Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 22:07

@amoobaa you are ignoring most of the responses. I assume because you can’t argue with it.

Why do women who to keep sex based spaces, sex based news to be consulted? As long as sex based space are kept that way it doesn’t matter.

Ask transwomen ‘you can’t have access to spaces for women as they are sex based spaces. What alternative works for you’

Surely that’s the only opinion that matters? Why would a space for trans people need the input of non trans people?

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 22:03

I just know there is a difference and we can’t deny they both exist, but we mustn’t treat them as the same.

@amoobaa but how can we treat them differently if we can’t tell which is which?

amoobaa · 10/10/2022 22:01

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:00

“How are you classing transwomen? Which spaces are you advocating they use?”
I’d suggest a space where they are safe. Just like I advocate for safe spaces for women. Mind blowing stuff right?

And once again @amoobaa you shuffled away from actually answering that question, which space are you advocating that transwomen use? Which spaces are transwomen unsafe in? and why are they unsafe in them?

Furthermore @amoobaa you are continually saying what transwomen are like and ignoring the massive elephant in the room which is that:

if you believe that there is some innate, inexplicable, invisible gender identity that over-rides sex

if you believe in self identity of said gender identity/sex

if you believe that anyone is who they say they are on the basis of said gender identity, and must be accepted without exception and no debate

if you believe TWAW

THEN this person, as per Canadian Law and the change in law that is being pushed for here in the UK IS A WOMAN and is therefore allowed full, unfettered access to all spaces and services with the word woman on the door.

Again, as has been laboriously pointed out this is exactly what anyone is who they say they are, acceptance without exception, no debate, TWAW is in action.

What measures of safeguarding are you suggesting that will not go against the above? How are you going to separate the 'good' ones from the 'bad'? What test will you apply? And how are you suggesting woman who cannot share spaces with ANY male are accommodated? Or do they not matter in your Brave New World?

No I genuinely think that answers the question. I think transwomen need safe spaces just like anybody needs a safe space.

Do I think that safe space has to be a women’s only space? No.

I think the only way to design those spaces well, is to consult with women who are not ok with sharing their spaces with transwomen and consult with transwomen who don’t want to be in men’s spaces. I can’t speak for transwomen, so I can’t give a well thought out solution.

Transwomen can be very unsafe in certain contexts.

ovc.ojp.gov/sites/g/files/xyckuh226/files/pubs/forge/sexual_numbers.html

So their need for safe spaces is important. I’m not saying that means women only spaces should be compromised.

I know men and women alike, who absolutely cannot share spaces with men. They matter to me. As do the trans community.

I know you’re angry about what I’m saying but I don’t have the answers you’re asking me for. I don’t know how you tell the difference between a transwoman and a sexual offender who is pretending to be a transwoman.

I just know there is a difference and we can’t deny they both exist, but we mustn’t treat them as the same.

OMG12 · 10/10/2022 22:00

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:50

But if we are allowing males into female spaces (even those operated on), they are automatically not female spaces any more are they? They are now mixed sex. How would we police this? In the UK no one is even allowed to ask to see a GRC.

As I said I’m not happy about it but might minimise the risk whilst this mess is sorted.

there is nothing a man can do that will make him a woman. He can become a trans woman but that is very very different to being a woman because he will never experience what it’s like to be a woman. We need the world to acknowledge this rather than be dragged into the fantasy. Until then it is fire fighting

TheKeatingFive · 10/10/2022 21:58

I be still think the lack of distinction between aggressive dangerous sex offenders and transwomen who have done nothing wrong is unhealthy, unbalanced and hateful.

You're failing to pick up the pertinent point here. They aren't distinctive in law. How do you do that with Self ID and TWAW? What's your suggestion here?

Of course everyone would agree with you that there are TW who have done nothing wrong. But simply advocating for them, like there's no danger of other groups taking advantage, is seriously undermining women's rights. Pointing that out isn't hate. It's important fact

Brefugee · 10/10/2022 21:58

Therefore I think there’s a lot of hate for transwomen who have done nothing wrong.

but you (I think it's you, if not sorry) keep saying this thread is full of hate. And after repeated requests nobody has managed to show any. So i am going to assume it is hyperbole and ignore it.

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 21:51

amoobaa · 10/10/2022 21:38

I don’t have a husband or a fiancée.

I also don’t think if someone says they are a woman, that this has to be accepted without question, in any situation. I’ve never said anything different.

Never ever being allowed to ask questions is a bad idea.

There are concrete differences between a woman and a transwoman. not sure how you could argue otherwise.

I be still think the lack of distinction between aggressive dangerous sex offenders and transwomen who have done nothing wrong is unhealthy, unbalanced and hateful. Therefore I think there’s a lot of hate for transwomen who have done nothing wrong.

Again. Who invented the ‘acceptance without exception’

Who decided that anyone who says they are a woman, is a woman. Who decided that all have to be treated the same and that women could not speak up against any of them?

The pro trans lobby says your opinion (pasted below) is hate and transphobic. Or ‘literal violence’.

I also don’t think if someone says they are a woman, that this has to be accepted without question, in any situation. I’ve never said anything different.

Do you see how one person or group labelling something as ‘hate’ doesn’t make so?

Your response is so weak it unreal. It’s essentially ‘well I am still going to keep my point of view and not read what’s actually written because I don’t understand the actual issue’

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:50

But if we are allowing males into female spaces (even those operated on), they are automatically not female spaces any more are they? They are now mixed sex. How would we police this? In the UK no one is even allowed to ask to see a GRC.

Baldieheid · 10/10/2022 21:48

"There are concrete differences between a woman and a transwoman. not sure how you could argue otherwise."

And there are no concrete differences between a man and a transwoman. Not sure how you could argue otherwise.

So why should we treat them differently?

OMG12 · 10/10/2022 21:47

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:42

So again, how do we tell the difference between a male claiming to be trans and a male who claims they are truly trans? At what point does that male become not a man? What he says the words ‘I identify as a woman’ or is there something else one needs to do to ‘identify’ as a woman?

I think that before any man is allowed access to female spaces he should have been operated on or at the very very least chemically castrated. If a man feels like a woman that shouldn’t be an issue and might deter the fakers. This should be certified my a medical professional.

im still not happy with it, but might be a working compromise.

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:42

So again, how do we tell the difference between a male claiming to be trans and a male who claims they are truly trans? At what point does that male become not a man? What he says the words ‘I identify as a woman’ or is there something else one needs to do to ‘identify’ as a woman?

amoobaa · 10/10/2022 21:38

Brefugee · 10/10/2022 19:34

I'll take one example:

“Autogynaphelia is a thing. Look it up.”
That’s really offensive. Autogynaphelia is not the same as transgender.

you said it yourself: "offensive" is not hate. They are not the same thing. Also many of the TW and the descriptions of their behaviour fits the AGP profile. So how do you know which is which? (I think you "know" because you just accept "I'm a woman" from anyone who says it?) But if that is your husband or fiancé? And according to Stonewall, nobody but nobody is ever ever ever allowed to differentiate between an AGP or a TW and nobody is ever ever ever allowed to ask.

But you said "hate" and came up with... offensive? Do you see why this frustrates, irritates and puts people off from engaging with the "debate"?

I don’t have a husband or a fiancée.

I also don’t think if someone says they are a woman, that this has to be accepted without question, in any situation. I’ve never said anything different.

Never ever being allowed to ask questions is a bad idea.

There are concrete differences between a woman and a transwoman. not sure how you could argue otherwise.

I be still think the lack of distinction between aggressive dangerous sex offenders and transwomen who have done nothing wrong is unhealthy, unbalanced and hateful. Therefore I think there’s a lot of hate for transwomen who have done nothing wrong.

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:30

@katmeouws 1/10. Must try harder.

OMG12 · 10/10/2022 21:30

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:16

What I want to know is how would a man know he is ‘really a woman’? I always have to fight the urge to say ‘which one’? when told ‘a TW feels like a woman’. To say someone can feel like a woman suggests either all women feel exactly the same or someone is relying on sexist stereotypes to define woman

Yep slowly these sexist stereotypes are being seen by society as defining women. Women have never been under such threat.

I’ve recently complained to the BBC about Ru Paul’s drag race in this basis and the derogatory language used. They justified it by saying it had historical legitimacy, rather questionably stating it started in Tudor England. Interestingly enough they used almost exactly the same defence in 1967 defending the Black and White Minstral show

katmeouws · 10/10/2022 21:29

why do some lesbians use strap on dicks on their partners if they dont like dicks?

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 21:16

What I want to know is how would a man know he is ‘really a woman’? I always have to fight the urge to say ‘which one’? when told ‘a TW feels like a woman’. To say someone can feel like a woman suggests either all women feel exactly the same or someone is relying on sexist stereotypes to define woman

OMG12 · 10/10/2022 21:13

Most of the time a man feeling like he is a woman is nothing more than a fetish of wanting to live as a man’s fantasy of what it means to be a woman, the stockings, suspenders, big hair, make up stilettos etc. none of them want to actually experience life as a woman with everything that entails, even if they could.

They limit their experience of being a woman to a stereotype which is then fed back into society as what it means to be a woman, pure sexual fantasy.

its this sexual fantasy adults are pushing in kids. Thank god mermaids is being shown for what it is

meanwhile, all the language, people who mensturate, birth givers are all designed to dehumanise women I mean why not say brood mares? Trying to take away our very identities without consent - language is a powerful thing.

if men really want to live as women, ditch the stockings, ditch the fake boobs, picture a man’s boot stamping on a woman’s face forever!

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:52

It also suggests that transwomen are trying to erase gay men and make them have sex with them. I’d like to understand more about this. I don’t understand it.

I don't know if you are being wilfully obtuse or something else but this statement is completely at odds with the statement of yours in response to:

Lesbians being told to accept penises in their dating pools”

Lesbians aren’t all the same. Some lesbians would be horrified, others may be entirely fine with that arrangement, others curious or indifferent… so the list goes on. The thing that matters is that the lesbian community are able to voice their collective views and that all sides, including trans, are heard. How else can a resolution be agreed upon that respects everyone’s rights?

Transwomen are trying to erase lesbians - female homosexuality as your diatribe above proves.

Lesbians are females attracted solely to members of the same sex as them
Gay men are males attracted solely to members of the same sex as them

The only resolution required is that trans people accept that and respect totally the rights of gay men and lesbians to their same sex attraction, anything else is homophobic.

I could point you to some really hideous things transwomen and transmen are saying about lesbians and gays regarding same sex attraction and then you can come back and tell me all about respect.

Or perhaps the Cotton ceiling might open your eyes?

this whole ‘some lesbians might like dick’. What is the difference between that and the blokes down the pub telling lesbians ‘they just haven’t found the right man yet’.

There is absolutely NO difference.

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 20:37

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:33

how are transwomen the most vulnerable members of society? 1TW has been killed in the UK in the last decade.

Was that the one that was killed by another transwoman?

Yes it was. Another victim of male on male violence. Nothing to do with women.

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 20:36

this whole ‘some lesbians might like dick’. What is the difference between that and the blokes down the pub telling lesbians ‘they just haven’t found the right man yet’.
lesbians don’t do dick. And telling lesbians ‘well some lesbians do’ just opens up lesbians to abuse. We’ve seen that. It’s the equivalent of ‘all the cool kids are doing it’
If posters such as @amoobaa cannot see how homophobic and disgusting this is, I really believe they must be homophobes themselves.

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:33

how are transwomen the most vulnerable members of society? 1TW has been killed in the UK in the last decade.

Was that the one that was killed by another transwoman?

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 20:31

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 20:30

So sick of the ‘lesbians sometimes have socks’ and ‘Some lesbians like people with dicks’

as pp said it’s so fucking homophobic. But it appears it’s ok to be homophobic as long as it’s aimed at lesbians.

This sort of rhetoric is why my dd, a lesbian, was forced out of 2 support groups at college and won’t seek a support group at Uni that is aimed towards the gay community.

But it’s ok that support groups for the gay community don’t want to support lesbians, as long as transwomen are allowed to claim and change the definition of a word so they can become it? Going back to my earlier post, why should dd try and negotiate and cajole and compromise?

Ffs sake ‘socks’ should be ‘socks’ in that first sentence.

Of course lesbians have socks. I would imagine most do 😂

TheKeatingFive · 10/10/2022 20:31

I was told off for using the term 'biological woman' so it seems they don't want a distinction.

That's right. The TRAs want all references to sex / sex differences erased, to be replaced with gender differentiation only. When they say reference 'rights' I presume this is what they mean.

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 20:30

So sick of the ‘lesbians sometimes have socks’ and ‘Some lesbians like people with dicks’

as pp said it’s so fucking homophobic. But it appears it’s ok to be homophobic as long as it’s aimed at lesbians.

This sort of rhetoric is why my dd, a lesbian, was forced out of 2 support groups at college and won’t seek a support group at Uni that is aimed towards the gay community.

But it’s ok that support groups for the gay community don’t want to support lesbians, as long as transwomen are allowed to claim and change the definition of a word so they can become it? Going back to my earlier post, why should dd try and negotiate and cajole and compromise?

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 20:28

And I would also like to ask @amoobaa

The only trans people I know are just asking for equal rights, dignity and respect. And they aren’t asking to eradicate the rights of women and children. They would find your statements hateful. Talk about sexual predators, yes, but don’t deny the existence of transwomen who have done nothing wrong by never acknowledging them. It’s not reasonable and it doesn’t help protect the most vulnerable members of society, who need this whole mess sorted out by civilised and intelligent debate and resolution.

how are transwomen the most vulnerable members of society? 1TW has been killed in the UK in the last decade. 2 women a week are killed.

women are most likely to suffer domestic violence.
teenage boys are at the most risk of assault or experiencing violence by their peers.

The suicide rate for men is soaring exponentially
teenage girls are most at risk of eating disorders
the occurrences of child abuse, child poverty and child neglect are soaring in the ik
so tell me again how TW are the most vulnerable members of society?

Swipe left for the next trending thread