Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
RaininginDarling · 06/10/2022 19:37

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 17:03

If it is a stunt to highlight the absurdity of self ID and TWAW I'd say he's succeeded spectacularly.

The school is backed into a corner, looking like idiots who can't safeguard their pupils.

The extreme TRAs are also in a bind, because by declaring himself a woman, he is one (according to their own rules).

Game set and match

This

Also why are womens needs and safeguarding always second to the whims of a tiny minority - a tiny minority who also happen to be over represented in the UK prison system for sexual offences? I mean really, this is where self ID takes you.

Also, I'm fed up of the conflation with gay rights - gay people were just asking for equal rights dignity and respect. The trans movement demands extra special rights, not least compelling others to lie and the removal of rights from women.

No, thank you.

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2022 19:33

Whether it is a stunt is irrelevant.

THIS IS WHERE SELF ID LEADS us, along with:

Women imprisoned with male rapists and paedophiles
Males winning women's sporting titles.
Lesbians being told to accept penises in their dating pools

The list goes on...

samyeagar · 06/10/2022 19:33

TempName01 · 06/10/2022 18:31

If he is self ID and using women’s spaces then yes he is undermining women. If he is making a point about the ridiculousness of self ID etc then would that be in support of women? But then it’s not helpful to people with genuine gender issues. The whole thing is just a mess.

The irony is that in their rush to signal just how supportive they are of trans people and trans rights, they created the legislative and social environment that allows for this.

And to take this one step further, by their own declarations and rules, all Donald Trump would have had to do was declare that he was a woman and he would have become the first woman president of the USA. Not necessarily in the strictest legal sense as the law in Canada, however in a number of states and many more municipalities, they would have had no choice to acknowledge Trump as the first woman president.

And if they did not acknowledge it, or even deny and argue against that, then they have declared themselves the arbiter of who really is and really isn't trans which is directly contrary to trans women are women.

This is a text book example of Reducto ad Absurdum.

cigiwi · 06/10/2022 19:30

LakieLady · 06/10/2022 19:07

However, I’m wondering if there is any space for the acknowledgment that there are a lot of people who identify as trans and have done nothing wrong and have no intention of hurting anyone. If anything they are the ones being treated badly by society.

I agree @amoobaa . The vast majority of trans people just want to get on with their lives.

OK. We cannot but agree. So, fine, "Dress however you please. Call yourself whatever you like. Sleep with any consenting adult who’ll have you. Live your best life in peace and security."

Should we, though, ...
... "force women out of their jobs for stating that sex is real?"
... "tell children lies about changing sex?"
... "allow male sex offenders in women's prisons?"
... "organise breast binders for children behind their parents' back?"
... and so on and so forth.

-- Should we allow all this while "getting on with our lives", no matter what we call ourselves (sc. "identify as")?

Or is agitating against such wrongs to be counted as dog-whistle phobia and discrimination against those "getting on with" their lives?

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 19:27

but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people

Gotta love a meaningless, nonsensical mantra chant. Top marks.

seXX · 06/10/2022 19:24

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 19:00

the transphobia on this thread is appalling. obviously that man is being a total idiot, he’s ridiculing women, both trans and cis, and that’s absolutely wrong. but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people and it’s blatantly ignorant to not acknowledge that.

Could you explain why this teacher, who is being their authentic self, is ridiculing anyone? Are you implying they are not genuinely trans? How can you tell? You also seem to have misgendered them. Is that not very transphobic of you?

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 06/10/2022 19:17

When I rule the world, there will be a tax on the word 'hate' when used to mean mild irritation or sarcasm; well-founded annoyance or disapproval with the actions of an individual or group; dislike of/disagreement with an ideology; etc etc. The revenues will be enormous, at first anyway, and will be used for assorted good causes. Getting children out into the fresh air and away from screens, for example.

Brefugee · 06/10/2022 19:13

MN is known for being very offensive to trans people.

i see this a lot - but nobody is apparently able to show this. Because MN doesn't allow it. This claim without proof is absolutely goady as much as it is batshit.

I hadn't realised that this teacher is trying to highlight the absurdity of Canadian law. Clever.

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/10/2022 19:10

Choconut · 06/10/2022 18:39

The reason there's little talk of transmen is because transwomen frequently act like the entitled male pricks that they are and transmen don't.

If both groups were actually the sex they think they are/want to be then the behaviour would be reversed - but it isn't. To me it's one of the clearest reasons why TW are not W.

At the risk of being deleted:
For me one of the clearest reasons that TW are not W and TM are not M is childhood. There is a kindly(?) ignorance in the TWAW, TMAM stance. As kind as people think they are being, being Trans is not the same as being biological sex.

The experiences and challenges in childhood and beyond are so different that they are not comparable.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 06/10/2022 19:09

Every mild criticism of awful behaviour by a transwoman is prefaced by a 2000-word essay of disclaimers: 'not all trans, trans is valid, trans are so discriminated against' and so on. They've become a sacred caste against whom not one word can be said no matter what. No other group enjoys this privilege. And we still get ridiculous posts like that of Startagain51 and robin5810 with baseless, fantastical accusations of hatred, chastising women for 'transphobia' and smearing us as the C word. The teacher's actions are appalling and I for one will not be shamed out of morality.

LakieLady · 06/10/2022 19:07

However, I’m wondering if there is any space for the acknowledgment that there are a lot of people who identify as trans and have done nothing wrong and have no intention of hurting anyone. If anything they are the ones being treated badly by society.

I agree @amoobaa . The vast majority of trans people just want to get on with their lives.

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 19:00

the transphobia on this thread is appalling. obviously that man is being a total idiot, he’s ridiculing women, both trans and cis, and that’s absolutely wrong. but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people and it’s blatantly ignorant to not acknowledge that.

Startagain51 · 06/10/2022 19:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Naunet · 06/10/2022 18:52

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 18:47

Its total fetishisation of trans people

No, it’s fetishisation of women FFS 🙄

Naunet · 06/10/2022 18:48

TempName01 · 06/10/2022 18:31

If he is self ID and using women’s spaces then yes he is undermining women. If he is making a point about the ridiculousness of self ID etc then would that be in support of women? But then it’s not helpful to people with genuine gender issues. The whole thing is just a mess.

Where has this narrative come from that he’s doing it to make a political point? Has he said that?
Either way, under Canadian law, if he says he’s a woman, he’s a woman, so it still undermines us.

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 18:47

Its total fetishisation of trans people

coffeeandpoetry · 06/10/2022 18:46

TempName01 · 06/10/2022 18:42

So true but could that be somewhat down to socialisation?

Not everything is 'socialisation'. Very few differences between men and women is down to 'socialisation'. It's also not even a proved scientific hypothesis. It's nothing but a theory.

Hearthnhome · 06/10/2022 18:46

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 18:09

Whichever one it may be the crucial point that everyone is missing is that children/young adults are being used as unwilling participants to push one side or the other. Where is the outrage for that? Because that is abhorrent.

That’s not the point that people are missing kids and young adults had already been pulled into it. There’s no fighting it AND keeping young people out it.

Especially, since kids need young people are being groomed into the ideology.

TempName01 · 06/10/2022 18:42

Choconut · 06/10/2022 18:39

The reason there's little talk of transmen is because transwomen frequently act like the entitled male pricks that they are and transmen don't.

If both groups were actually the sex they think they are/want to be then the behaviour would be reversed - but it isn't. To me it's one of the clearest reasons why TW are not W.

So true but could that be somewhat down to socialisation?

OP posts:
Choconut · 06/10/2022 18:39

The reason there's little talk of transmen is because transwomen frequently act like the entitled male pricks that they are and transmen don't.

If both groups were actually the sex they think they are/want to be then the behaviour would be reversed - but it isn't. To me it's one of the clearest reasons why TW are not W.

TempName01 · 06/10/2022 18:31

Naunet · 06/10/2022 17:45

Can you explain why you find this undermines other men who want to be women, rather than women?

If he is self ID and using women’s spaces then yes he is undermining women. If he is making a point about the ridiculousness of self ID etc then would that be in support of women? But then it’s not helpful to people with genuine gender issues. The whole thing is just a mess.

OP posts:
VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 18:29

@amoobaa

Yes, the erosion of women isn’t ok.

It's a fucking hell of a lot worse than not ok

But I stand by my point that there is a lot of hate for transwomen on mumsnet. Surely you see that?

No, I don't see that. I wouldn't even describe it as hate, there is a hell of a lot of anger against those TRAs and their submissive, simpering allies, the majority of whom aren't even trans who are pushing the Gender Ideology Agenda, determined to close down women who speak about it and determined to remove all rights and safeguards from women and children. That also includes Government Institutions, Publicly funded bodies that are supposed to serve ALL members of the public equally and private businesses whose raison d'etre is selling products and services NOT preaching and lecturing their customers.

just because I think transwomen are generally being discriminated against, doesn’t mean I don’t understand the other issues going on nor does it mean I think they are less important.

How are they being discriminated against? They have the same rights as everyone else plus some additional rights that no-one else has. The mention of the word transwoman and publicly funded bodies and private businesses can't prostrate themselves fast enough to accommodate them.

Your black and white thinking isn’t going to help. I know it’s hard to hold multiple complex perspectives in mind but if we want to make progress, surely it’s worth the effort and time?

Don't be so bloody patronising. What black and white thinking? The fact that no-one can change sex perhaps? What progress do you have in mind?

I’m painfully aware of the patriarchy and the many threats to women’s lives.

The Gender Ideology Agenda/Trans Rights Agenda is patriarchy and misogyny on crack.

What on earth makes you think I’m not concerned about that?

I don't know, are you?

I’m simply saying that the way these posts tend to go, is a lot of hate is expressed towards all transwomen.

Covered in response to the same point above.

Also, if you care so much then share your views. I’m here to learn. There’s no need to accuse me of shutting down a conversation.

We do share our views, are you listening and learning?

I’m trying to make it more intelligent, not shut it down.

Again stop being so bloody patronising, you clearly have no idea of the intelligence and qualifications of the many, many, women on FWR S&G who speak out on this topic.

Fairislefandango · 06/10/2022 18:26

But I stand by my point that there is a lot of hate for transwomen on mumsnet. Surely you see that?

No. What makes you call it hate? Recognising that biological sex is real and important is not hate. Expecting safeguarding for women and children to be respected is not hate. Refusing to accept the lie that people can change sex is not hate.

AsAnyFuleKno · 06/10/2022 18:18

It's a difficult one for the school to rule on. They can't say 'no prosthetic breasts' as some women (including transwomen) might want or need to wear prosthetic breasts simply to appear 'normal'. So then you get into awkwardness and subjectivity about acceptable 'size' of prosthetic breasts; and this again is dependent on proportion - 38 JJJ will look very different on a woman who's a size 8 than a woman who is a size 20.

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 18:09

FamilyTreeBuilder · 06/10/2022 17:49

I think what the OP is getting at is that this is a stunt not to "undermine trans issues" but to show just how damaging the Canadian legislation is. There is a school of thought that Kayla Lemieux is not trans at all, that Kayla Lemieux is a "persona" adopted by an individual who wishes to point out what the Canadian legislation permits. So Kayla Lemieux pops up, with comedy breasts, and most Canadians are horrified, the school and COuncil and government tie themselves in knots over what to do, because Kayla Lemieux's actions are in fact perfectly fine according to Canadian law which states that a woman is anyone who says they are a woman.

Whether this is true or not doesn't really matter. Kayla Lemieux might genuinely think that the fake tits are the best thing since sliced bread and entirely appropriate for a classroom. Kayla Lemieux's actions - whatever the motive - are having the effect of peak-transing a lot of parents in the same was as Lia Thomas shed a huge spotlight on the issue in sport.

Whichever one it may be the crucial point that everyone is missing is that children/young adults are being used as unwilling participants to push one side or the other. Where is the outrage for that? Because that is abhorrent.