Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my daughters

110 replies

Foreveranxious22 · 21/09/2022 11:00

Hi! I have 2DD (5yo and 5months) and my partner and I have been wanting to go for a weekend trip to London. We went in the summer last year but I was very early pregnant and super tired and sick so we planned to return.
My partner and I have been talking about it in a casual way to go in November. We both have birthdays in nov and would love to do some Christmas markets and do some shopping. It’s now getting to the time to start to book trains and hotels but I’m worried about leaving DD2 in particular.
Both girls would stay with my partners parents and I know DD1 would be completely fine it’s just the baby I’m worried about. I’d love to know peoples opinions and WWYD? She would be 7 and a half months when we are planning to go, she sleeps through the night well but is very clingy with me. We see their grandparents regularly - at least once a week. I don’t know I guess I feel guilty for wanting to go away as she is so young and I don’t think DD1 slept out until she about 2. Opinions are welcome, I just want to know what others would do/have done.
Thank you x

OP posts:
Foreveranxious22 · 21/09/2022 15:05

Please don’t forget that I asked for your unbiased views on my situation and you are doing that. Just because you don’t agree with OTHERS please keep that to yourself. Tell me your option, that’s fine and what I asked, but others didn’t. We all have our ways of parenting, it’s the hardest job in the world. Thank you everyone

OP posts:
abovedecknotbelow · 21/09/2022 15:00

I left Dts at 7 weeks for a night for Sils wedding. It was a brilliant night, kids didn't notice. Go!

Thetractorjustmoved · 21/09/2022 14:59

These kind of threads make me realise why being a mum is so hard! Everyone has different opinions, strongly held.
There's no right or wrong answer, only what's right for you. Leaving your baby for a weekend with loving grandparents and enjoying yourself is absolutely fine, absolutely no harm will come to your baby and it doesn't mean you love them any less!
Equally if you don't feel ready, or can't be bothered with the faff of settling a baby at their grandparents or whatever, that's fine too!
There is genuinely no right answer. I beat myself up when my baby was small- I craved alone time but felt that it must 'prove' that I didn't love my baby enough. It's rubbish. Everyone's different, and some babies are harder to settle than others. That's all it is. If you think you'll be able to enjoy it, then go for it! But don't worry about what other people do and don't do- it's absolutely just about you.

Onestepforwards2back · 21/09/2022 14:49

Lurkingandlearning · 21/09/2022 12:03

Can you do a trial run before you book? When you are close by and can go and get her if she won’t settle

This. It’s a trial for both your partner’s parents and the dc

queenatom · 21/09/2022 14:44

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:26

@queenatom I haven’t insinuated anything of the sort. I’ve said more times than I care to repeat, EVERYONE SHOULD DO WHAT THEY FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH.

A baby that cries for its mum, and gets no response, WILL stop crying. Not because theyre fine and happy, but because they’ve seen that crying makes no difference and it’s an evolutionary response to then be quiet when they feel particularly vulnerable.

If you’re fine with that, you’re fine with that. I’m not. So you might leave your baby and I might not. There’s seriously no point in arguing about it with me - we aren’t going to agree, as we see it differently.

What the OP chooses to do, is up to her. Not you, and not me.

Is it possible that a baby in that scenario might stop crying because another caregiver is there to meet their needs? If I leave the room and my baby starts crying, he will stop if my husband or his grandmother is there and engages him. Has he stopped crying then because it makes no difference, or is it possible that I am not the only person capable of meeting his needs?

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 21/09/2022 14:44

I wouldn't bit I am a soft touch and hate the thought of my children being upset. I have left my 3 yr old maybe 3 times when absolutely necessary but that's it. 10month old still BF so I think night time would be hell for whoever had him.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/09/2022 14:39

Floomobal · 21/09/2022 14:37

And the NHS guidance is that if you are hospitalised for treatment, your baby will come with you. Because they deem it in the baby’s best interest.

I don’t understand why you’re arguing about it with me? It’s the guidance, I didn’t write it

@Floomobal

you didn’t answer my question

how is she supposed to get treatment and rest and recover etc if she has a baby with her that she has to look after?!

honestly! You do not cease to be a person with needs just cos you have a baby you know

baby can stay with dad or another relative and be just fine

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:37

*name change from a previous thread 🙄

Floomobal · 21/09/2022 14:37

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/09/2022 14:34

@Derbee

she was at the hospital because she was ill! Baby can stay at home with their dad or relative

how is she supposed to get treatment and rest and recover etc if she has a baby with her that she has to look after?!

honestly! You do not cease to be a person with needs just cos you have a baby you know

And the NHS guidance is that if you are hospitalised for treatment, your baby will come with you. Because they deem it in the baby’s best interest.

I don’t understand why you’re arguing about it with me? It’s the guidance, I didn’t write it

Luredbyapomegranate · 21/09/2022 14:37

It will be fine - you've got plenty of time till November to get her used to spending a bit more time with them.

Undertheoldlindentree · 21/09/2022 14:37

Personally I wouldn't contemplate leaving overnight until youngest was 3 or 4 years old, but only you know what's right for you.

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/09/2022 14:35

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:30

I don’t know where or when that was, but the NHS guidance would now be that your baby would stay with you in hospital. So clearly others in the know feel that it’s best for a young baby to be with its mother where possible.

Some things can’t be helped. But a shopping weekend away isn’t one of those things

@Derbee

actually it is one of those things if it’s conducive to maternal mental health, it’s v important

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/09/2022 14:34

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:30

I don’t know where or when that was, but the NHS guidance would now be that your baby would stay with you in hospital. So clearly others in the know feel that it’s best for a young baby to be with its mother where possible.

Some things can’t be helped. But a shopping weekend away isn’t one of those things

@Derbee

she was at the hospital because she was ill! Baby can stay at home with their dad or relative

how is she supposed to get treatment and rest and recover etc if she has a baby with her that she has to look after?!

honestly! You do not cease to be a person with needs just cos you have a baby you know

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:30

Livpool · 21/09/2022 14:24

The language you use if very emotional and quite guilt-inducing.

I had to spend 3 nights in hospital when I had an asthma attack when DS was 2 months old. Mummy wasn't coming if he cried!

I also did overnight trips with DH before he was one.

Me and DS have a lovely relationship and have a loving bond. Nothing was broken!

Go OP, if you want to. You know your children and the grandparents best

I don’t know where or when that was, but the NHS guidance would now be that your baby would stay with you in hospital. So clearly others in the know feel that it’s best for a young baby to be with its mother where possible.

Some things can’t be helped. But a shopping weekend away isn’t one of those things

Derbee · 21/09/2022 14:26

@queenatom I haven’t insinuated anything of the sort. I’ve said more times than I care to repeat, EVERYONE SHOULD DO WHAT THEY FEEL COMFORTABLE WITH.

A baby that cries for its mum, and gets no response, WILL stop crying. Not because theyre fine and happy, but because they’ve seen that crying makes no difference and it’s an evolutionary response to then be quiet when they feel particularly vulnerable.

If you’re fine with that, you’re fine with that. I’m not. So you might leave your baby and I might not. There’s seriously no point in arguing about it with me - we aren’t going to agree, as we see it differently.

What the OP chooses to do, is up to her. Not you, and not me.

Livpool · 21/09/2022 14:24

Derbee · 21/09/2022 13:53

Although she cried for a while when we left she was really good.

See for me, that’s would be horrific. I couldn’t do something to my baby that makes them cry. I also don’t see it as being “good” that a baby stops crying when they realise their mum isn’t coming when they cry. It’s heartbreaking.

Everyone has their opinions and boundaries, and you do what you’re comfortable with. I don’t really see the point of asking here. People that have done it aren’t going to say they feel their babies suffered in hindsight.

The language you use if very emotional and quite guilt-inducing.

I had to spend 3 nights in hospital when I had an asthma attack when DS was 2 months old. Mummy wasn't coming if he cried!

I also did overnight trips with DH before he was one.

Me and DS have a lovely relationship and have a loving bond. Nothing was broken!

Go OP, if you want to. You know your children and the grandparents best

Ssmiler · 21/09/2022 14:18

I didn’t leave DD1 with DGP until she was over 2yo - but I was happy to leave DS much earlier as he was very happy as long as his big sister was still in his line of sight! So my experience is that with a second child it can be easier as they still have a big degree of familiarity, in their sibling.
Obviously depends on the child etc but just that different perspective relating to second child being left with DGP along with their sibling - rather than first child going there alone made a big difference for us
maybe worth thinking about if that is relevant to you -also same age gap with my two as yours

LuckySantangelo35 · 21/09/2022 14:13

queenatom · 21/09/2022 14:10

My baby cries when I have to stop him playing to change his nappy, when I try to put him in his high chair, when I tell him not to touch the radiator...If I didn't do things that made him cry he'd probably be crying for other reasons!

Also "I also don’t see it as being “good” that a baby stops crying when they realise their mum isn’t coming when they cry"? No-one's talking about leaving the baby in a skip, or even talking about leaving them with a babysitter they don't know. They'll be staying with family members who love them and who they see regularly and know well. Fair enough if you aren't personally comfortable with it, but bit much to insinuate that people are heartless monsters for making a different choice.

@Derbee

exactly!

babies cry 🤷‍♀️

if going away for an adult only weekend is important for OP’s mental health she should do it. Op is every bit as important as the baby

QueenCarrot · 21/09/2022 14:12

When my kids were very small I had an unexpected stay in hospital. I was very glad that they already had the experience of staying over night with their grandparents. They loved their stays with Nanny and Grandad.

queenatom · 21/09/2022 14:10

Derbee · 21/09/2022 13:53

Although she cried for a while when we left she was really good.

See for me, that’s would be horrific. I couldn’t do something to my baby that makes them cry. I also don’t see it as being “good” that a baby stops crying when they realise their mum isn’t coming when they cry. It’s heartbreaking.

Everyone has their opinions and boundaries, and you do what you’re comfortable with. I don’t really see the point of asking here. People that have done it aren’t going to say they feel their babies suffered in hindsight.

My baby cries when I have to stop him playing to change his nappy, when I try to put him in his high chair, when I tell him not to touch the radiator...If I didn't do things that made him cry he'd probably be crying for other reasons!

Also "I also don’t see it as being “good” that a baby stops crying when they realise their mum isn’t coming when they cry"? No-one's talking about leaving the baby in a skip, or even talking about leaving them with a babysitter they don't know. They'll be staying with family members who love them and who they see regularly and know well. Fair enough if you aren't personally comfortable with it, but bit much to insinuate that people are heartless monsters for making a different choice.

BloodAndFire · 21/09/2022 14:08

Personally I wouldn't have left mine when they were five months old overnight without a very good reason, but it's a personal decision, no absolute right or wrong.

Derbee · 21/09/2022 13:53

Although she cried for a while when we left she was really good.

See for me, that’s would be horrific. I couldn’t do something to my baby that makes them cry. I also don’t see it as being “good” that a baby stops crying when they realise their mum isn’t coming when they cry. It’s heartbreaking.

Everyone has their opinions and boundaries, and you do what you’re comfortable with. I don’t really see the point of asking here. People that have done it aren’t going to say they feel their babies suffered in hindsight.

queenatom · 21/09/2022 13:50

We left my son with his grandma when he was 8 months for two nights to go to a wedding near London. He was totally fine. He saw her regularly anyway and we did plenty of practice runs of them having one on one time, including a sleepover a couple of weeks before whilst we were nearby. If you're comfortable with them and you think you'll be able to relax and enjoy your trip then I'd go for it!

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 21/09/2022 13:49

I left DS for a week when he was 6 months when I went on honeymoon. Looking back it was too long but his grandparents fussed over him all week and he came home unscathed so all’s well that ends well.

Somethingneedstochange · 21/09/2022 13:46

If they're GP are happy to have them then go. Could they look after the children in your home then it will be DD2 own home? If she's clingy the younger you leave her with someone the better. My daughter used to be really clingy with me I got family to have her overnight. I didn't want her being clingy and unhappy when she started nursery. She settled in straight away and loved it.