Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Working mothers can't have it all?

597 replies

Unicornhat · 21/09/2022 12:27

I've never been ruthlessly ambitious but have always worked hard and been in pretty senior roles since my mid 20s. I'm currently in a snr manager role in a large company and earn a really good salary with perks etc. I feel like I kind of fell into this role - I've never consciously decided this is where I've wanted my career to be, I was approached about the job and here we are.
I now have an almost 2 year old and I hope to have another.
I'm finding the balance really difficult. I have so much less interest in my job and I'm fed up of it taking up so much headspace outside of the office, and I'm fed up of being the manager. It's a role where you're creative and always coming up with more and more new ideas. The workload is intense I always feel I'm letting someone down.
Realistically, for me to get a part time job, or even one that gives you an opportunity for a proper lunch break and to leave on time, would mean a massive pay cut. Also, if I step back for a while I'm concerned I wouldn't get back into a senior role and salary for a v long time.
Am I just crap at managing things, or is it possible to hold down a good career and have young children? Has anyone given up a job like this and then regretted it? Have you struggled financially?
My sister and in laws keep telling me to get an easier job but it's not that simple!

OP posts:
Topgub · 22/09/2022 13:08

I'd also change this

The huge majority of the nurses I work with who have young children do not work full time hours because the shift work can be so incompatible with family life once there are little children on the scene.

To most of the women dont work full time because they prioritise their ohs career under the guise of 'family life'

Delatron · 22/09/2022 13:08

I don’t think anyone is saying being at home full time is having it all either.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 13:07

@Delatron what industry do you work in? When you say industry do you mean workplace?

Topgub · 22/09/2022 13:06

@Delatron

Yup.

Not easy for everyone.

Again. Never said it was.

Pushing back against sexist expectations and over worked culture is a start

Topgub · 22/09/2022 13:05

@EmptyHouse0822

So we're back to you basically saying that unless you're at home almost full time you can't have it all.

I completely disagree.

It might not be what you want but that's not the same as impossible for everyone.

The long shifts work absolutely fine for us as a family. When they were pre school it meant no external childcare.

I should be doing mon to Thurs in my current role but its not possible at the moment and I'm liking being back on the shifts.

My kids are fully prioritised.

Delatron · 22/09/2022 13:02

And 12 hour shifts do not sound like having it all to me.

Delatron · 22/09/2022 13:01

@Topgub and that’s great. But our parenting equally looked like this : both getting home no earlier than 7.30 due to the nature of our jobs.
In my industry one woman was finally allowed to leave on a Friday at 4pm to pick up her kids after years of asking.

I agree, those that have the best set up are where it’s 50:50 but both jobs need to be flexible. Not many can have that ideal arrangement.

Rightmoveanon · 22/09/2022 13:00

@outtheshowernow

Presume that was aimed at me?

My children will likely have to work full time their entire lives, they won’t be able to afford houses, possibly children. The world is fucked. The country is fucked.

Me working full time means that we are in a much better financial position, I am saving for their future and I am showing them that DH and I are equals and that they and any future partners can also be equals.

I am also in the position where I have pushed and pushed to make my job fit in with the kids. I drop off at school (breakfast club, not sure if I’ll be judged for that?) every day. I pick up 1-2 times. DH does the other pick ups. Our kids and their future are the priority for both of us.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 13:00

TheMoops · 22/09/2022 12:59

Will you be the first poster to answer this I wonder - how many hours do you have to spend with children to prove you a prioritising them?

Excellent question!

Thanks. It's probably the 5th time I've asked it on this thread. Oddly none of the posters claiming that people who work don't really love their children wany to actually answer it.

EmptyHouse0822 · 22/09/2022 12:59

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:49

@EmptyHouse0822

Pretty much yeah.

I work/worked 3 weeks of 3 and one week of 4 12 hour shifts.

Its absolutely fine. Great even.

It means you have 4 full days at least at home.

You seem to be implying full time is 7 12 hours. Its not.

Balance is actual balance? Not the vast majority at home or at work. But as equal as possible between the 2.

And that’s great that you didn’t mind doing long shifts, but that doesn’t mean everyone else does.

I used to do long shifts (13 hour shifts) three days a week when I went back to work after my first son but I hated it and I missed him.

After my second son I went down to two long shifts a week which although was obviously better I still found it hard not seeing my children two days a week.

The role I have now is much more family friendly in that I’m home 4 days a week and on the days that I do work, I work hours that allow for me to see my children for over 2 hours in the morning before school and then another 2.5 hours before they go to bed. I would still like more time with them in the evenings but like you said, I still get 4 days a week where I’m home every evening so it makes it more bearable.

The huge majority of the nurses I work with who have young children do not work full time hours because the shift work can be so incompatible with family life once there are little children on the scene.

TheMoops · 22/09/2022 12:59

Will you be the first poster to answer this I wonder - how many hours do you have to spend with children to prove you a prioritising them?

Excellent question!

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:58

@outtheshowernow

Can you explain why its not?

We role model shared / equal parenting

We provide their lifestyle.

Spend quality time with them

They get time with other family and friends, clubs etc

Where is the lack of priority?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 12:57

And, to add, it's a result of shitty gender stereotyping and presenteeism that people don't progress on part time. It's simply untrue that people have to be physically in a work place 60 hrs a week to be successful. We should be judged based on our work output, not the hours we are there.

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:56

@Delatron

I didnt choose my oh based on him not threatening my career

I chose to have children with him (amongst other things) based on the fact I expected him to parent them equally.

Rightmoveanon · 22/09/2022 12:55

@EmptyHouse0822

Having read your updates I think you are doing amazing as you are.

In spite of the tone of my posts I have no issue with people working part time!

I only took offence to the insinuation that those working full time were not prioritising their children.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 12:53

outtheshowernow · 22/09/2022 12:50

You can not possible believe that prioritising your children is working full time are you trying to kid yourself aswell as us ?

@outtheshowernow

Will you be the first poster to answer this I wonder - how many hours do you have to spend with children to prove you a prioritising them?

Delatron · 22/09/2022 12:53

@Topgub

But if both parents have jobs where they are unable to be home before 7.30 then neither parent sees the children in the week. And not many would be happy with that.

Now I get what you are saying. In my industry there were a few (successful) women who married men with let’s say much more flexible (lower status) jobs - they could be at home with the kids more - women could work all hours. This was deliberate. They chose the man based on the fact he wouldn’t threaten her career.

But alas that wasn’t something I considered.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 12:52

@EmptyHouse0822 You might not be able to get the balance in your current role. Some roles/ employers just aren't open to it. That doesn't mean it's not possible, just that you might not get exactly what you want where you are now.

It might also mean challenging a no, thinking of a different avenue, finding a different way to progress.

I am part time (32hrs vs 37.5 full time, compressed so work 4 days). We didn't "do" part time in my department, but I made a compelling business case as to how it would work and I made sure it did work. I will likely go full time soon, mainly because I have just had a promotion which means it's awkward to be unavailable a set day consistently and I want to be paid for my time, but as I wfh and have good autonomy I plan to continue being available for my kids.

it's not always easy to get there, but just because it's not easy doesn't mean it's not possible.

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:51

Also what @Rightmoveanon said

EmptyHouse0822 · 22/09/2022 12:50

Sorry, I’m not sure if you work at all but there are flexible jobs, ones that allow some WFH, good work life balance. I have one.

I’m a nurse so definitely no WFH option unfortunately.

outtheshowernow · 22/09/2022 12:50

Rightmoveanon · 22/09/2022 12:16

@EmptyHouse0822

So children are your priority. Presumably then work is your husband’s priority?

Or would you say that the children are still his priority but he manages to work alongside them being his priority?

Because those two things are not mutually exclusive you know?

You can not possible believe that prioritising your children is working full time are you trying to kid yourself aswell as us ?

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:49

@EmptyHouse0822

Pretty much yeah.

I work/worked 3 weeks of 3 and one week of 4 12 hour shifts.

Its absolutely fine. Great even.

It means you have 4 full days at least at home.

You seem to be implying full time is 7 12 hours. Its not.

Balance is actual balance? Not the vast majority at home or at work. But as equal as possible between the 2.

Rightmoveanon · 22/09/2022 12:47

@EmptyHouse0822

Sorry, I’m not sure if you work at all but there are flexible jobs, ones that allow some WFH, good work life balance. I have one.

The only way I got it was by Flexible working requests to HR by me, 2 turned down, 3rd accepted when they realised there was no business reason for me not to do it, and that I wasn’t going to give up.

Flexible working request for DH. Surprisingly this was actually very easy. Men just don’t ask for it! They can’t be discriminated against because they are a man.

Our flexible working was to go down to 0.8 when DC were in nursery and have a day at home each, 3 days nursery. Now we are both full time but work flexibly around the kids. We have no outside help.

When one persons income is not the most important thing in the world. Then you split of everything else down the middle. We do half of everything and it works. There is no power play. No micromanaging.

It might not be doable for you now but if more people did this then we’d see a big shift which would make a lot of people a lot happier.

Of course, we wouldn’t please those of us who want a rich man to take care of them. And there’s still a lot of those about.

We would see more women continue their careers (not necessarily full time, no one necessarily needs to be full time) that they have worked so hard for. More women would be financially independent if marriages fail. Less women would be in poverty in their old age. Men’s expectations would change from wanting a wife to do everything for them and the kids (still rife in my social circle!) to having an equal.

There is a massive shift needed. It will never happen when you have people telling Mother’s that their children aren’t their priority if they work, or work full time.

I work full time (did I mention 😂) and by doing that I am prioritising my children, I am giving them an excellent role model and teaching them that men and women are equals. I’m damned if I’ll be made to feel an inferior parent because of it.

EmptyHouse0822 · 22/09/2022 12:44

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:37

@EmptyHouse0822

Oh well.

Like I said, a choice.

Hopefully the role doesn't go to someone else on the meantime and you can take it on when you no longer need to 'prioritise' your kids so much.

And that’s your advice when I ask you how I “can have it all”?! 😂

Well, aren’t you a fountain of knowledge and guidance. All you’ve done is bang on about how women can have full time high flying careers as well as spend quality time with their children, and when I ask you how you think I would do it, the best you can come up with is “Oh well.”

You actually make it sound like a parent thinking spending time with their children is more important than their job is a bad thing?!

If I went full time I would spend 12 hours a day out the house and only 2 hours a day with my children and is that your perfect scenario and balanced version of “women being able to have it all” ?

Topgub · 22/09/2022 12:42

@Delatron

Did you ask me that before? Someone did and I answered.

Of course I realise it's not easy for everyone. It wasn't easy for me/us.

No, dh didn't stay at home. Neither of us did. We were equal parents. I wouldnt have had kids other wise.

Certainly wouldn't have had them with someone who prioritise ld their own career/worked away.