Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:28

OMG12 · 10/10/2022 21:13

Most of the time a man feeling like he is a woman is nothing more than a fetish of wanting to live as a man’s fantasy of what it means to be a woman, the stockings, suspenders, big hair, make up stilettos etc. none of them want to actually experience life as a woman with everything that entails, even if they could.

They limit their experience of being a woman to a stereotype which is then fed back into society as what it means to be a woman, pure sexual fantasy.

its this sexual fantasy adults are pushing in kids. Thank god mermaids is being shown for what it is

meanwhile, all the language, people who mensturate, birth givers are all designed to dehumanise women I mean why not say brood mares? Trying to take away our very identities without consent - language is a powerful thing.

if men really want to live as women, ditch the stockings, ditch the fake boobs, picture a man’s boot stamping on a woman’s face forever!

I disagree with the bit about most of the time it’s a fetish.

But I absolutely agree that the words we choose to use and the language we cultivate is incredibly powerful.

I also agree that I’m a woman, not only a person who menstruates.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:24

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:52

It also suggests that transwomen are trying to erase gay men and make them have sex with them. I’d like to understand more about this. I don’t understand it.

I don't know if you are being wilfully obtuse or something else but this statement is completely at odds with the statement of yours in response to:

Lesbians being told to accept penises in their dating pools”

Lesbians aren’t all the same. Some lesbians would be horrified, others may be entirely fine with that arrangement, others curious or indifferent… so the list goes on. The thing that matters is that the lesbian community are able to voice their collective views and that all sides, including trans, are heard. How else can a resolution be agreed upon that respects everyone’s rights?

Transwomen are trying to erase lesbians - female homosexuality as your diatribe above proves.

Lesbians are females attracted solely to members of the same sex as them
Gay men are males attracted solely to members of the same sex as them

The only resolution required is that trans people accept that and respect totally the rights of gay men and lesbians to their same sex attraction, anything else is homophobic.

I could point you to some really hideous things transwomen and transmen are saying about lesbians and gays regarding same sex attraction and then you can come back and tell me all about respect.

Or perhaps the Cotton ceiling might open your eyes?

this whole ‘some lesbians might like dick’. What is the difference between that and the blokes down the pub telling lesbians ‘they just haven’t found the right man yet’.

There is absolutely NO difference.

Are you saying a transwoman has to identify as a gay man if they want to date men?

I assume we can all agree that sexual offenders are not to be afforded rights to harm anyone.

But you’re not taking about that, you’re taking about transwomen simply not being allowed to exist. Even if they are great people who have done no wrong and do not want to erase women rights.

Either that or you simply don’t believe transwomen like that exist. You seem to think they are all sexual predators in disguise.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:17

I didn’t say some lesbians do dicks. I said some might not mind transwomen being in their dating pool.

When I used dating apps, I selected to see and be seen by women only.

I haven’t dated a transwoman. However, I wasn’t personally concerned with transwomen being in the dating pool. What about transwomen without a penis? What if a lesbian perceives them as female? Are lesbians not allowed to date transwomen?

Since when did lesbians have to follow strict protocols on their dating preferences to placate you?

YouSirNeighMmmm · 11/10/2022 17:10

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:06

Where did I say transwomen are the most vulnerable members of society?

I think you need to re-read my post.

I believe that unintelligent debate, sweeping generalisations and black & white thinking are not going to do anything positive to protect the most vulnerable members of society.

I think you are assuming what I think, feel and believe, based on one fact alone- I believe transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders or trying to erase women’s rights, deserve to have their rights and dignity respected. Surely we all agree about that?

I think the situation as it stands is not ok. I keep reiterating that one person’s rights shouldn’t erode another’s, that I believe in rights for everyone and that more consideration needs to be given to issues such as safe spaces for women and women’s sports.

But you don’t want know about that. That doesn’t support your assumptions about me.

"I believe transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders or trying to erase women’s rights, deserve to have their rights and dignity respected. Surely we all agree about that?" You seem to be talking about those TW who use men's toilets because they know that sex change is impossible and toilets are segregated by sex. What rights don't they currently have?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:06

Where did I say transwomen are the most vulnerable members of society?

I think you need to re-read my post.

I believe that unintelligent debate, sweeping generalisations and black & white thinking are not going to do anything positive to protect the most vulnerable members of society.

I think you are assuming what I think, feel and believe, based on one fact alone- I believe transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders or trying to erase women’s rights, deserve to have their rights and dignity respected. Surely we all agree about that?

I think the situation as it stands is not ok. I keep reiterating that one person’s rights shouldn’t erode another’s, that I believe in rights for everyone and that more consideration needs to be given to issues such as safe spaces for women and women’s sports.

But you don’t want know about that. That doesn’t support your assumptions about me.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 09:14

I sincerely hope you are not saying that a woman is just a man without a penis.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 11/10/2022 09:09

amoobaa Are transwomen human beings like everyone else or are they modern day flawless saints?

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 09:06

Not all transwomen have penises!

But they are still biologically male, they are of the male sex class, homosexuality is same sex attraction, that's it simple, straightforward no ifs, buts or maybes to class it as anything else is homophobia.

I’m well aware of the experiences of lesbians, being one myself. No I don’t live under a rock.

Are you really? You've heard of the Cotton Ceiling then? You've read all the reports on lesbians being removed from lesbian dating sites for stating they are only interested in dating those of the female sex, you've read the reports of young lesbians being pressured and coerced into having sex with men who identify as women because not to do so is transphobic and will see them shunned, shamed and removed from groups and dating sites that are purported to be for them? You've heard the CEO of Stonewall describe lesbians who don't want to date or have sex with TW whether they have a penis or not akin to racists and anti semites or perhaps the infamous TW who stated that lesbians just need to learn to cope with PIV sex and get over their genital preferences?

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 08:50

My opinion is half formed because I don’t know enough, for example about women’s sports issues and exactly what the implications of self identity are and how best to address these.

You don't know enough and yet happy to throw out accusations of hate and transphobia against those who do.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 08:44

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:14

Lesbians being told to accept penises in their dating pools”

Lesbians aren’t all the same. Some lesbians would be horrified, others may be entirely fine with that arrangement, others curious or indifferent… so the list goes on. The thing that matters is that the lesbian community are able to voice their collective views and that all sides, including trans, are heard. How else can a resolution be agreed upon that respects everyone’s rights?

Lesbians who are fine with penises are not lesbians, lesbian is a legally defined term and it does NOT include male people to do so is fucking homophobic, but then again this whole ideology is homophobic and misogynist.

You think lesbians, as per the legal definition, are able to voice this? Do you live under a rock? Lesbians have been utterly and completely vilified, abused and threatened for saying they don't accept TW. The rights of lesbians are not being remotely respected.

The word lesbian is taken by lesbians it is not available for men who believe they are women whatever modifications or not they have made to their bodies.

Not all transwomen have penises!

But that aside, this morning I told my wife about this thread and she said that when she dated, she had never objected to the penis, but the man behind it. She personally chose not to date transwomen but had no issue with transwomen being in the dating pool because she had a choice and nobody forced her to date anyone she didn’t want to. She said there was no quota.

I’m having to think about this one. Are you saying I’m a lesbian with internalised homophobia? Maybe I am… I dated boys as a teenager and when I thought the whole world hated me because I was gay. But I’m definitely a lesbian. My wife would probably get more approval and lesbian points from you. But I’m a woman married to a woman and I would be deeply unhappy in a relationship with a man.

I’m well aware of the experiences of lesbians, being one myself. No I don’t live under a rock.

And whilst I can’t speak for all lesbians, I’d like you to let me speak for myself thank you very much.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 08:42

The history of trans rights is pretty appalling. People being sacked simply because they are trans and this being legal. Now this has all changed. So I imagine the trans community think they have equal legal rights but are afraid of them being taken away?

Nobody, absolutely nobody is saying trans people should be discriminated against at work or anywhere else. Nobody, absolutely nobody. is saying that trans people should not have the same rights to healthcare, education, housing, employment, voting or welfare as anyone else.

But people who disagree with transwomen having the current rights they have, consider some of these right to be additional rights?

No, that is not the additional right granted to trans people, the additional right they have is to change the sex marker on their birth certificate by way of a GRC they then acquire what is defined as a legal fiction as their sex is not actually deemed to have physically changed as that is an impossibility. A GRC can only be asked for or seen in very rare, exceptional circumstances. Now name me one other group in society that has the right to hide such a fundamental aspect of their being, is allowed to change such a fundamental aspect on an official record and then hide it.

And maybe valid points are being made on both sides. There are still issues to be resolved to ensure everyone is respected and safe.

There would be no issues to resolve if trans people were not demanding that society cleave to their belief system.

If one person’s rights began to erode another’s then everything needs reconsidering.

Women and girls rights are being systematically destroyed by the push for ever more rights for trans people, not just eroded, totally destroyed.

But I can understand if the trans community feel anxious about their rights being taken away, because they know what it feels like to have no legal protection. It must be a scary prospect.

They will never not have the same legal protection as everyone else what they want are additional rights and to ride roughshod over the rights of everyone else.

Something I empathise with, as a woman.

Try empathising with women and girls instead they are the ones who are losing rights.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 08:33

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 20:10

@amoobaa that’s a lot of words for ‘I am choosing to ignore anyone whose opinion is different from mine and just going to carry on saying what I have always said’

Autogynaphelia for example/ is a definite thing. No one said all transwomen fit into that. The point is that if anyone can say they are trans and they must be treated as a woman, there’s no distinction between the 2. GC women didn’t come up with that. We have been fighting that. Its Stonewall and pro trans lobby that came up with rules that put both groups together.

But you think WE have to come up with a. Solution that make trans women happy?”

Nobody is free until we are all free. You might only care about one group of people. But I care about the bigger picture.

And it was me that asked why women had to come up with a solution. You response of ‘nobody is free until we all are’ is, again, missing the point. Lots of women are not happy at their sex based rights being removed. A large, loud, portion of the trans right movement want to remove sex based rights. The pro trans lobby will not accept a compromise. So why would women waste their time? ‘Please don’t take our sex based rights away. What about if we do X,Y or Z…would that please you’.

Why would I spend my time trying to negotiate with someone who has made their line in the sand clear. It’s not up to me to cajole and compromise with someone trying to remove my rights.

I am mixed race. I don’t cajole and compromise with people (of all colours) that believe my rights should be removed because of the colour of my skin and my culture. Large parts of My fathers community believe I should have had an arranged marriage and take away my right to chose to marry who I wanted. I wasn’t (and my dad wasn’t) going to try and compromise and cajole them. Some people (usually white men) really hate a successful woman of colour and try and deny me a seat at the table, or belittle me in my professional life. They try to take something I have worked for and deserve. I am not going to negotiate with and cajole them either.

Do you really believe I should?

You are dismissing absolutely everything I have said as nothing more than ‘a lot of words’ that ignore anyone whose opinion is different to mine?

My opinion is half formed because I don’t know enough, for example about women’s sports issues and exactly what the implications of self identity are and how best to address these.

I haven’t dismissed everything being said to me. In fact, I keep needing to correct people who are making the assumption that I don’t care about women’s spaces and that I think nobody can question anybody about their gender identity in any circumstances.

I never said autogynaphelia isn’t a thing!

I also never said I wanted my sex based rights taken away. I think I’ve made that abundantly clear. You just want to disagree with me because I also have concern for transwomen’s rights. So you are ignoring everything h say that doesn’t fit your narrative.

The person you are arguing with is an imaginary person in your head. It’s not me.

And no, in answer to your question, of course not- don’t negotiate and cajol with bigoted racist arseholes. Carry on as you are.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 08:11

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 20:09

Ooh. Maybe @amoobaa will be able to answer the age old question? What rights do transpeople not have that everyone else has?

The history of trans rights is pretty appalling. People being sacked simply because they are trans and this being legal. Now this has all changed. So I imagine the trans community think they have equal legal rights but are afraid of them being taken away?

But people who disagree with transwomen having the current rights they have, consider some of these right to be additional rights?

And maybe valid points are being made on both sides. There are still issues to be resolved to ensure everyone is respected and safe.

If one person’s rights began to erode another’s then everything needs reconsidering.

But I can understand if the trans community feel anxious about their rights being taken away, because they know what it feels like to have no legal protection. It must be a scary prospect.

Something I empathise with, as a woman.

OMG12 · 11/10/2022 07:55

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 07:50

I think if I had an answer to that then there wouldn’t be a problem.

I’m not denying there are issues. I think solutions need to be created that take into account all the different aspects of the problem.

Collaboration is needed.

There is an obvious answer to this though. Everyone accepts that Self ID shouldn’t happen and third spaces are created for those medically diagnosed.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 07:54

We'd all love an answer to that question @Shakenotslurred we ask every time it is stated and answer comes there none.

I only hope that all aspects of this debate are thought about carefully so that we don’t end up with unnecessary divides, believing that the only way of securing safe spaces for women is to dehumanise transwomen.

That's rich, the ones being dehumanised, treated as nothing more than validation tools, human shields, collateral damage and service humans are women and girls. The entire basis of the ideology dehumanises women. Women have put a lot of thought into this debate, they are the ones bearing the brunt of this ideology now, the level of thought on the TRA side? No evidence of that whatsoever, questions are never answered as per the above example, abuse, threats, violence and accusations of hate and transphobia, as done by you, are the sum total of the contribution from the trans side.

OMG12 · 11/10/2022 07:51

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 06:37

Yes, things need evaluating. I agree changes are needed, as we develop and progress as a society.

I only hope that all aspects of this debate are thought about carefully so that we don’t end up with unnecessary divides, believing that the only way of securing safe spaces for women is to dehumanise transwomen.

The TRA are quick enough to dehumanise women though, demanding phrases such as “Person who menstruates” and “Birth Person” why aren’t trans women standing up to this recategorisation of women as live stock?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 07:50

TheKeatingFive · 10/10/2022 20:09

I’m not saying sexual predators can’t impersonate transwomen. I’m simply saying transwomen are not the issue. Sexual predators are.

Sure. But given that we're being asked to accept anyone as a woman who identifies as one, how are we supposed to differentiate for the purposes of safeguarding biological women?

I think if I had an answer to that then there wouldn’t be a problem.

I’m not denying there are issues. I think solutions need to be created that take into account all the different aspects of the problem.

Collaboration is needed.

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 06:39

So again @amoobaa and sorry if you’ve already answered this, what rights do transpeople want that they do not have but everyone else has?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 06:37

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:06

The only trans people I know are just asking for equal rights, dignity and respect. And they aren’t asking to eradicate the rights of women and children.

They already have equal rights and indeed an extra right that no-one else in this country has conferred by the GRA/GRC.

I would suggest that the trans people you know speak out against those who are attempting to eradicate the rights of women and children and doing it in their name, notably most of the most virulent TRAs and allies pushing for said eradication are not actually trans, strange that the trans people you know are not outraged by that.

Yes, things need evaluating. I agree changes are needed, as we develop and progress as a society.

I only hope that all aspects of this debate are thought about carefully so that we don’t end up with unnecessary divides, believing that the only way of securing safe spaces for women is to dehumanise transwomen.

Hearthnhome · 11/10/2022 06:08

Because one is lying and the other is telling the truth and doing nothing wrong. I’m not sure what you’re getting at?

No they aren’t lying. If you say you are trans then you are trans. That’s the point. If simply saying you are trans, makes you trans then it’s impossible to lie.

Thats the position this is all based on. And it’s not GC women that came up with it. If you have a problem with it, then your issue is not with GC women.

Mummysharkdoodoodoodoodoodoo · 11/10/2022 05:56

I read that the children have been complaining and joining protests, saying they don’t feel safe and comfortable and that they ‘just want to learn’. They clearly are very disturbed and unnerved by this. I think it’s disgusting if I’m honest and I also think this person is making an absolute mockery of women.

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 05:47

@amoobaa you think there is a difference between one male saying they are a women for nefarious reasons and another male saying they are a woman because they truly believe it. Now the male doing it for nefarious reasons is not going to admit it, so how do we know which TW are safe and innocent according to you and which should be feared. Both are trans. Which ones should women allow in womens spaces?

amoobaa · 10/10/2022 23:24

Shakenotslurred · 10/10/2022 20:03

So @amoobaa just picking up on this

Again this is describing ‘awful behaviour perpetrated by transwomen’. In reality, this behaviour is perpetrated by people, usually men, who are strategically and maliciously using a trans identity that isn’t genuine, in order to get away with awful behaviour. And that’s on them. It’s not the fault of transwomen.

how do we tell the difference? Can you explain why one male saying they are trans Is maliciously using an identity that isn’t genuine and another is a true and honest transwoman?

Well quite. How do we tell the difference?

Can I explain why a man would lie and pretend they are transgender but another is actually a transwoman?

Because one is lying and the other is telling the truth and doing nothing wrong. I’m not sure what you’re getting at?

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 22:43

I know you’re angry about what I’m saying but I don’t have the answers you’re asking me for. I don’t know how you tell the difference between a transwoman and a sexual offender who is pretending to be a transwoman.

No-one does which is why self-id, everyone is who they say they are, exception without exception is a safeguarding nightmare. No-one can tell which man is a sexual offender or not either hence single sex spaces and services are there to mitigate the risk. What is offensive or hateful about the same rule applying to transwomen who are, as everyone is aware, male? Men who do not identify as woman or think they are women manage to cope and understand. Why should transwomen be treated differently from any other member of their sex class?

I just know there is a difference and we can’t deny they both exist, but we mustn’t treat them as the same.

Apply your logic in both these statements to men as a sex class.

I think the only way to design those spaces well, is to consult with women who are not ok with sharing their spaces with transwomen and consult with transwomen who don’t want to be in men’s spaces. I can’t speak for transwomen, so I can’t give a well thought out solution.

There is a simple solution - spaces and services are segregated on the basis of sex, transwomen and transmen need to advocate for their own separate spaces and services if they do not want to share with their own sex. Women have said clearly they want single sex spaces and services to be just that, single sex, that should be the end of the 'consultation' with women. Women have suggested additional, separate spaces for transwomen, transmen and those who do not mind using mixed sex spaces, this is not acceptable to TRAs, even when these spaces are provided some high profile transwomen insist on accessing the female only space and bragging about it because at the bottom of all this it is not the space that matters to them it is the people in that space and the validation and power that brings.

Also, it is not just about safety it is about privacy, dignity and comfort a fairly basic consideration would you not agree and yet it seems women and girls are not worthy of such a consideration.

I’m aware and think that’s horrendous. Nothing I think contradicts the idea that spaces specifically for women are necessary and need safeguarding.

We agree that spaces specifically for women and girls need safeguarding, they should NEVER have been opened up to allow males into them. As keeps being pointed out to you though if TWAW the whole edifice crumbles.

It contradicts your idea that transwomen as a class are devoid of sexual predators and that the only predators are men who are not really trans. Several sex offenders who now declare they are women are in the process of applying for GRCs and their sexual offence history is not a bar to them gaining one.

amoobaa · 10/10/2022 22:08

VestofAbsurdity · 10/10/2022 20:02

I’m not saying sexual predators can’t impersonate transwomen. I’m simply saying transwomen are not the issue. Sexual predators are.

There are several transwomen in prisons who are sexual predators and female prisoners incarcerated with them have found that out to their cost.

I’m aware and think that’s horrendous. Nothing I think contradicts the idea that spaces specifically for women are necessary and need safeguarding.

Swipe left for the next trending thread