Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
amoobaa · 11/10/2022 20:32

Hearthnhome · 10/10/2022 21:51

Again. Who invented the ‘acceptance without exception’

Who decided that anyone who says they are a woman, is a woman. Who decided that all have to be treated the same and that women could not speak up against any of them?

The pro trans lobby says your opinion (pasted below) is hate and transphobic. Or ‘literal violence’.

I also don’t think if someone says they are a woman, that this has to be accepted without question, in any situation. I’ve never said anything different.

Do you see how one person or group labelling something as ‘hate’ doesn’t make so?

Your response is so weak it unreal. It’s essentially ‘well I am still going to keep my point of view and not read what’s actually written because I don’t understand the actual issue’

If the pro trans lobby would find my views nothing but transphobic hate, then it would follow that I’m not advocating for the principles you disagree with.

So what exactly is your issue with my views?

I think transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders should be afforded the same respect as everyone else.

I think woman’s spaces should be protected, women’s right should be protected and issues like woman’s sports should be carefully reconsidered.

I believe all of this can be done without hating transwomen.

Not sure why that’s so difficult to comprehend.

ILikeDungs · 11/10/2022 20:31

If she was a cis woman the head teacher would be able to say

"If he was a woman the head teacher would..." works fine. Base your argument in reality and everyone will understand.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 20:22

Baldieheid · 10/10/2022 21:48

"There are concrete differences between a woman and a transwoman. not sure how you could argue otherwise."

And there are no concrete differences between a man and a transwoman. Not sure how you could argue otherwise.

So why should we treat them differently?

I’ve never argued that transwomen should be treated exactly the same as women. I’ve argued that transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders should be given the same respect as everyone else. Free of discrimination and hate.

Transwomen have needs specific to transwomen. So they may need different things to women. It’s ok to be different and sometimes being treated differently is a supportive thing.

I think you’re imagining that I believe all the things you disagree with. Stop assuming what I think and have a conversation with me.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 19:15

I don't disagree with you as it is not my favourite of terms but for brevity of discussion points , I used it instead of "same sex as at birth"

Neither cis nor same sex as at birth are required - woman is enough and if you are talking about women and transwomen then use women and transwomen. The use of cis adds neither clarity or brevity it is not required.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 19:06

@Shakenotslurred
That is not a woman so wearing those prosthetics is entirely his choice. I would feel more sympathy for an actual woman who had to live with a chest that size.

I agree with you

It has got to be a parody political statement surely, that is in bad taste ? I really struggle to believe this ...

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 19:01

@Shakenotslurred

Please do not use cis. It is demeaning and offensive. Women are not a subset of woman.

I don't disagree with you as it is not my favourite of terms but for brevity of discussion points , I used it instead of "same sex as at birth"

Lots of women and men react very strongly to being labelled cis women or cis men when we are simply women or men and that's our identity not wanting other people to decide on new terms for our identities to force upon us

I don't disagree with you but for purposes of this discussion I used it for clarity

(But call me a cis woman to my face though- for my identity - and I'll frown and say "I'm a woman, you don't get to redefine my identity.. " bc that's a time I can do that)

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 18:58

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:54

What's really sad is that IF this is genuine, it undermines trans issues and simply is a choice to wear huge cartoonish inflated fake breasts inappropriate to working in a school.

If they were real, that's different and more about covering more discretely the pointy nipple area and Oml unlucky woman to have that backache ...

If it's a parody photo ... then it's in extremely poor form

OP was spot on with her original post

That is not a woman so wearing those prosthetics is entirely his choice. I would feel more sympathy for an actual woman who had to live with a chest that size.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:55

FrippEnos · 11/10/2022 18:52

Tiani4

If the teacher was a woman I suspect that they would also be being told off for inappropriate clothing in the workshop (as this is a shop teacher)

Yes
I agree

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:54

What's really sad is that IF this is genuine, it undermines trans issues and simply is a choice to wear huge cartoonish inflated fake breasts inappropriate to working in a school.

If they were real, that's different and more about covering more discretely the pointy nipple area and Oml unlucky woman to have that backache ...

If it's a parody photo ... then it's in extremely poor form

OP was spot on with her original post

FrippEnos · 11/10/2022 18:52

Tiani4

If the teacher was a woman I suspect that they would also be being told off for inappropriate clothing in the workshop (as this is a shop teacher)

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 18:49

Are you saying a transwoman has to identify as a gay man if they want to date men?

Bearing in mind a transwoman is male if they are sexually attracted to other males they are homosexual men, i.e., gay.

But you’re not taking about that, you’re taking about transwomen simply not being allowed to exist. Even if they are great people who have done no wrong and do not want to erase women rights.

Another one of the great mantras - not allowed to exist, you've truly swallowed the playbook. Exist as what?

Either that or you simply don’t believe transwomen like that exist. You seem to think they are all sexual predators in disguise.

Nope, try harder I've never said they are all sexual predators in disguise. I don't believe all men are sexual predators, however, as a sex class males (the sex class transwomen belong to) commit 98% of all sex crimes, that is a fact there is no getting away from it. It is impossible to tell merely by looking which males are one of those males who are sexual predators and that applies to all males whether trans or not.

There are very good reasons for definitions and boundaries to remain clearly defined, people who want to blur either are a problem, it's what leads to the person this thread was started about, it leads to the issues currently being discovered at Mermaids.

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 18:45

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:41

If she was a cis woman the head teacher would be able to say I'm sorry but you do need to cover your nipples as top is fairly see-through/ thin but it'd be said very careful with difficulty and HR advice as ahem .. body type/natural boobs ...

But someone choosing to wear these into a school to work with children?? ... no that's gone awry and a sexualised parody of a woman by choice ... to work in a school ?? I'd be questioning appropriateness
I cannot imagine the children / pupils are comfortable with this

So yes OP is right to question whether this is a stunt to undermine trans issues . Or genuine ? What's the feedback so far?

Please do not use cis. It is demeaning and offensive. Women are not a subset of woman.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:43

TheKeatingFive · 11/10/2022 18:38

I can imagine if she has too much cleavage on show that might be inappropriate for work in a school

The issue isn't cleavage. Hard to comment in any helpful way without seeing the images. They're easy to find.

Regardless of being cis or trans, there is a dress code for schools.

In this case the school has gone on record to say that their dress code (which this person is clearly flouting) only applies to students.

Yeah I've seen it now
Couldnt find it before
Thx

Choconut · 11/10/2022 18:41

Just been doing safe guarding training and I have no idea how this isn't a major safeguarding issue.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:41

If she was a cis woman the head teacher would be able to say I'm sorry but you do need to cover your nipples as top is fairly see-through/ thin but it'd be said very careful with difficulty and HR advice as ahem .. body type/natural boobs ...

But someone choosing to wear these into a school to work with children?? ... no that's gone awry and a sexualised parody of a woman by choice ... to work in a school ?? I'd be questioning appropriateness
I cannot imagine the children / pupils are comfortable with this

So yes OP is right to question whether this is a stunt to undermine trans issues . Or genuine ? What's the feedback so far?

CMZ2018 · 11/10/2022 18:39

That’s brilliant 😂😂 what a weirdo

TheKeatingFive · 11/10/2022 18:38

I can imagine if she has too much cleavage on show that might be inappropriate for work in a school

The issue isn't cleavage. Hard to comment in any helpful way without seeing the images. They're easy to find.

Regardless of being cis or trans, there is a dress code for schools.

In this case the school has gone on record to say that their dress code (which this person is clearly flouting) only applies to students.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:34

FamilyTreeBuilder · 11/10/2022 18:31

I haven't seen the photos of how this teacher is dressed

yeah, you really need to google the photos.

Oh Lord
That is appalling and clearly meant to be overly sexualised for a work teaching environment with DCs

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:33

Sorry I meant yo type

I think we are better these days at society being more accepting of unisex or personalised expressions through dress and style without expecting people (not people!!) to conform.

FamilyTreeBuilder · 11/10/2022 18:31

I haven't seen the photos of how this teacher is dressed

yeah, you really need to google the photos.

Tiani4 · 11/10/2022 18:29

I haven't seen the photos of how this teacher is dressed
I can imagine if she has too much cleavage on show that might be inappropriate for work in a school

Regardless of being cis or trans, there is a dress code for schools.

It is sad to read and inappropriate if someone is breaching that to dress in an overly sexualised way in a school. Is this what this thread is about? I've read OPs posts ..

Most trans women or trans men I know want to blend in as women or men at work because it's about identity who they are and not sexualised for work same as rest of us who are cis (identify as same gender as was their identified sex at birth, as cis isn't my favourite label at all / it's an imposed label)

It's so difficult and emotive a topic though as we each have our own styles over a range of how we dress within reason for professional work situations. I think we are better these days at society being more accepting of unisex or personalised expressions through dress and style without expecting problem to conform.

But there's no place for choosing something overly sexualised for work in a school.

I find it uncomfortable when someone appears to be dressing as a sexualised parody stereotype of what a woman is or a man is, if inappropriately in said work environments especially when working with children.

Quite a few years ago my DCs secondary school SLT had criticisms from parents about a female teacher (cis) who wore short skirts or tight ones with too high slits that pupils could see her knickers as she learnt over to look at someone's work . This teacher was new and a bit naive . Parents were saying 'all for a woman dressing how she wants. but that no one children seeing their teacher's knickers and a*se cheeks on a regular basis'! Tbfair the headteacher acted fairly swiftly an discretely and said teacher dresses in slightly longer skirt lengths now at school. Apparently she got a mouthful from some girls where were sent to exclusion lessons that day for uniform breaches of too short skirts which were still longer than hers Grin when she arrived to supervise. Same should apply whether you are cos or trans

Id also have an issue if a male teacher had too much of his underwear at butt level on show regularly by not doing up his belt/ having very low slung trews ! Or a male PE teachers wearing too short shorts

FrippEnos · 11/10/2022 18:21

robin5810
Trans women are women, but he is not a trans woman. He is very clearly mocking trans women, and using Canadian law to be an idiot.

Trans women are Trans women, no amount of twisting will allow them to be women.

Also drop the term cis many on here find it offensive.

Hearthnhome · 11/10/2022 18:17

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 08:33

You are dismissing absolutely everything I have said as nothing more than ‘a lot of words’ that ignore anyone whose opinion is different to mine?

My opinion is half formed because I don’t know enough, for example about women’s sports issues and exactly what the implications of self identity are and how best to address these.

I haven’t dismissed everything being said to me. In fact, I keep needing to correct people who are making the assumption that I don’t care about women’s spaces and that I think nobody can question anybody about their gender identity in any circumstances.

I never said autogynaphelia isn’t a thing!

I also never said I wanted my sex based rights taken away. I think I’ve made that abundantly clear. You just want to disagree with me because I also have concern for transwomen’s rights. So you are ignoring everything h say that doesn’t fit your narrative.

The person you are arguing with is an imaginary person in your head. It’s not me.

And no, in answer to your question, of course not- don’t negotiate and cajol with bigoted racist arseholes. Carry on as you are.

So people who want take away my rights based on the colour of my skin are racist bigots. So what are people, who want to take away my rights based on my sex?

If you opinion is half formed why are you so sure that everyone else is spreading hate? Why do you think you have the right to tell other people they are wrong or what they should be doing?

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 17:45

So @amoo who were you talking about when you were referencing ‘the most vulnerable members of society’. We are told that is TW.
these ‘innocent TW who just want to live their lives’. I assume they are using male spaces as women have made it very clear they do not want males in their spaces. If they insist on using womens spaces, what is the difference between then and those men who say they are trans. Both are ignoring womens boundaries.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 17:30

katmeouws · 10/10/2022 21:29

why do some lesbians use strap on dicks on their partners if they dont like dicks?

Quite.

My wife says it because she doesn’t object to the penis, she objects to the man behind it.