Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
Baldieheid · 11/10/2022 23:15

Are we all still hateful?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 23:08

pattihews · 11/10/2022 23:00

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

Are you suggesting that because lesbians, who are women who are sexually attracted to women, won't have sex with a man who says he's a woman (I presume you're aware that 98% of TWs still have fully-operative male genitalia) that that man's existence is being denied? Are you suggesting that his very existence depends on a lesbian shagging him? This would suggest that any man who can't find someone to have sex with is having his existence denied — which of course is the Incel argument.

You really do need to check your homophobia and misogyny, because you're off the scale here.

You’re a bit late here, I’ve already taken on board several responses to this.

No I didn’t know that 98% of transwomen have fully operative male genitalia.

I’m a woman.

I’m a lesbian.

I’m learning.

@VestofAbsurdity thank you for the BBC article link

pattihews · 11/10/2022 23:00

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

Are you suggesting that because lesbians, who are women who are sexually attracted to women, won't have sex with a man who says he's a woman (I presume you're aware that 98% of TWs still have fully-operative male genitalia) that that man's existence is being denied? Are you suggesting that his very existence depends on a lesbian shagging him? This would suggest that any man who can't find someone to have sex with is having his existence denied — which of course is the Incel argument.

You really do need to check your homophobia and misogyny, because you're off the scale here.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:54

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 22:07

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

and you really can’t see the homophobia in this?? Really??

for one thing, transwomen are not female, they are male, if they were female they could not be transwomen. Only males can be transwomen. A lesbian is a female homosexual. You should know this as you claim to be one. No male can be a lesbian. We all had to put up with the jokes from the blokes down the pub claiming to be a lesbian trapped in the wrong body. We called it out as the shitty homophobia it was. Now what is the difference between those males saying it and a male wearing a dress saying it? Why is one acceptable and the other not?

How unpleasant. I’m not claiming to be a lesbian. I am one. My wife can vouch for that.

I think I’ll save my time for people who are engaging in meaningful conversation.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:49

Brefugee · 11/10/2022 21:54

Am still patiently waiting for @aamoobaa to show us this hate.
It renders all their other witterings as piffle

Her. I’m a woman.

I’ve explained as far as I can. You either haven’t read what I’ve written or you disagree.

Fine if you disagree. I’m starting to disagree with some of my own ideas too. But I’m not going to keep repeating myself for your entertainment.

I’m here to learn, so thank fuck @vestofabsurdity is engaging in a meaningful conversation. Providing information, despite it not being a personal responsibility, helping me to learn.

If it was just you and me, we’d be going round in circles. Boring, unintelligent, miserable circles.

It may be disappointing but I’m actually taking on board what is being said.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 22:47

It matters to me because many years ago I dated a person who was born with ambiguous genitals as a result of a rare endocrine disorder and they later ended up transitioning from the gender they were assigned at birth. So I viewed a lot of trans issues through a very specific lens. Probably unhelpfully so. They were treated unspeakably and the situation was more complex than I realised at the time.

People with DSDs have been treated appallingly in the past no doubt about it which is why it is important to respect their wishes and views now, they are not trans and for TRAs to use them as some kind of 'gotcha' or portray them as some kind of third sex is repugnant.

Baaaaaa · 11/10/2022 22:39

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 19:00

the transphobia on this thread is appalling. obviously that man is being a total idiot, he’s ridiculing women, both trans and cis, and that’s absolutely wrong. but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people and it’s blatantly ignorant to not acknowledge that.

You just misgendered that woman.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:36

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 21:20

Apparently. And shed glitter as they go. All the offenders and criminals are only claiming to be trans you see. No true transwoman would ever be a sex offender, or abuse women or children, or be violent, or issue. rape or death threats. Those are just people pretending to be trans.

That’s a worryingly naive view.

Of course transwomen can offend. Like any other human. Predominantly men.

but you knew that right?

Baaaaaa · 11/10/2022 22:35

Having huge norks doesn't effect how you teach. Having huge prosthetic norks doesn't effect how you teach. This is autogynephilia. Autogynephilia doesn't affect how you teach( or make you a bad person) but it doesn't make you a woman either This in not appropriate in a classroom. Especially a woodwork teacher. Dressing like that( with breasts like that) wouldn't be tolerated in a female teacher .

You can see that.

The people saying ' it must just be how they live their life' can see that.

Wake up people.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:33

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 21:08

I’m not completely sold on the idea that transgender identity is a belief system. Because some people are born intersex and I’ve read about studies on the physiological similarities in the brains of women and transwomen compared to men. So I feel like it’s a lot more complex than ‘mostly a sexual fetish’.

People who are born with DSDs and their organisations have repeatedly asked to be left out of this debate, they find it extremely offensive to use them in this way. People with DSDs are still either one sex or the other as the DSDs they have are sex specific. Please respect their wishes.

Those studies you have read about have been debunked several times. To actually venture down the route of some kind of 'lady brain' is again so regressive, sexist and offensive, it is exactly the kind of rhetoric that has been used against women for millenia and resulted in and still results in them being denied education, employment opportunities and having their opinions dismissed as 'hysterical'.

Thank you. Yes.

I’ve just re-read it and commented about that already.

It matters to me because many years ago I dated a person who was born with ambiguous genitals as a result of a rare endocrine disorder and they later ended up transitioning from the gender they were assigned at birth. So I viewed a lot of trans issues through a very specific lens. Probably unhelpfully so. They were treated unspeakably and the situation was more complex than I realised at the time.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 22:31

So I’m not sure it proves anything.

It doesn't and it has been debunked several times over.

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:23

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 21:07

So if transwomen are women, how did they know they were competing the brain of a woman and a transwoman, and not two women or two transwomen?
how big was the study? It’s not the one with only 42 subjects in which only 2 similarities were found is it? I am sure the male brain and female brain theory has been thoroughly debunked. Unless you are aware of more research?

I’ve been searching for it to re-read.

I think that was the point- that there was little difference between specific areas of the brain, relating to gender, in the woman’s brain vs the transwoman’s brain and both the transwomen and woman had shared differences to the man’s brain.

However, from what I can see, in addition to the small sample group, it seems they didn’t take into account the effects that previous hormone therapy had on the brain.

So I’m not sure it proves anything.

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 22:20

Wonder if we’ll ever get any proof of the hate we have apparently shown. @amoobaa any luck finding those receipts yet?

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 22:19

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

This is the problem with definitions being blurred and obfuscated - a TW cannot identify as female as that is a sex class, they cannot be female as sex change is impossible, even that is recognised in the GRA which deems the use of female by TW as a legal fiction. Again this is why the TWAW mantra is so damaging, and how have we now moved from woman which they incorrectly deem as a gender to female? Reducing lesbianism to something anyone can identify as is homophobic as hell.

How is their existence being denied? Because they can't have what they want?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:15

Baldieheid · 11/10/2022 21:02

I have to admit that I have absolutely no idea what you're wittering on about. You've no interest in discussing anything, its just the same old soundbites over and over. Almost like you're trying to provoke a negative reaction via frustration.
Not playing your silly game.

I’m mostly agreeing with you but you seem so intent on having an argument that you can’t comprehend it. Good luck with that.

Baldieheid · 11/10/2022 22:13

The truth is that all TW are of the male sex.
The truth is that all TM are of the female sex.
The truth is that homosexuality means same-sex attracted.
The truth is that lesbian is the term for a female homosexual.

The truth is that TW (who are male, remember) who are attracted to females are heterosexual (which means opposite-sex attracted).

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:12

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 20:44

I think transwomen who have done nothing wrong and are not sexual offenders should be afforded the same respect as everyone else.

Are they not? What disrespect are they receiving?

I think woman’s spaces should be protected, women’s right should be protected and issues like woman’s sports should be carefully reconsidered.

Women's spaces, services and rights can be easily protected, however, there needs to be legislation enshrining these rights as some - note the word some - transwomen will otherwise not comply as has been amply demonstrated.

What careful reconsideration are you thinking of for women's sports? You earlier said you did not know anything about this, are you for or against transwomen being included in women's sports?

I believe all of this can be done without hating transwomen.

I don't hate transwomen, I disagree vehemently with some of them and with the TRAs and their allies that are intent on destroying women's rights, any hatred is coming from their direction aimed squarely at women. I detest their attempts at manipulation, emotional blackmail and guilt tripping.

We are going round in unnecessary circles. I don’t think you hate transwomen. And I agree with regards to women’s spaces.

Yes, I don’t know enough about the issues regarding women’s sports. You aren’t going to force me to give an poorly informed assessment. My current thoughts are that transwomen who have gone through male puberty are at an unfair advantage and therefore we need trans specific categories.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/10/2022 22:11

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

There is so much wrong with this that I don't even really know where to start.

Female is a sex not a gender. Trans women identifying as female makes no sense. It's impossible to be the opposite sex. Sex change doesn't exit.

Lesbian has a specific meaning at law, single sex attracted. It is homophobic to give it a meaning that includes a heterosexual relationship. Which is what a relationship between a male and a female is no matter their gender identity.

It is lesbian erasure to state that males can be lesbians.

But you keep harping on about transwomen's existence being denied. What a fucking joke.

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 22:07

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

and you really can’t see the homophobia in this?? Really??

for one thing, transwomen are not female, they are male, if they were female they could not be transwomen. Only males can be transwomen. A lesbian is a female homosexual. You should know this as you claim to be one. No male can be a lesbian. We all had to put up with the jokes from the blokes down the pub claiming to be a lesbian trapped in the wrong body. We called it out as the shitty homophobia it was. Now what is the difference between those males saying it and a male wearing a dress saying it? Why is one acceptable and the other not?

amoobaa · 11/10/2022 22:01

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 18:49

Are you saying a transwoman has to identify as a gay man if they want to date men?

Bearing in mind a transwoman is male if they are sexually attracted to other males they are homosexual men, i.e., gay.

But you’re not taking about that, you’re taking about transwomen simply not being allowed to exist. Even if they are great people who have done no wrong and do not want to erase women rights.

Another one of the great mantras - not allowed to exist, you've truly swallowed the playbook. Exist as what?

Either that or you simply don’t believe transwomen like that exist. You seem to think they are all sexual predators in disguise.

Nope, try harder I've never said they are all sexual predators in disguise. I don't believe all men are sexual predators, however, as a sex class males (the sex class transwomen belong to) commit 98% of all sex crimes, that is a fact there is no getting away from it. It is impossible to tell merely by looking which males are one of those males who are sexual predators and that applies to all males whether trans or not.

There are very good reasons for definitions and boundaries to remain clearly defined, people who want to blur either are a problem, it's what leads to the person this thread was started about, it leads to the issues currently being discovered at Mermaids.

I can understand why transwomen who identify as female and are attracted to women would identify as lesbians. It makes logical sense if you accept transwomen as female. and that’s why it sounds like their existence is being denied.

However, I do understand and agree with the second half of your post.

Also, the try harder comments are really condescending. It’s as if you think I’m trying to prove a point regardless of facts. I’ll readily change my stance if it makes sense to do so.

I’m not interested in winning points. I’m interested in the truth. This matters to me.

I’ve obtained some important information here.

VestofAbsurdity · 11/10/2022 21:56

As someone else said… we need more safe spaces. The transwomen you are describing are at risk of harm from men.

I disagree, do you have evidence of this? As YouSirNeighMmmm stated there are TW who happily use the males spaces and services, they do not describe feeling unsafe or uncomfortable.

Baldieheid · 11/10/2022 21:54

I'm curious but too scared to Google. Where do you think the teacher found such ginormous boobies??? What on earth are they made of?

Brefugee · 11/10/2022 21:54

Am still patiently waiting for @aamoobaa to show us this hate.
It renders all their other witterings as piffle

Shakenotslurred · 11/10/2022 21:49

@amoobaa i feel you are being hateful. So far you have accused people of misguided hate but have produced no proof of this, therefore you are hateful

Swipe left for the next trending thread