending that appearance or dress sense makes the slightest bit of difference to, or alters, a person's sex.

sounds a lot like 2nd wave feminism to me. It is how i have always lived my life: not constrained by the social construct of Gender to do the things that i want to do and am good at. I identify , however, as a woman because that is my sex. I have no idea what makes me a woman outside of biology. It isn't a feeling it is a being.

Women are women. Transwomen are transwomen.

As for transwomen always trying to pass as "cis" women? ODFOD. We have ALL seen women with dicks, women with beards, etc - insisting they are women. No "cis" woman does that. Nice try though.

And again: those who accuse MN of hate of tw. Where are the receipts? you don't have any. Because it is a lie.

CatsandFish · 07/10/2022 08:53

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 20:26

Trans women are women regardless of medical or social transition but due to social and gender dysphoria, if it’s safe to do so then they’ll often try to express who they are with what they look like.

@robin5810 You are delusional if you believe that. Trans women are NOT women. They are men. And always will be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread