Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Royal commentator says that African descendants of past kings should pay reparations for slavery

184 replies

cocococococococo · 21/09/2022 06:38

😳
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-jr-fordwich-slave-trade-reparations-b2171510.html

OP posts:
MangyInseam · 22/09/2022 17:34

Getoff · 22/09/2022 17:08

Thomas Sowell (a black american economist) has some interesting videos on Youtube on the subject of slavery.

According to him, it was ubiquitous throughout history, in almost every civilisation in every part of the world, slavery was a normal thing.

It almost never had anything to do with race, across history as a whole most slaves looked like their owners. (Even though prisoners-of-war was one of the most common ways of creating new slaves.)

Thomas More's "Utopia" envisaged that there would be slaves in Utopia! Among his rules for more humane slavery were that only prisoners-of-war and serious criminals could be enslaved, and the children of slaves would not be slaves. (But apparently Utopia was a satire, so not sure if we should take this seriously.)

Sowell says that 19th century European imperialists did in fact make a unique contribution to the history of slavery - by deciding to end it. The British made the biggest contribution, once they decided slavery was wrong they sent (or threatend to send) warships to many places to end it, including in countries that weren't part of the British empire. But it wasn't just the British, the French and some other European countries also got involved in ending it. He claims this is the first time in human history that it became widely accepted that slavery was wrong. (Although my own googling found that one Chinese emperor banned it a thousand years ago, but it returned after his death.)

With regard to black American disadvantage being a legacy of slavery, I don't remember the details, but he claims that the discrepancies people blame on slavery only came into existence after the American welfare state was founded, a long time after the end of slavery. (I think he was focusing on single parenthood, which only became more prevalent among black Americans than among whites in the 1960's.) (I may not have got the details in this paragraph right, please refer to YouTube if this matters to you!)

I think his take on your last paragraph would be somewhat more complicated. Though he does see a lot of poverty among the poor and the black poor in particular today as stemming from the precipitous drop in two parent families in the 60s and 70s.

MangyInseam · 22/09/2022 17:31

I always wonder to what extent people who say things like this are basically using a "taste of their own medicine" strategy.

What he's suggesting makes as much sense as most of the suggestions for reparations from people like Ibram Kendi. You could probably equally reasonably call from the descendants of these people to pay the descendants of the people who were sold off.

Of course in every instance it's pretty much totally impractical to do any of these things and won't solve a damn thing.

I tend to think it's a kind of upper middle class distraction technique to stop people thinking about the degree to which most of us depend on the exploitation of people in non-western countries right now.

Getoff · 22/09/2022 17:08

Thomas Sowell (a black american economist) has some interesting videos on Youtube on the subject of slavery.

According to him, it was ubiquitous throughout history, in almost every civilisation in every part of the world, slavery was a normal thing.

It almost never had anything to do with race, across history as a whole most slaves looked like their owners. (Even though prisoners-of-war was one of the most common ways of creating new slaves.)

Thomas More's "Utopia" envisaged that there would be slaves in Utopia! Among his rules for more humane slavery were that only prisoners-of-war and serious criminals could be enslaved, and the children of slaves would not be slaves. (But apparently Utopia was a satire, so not sure if we should take this seriously.)

Sowell says that 19th century European imperialists did in fact make a unique contribution to the history of slavery - by deciding to end it. The British made the biggest contribution, once they decided slavery was wrong they sent (or threatend to send) warships to many places to end it, including in countries that weren't part of the British empire. But it wasn't just the British, the French and some other European countries also got involved in ending it. He claims this is the first time in human history that it became widely accepted that slavery was wrong. (Although my own googling found that one Chinese emperor banned it a thousand years ago, but it returned after his death.)

With regard to black American disadvantage being a legacy of slavery, I don't remember the details, but he claims that the discrepancies people blame on slavery only came into existence after the American welfare state was founded, a long time after the end of slavery. (I think he was focusing on single parenthood, which only became more prevalent among black Americans than among whites in the 1960's.) (I may not have got the details in this paragraph right, please refer to YouTube if this matters to you!)

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 15:52

If you were not around when slavery took place and do not want hear about reparations. Why pay slavers up until 2015 - your taxes paid for this. Why didn't you complain then?

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 22/09/2022 11:23

Dibbydoos · 21/09/2022 07:41

That is exactly what happened. Tribal leaders kidnapped people from other tribes to sell as slaves.

The British intervened to save slaves when slavery was abolished here.

But noone should pay anything. I mean who's with me to start a campaign to get Rome, Anglo, Saxons, Viking nations etc to pay us for what thry did to the indigenous Brits? And don't think none of those Brits weren't in servitude/enslaved. They were. Viking nations used to kidnap British females to be the wives of men back home.

When I worked in Zambia, I was shown all the slavery places by the engineer I was working with. The tree where slaves were tied in readiness for slavers buying them etc. I asked how they felt about slavery and was told - there are 7 tribes in Zambia. We used to all fight amongst ourselves. We could not marry across tribes etc. We all had our own language. We now all speak English. We are one nation and can marry anyone. Ergo that person, at least, was happier with the way the country was. He married a woman from a different tribe.

Frankly I'm done with all talk of paying for slavery. History is history, none of us were around to feel responsible. Sure it's very uncomfortable to know that's what our ancestors did, but equally the British ended slavery and enforced it, so grateful William Wilberforce for taking action in 1787 which resulted in anti slavery legislation in 1807.

Slavery is still ongoing today, right under our noses - sex workers, car washes, nail salons, local construction companies using asylum seekers, people with learning disabilities being used by their so-called friends etc. Some humans will use other humans to bring them 'riches'. It's those humans we need to seek out and deal with.

A historian told me Britain should apologise for plundering nations in the Commonwealth. I'm not sure an apology is what they really want - we should return treasures we have taken (not those the Royals or Britain were gifted) like the Elgin stones. And America should give us our Eagle back.

History is fascinating and can be dark, but it's history. No need for hysterics.

The commonly held belief that Vikings stole British women is largely found to be incorrect. There is very little British DNA in scandinavia, so actually it is thought some vikings may have raped/ had relationships with British women in the UK but they did not take them back home.

Sausagenbacon · 22/09/2022 11:16

Many ordinary people owned slaves, or part owned. It's not as simple as upper and lower classes.

Crazykatie · 22/09/2022 10:48

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 08:26

Up until 2015 we were paying back the slave owners via our taxes. Why wasn't any of that money paid to the enslaved?

Because the slave owners took the money and ran.
Most of the aristocracy had plantations in the Caribbean and other places, parliament voted this massive payout in the 1830s, most MPs benefited directly from that payout. Their names are recorded, some are available but most have not been released, a surprising amount of information about plantations is available online, right back to the mid 1600s, a lot more in archives not yet digitized.
Slaves were valuable and “breeding” records were carefully kept, just like cattle, odious but a fact of life at the time.

KnickerlessParsons · 22/09/2022 09:17

I have met people from Africa in healthcare working 7-14 days on site - not allowed to leave for £14 an hour! Meanwhile other British nurses and Doctors are earning 3-4 times that an hour

British nurses earning £56 per hour? 🤔

ancientgran · 22/09/2022 08:47

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:50

How is he able to travel his ancestry back to the 1600s? Where are the records he's seen?

I didn't say he'd traced them back to the 1600s. I said he could trace them back to slave times which is the 1800s. After slavery there are birth/death/marriage certificates, records when they left the island, before that there are records on the plantation books where slaves were recorded just like other stock. They are historic documents and I suppose it depends on local practice but in his case they were available.

His GF was born in the 1870s or 80s I think and he knew alot of the family oral history, name of plantation etc.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/09/2022 08:40

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 08:36

Some people HAD to buy slaves - they were buying their OWN family members to free them from the white slave owners! Read a bit more around this please.

Read a bit more around this please

I was making a comment, not asking for a tutorial.

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 08:36

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/09/2022 08:11

There's also the slight complication of what's to be done about the former slaves who were freed and then bought slaves of their own. How widespread it was I don't know, but it did happen.

Some people HAD to buy slaves - they were buying their OWN family members to free them from the white slave owners! Read a bit more around this please.

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 08:35

So much nonsense and re-writing of history to fit the coloniser's narrative.

People in Africa are still being taken advantage of today. The exploitation and bribery of African leaders to allow Europeans and Chinese to take over projects, diamond rich areas etc - it's happening today - but everyone is silent.

Healthcare staff being employed by the UK and paid peanuts - some have the most ridiculous contracts to basically keep them tied to the company. I have met people from Africa in healthcare working 7-14 days on site - not allowed to leave for £14 an hour! Meanwhile other British nurses and Doctors are earning 3-4 times that an hour.

We continue to exploit people from other nations even today. I want to see those who benefit from slavery - modern or ancient share with those they exploited.

Crazykatie · 22/09/2022 08:33

When slaves were freed many stayed and worked the plantations for meager wages, the rest left and many starved because there was no work. In the US many were gathered in camps, the men conscripted into the Army during and after the Civil War. They were concentration camps by any other name, gradually the survivors were dispersed, free but tied to hard labour for survival wages, for very many not much has changed today

Scianel · 22/09/2022 08:31

No-one should be paid reparations. The victims are long dead and how do you quantify who the descendents even are?

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 08:26

Up until 2015 we were paying back the slave owners via our taxes. Why wasn't any of that money paid to the enslaved?

Crazykatie · 22/09/2022 08:15

My mothers family tree goes back to the year dot and there are very interesting characters, plantation owners, merchants and pirates too, but the money disappeared long ago. I remember granny as a landlady of a spit and sawdust pub in the North West, pretty grim.
The Slave trade was an atrocity, in the same way Ukraine, Kosovo, the Holocaust and indigenous populations in many countries, we should let it lie in the past and learn. We don’t of course because exploitation of people is probably higher scale now than it ever was in the past.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/09/2022 08:11

sashagabadon · 21/09/2022 19:23

I think it’s very complicated and would be almost impossible to administer.
Two recent episodes of “who do you think you are” one with the actress naomi Harris and the other one with footballer and tv presenter Alex Scott showed that when they traced their ancestors both were descendants of slave owners and not as they had presumed slaves.
it was interesting as neither had imagined that outcome.
Alex commented that she has steeled herself to see her ancestors as slaves but in fact her great great etc grandfather owned 17 slaves.
that could the case for lots of people. How would you distinguish the two as you can’t trace everyone’s history.

There's also the slight complication of what's to be done about the former slaves who were freed and then bought slaves of their own. How widespread it was I don't know, but it did happen.

Daftasabroom · 22/09/2022 08:04

@00100001 Majority of them weren't recorded, because they weren't considered people, so there'd be huge gaps of information.

You completely made that up, the records are very detailed. Slaves were property, they could be bought, sold even inherited. It was possible to own a share in a slave. The value of a slave changed throughout their life and all this was documented. When the British Government paid off the slave owners every single slave was accounted for, the slave owners had to prove the slave existed and the claimant owned the slave. It's all in the National Archives. The information is incredibly detailed and well documented.

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:50

ancientgran · 21/09/2022 17:51

If you look at my posts I haven't said that, I specifically said if reparations are paid I thought they were to go to help developments in the Caribbean to help the descendants of slaves still living in poverty. My husband isn't in the Caribbean, his family left 3 generations ago, and he isn't in poverty.

If you have a look I added a post to explain that and to explain the point of the post about tracing his ancestry was in answer to one saying it would be impossible. Well it isn't impossible for him.

You sound very angry but hopefully you can read my posts, not just the one.

How is he able to travel his ancestry back to the 1600s? Where are the records he's seen?

sst1234 · 21/09/2022 23:45

VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 15:31

I genuinely think reparations should be a topic as big in the UK news scene as the cost of living crisis. I genuinely think this.

Somewhere in an echo chamber, this statement reverberates over and over again. While everyone outside gets on in the real world gets on with dealing with real problems.

00100001 · 21/09/2022 21:06

Most posters here probably couldn't even find their ancestors in the UK from 1600s without crawling through parish records for ages and ages. If they could find them at all....

Imagine trying to find descendants of the millions of slaves from the 1600-1800s.... how could you? Majority of them weren't recorded, because they weren't considered people, so there'd be huge gaps of information.
it would be impossible.

So I guess you'd have to just pay the relevant governments in various countries a sum of money and hope they spend it on the "correct" people... somehow....

How much you pay... Who knows?

sashagabadon · 21/09/2022 19:23

I think it’s very complicated and would be almost impossible to administer.
Two recent episodes of “who do you think you are” one with the actress naomi Harris and the other one with footballer and tv presenter Alex Scott showed that when they traced their ancestors both were descendants of slave owners and not as they had presumed slaves.
it was interesting as neither had imagined that outcome.
Alex commented that she has steeled herself to see her ancestors as slaves but in fact her great great etc grandfather owned 17 slaves.
that could the case for lots of people. How would you distinguish the two as you can’t trace everyone’s history.

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 19:09

VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 18:52

Whether or not we have just paid off borrowing from that time is neither here nor there.

Of course. Grin About as neither here nor there than as an oil tanker spillage in the ocean Grin

Those are two unrelated things.

also as I noted above we haven’t really just paid it off - it’s just that we only finally got rid of undated gilts in 2016.

MsPincher · 21/09/2022 19:07

LetMeSpeak · 21/09/2022 17:39

The slave owners where paid off with tax payer money that they continued to receive until 2016.

Don’t be daft - the money was paid in early 1800. The government did borrow at the time but it’s a bit misleading to say it was just paid off in 2016. Basically that’s when we tidied up gilts (government bonds) and got rid of undated ones. So yes, there were bonds from that time redeemed in 2016 but we have issued a great many gilts since 1800s.

Hearthnhome · 21/09/2022 18:59

I can't for the life of me see anything wrong with asking the present generations of these families to cough up for, say, a fund to mitigate educational disadvantages for Black kids now in the UK

This doesn’t even make sense. Not all black kids in the UK are are descendants of slavery. Which period of slavery do you think they are ALL descended from.

And how does the fact that White Working Class boys suffer from more education disadvantages in our schools fit in there.

If the transatlantic slave trade is to blame for disadvantages for their descendants here it would be all black people in the UK. And how do you explain they aren’t the most education disadvantaged if you look at demographics? If it’s just a left over problem from slavery?