Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

V concerned about elderly neighbour

242 replies

NoFrills01 · 21/09/2022 16:59

We have a new neighbour, she is 91 and just got here from America, no family or friends, and she is renting the three story property which is over £1000+ a month.

We live in a rural area, there are buses, but still its a long walk to get around to anywhere, she obviously has no car.

She has no internet to set up a food delivery (what she wants to do) no phone, no bank account, and is struggling to work the gas cooker ect as she is from the states and things are a little different within the home.

I have a background in care, I find it a very odd situation. She seems frail, and she seems like she has early dementia to me.

I feel she is very vulnerable, I've offered to help all I can when I'm not working but she declines.

The house is the same as ours, and the stairs are steep. I'm worried we are the only ones who basically are checking in and would notice anything.

I'm not sure what to do. I think I need to gently ask a little more information, I'm worried about her health and welfare, and I'm not sure how she will keep up with bills or even pay them? It all seems so strange. She wasn't aware the bills are going up here, and she doesn't know how to work the heating and is currently just living off the microwave.

OP posts:
AttilaTheMeerkat · 22/09/2022 15:00

It's estimated that about 100,000 elderly Americans are abandoned every year, by relatives who are unable or unwilling to help look after them or pay for their care

Minfilia · 22/09/2022 14:58

Doingprettywellthanks · 22/09/2022 13:37

Bull shit.

This nurse friend has a vivid imagination or she enjoys winding you up.

I can assure you it isn’t bullshit - because I worked on the child protection cases of two of the kids involved. They had somewhat unique names that my nurse friend mentioned to me so it wasn’t exactly difficult to make the connection!

SatInTheCorner · 22/09/2022 14:54

Blimey, so odd. I'd speak to the GP and get advice from social care.

Wafflesnsniffles · 22/09/2022 14:52

Well done for caring about her. No advice except yes I definitely think you should find some way to get her some proper help.

CuriousMama · 22/09/2022 14:48

How awful. Thank goodness she has you looking out for her.

AttilaTheMeerkat · 22/09/2022 14:47

Sounds like granny dumping to me and she needs a safe guarding assessment from Social Services. Her relatives cannot or will not be able to afford dementia care for his mother so has looked overseas.

MiniTheMinx · 22/09/2022 14:32

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 14:10

If she was wandering the streets she should have been under the care of a dementia consultant not a GP. She would have had an MRI and a long neuropsychological assessment. Then no GP would be able to claim she was “fine”.

Except you need a GP to refer to a dementia / EMI consultant.

I can't speak for others experiences, but my father had these assessments ten years before we hit crisis point. He then had more scans and assessments. But still the GP insisted my father was fine, as did social services. Every time he was admitted to hospital he was sent home in a taxi.

The fashion now is "variable or fluctuating capacity" so whilst an individual may lack capacity over one decision, they are deemed to have capacity to make another, or have capacity to make the the same decision on a different day! You may have the capacity to choose only to eat marshmallows whilst lacking the capacity to choose sugar in your coffee......A diagnosis of dementia alone is insufficient reason to over ride the persons stated preferences in relation to how and where they live.

I hope OP can get some help for this lady.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 14:27

You sometimes have no choice but to "abandon" the older person before you can get any real help. We tried and failed to work with SS and got nowhere until we all agreed on the next hospital admission we wouldn't travel to visit and help get them back home. It doesn't feel good but we didn't feel we had a choice at that point.

TheGander · 22/09/2022 14:14

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 13:59

what did you actually do? Dump at a&e and leave the site or something else?

Pretty much. I'm a nurse and am ashamed to say that I used to judge people for Granny dumping and always said I'd never do it. And yet despite knowing the system, despite working with the continuing healthcare team, despite trying to put a plan in place to prevent a sudden crisis the system didn't work when it needed to.

It was complicated by the fact that I didn't live locally and had small children of my own, but there was an assumption that I could drop everything and drive 3 hours down the motorway to resolve every issue. I was getting daily phone calls from friends and neighbours who could see the problems and were desperately worried and yet her GP was a complete chocolate Tea pot.

I took her to A&E for a UTI and told them she was a safeguarding concern and couldn't be discharged alone. This finally led to a social care assessment and I got support to move her to a care home (she could self-fund). She was actually well cared for and settled well but the move was hugely more traumatic for her than it needed to be.

This isn’t quite granny dumping, I think
you’re being hard on yourself . You didn’t disappear and eventually helped move her to a care home which she apparently paid for , meaning presumably you inherited less in the long run. I think anyone who’s had any dealings with elderly relatives with dementia will understand you get pushed to breaking point because “ services “ expect the (usually female) child(ren) to mop every crisis up. Been there, got a drawer full of t shirts.

zingally · 22/09/2022 14:12

There's something fishy about this... How did she get from the airport to a rural house with no car, phone or bank card? How did she manage to organise a rental of a middle-of-nowhere-house from the US? Someone must have helped her/dropped her off.

The fact that she seems to be unwilling/unable to give you any of those quite basic details... to me, I smell a rat.

I'd be contacting your local social services, and tell them everything you've said here.

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 14:10

If she was wandering the streets she should have been under the care of a dementia consultant not a GP. She would have had an MRI and a long neuropsychological assessment. Then no GP would be able to claim she was “fine”.

Except you need a GP to refer to a dementia / EMI consultant.

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 14:08

If she could self fund, why didn’t you just get her in to a care home?

Because she refused. And her idiot GP told her she was doing well to live independently.

It was only after social care reviewed her in hospital along with the medical and nursing records that they agreed she was at risk.

I don't want to hijack the thread anymore, I agree the scenario the OP describes needs checking. I just wanted to explain that "Granny dumping" is complicated. As with many things, best not to judge until you have walked in another person's shoes.

Neverendingdust · 22/09/2022 14:05

You’re doing the right thing OP, she is fortunate to have you as a neighbour. I hadn’t heard of this before but I can absolutely see why those in desperate need could resort to such an act but also how attractive it would be for some heartless relative to take advantage of.

For those familiar with this what I don’t understand is how the authorities in the US wouldn’t be questioning where Mr or Mrs X was? Can you just slip off the radar like that? Surely if there’s property and an estate involved you need a death certificate? Or is it a case of them coming here for the free treatment and the ’relatives’ keep in touch distantly awaiting the death?

Doingprettywellthanks · 22/09/2022 14:04

IrisVersicolor · 22/09/2022 14:03

If she was wandering the streets she should have been under the care of a dementia consultant not a GP. She would have had an MRI and a long neuropsychological assessment. Then no GP would be able to claim she was “fine”.

This.

Doingprettywellthanks · 22/09/2022 14:03

In my experience, the I’m not judging

But if someone can self-fund and that was the intention, why do you need social care involvement.

My great uncle could self Fund so allowed us to jump over social care involvement

IrisVersicolor · 22/09/2022 14:03

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 13:27

I was a Granny dumper. It was the only way to get help for my DM when she began to wander the streets in her nightie handing money out, because her GP kept insisting she was fine. (Probably because the canny so and so used to revise for the mini mental state examination and completely pulled the wool over his eyes). Don't assume all Granny dumpers have Ill intent, they might just be at the end of their tether.

I agree that this scenario is worrying though. Hopefully Social Care can look in to it.

If she was wandering the streets she should have been under the care of a dementia consultant not a GP. She would have had an MRI and a long neuropsychological assessment. Then no GP would be able to claim she was “fine”.

Doingprettywellthanks · 22/09/2022 14:01

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 13:59

what did you actually do? Dump at a&e and leave the site or something else?

Pretty much. I'm a nurse and am ashamed to say that I used to judge people for Granny dumping and always said I'd never do it. And yet despite knowing the system, despite working with the continuing healthcare team, despite trying to put a plan in place to prevent a sudden crisis the system didn't work when it needed to.

It was complicated by the fact that I didn't live locally and had small children of my own, but there was an assumption that I could drop everything and drive 3 hours down the motorway to resolve every issue. I was getting daily phone calls from friends and neighbours who could see the problems and were desperately worried and yet her GP was a complete chocolate Tea pot.

I took her to A&E for a UTI and told them she was a safeguarding concern and couldn't be discharged alone. This finally led to a social care assessment and I got support to move her to a care home (she could self-fund). She was actually well cared for and settled well but the move was hugely more traumatic for her than it needed to be.

If she could self fund, why didn’t you just get her in to a care home?

MiniTheMinx · 22/09/2022 14:00

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 13:27

I was a Granny dumper. It was the only way to get help for my DM when she began to wander the streets in her nightie handing money out, because her GP kept insisting she was fine. (Probably because the canny so and so used to revise for the mini mental state examination and completely pulled the wool over his eyes). Don't assume all Granny dumpers have Ill intent, they might just be at the end of their tether.

I agree that this scenario is worrying though. Hopefully Social Care can look in to it.

I'm another granny dumper.
mam0918 you don't have a clue. I coped for 7 years after my mother's death, not even time to reflect, think, grieve.

I had DC to look after, a job, my own home, my own worries, and yet there I was being kicked, harassed, shouted at, having to get out of bed in the night, tour the streets in the dark, visit the pubs, deal with the people he pissed off, clean up after his "imaginary parties" excuse his behaviour often inappropriate, listen to how other men's wives were running after him, taxi drivers stealing from him, neighbours taking stuff, and call pest control numerous times when he scratched his skin until it bled. He could "see the bugs under his skin crawling, and they crawled the walls" despite being quite blind, and there being no bugs. He introduced me to his mother, the same one that had died when he was 2 days old. He kicked my front door many times a day, threatened to hit me, he called all three emergency services one day, that was a real adventure, usually it was just one or two calls to the police or for an ambulance. I kicked the door in twice with emergency services because he had barricaded himself in, and had to speak to police when they found a revolver under his pillow, but only after he threatened to hit the copper with a spade. He was drunk, obnoxious, impossible and demented. At 96 he can still run, but his mind is mash. He rang to police making false allegations about everyone in the end, including me. Two years later I still jump out of my skin if anyone knocks o the front door, I probably have PTSD, I certainly now live with anxiety. And yet I deal with violent kids.....but they are piece of cake compared to a demented man.

YOU have NO fucking clue. Social care is on its knees. I worked for LA for years, the same LA that denied any support to my father. My story is not unusual. And the thing that pisses me off the most, I am almost 100% certain that had I been his son and not his daughter I would have succeeded in getting help for him. Your post is not just ignorant, but takes no account of the fact that its usually women having to provide care to elderly relatives and children, and even social workers, ourselves supposedly paragons of equality speak and think are sexist in the assumption that "women care"

OP make an ordinary referral to adult social care, although, in some areas they will not take you seriously unless the referral comes through another agency such as GP, hospital, Age concern or similar. They are not obliged to make any assessment. If you have specific and serious concerns regarding welfare when no assessment is offered, then raise it as safeguarding and don't hesitate to point out that the LA are failing in their duty to safeguard.

Cuck00soup · 22/09/2022 13:59

what did you actually do? Dump at a&e and leave the site or something else?

Pretty much. I'm a nurse and am ashamed to say that I used to judge people for Granny dumping and always said I'd never do it. And yet despite knowing the system, despite working with the continuing healthcare team, despite trying to put a plan in place to prevent a sudden crisis the system didn't work when it needed to.

It was complicated by the fact that I didn't live locally and had small children of my own, but there was an assumption that I could drop everything and drive 3 hours down the motorway to resolve every issue. I was getting daily phone calls from friends and neighbours who could see the problems and were desperately worried and yet her GP was a complete chocolate Tea pot.

I took her to A&E for a UTI and told them she was a safeguarding concern and couldn't be discharged alone. This finally led to a social care assessment and I got support to move her to a care home (she could self-fund). She was actually well cared for and settled well but the move was hugely more traumatic for her than it needed to be.

theDudesmummy · 22/09/2022 13:55

We can't tell from the OP whether she is significantly self-neglecting. If she did not have the help of the neighbour would she have access to food? How? Does she have health conditions she is not getting/complying with treatment for? etc etc

entropynow · 22/09/2022 13:54

entropynow · 22/09/2022 13:53

And this is one of the wrong pieces of advice. I used to be a LA manager in elder social care so oddly enough I know what I'm talking about. There is no clear evidence of abuse not is she self neglecting to SAFA standards. It's a social support issue, and you need consent to refer.

And in any case you are much, much more likely to get a good outcome than if it is sprung on her without warning

entropynow · 22/09/2022 13:53

ScarlettnotOHara · 22/09/2022 07:07

@entropynow yes you can report to adult social care without a person’s knowledge if it’s a safeguarding concern . OP you’re getting a lot of wrong advice on this thread, you need to contact adult social services and they will point you in the right direction . Other age related charities are a good starting point .

And this is one of the wrong pieces of advice. I used to be a LA manager in elder social care so oddly enough I know what I'm talking about. There is no clear evidence of abuse not is she self neglecting to SAFA standards. It's a social support issue, and you need consent to refer.

justasking111 · 22/09/2022 13:50

Mafioso nonna in hiding?

theDudesmummy · 22/09/2022 13:50

@Doingprettywellthanks

It really does happen that parents will invent or even cause symptoms in children in order to access free childcare by way of a hospital admission. It is not "common" though, the nurse is exaggerating there, they are quite extreme cases really, but I used to work in assessing parents for family court cases and I saw this multiple times. Often of course it is related to mental illness, or true desperation for social help, and so rather a different thing. But the former scenario does happen.

NeckFanInSoftPlay · 22/09/2022 13:42

@Cosmos123 Sad You really think your kids would do this?