Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Royal commentator says that African descendants of past kings should pay reparations for slavery

184 replies

cocococococococo · 21/09/2022 06:38

😳
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-jr-fordwich-slave-trade-reparations-b2171510.html

OP posts:
MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 09:55

What about rich Africans who profited from the slave trade before Europe arrived on the scene? Or do they get a pass because they're black?

What about African leaders who have syphoned away money meant for their people? That money would have contributed to the good of their people?

It wouldn't astonish me to learn that we're not allowed to mention that for fear we might be seen as racist.

ohfook · 21/09/2022 09:48

Userg1234 · 21/09/2022 07:18

No as a white man from the west of England I'm all in favour....as an ancestor was barbadosed following the Monmouth rebellion.
Slavery has nothing to do with race, creed or colour. It's wrong then and now.
BUT why should people today pay for something done 200 plus years ago?

Because the best ways of strengthening your wealth to pass on to your children are opportunity of employment, education and property ownership all things that were specifically denied to groups of people for over four generations and their ancestors are still playing on an uneven playing field now because of that. I'm not sure that reparations are the answer but something to redress the balance is needed particularly when the ancestors of those who benefited from hundreds of years of free labour are still repeating the benefits of that wealth now.

ohfook · 21/09/2022 09:43

Northernsoullover · 21/09/2022 07:03

Where does it stop? The USA was colonised. South America was colonised by the Spanish. Caribbean islands colonised by both French and British. Brazil by Portugal. There seems to be a narrative that British were the only ones. Yes it was wrong but if we are expected to pay reparation shouldn't everyone?

That narrative doesn't exist - people know who the perpetrators of slavery were.

Georgeskitchen · 21/09/2022 09:15

kewinsurreylass · 21/09/2022 09:07

"We all know who the victims of slavery were."
It is not about victims (Ireland had slaves taken by Africans) it i8s about perpetrators
There i8s a narrative that only white people did slave trading which is totally untrue and not know by the uninformed woke left

They do know, but anything that doesn't fit their narrative is just ignored

kewinsurreylass · 21/09/2022 09:07

"We all know who the victims of slavery were."
It is not about victims (Ireland had slaves taken by Africans) it i8s about perpetrators
There i8s a narrative that only white people did slave trading which is totally untrue and not know by the uninformed woke left

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 08:59

@ConnectFortyFour
Yes, put in a claim immediately.

It is all such dangerous shite. Following it to its entirely stupid conclusion, if a nation is found guilty because of something done hundreds of years ago, does that mean that descendants of murderers and rapists should always be guilty.

If not, why not? After all, if we can be held collectively responsible as descendants, why shouldn't it apply to individuals as well.

If a group of my ancestors did something wrong and I have to be a part of apologising and paying out just because I share the same blood, then why should descendants of murders get a free pass. They share the same blood as their ancestor and should be judged guilty for ever more.

If my grandfather murdered someone, should I be apologising to his victim's grandchildren.

Stupid. I don't apologise for anything my ancestors-or even my parents did and nor does anyone else. I would apologise for my dog or children under 18 but that's your lot!

Sausagenbacon · 21/09/2022 08:57

The Ottaman Empire killed or enslaved whole swaths of South Eastern Europe. Perhaps Romania should be asking for money from Turkey?

ginandbearit · 21/09/2022 08:52

There may be some embarrassed shuffling of feet and coughing if the descendants of certain Nigerian and other sub Saharan royal families who benefitted massively from the slave trade had to answer certain questions...

RudsyFarmer · 21/09/2022 08:51

Well those comments aren’t likely to offend at ALL are they?!!!! 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

oakleaffy · 21/09/2022 08:51

MbatataOwl · 21/09/2022 08:39

People are still being beaten by their captors

In the UK there have been cases here of maids kept as slaves, abused and sometimes even murdered by people with diplomatic immunity.
The police very, very, very rarely do anything.

Terrifying.
Also Kuwait..Filipino maid killed by her Syrian female captor.

ConnectFortyFour · 21/09/2022 08:47

My grandpa was always very proud of his ancestors who were senior naval establishment figures who were famous then (not now). This was always regarded as embarrassing by younger members of the family who assumed they were colonial baddies.

after his death I looked into some of the family history and found they had been heavily involved in anti slavery measures both in terms of policy and policing the high seas. Some family members died when their ships went down.

Do I get some money?

DevilsVineBlues · 21/09/2022 08:47

BUT why should people today pay for something done 200 plus years ago?

I think the theory is that, the mass removal of large numbers of healthy young people from countries 200 years ago meant those people were not available to advance that country in a way that might have happened if they were left alone. i.e. infrastructure was not built, no one received health care or education, standard of living stagnated etc.

Instead those people were used to generate income or provide manpower to other counties who were able to advance their own infrastructure. By doing so, they were able to 'get ahead' and continue to benefit from that advanced start today. e.g. most people in those countries do receive some form of health care, education etc. Most of those counties established universities providing advanced education allowing for further innovation and development etc. Most people living in those countries are benefitting from that head start in all sorts of indirect ways.

Reparation is a complex issue and I am not arguing for it, because it's beyond my knowledge and ability to understand all the aspects. But, it's also more than just money as a way to say sorry. It's about how those actions decided the future/current states of those countries involved.

Trainbear · 21/09/2022 08:46

The World Cup is taking place in an Arabian nation this year/next year. Much has been said about Arabian countries attitudes to homosexuality. Protests are planned. The role of Arab merchants in slavery is and was much bigger. Will black players and anti racist protesters be protesting about Arabian rulers leading the enslavement of blacks in Africa?

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 21/09/2022 08:41

Should Turkey pay reparation to Ukraine? Many of the women in the harems of the Ottoman rulers were slaves from Ukraine.

MbatataOwl · 21/09/2022 08:39

People are still being beaten by their captors

In the UK there have been cases here of maids kept as slaves, abused and sometimes even murdered by people with diplomatic immunity.
The police very, very, very rarely do anything.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/09/2022 08:36

Role of the kingdom of Angola, I should have said.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/09/2022 08:36

And where's this money coming from and who decides who gets it? bureaucratic nightmare doesn't even begin to start to describe that one.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 21/09/2022 08:32

Sausagenbacon · 21/09/2022 06:59

The Arabs were also a key part of slave trading, while we're at it.

And the Romans, they certainly seem to be keeping a low profile over it at the moment.
And they built a wall to keep people out.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 21/09/2022 08:29

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 08:07

Will the descendants of African chiefs who sold their people to slavers have to pay out as well?

I have found out that Joan down the road from me is a descendant of a Black and Tan who killed one of my ancestors in Ireland? Should I be expecting a big pay out from her too?

What about Derek whose ancestor murdered Jenny's ancestor. is Jenny ready for a pay out?

It is bollocks to think that anyone or any collection of people can pay for something that happened in the past. TOTAL BOLLOCKS.

I do hope though that if some gobshite nation-probably the UK-pays out in any way that the history of some of these African nations be looked at too. They don't have glorious pre=lasparian societies either. Pol Pot, Idi Amin spring to mind. Shocking isn't it to discover that every nation on earth will have done something wrong at some point.

How is money going to make it all better? No fucker need bother apologising for anything my ancestor might or might have or not done.

There is plenty of shite going on now all around the world and not one fucking nation-including African nations-has the right to throw the first stone.

Sorry for something that happened hundreds of years ago. Balls. It's a narrative that needs to stop.

Henry Louis Gates Jr has a very interesting programme about the empires of Africa - probably on YT. The episode about the role of the kingdom in slavery goes into the subject in some detail, and this was before the arrival of the Europeans, who tapped into a lucrative and well establised market.

historynewsnetwork.org/article/125861

Glitteratitar · 21/09/2022 08:27

midgetastic · 21/09/2022 08:25

Those problems apply to the UK also

The focus should be on recognising those problems exist , understanding why and fixing them going forward

good education - the good schools and teachers are not attracted to the poorer areas, job opportunities, role models , investment uplifting the infrastructure where poor people predominantly live , reducing the police bias

That’s exactly it - you need more investment in those areas. Some could argue that’s akin to reparations though.

midgetastic · 21/09/2022 08:25

Glitteratitar · 21/09/2022 08:16

It’s a tough one because if you pay reparations for slavery, where does it stop? Will England start paying reparations for other atrocities it has been involved in?

That said, the effects of slavery are still felt in the US today, with the high level of poverty amongst African Americans being directly linked to the end of slavery. So it’s difficult to just ignore that and say slavery happened in the past.

Those problems apply to the UK also

The focus should be on recognising those problems exist , understanding why and fixing them going forward

good education - the good schools and teachers are not attracted to the poorer areas, job opportunities, role models , investment uplifting the infrastructure where poor people predominantly live , reducing the police bias

Glitteratitar · 21/09/2022 08:23

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 08:20

Will everyone else pay reparations for all the things they’ve done too? To all the long dead victims?

Did you read the first paragraph? Where I made that same point?

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 08:20

Glitteratitar · 21/09/2022 08:16

It’s a tough one because if you pay reparations for slavery, where does it stop? Will England start paying reparations for other atrocities it has been involved in?

That said, the effects of slavery are still felt in the US today, with the high level of poverty amongst African Americans being directly linked to the end of slavery. So it’s difficult to just ignore that and say slavery happened in the past.

Will everyone else pay reparations for all the things they’ve done too? To all the long dead victims?

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 08:18

TomPinch · 21/09/2022 07:22

It is a fair response to the claim that the descendents of those who profited should pay.

It will also cause offence, but it's no less true for that.

It's a classic illustration of why there is no right not to be offended.

This. Many black and mixed race people from the Caribbean are descendants of both slaves and slave owners. Are they responsible for what their slave owner ancestors did?

Glitteratitar · 21/09/2022 08:16

It’s a tough one because if you pay reparations for slavery, where does it stop? Will England start paying reparations for other atrocities it has been involved in?

That said, the effects of slavery are still felt in the US today, with the high level of poverty amongst African Americans being directly linked to the end of slavery. So it’s difficult to just ignore that and say slavery happened in the past.

Swipe left for the next trending thread