Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Royal commentator says that African descendants of past kings should pay reparations for slavery

184 replies

cocococococococo · 21/09/2022 06:38

😳
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-jr-fordwich-slave-trade-reparations-b2171510.html

OP posts:
hattie43 · 21/09/2022 08:15

It's all very strange , paying reparations today by people who didn't do anything to people nothing happened to .
It's historic and it'd be far better to abolish slavery today .

Crazykatie · 21/09/2022 08:13

There is no difference between reparations for slavery and that for indigenous populations around the world. There is hardly any country that has not exploited and slaughtered it’s neighbours or enslave others in the past.

IT IS STILL HAPPENING TODAY we are all benefiting from exploitation in our daily lives

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 08:08

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:44

Simple.

  1. Money gets paid to government of country x.
  1. President of country x (probably the descendent of slavers) siphons off the money.
  1. It gets laundered back to Canary Wharf and gets spent on Kensington High St by said president and his family.

This.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 08:07

Will the descendants of African chiefs who sold their people to slavers have to pay out as well?

I have found out that Joan down the road from me is a descendant of a Black and Tan who killed one of my ancestors in Ireland? Should I be expecting a big pay out from her too?

What about Derek whose ancestor murdered Jenny's ancestor. is Jenny ready for a pay out?

It is bollocks to think that anyone or any collection of people can pay for something that happened in the past. TOTAL BOLLOCKS.

I do hope though that if some gobshite nation-probably the UK-pays out in any way that the history of some of these African nations be looked at too. They don't have glorious pre=lasparian societies either. Pol Pot, Idi Amin spring to mind. Shocking isn't it to discover that every nation on earth will have done something wrong at some point.

How is money going to make it all better? No fucker need bother apologising for anything my ancestor might or might have or not done.

There is plenty of shite going on now all around the world and not one fucking nation-including African nations-has the right to throw the first stone.

Sorry for something that happened hundreds of years ago. Balls. It's a narrative that needs to stop.

sst1234 · 21/09/2022 07:59

Why not start with the corrupt African leaders of today by making them give up their looted trillions back to the people they looted them from, just in the last 60 years. Wouldn’t that be a noble idea.

But oh no, that’s not progressive enough right? Maybe someone will come along and say it’s even racist.

oakleaffy · 21/09/2022 07:53

MbatataOwl · 21/09/2022 07:36

We need to concentrate on slavery that is happening today.
In the UK we have people held as domestic slaves and sex slaves. I can't understand why by people insist on harping on about past slavery when right now it's happening, we can see it but yet no body cares. It's mind blowing.

Absolutely agree.
Slaves held in cannabis 'Farms' without access to fresh air or outdoors for months on end, Held on Trawlers to fish, nail bars, restaurants and sex work...
I had no idea how prevalent it was, until seeing an exhibition visiting Bristol, where they had an exhibition about Modern Day slavery.

People are still being beaten by their captors.

thecatsthecats · 21/09/2022 07:47

It's a ridiculous suggestion, but it is at least a bit more focused than other ridiculous reparation suggestions.

One percenters have been abusing the common man since time immemorial. It makes more sense to target them rather than simply say the British or Dutch were responsible. Because 99% of the British or Dutch etc were subject to the exploitation of the same people profiting from slavery, and they didn't have any power to stop it.

ChagSameachDoreen · 21/09/2022 07:45

Should pay, or be paid?

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:44

ShirtingForkBalls · 21/09/2022 07:27

How would it work? In practice?

Simple.

  1. Money gets paid to government of country x.
  1. President of country x (probably the descendent of slavers) siphons off the money.
  1. It gets laundered back to Canary Wharf and gets spent on Kensington High St by said president and his family.
Dibbydoos · 21/09/2022 07:41

That is exactly what happened. Tribal leaders kidnapped people from other tribes to sell as slaves.

The British intervened to save slaves when slavery was abolished here.

But noone should pay anything. I mean who's with me to start a campaign to get Rome, Anglo, Saxons, Viking nations etc to pay us for what thry did to the indigenous Brits? And don't think none of those Brits weren't in servitude/enslaved. They were. Viking nations used to kidnap British females to be the wives of men back home.

When I worked in Zambia, I was shown all the slavery places by the engineer I was working with. The tree where slaves were tied in readiness for slavers buying them etc. I asked how they felt about slavery and was told - there are 7 tribes in Zambia. We used to all fight amongst ourselves. We could not marry across tribes etc. We all had our own language. We now all speak English. We are one nation and can marry anyone. Ergo that person, at least, was happier with the way the country was. He married a woman from a different tribe.

Frankly I'm done with all talk of paying for slavery. History is history, none of us were around to feel responsible. Sure it's very uncomfortable to know that's what our ancestors did, but equally the British ended slavery and enforced it, so grateful William Wilberforce for taking action in 1787 which resulted in anti slavery legislation in 1807.

Slavery is still ongoing today, right under our noses - sex workers, car washes, nail salons, local construction companies using asylum seekers, people with learning disabilities being used by their so-called friends etc. Some humans will use other humans to bring them 'riches'. It's those humans we need to seek out and deal with.

A historian told me Britain should apologise for plundering nations in the Commonwealth. I'm not sure an apology is what they really want - we should return treasures we have taken (not those the Royals or Britain were gifted) like the Elgin stones. And America should give us our Eagle back.

History is fascinating and can be dark, but it's history. No need for hysterics.

Hearthnhome · 21/09/2022 07:38

The problem is when people talk about ‘slavery’ and reparations, they are usually talking about a period of time, which considering the timeline of slavery is very small.

When considering reparations, you can’t just look at one part of the story. You need to look at it all. Very few, if any, countries have their hands clean when it comes to the history of all slavery.

It could be argued that the independent America agenda to make black people sub human, so they could still say all men were created equal and keep black people enslaved as they were sub human, has had more of an impact on people alive today. Should that not be tackled first.

and what reparations are better than working to abolish slavery. Which countries were involved in trying to ban slavery across the world. Which countries pushed that forward. As a mixed race person I would prefer people who have done something awful, to work towards stopping the awful thing happening in future, rather than slipping some cash over.

And instead of reparations, wouldn’t money be better spent on stamping out slavery today and freeing people who are right this minute, enslaved?

This is why reparations, in my opinion, is a distraction debate. The whole history of Slavery is long and complicated, but only a small amount of it is taught or deemed socially acceptable to talk about. Which isn’t going to move anything forward.

MbatataOwl · 21/09/2022 07:36

We need to concentrate on slavery that is happening today.
In the UK we have people held as domestic slaves and sex slaves. I can't understand why by people insist on harping on about past slavery when right now it's happening, we can see it but yet no body cares. It's mind blowing.

ShirtingForkBalls · 21/09/2022 07:27

How would it work? In practice?

sashagabadon · 21/09/2022 07:23

The sub Saharan slave trade was massive too as big as the trans Atlantic one and it went on for longer. That was selling slaves to Middle Eastern countries.
I think it’s a fair point to make in an open debate. I want to hear all the arguments before I decide what I think.
I hadn’t considered the navy seamen that died trying to stop Africa sending more slaves ( who was the Navy trying to stop?)
That is a valid point imo.
And yes the slave trade continues in large parts of the world as we speak.

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:22

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 06:57

It is not a fair response, it's an offensive response.

It is a fair response to the claim that the descendents of those who profited should pay.

It will also cause offence, but it's no less true for that.

It's a classic illustration of why there is no right not to be offended.

Thisbastardcomputer · 21/09/2022 07:20

Userg1234 · 21/09/2022 07:18

No as a white man from the west of England I'm all in favour....as an ancestor was barbadosed following the Monmouth rebellion.
Slavery has nothing to do with race, creed or colour. It's wrong then and now.
BUT why should people today pay for something done 200 plus years ago?

Exactly

Userg1234 · 21/09/2022 07:18

No as a white man from the west of England I'm all in favour....as an ancestor was barbadosed following the Monmouth rebellion.
Slavery has nothing to do with race, creed or colour. It's wrong then and now.
BUT why should people today pay for something done 200 plus years ago?

Namenic · 21/09/2022 07:17

I disagree with reparations but I think financial aid (without strings) to strengthen things like health systems or infrastructure for groups badly affected by slavery would be good.

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:17

Sausagenbacon · 21/09/2022 06:58

The idea if paying reparations is gaining traction in the C of E. But the C of E prefer paying attention to the past rather than present-day slavery. And I say that as a member.
But IMO it's nuts.

As a fellow member I agree. The C of E needs to realise it makes itself look stupid by trying to get it right 300 years after the event.

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:14

I think there should be massive reparations.

.... because they will end up straight back in the UK via some kleptomaniac's trust fund managed from Canary Wharf.

HappyHappyHermit · 21/09/2022 07:12

I disagree with reparations, as others have said, where would it end.

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 07:06

00100001 · 21/09/2022 07:04

The level of modern day slavery is mind blowing.

Oh yes absolutely. We can all see that with our own eyes if we choose to look.

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 07:05

There isn't a narrative it is only the British, it is just the British press cover that more and want to drum up the sense of injustice.

00100001 · 21/09/2022 07:04

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 07:03

The level of exploitation and appropriation under the slave trade is so mind-blowing.

The level of modern day slavery is mind blowing.

lannistunut · 21/09/2022 07:03

The level of exploitation and appropriation under the slave trade is so mind-blowing.