Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That this looks like a stunt to undermine trans issues

369 replies

TempName01 · 21/09/2022 18:03

Article in the Daily Mail, not sure if I should link to it…

A Canadian teacher in transition to female is pictured with enormous prosthetic breasts which they wear as part of their gender identity. When I saw the article I thought it must be a stunt against transgender people and trying to ridicule men transitioning to female. If they actually want to dress that way then to me, it looks like they are fetishising rather than genuinely transgender.

I am usually all for dressing how ever you want but it just looks so inappropriate, AIBU?

OP posts:
amoobaa · 06/10/2022 20:13

jewishmum · 06/10/2022 20:10

We get it; he can dress how he likes and make us accept it because it's his expression of himself as a woman.
I wonder if he is half mocking how liberal Canada has become.

He can’t make me accept it. And respecting transwomen does not mean accepting this behaviour. They are two separate things.

samyeagar · 06/10/2022 20:12

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 20:04

You’re putting me solely in charge of that decision?

This is complex and has many layers. I hope that there will be a solution that safeguards everyone.

You don’t have to choose between the rights of women, children and transwomen.

Unless you lump all transwomen in the same box as dangerous perverts. In which case, of course, transwomen’s rights will get eroded because nobody is advocating for the rights of dangerous perverts.

because nobody is advocating for the rights of dangerous perverts.

Yet that is an inevitable outcome and consequence of Self ID and Trans Women Are Women. Self ID and Trans Women Are Women covers the dangerous perverts too. No way around that.

So while it may feel distasteful to some who adhere to Self ID and Trans Women Are Women, that is exactly what they are advocating for.

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 20:11

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 19:57

With self-ID, how do you make sure that the only people accessing women's spaces (say a communal changing area) are genuine transpeople and not someone with autogynaephiliac tendencies?

What system would you put in place to differentiate them?

Well yes exactly.

How do you keep people safe?

I’m simply phrasing the question as:

How do you safeguard against dangerous sexual predators in a way that doesn’t deny transwomen their human rights.

jewishmum · 06/10/2022 20:10

We get it; he can dress how he likes and make us accept it because it's his expression of himself as a woman.
I wonder if he is half mocking how liberal Canada has become.

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 20:09

Theeyeballsinthesky · 06/10/2022 19:55

“Non binary ppl are valid”

so what is this binary that the rest of us are then? because I’ve never seen it as anything other than sexist stereotypes

The gender binary is the societal construct of being a man or being a woman. Of course, being female or male is a biological matter, but I’m talking about gender, the identity people attach to themselves to feel more comfortable. Some people, including me, feel they are neither a man or a woman and prefer to identify outside that, or as something in between.

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 20:06

DdraigGoch · 06/10/2022 19:51

@robin5810 how dare you misgender this stunning and brave woman. Transwomen are women you know, we must have total acceptance without exception and there can be no debate about it.

I'm glad that you have spotted the transphobia in this thread and trust that you will be withdrawing your utterly hateful and transphobic post.

Trans women are women, but he is not a trans woman. He is very clearly mocking trans women, and using Canadian law to be an idiot.

Hearthnhome · 06/10/2022 20:05

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:57

Come on. There’s quite a bit of hate on here.

At no point have I suggested that I agree with any of these awful things. All I’ve done is suggest that not all transwomen are dangerous sexual fetishists. And look at all the lovely replies I got.

Who said ALL trans women are dangerous sexual fetishists?

You don’t want womens spaces eroded - that’s commonly called Transphobic hate speech. Or do you include trans women in the group who should be able to use womens spaces. In which case you do agree with eroding womens spaces. Because you can’t change sex.

You are aware there’s no distinction between ‘genuine trans women’ and Men who dress as women for sexual kicks. If the latter say they are women and you think there’s a difference - this is commonly called transphobic hate speech.

Can you direct us to where there is actual hate speech directed at all trans women, on this thread?

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 20:04

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 19:53

And I don’t pretend to have the answers

Well someone's going to have to come up with those answers if we're going to allow some TW into woman's spaces and not others. As it stands it's a free for all. So who do you suggest makes that call and based on what?

You’re putting me solely in charge of that decision?

This is complex and has many layers. I hope that there will be a solution that safeguards everyone.

You don’t have to choose between the rights of women, children and transwomen.

Unless you lump all transwomen in the same box as dangerous perverts. In which case, of course, transwomen’s rights will get eroded because nobody is advocating for the rights of dangerous perverts.

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 20:03

MbatataOwl · 06/10/2022 20:00

What does non-binary people are valid actually mean? It's not based in reason so can't mean that and there is no legal recognition of non-binary so it obviously doesn't mean that either. What does it mean?

It means there are, and always have been, people who haven’t perfectly slotted into societal expectations :)

MbatataOwl · 06/10/2022 20:00

What does non-binary people are valid actually mean? It's not based in reason so can't mean that and there is no legal recognition of non-binary so it obviously doesn't mean that either. What does it mean?

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 19:57

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:46

That’s pretty offensive. Being transgender is entirely different to Autogynephilia.

With self-ID, how do you make sure that the only people accessing women's spaces (say a communal changing area) are genuine transpeople and not someone with autogynaephiliac tendencies?

What system would you put in place to differentiate them?

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:57

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 19:50

What I find completely unacceptable is lumping all transwomen in the same box.

Transwomen who deserve respect and dignity do exist. Why is that idea so outrageous?

No one's saying they don't deserve dignity or respect.

They're saying male bodies don't belong in female sex specific spaces.

Come on. There’s quite a bit of hate on here.

At no point have I suggested that I agree with any of these awful things. All I’ve done is suggest that not all transwomen are dangerous sexual fetishists. And look at all the lovely replies I got.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 06/10/2022 19:55

“Non binary ppl are valid”

so what is this binary that the rest of us are then? because I’ve never seen it as anything other than sexist stereotypes

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 19:53

And I don’t pretend to have the answers

Well someone's going to have to come up with those answers if we're going to allow some TW into woman's spaces and not others. As it stands it's a free for all. So who do you suggest makes that call and based on what?

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 19:52

Good question. And I don’t pretend to have the answers, as I said in my first post.

Stonewall who are apparently the gospel on all things trans has some interesting takes on who is trans and who isn't and cross dressers are most definitely under the Trans Umbrella.

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:52

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 19:00

the transphobia on this thread is appalling. obviously that man is being a total idiot, he’s ridiculing women, both trans and cis, and that’s absolutely wrong. but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people and it’s blatantly ignorant to not acknowledge that.

Exactly

DdraigGoch · 06/10/2022 19:51

robin5810 · 06/10/2022 19:00

the transphobia on this thread is appalling. obviously that man is being a total idiot, he’s ridiculing women, both trans and cis, and that’s absolutely wrong. but on a seperate note, trans people are real and valid, as are nonbinary people and gay people and it’s blatantly ignorant to not acknowledge that.

@robin5810 how dare you misgender this stunning and brave woman. Transwomen are women you know, we must have total acceptance without exception and there can be no debate about it.

I'm glad that you have spotted the transphobia in this thread and trust that you will be withdrawing your utterly hateful and transphobic post.

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:50

samyeagar · 06/10/2022 19:41

But who is the arbiter of who is and who isn't a trans woman?

Good question. And I don’t pretend to have the answers, as I said in my first post.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 19:50

What I find completely unacceptable is lumping all transwomen in the same box.

Transwomen who deserve respect and dignity do exist. Why is that idea so outrageous?

No one's saying they don't deserve dignity or respect.

They're saying male bodies don't belong in female sex specific spaces.

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 19:50

That’s pretty offensive. Being transgender is entirely different to Autogynephilia.

Do enlighten us, please.

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:46

BaggyAndWrinkled · 06/10/2022 17:03

Really poor argument.
Autogynaphelia is a thing. Look it up.

That’s pretty offensive. Being transgender is entirely different to Autogynephilia.

VestofAbsurdity · 06/10/2022 19:43

I’m not defending the erosion of women or women’s rights. That would make me a piece of shit. I’m not agreeing with men invading women’s spaces, again that would be really shitty.

How are you classing transwomen? Which spaces are you advocating they use?

lifeturnsonadime · 06/10/2022 19:42

What I find completely unacceptable is lumping all transwomen in the same box.

Transwomen who deserve respect and dignity do exist. Why is that idea so outrageous?

The transwomen who have my dignity and respect are the ones who recognise the issues with Self ID and the impact of women on the erosion of our rights in their names.

The ones who want to destroy boundaries, not so much.

samyeagar · 06/10/2022 19:41

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:38

See this is my point entirely.

I’m not defending the erosion of women or women’s rights. That would make me a piece of shit. I’m not agreeing with men invading women’s spaces, again that would be really shitty. And I’m certainly not condoning the prosthetics breasts this person is wearing. I personally find it offensive.

I’m in agreement with points made about specific incidents or people who are contributing to the above.

What I find completely unacceptable is lumping all transwomen in the same box.

Transwomen who deserve respect and dignity do exist. Why is that idea so outrageous?

But who is the arbiter of who is and who isn't a trans woman?

amoobaa · 06/10/2022 19:38

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 16:56

Some paedophiles are gay men. But you can’t say all gay men are paedophiles.

You basically say ‘for a lot of them’ it’s just a fetish and ‘maybe a few’ are deserving of basic respect.

There’s a similarity in the pattern of discrimination

No. That's very lazy arguing.

Gay men never asked for access to female spaces. Granting gay men rights never impinged upon the rights of anyone else or made women less safe.

Don't you see this colossal difference?

See this is my point entirely.

I’m not defending the erosion of women or women’s rights. That would make me a piece of shit. I’m not agreeing with men invading women’s spaces, again that would be really shitty. And I’m certainly not condoning the prosthetics breasts this person is wearing. I personally find it offensive.

I’m in agreement with points made about specific incidents or people who are contributing to the above.

What I find completely unacceptable is lumping all transwomen in the same box.

Transwomen who deserve respect and dignity do exist. Why is that idea so outrageous?