Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Royal commentator says that African descendants of past kings should pay reparations for slavery

184 replies

cocococococococo · 21/09/2022 06:38

😳
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-jr-fordwich-slave-trade-reparations-b2171510.html

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 18:52

Whether or not we have just paid off borrowing from that time is neither here nor there.

Of course. Grin About as neither here nor there than as an oil tanker spillage in the ocean Grin

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 18:49

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:37

I always find is hilarious how working class people are quick to defend these millionaires who are living of slave money. Firstly you are victims in this too. You ancestors tax money was paid to them to give up the slaves. Secondly these would never go out their way to defend you the way you are defending them.

They’re dead. Whh waste your time raging against people who died nearly 200 years ago?

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 18:44

ancientgran · 21/09/2022 17:54

Most, but not all, descendants of slaves who are in need are in the Caribbean or the US. I assumed reparations would be to help them, why would they be paid in Africa, surely the people left in Africa didn't suffer from slavery in the same way as slaves did?

I think that’s the point though- slavery isn’t what caused modern day poverty in the Caribbean. Some islands are very wealthy despite slavery whereas others are impoverished but also have a history of slavery.

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 18:37

VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 16:46

Given that we finished paying 'compensation' to enslavers just in 2015, so everyone who has paid tax till then contributed, I want reparations. The truth is no-one with any vested interest in reparations has the power to enact it but it's something I hope increases in popularity. Pay Up! And not just because it was centuries ago does not matter one jot!

As we covered above, the compensation to slave owners was paid nearly 200 years ago. Whether or not we have just paid off borrowing from that time is neither here nor there. The money was paid long ago to people who are long dead. There is equally no one subject to the slavery of that particular slave trade alive. It’s not possible to pay reparations even if it were desirable.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/09/2022 18:14

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:50

What about Lancashire people who did without-in the cotton years-to fight American slavery?

Go and have a look at their descendants now. They're not booming! White working-class males in this group are seriously disadvantaged. They have no privileges.

Agree ... ^ Oh but we must NEVER say that white people are disadvantaged in any way. According to some, we all all born with a silver spoon in our mouth dontcha know? By the very virtue of being born white, we will automatically have an easy, carefree life, full of riches and wealth and things being given to us for free, without any disadvantages. We don't need to work harder at school or college or work, because things will fall in our lap because we're white.

Hmm
ancientgran · 21/09/2022 18:07

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:57

I am quite angry @ancientgran

I despair that some people want to pay out for complex historical wrongs while whole swathes of the world need our help now.

The self-loathing that has taken over certain sections is worrying and leads to people saying the daftest things like a white beggar is better than a Eton educated black, simply because they are white.

To argue against it is to be called 'racist' the magic word which shuts debate down. Whoever expanded the term 'racist' to include any critical thought of a black person or nation is an absolute PR genius.

Anyway, back to the point of the thread. No payment for Historical Wrongs from governments but a facility to pay to black charities on a personal level and I think that already exists.

Well I'm a bit angry that you don't acknowledge that you got it wrong. I never asked for compensation for my husband so your "how is your husband being "paid up" going to help him?" was neither relevant or appropriate.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:57

I am quite angry @ancientgran

I despair that some people want to pay out for complex historical wrongs while whole swathes of the world need our help now.

The self-loathing that has taken over certain sections is worrying and leads to people saying the daftest things like a white beggar is better than a Eton educated black, simply because they are white.

To argue against it is to be called 'racist' the magic word which shuts debate down. Whoever expanded the term 'racist' to include any critical thought of a black person or nation is an absolute PR genius.

Anyway, back to the point of the thread. No payment for Historical Wrongs from governments but a facility to pay to black charities on a personal level and I think that already exists.

ancientgran · 21/09/2022 17:54

Crazykatie · 21/09/2022 17:04

I’ve travelled to The West Indies also in Africa when it comes to poverty Africa is far worse off . Poverty is relative to each country there is poverty in the US and the UK too

Most, but not all, descendants of slaves who are in need are in the Caribbean or the US. I assumed reparations would be to help them, why would they be paid in Africa, surely the people left in Africa didn't suffer from slavery in the same way as slaves did?

ancientgran · 21/09/2022 17:51

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:37

@ancientgran.how is your husband being "paid up" going to help him?

Will Ethiopia and Somalia be paying up? After all, slavery was-and may still be-rife there. That is slavery of Africans by Africans.
Will Arab nations be paying up?
Will China be paying up?
What will happen to mixed race people? Will they be given money which they will then symbolically pay back?

I can probably answer my own question there and that answer will be no, they won't!

Am I going to get some payment for the Elizabethan takeover of Ireland?
Will English people be compensated for the William the Conqueror's Burnt Earth Policy?
Will the Jewish people of medieval Europe be able to get payment for their treatment too?
Will I be compensated by Africa for the slaves they took from Ireland?
Will men who were conscripted into armies be paid? After all, they were often sent to death against their will.
Will Italy pay for the atrocities committed by the Roman Empire?
Will Norse countries pay out for the damage caused by Vikings?

Insert your own possible claim here.

Don't worry if one doesn't immediately occur-it could be a Christmas family parlour game in which you all brainstorm in order to come up with something.

If we accept that money makes past wrongs right, then why can't we all claim?

It is all absolute bollocks and, as for all these documents that @ancientgran refers to-I would bet my first born that if this madness goes ahead, it will be accompanied by a booming market in forgeries.

There is nothing to pay for. Nothing. Yes, that's right. Nothing

For all those who feel such white guilt, that they want to feel pain, sell your house and send the money to an African charity. Somehow though, I think that won't be done. A cheaper alternative is to get a hair shirt and wear it every day as a symbol of all the shame that you feel on behalf of your ancestors. That won't be done either.

If you look at my posts I haven't said that, I specifically said if reparations are paid I thought they were to go to help developments in the Caribbean to help the descendants of slaves still living in poverty. My husband isn't in the Caribbean, his family left 3 generations ago, and he isn't in poverty.

If you have a look I added a post to explain that and to explain the point of the post about tracing his ancestry was in answer to one saying it would be impossible. Well it isn't impossible for him.

You sound very angry but hopefully you can read my posts, not just the one.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:50

What about Lancashire people who did without-in the cotton years-to fight American slavery?

Go and have a look at their descendants now. They're not booming! White working-class males in this group are seriously disadvantaged. They have no privileges.

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:46

African nations definitely shouldn’t be paid when it comes to reparations. Many of them gained for the practice themselves this is conversation should be had only with the America’s and Europe.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:43

@ThreeLocusts Sell your house. Give the money you have set aside for your children-from paying college fees to swimming club fees to a black educational charity.

You'll feel better, it will ease your shame or is it that you don't want to put your hand in your own pocket?

If you're daft enough to want to pay for complex historical matters-a stupid idea in the first place-fill your boots.

I don't accept the idea because it is stupid and exonerates guilty African nations from blame.

ThreeLocusts · 21/09/2022 17:39

Fun, little known, fact: compensation was paid when slavery officially ended in the British empire -- to the slave owners. The records of these payments exist. Many went to families that continue to form part of the UK establishment (at least one of the Camerons - not sure if David or Samantha or both - have ancestors on this list).

I can't for the life of me see anything wrong with asking the present generations of these families to cough up for, say, a fund to mitigate educational disadvantages for Black kids now in the UK. Of course there are constructive ways to redistribute some of the ill-gotten gains of the era of slavery. They just won't be pursued because - see above - the same establishment is still in charge.

Don Lemon isn't very smart, alas. But his prissy interlocutor is wrong; the holding facilities for slaves on the West African coast were typically provided by the European buyers. If African kings' descendants ought to pay reparations, then so ought the descendants of the Europeans who profited.

At one point the average time of a slave's survival after arrival on a plantation in the Caribbean was seven years - and I'm not even sure that is the lowest number across the different islands. They were worked to death, and that was on their European owners, no matter what had led to their enslavement.

The thing that this thread shows the most clearly is that teaching on the history of the Transatlantic slave trade continues to be woefully inadequate. It wasn't just another slave trade. It dwarfs the others, and it dwarfs 'modern slavery'. Nobody is openly embarking 25,000 people a year for sale at market today, while arguing that it's OK because they don't have souls or some such.

It has been argued, convincingly, that Transatlantic slavery created the conditions for industrialization - it made the modern world. Europeans didn't get richer than the rest just by 'work ethic' or similar. Useful reading on this point:

press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691090108/the-great-divergence

I don't normally feel ashamed of being European - it's not like I can help it - but some of the posts on here make me embarrassed to be so.

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:39

Trainbear · 21/09/2022 13:30

Britain along with virtually every other developed country at the time and countless countries and tribes prior to participated in slavery. Britain agreed to end not only its own but the actively stop Slavery. It was very effective because of the Royal Navy. Well done Royal Navy, thank you from the grateful slaves freed?

The slave owners where paid off with tax payer money that they continued to receive until 2016.

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:37

I always find is hilarious how working class people are quick to defend these millionaires who are living of slave money. Firstly you are victims in this too. You ancestors tax money was paid to them to give up the slaves. Secondly these would never go out their way to defend you the way you are defending them.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:37

@ancientgran.how is your husband being "paid up" going to help him?

Will Ethiopia and Somalia be paying up? After all, slavery was-and may still be-rife there. That is slavery of Africans by Africans.
Will Arab nations be paying up?
Will China be paying up?
What will happen to mixed race people? Will they be given money which they will then symbolically pay back?

I can probably answer my own question there and that answer will be no, they won't!

Am I going to get some payment for the Elizabethan takeover of Ireland?
Will English people be compensated for the William the Conqueror's Burnt Earth Policy?
Will the Jewish people of medieval Europe be able to get payment for their treatment too?
Will I be compensated by Africa for the slaves they took from Ireland?
Will men who were conscripted into armies be paid? After all, they were often sent to death against their will.
Will Italy pay for the atrocities committed by the Roman Empire?
Will Norse countries pay out for the damage caused by Vikings?

Insert your own possible claim here.

Don't worry if one doesn't immediately occur-it could be a Christmas family parlour game in which you all brainstorm in order to come up with something.

If we accept that money makes past wrongs right, then why can't we all claim?

It is all absolute bollocks and, as for all these documents that @ancientgran refers to-I would bet my first born that if this madness goes ahead, it will be accompanied by a booming market in forgeries.

There is nothing to pay for. Nothing. Yes, that's right. Nothing

For all those who feel such white guilt, that they want to feel pain, sell your house and send the money to an African charity. Somehow though, I think that won't be done. A cheaper alternative is to get a hair shirt and wear it every day as a symbol of all the shame that you feel on behalf of your ancestors. That won't be done either.

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:34

I do think the billion pound business that where built on the slave trade need to pay up for the reparations and also need to refund ( with inflation) the money back to the tax payer who paid them off to give up the slaves. Problem solved!

Crazykatie · 21/09/2022 17:29

Aishah231 · 21/09/2022 17:19

The country, i.e tax payers, shouldn't have to pay reparations. If anyone should it is the descendants of the people who made money from the slave trade. That would however mean the elite - the royal family, the Middletons for example. The descendants of those working in mills - many of whom protested against slavery - bear no guilt.

Much of the Slavery compensation money was spent on building mansions and high living, many/most have been given to the National Trust in lieu of Estate Duty.

Aishah231 · 21/09/2022 17:19

The country, i.e tax payers, shouldn't have to pay reparations. If anyone should it is the descendants of the people who made money from the slave trade. That would however mean the elite - the royal family, the Middletons for example. The descendants of those working in mills - many of whom protested against slavery - bear no guilt.

Crazykatie · 21/09/2022 17:04

ancientgran · 21/09/2022 16:39

I always thought the argument about reparations wasn't about money for Africa, I thought it was to help development in the West Indies where many descendants of slaves live in poverty.

I’ve travelled to The West Indies also in Africa when it comes to poverty Africa is far worse off . Poverty is relative to each country there is poverty in the US and the UK too

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 21/09/2022 16:55

Northernsoullover · 21/09/2022 07:03

Where does it stop? The USA was colonised. South America was colonised by the Spanish. Caribbean islands colonised by both French and British. Brazil by Portugal. There seems to be a narrative that British were the only ones. Yes it was wrong but if we are expected to pay reparation shouldn't everyone?

Yeah this. ^ YABU @cocococococococo Everyone is quick enough to blame the Brits alive todays for the sins of their fathers, so why shouldn't everyone else be asked/expected to make reparations too?

Or is this a case of 'only the British - especially the English - should be called into question for anything EVER, forevermore?' Wink

It seems terribly fashionable - and acceptable to bash the white British people - especially the (white) English, but noooooooooooo we must NEVER attack anyone else! Save up all that energy to bash us eh?!

And the tragic thing is, it's OTHER white British people doing it. (Mostly!)

Seriously, it's becoming white noise now.

Andante57 · 21/09/2022 16:54

Pay Up! And not just because it was centuries ago does not matter one jot!

Who will be responsible for paying up? The tax payer?

MarigoldPetals · 21/09/2022 16:52

Sausagenbacon · 21/09/2022 06:58

The idea if paying reparations is gaining traction in the C of E. But the C of E prefer paying attention to the past rather than present-day slavery. And I say that as a member.
But IMO it's nuts.

Depends on your church. My C of E church are very active in campaigning against present day slavery.

Hearthnhome · 21/09/2022 16:50

VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 16:46

Given that we finished paying 'compensation' to enslavers just in 2015, so everyone who has paid tax till then contributed, I want reparations. The truth is no-one with any vested interest in reparations has the power to enact it but it's something I hope increases in popularity. Pay Up! And not just because it was centuries ago does not matter one jot!

That’s already been discussed. We finished paying the loans that paid reparations in 2015.

They were still sending payments to families of previous slave owners.

What happened centuries ago? Slavery? Slavery has always and still does exist.

Slavery is not one period of history.

ginghamstarfish · 21/09/2022 16:49

Well it is a matter of historical record that many many countries and peoples have enslaved others, going back to biblical times. Reparations don't make sense as if once country does it then yes all the others should do it too ....