Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Royal commentator says that African descendants of past kings should pay reparations for slavery

184 replies

cocococococococo · 21/09/2022 06:38

😳
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/donald-trump-jr-fordwich-slave-trade-reparations-b2171510.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Trainbear · 30/09/2022 13:23

Getoff · 22/09/2022 17:08

Thomas Sowell (a black american economist) has some interesting videos on Youtube on the subject of slavery.

According to him, it was ubiquitous throughout history, in almost every civilisation in every part of the world, slavery was a normal thing.

It almost never had anything to do with race, across history as a whole most slaves looked like their owners. (Even though prisoners-of-war was one of the most common ways of creating new slaves.)

Thomas More's "Utopia" envisaged that there would be slaves in Utopia! Among his rules for more humane slavery were that only prisoners-of-war and serious criminals could be enslaved, and the children of slaves would not be slaves. (But apparently Utopia was a satire, so not sure if we should take this seriously.)

Sowell says that 19th century European imperialists did in fact make a unique contribution to the history of slavery - by deciding to end it. The British made the biggest contribution, once they decided slavery was wrong they sent (or threatend to send) warships to many places to end it, including in countries that weren't part of the British empire. But it wasn't just the British, the French and some other European countries also got involved in ending it. He claims this is the first time in human history that it became widely accepted that slavery was wrong. (Although my own googling found that one Chinese emperor banned it a thousand years ago, but it returned after his death.)

With regard to black American disadvantage being a legacy of slavery, I don't remember the details, but he claims that the discrepancies people blame on slavery only came into existence after the American welfare state was founded, a long time after the end of slavery. (I think he was focusing on single parenthood, which only became more prevalent among black Americans than among whites in the 1960's.) (I may not have got the details in this paragraph right, please refer to YouTube if this matters to you!)

is this from the “Black rednecks/White liberals “ book? It is very much worth reading. Also “Black Lies Matter” written, inconveniently by a black anthropologist.

TomPinch · 27/09/2022 00:58

Daftasabroom · 26/09/2022 15:21

Slavery was not always illegal in the UK. It was increasingly illegal from the mid 14th century and laws had to be changed to allow the ownership of chattel slaves. Any argument that slavery was normal in the UK at the time is utter garbage. (I know that's not the point you're making).

Evidence that a substantial number of ordinary people in the UK owned a slaves is here.

This might be a bit more manageable.

Do you mean serfdom? I think it's important to distinguish between that and chattel slavery, which is what we are discussing here.

I'm pretty sure you couldn't own people in England from about the eleventh century onwards, only land that people had to live in

Daftasabroom · 26/09/2022 16:54

@MsPincher slavery or ownership on many levels was very much a part of the feudal system and from prehistory. As others have pointed out this is common across many times and people's. But, the north Atlantic slave trade was the first and only time that entire economies were built solely on chattel slavery. The Europeans were the first to build slavery specific transcontinental transport.

MsPincher · 26/09/2022 16:38

Daftasabroom · 26/09/2022 15:21

Slavery was not always illegal in the UK. It was increasingly illegal from the mid 14th century and laws had to be changed to allow the ownership of chattel slaves. Any argument that slavery was normal in the UK at the time is utter garbage. (I know that's not the point you're making).

Evidence that a substantial number of ordinary people in the UK owned a slaves is here.

This might be a bit more manageable.

slavery was never legally a concept of Scot’s or English law. In the last few hundred years at least. It could not be enforced in these jurisdictions ever. British people could own slaves overseas before abolition though.

it seems that about 46000 British people owned slaves in 1833. That’s out of a population of 16.5million or so. That’s more than I thought but it’s small overall. Slaves were not legally held in the uK though as I said above.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/vast-scale-of-british-slave-ownership-revealed-10383768.html

Daftasabroom · 26/09/2022 15:32

And to those who claim the wonderful Royal Navy were working hard to stop slave trading. They weren't, the UK was at war with France and the RN were bent on disrupting French income streams from slavery. The Portuguese (our allies) were allowed to go on their merry way.

Daftasabroom · 26/09/2022 15:21

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 19:53

Slavery was always illegal in the uK. If you have any evidence that a substantial number of people in the uK ever owned slaves abroad please post it.

Slavery was not always illegal in the UK. It was increasingly illegal from the mid 14th century and laws had to be changed to allow the ownership of chattel slaves. Any argument that slavery was normal in the UK at the time is utter garbage. (I know that's not the point you're making).

Evidence that a substantial number of ordinary people in the UK owned a slaves is here.

This might be a bit more manageable.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 20:10

Endlesssummer2022 · 24/09/2022 08:13

‘Up until 2015 we were paying back the slave owners via our taxes. Why wasn't any of that money paid to the enslaved?’

Exactly. All slave owners were extremely generously compensated when slavery was abolished. Their descendants live in the life of luxury. Meanwhile the actual slaves got nothing and their descendants therefore inherited nothing and suffered from the impacts of discrimination based on the fact they are the descendants of slaves.

Can you imagine an alternate reality where the Nazi’s had been compensated for losing the war and their descendants became rich and respected and the Jews were ‘freed’ from concentration camps, got nothing, had nothing to pass on to their children, suffered discrimination from state institutions all because they were despised for having ‘no history’ apart from being held in concentration camps?

The descendants of those who received compensation for having ‘their’ slaves taken away and are pictured in Tatler sitting in homes in Mayfair or The Hamptons should be charged a percentage to be given to Caribbean countries, African American institutions and South American African institutions. Alternatively, all Caribbean countries should have their debts cancelled. They do not owe European countries or America a brass tack. It’s they who are owed.

Article on the financial disparity between those families who owned slaves and those who were slaves. Mitch McConnnel is one. Lording it over people due to his ancestors crimes against humanity.
www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1028031

Alex Scott’s ancestors were slave owners. But I understand she grew up in relative poverty. yet she’s doing well now because she is is a talented footballer and presenter.

Just because someone got someone’s ancestors got some money nearly 200 years ago doesn’t mean they are wealthy now.

tbh (I’m a mixed race person) in the uK people of black Caribbean origin are probably most likely to be descendants of slave owners. Are you still ok with them paying compensation?

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 20:02

Endlesssummer2022 · 24/09/2022 08:29

The Trans-Atlantic slave trade is the only one where the slave owners received compensation.

The British government paid 20 million pounds – the equivalent of around 17 billion pounds today – to compensate slave owners for the lost capital associated with freeing slaves. This payout was a massive 40% of the government's budget and required many bonds to slave owners to effectuate the law. Their descendants are some of the wealthiest people on the world.

The government didn’t finish paying off the debt until 2015, hundreds of years after slavery was abolished. So if the slave owners descendants were still getting paid a monthly cheque into their bank account until less than 10 years ago, the argument that it happened hundreds of years ago and thus the descendants shouldn’t get anything doesn’t hold up.

No one was “getting monthly cheques into their bank accounts” as compensation for slavery in 2015. The compensation that was paid was nearly 200 years ago. as has been discussed the 2015 date was just when undated gilts were redeemed.

The slaves and slave owners are long dead. You can’t hold people responsible for what their ancestors did or reward them for what happened to their ancestors nearly 200 years ago.

it’s in the past. There are plenty of wrongs to right now.

MsPincher · 25/09/2022 19:53

Daftasabroom · 25/09/2022 16:02

Yes they did, it's incredibly well documented. Many ordinary people inherited slaves in the same way they inhertied Uncle Albert's rocking chair, or 1/100th of Auntie Doris's estate.

Slavery was always illegal in the uK. If you have any evidence that a substantial number of people in the uK ever owned slaves abroad please post it.

Daftasabroom · 25/09/2022 16:02

MsPincher · 24/09/2022 04:36

Not in the uK they didn’t.

Yes they did, it's incredibly well documented. Many ordinary people inherited slaves in the same way they inhertied Uncle Albert's rocking chair, or 1/100th of Auntie Doris's estate.

DownNative · 24/09/2022 15:41

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 17:37

@ancientgran.how is your husband being "paid up" going to help him?

Will Ethiopia and Somalia be paying up? After all, slavery was-and may still be-rife there. That is slavery of Africans by Africans.
Will Arab nations be paying up?
Will China be paying up?
What will happen to mixed race people? Will they be given money which they will then symbolically pay back?

I can probably answer my own question there and that answer will be no, they won't!

Am I going to get some payment for the Elizabethan takeover of Ireland?
Will English people be compensated for the William the Conqueror's Burnt Earth Policy?
Will the Jewish people of medieval Europe be able to get payment for their treatment too?
Will I be compensated by Africa for the slaves they took from Ireland?
Will men who were conscripted into armies be paid? After all, they were often sent to death against their will.
Will Italy pay for the atrocities committed by the Roman Empire?
Will Norse countries pay out for the damage caused by Vikings?

Insert your own possible claim here.

Don't worry if one doesn't immediately occur-it could be a Christmas family parlour game in which you all brainstorm in order to come up with something.

If we accept that money makes past wrongs right, then why can't we all claim?

It is all absolute bollocks and, as for all these documents that @ancientgran refers to-I would bet my first born that if this madness goes ahead, it will be accompanied by a booming market in forgeries.

There is nothing to pay for. Nothing. Yes, that's right. Nothing

For all those who feel such white guilt, that they want to feel pain, sell your house and send the money to an African charity. Somehow though, I think that won't be done. A cheaper alternative is to get a hair shirt and wear it every day as a symbol of all the shame that you feel on behalf of your ancestors. That won't be done either.

One more for your list:

"Will the Irish pay reparations for the people they took from Great Britain as slaves?"

St Patrick is the most famous slave, but not the first or the last.

I agree with you that reparations isn't the answer and neither is white guilt.

inheritanceshiteagain · 24/09/2022 11:48

Stop this nonsense and sort out modern slavery

Sausagenbacon · 24/09/2022 10:20

Yesterday I read about a 19th century woman, a slave, who married a white man. They moved from the USA to Antwerp because it was difficult for a mixed race couple to live together in the States at the time.
While in the USA they made money by renting out their two slaves by the day.
So would her descendants get reparations?
Plus it's very naive to think that only people who are rich today benefited from this.

SineOfTheThymes · 24/09/2022 09:09

They can state their opinion, but it's not going to happen. Working in the legal area, concepts of reparations and fairness and fraught with difficult. And generally, if you are the "winner", you get away with almost anything when you add in a longer time scale and cross-border legal systems.

We (and other empires in the past) regularly sent our armies abroad to invade, exploit, murder, rape. Most people think that was "bad", we don't do it so much these days, our victims will never get appropriate compensation.

From working with victims of serious crime (rape, abuse), it's an awful realisation that many of them encounter during the process, what is done is done, and there is no going back. Many continue in the legal process to hopefully make thing easier/better for others in the future.

If you are interested in a related current case, you could consider reading this:

www.theguardian.com/books/2022/aug/14/the-last-colony-by-philippe-sands-review-britains-chagos-islands-shame

Endlesssummer2022 · 24/09/2022 08:29

The Trans-Atlantic slave trade is the only one where the slave owners received compensation.

The British government paid 20 million pounds – the equivalent of around 17 billion pounds today – to compensate slave owners for the lost capital associated with freeing slaves. This payout was a massive 40% of the government's budget and required many bonds to slave owners to effectuate the law. Their descendants are some of the wealthiest people on the world.

The government didn’t finish paying off the debt until 2015, hundreds of years after slavery was abolished. So if the slave owners descendants were still getting paid a monthly cheque into their bank account until less than 10 years ago, the argument that it happened hundreds of years ago and thus the descendants shouldn’t get anything doesn’t hold up.

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 08:14

The commonly held belief that Vikings stole British women is largely found to be incorrect. There is very little British DNA in scandinavia, so actually it is thought some vikings may have raped/ had relationships with British women in the UK but they did not take them back home.

Or the kids did not survive the ill treatment meted out to their mothers at the time. Or some combination of both. DNA is not absolute.

Endlesssummer2022 · 24/09/2022 08:13

‘Up until 2015 we were paying back the slave owners via our taxes. Why wasn't any of that money paid to the enslaved?’

Exactly. All slave owners were extremely generously compensated when slavery was abolished. Their descendants live in the life of luxury. Meanwhile the actual slaves got nothing and their descendants therefore inherited nothing and suffered from the impacts of discrimination based on the fact they are the descendants of slaves.

Can you imagine an alternate reality where the Nazi’s had been compensated for losing the war and their descendants became rich and respected and the Jews were ‘freed’ from concentration camps, got nothing, had nothing to pass on to their children, suffered discrimination from state institutions all because they were despised for having ‘no history’ apart from being held in concentration camps?

The descendants of those who received compensation for having ‘their’ slaves taken away and are pictured in Tatler sitting in homes in Mayfair or The Hamptons should be charged a percentage to be given to Caribbean countries, African American institutions and South American African institutions. Alternatively, all Caribbean countries should have their debts cancelled. They do not owe European countries or America a brass tack. It’s they who are owed.

Article on the financial disparity between those families who owned slaves and those who were slaves. Mitch McConnnel is one. Lording it over people due to his ancestors crimes against humanity.
www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1028031

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 08:09

And if not, why not?

(and ‘bigger’ in first paragraph should have been ‘bugger’. I have a well-brought-up autocorrect).

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 08:06

Frankly as a working class descendant of working class ancestors the Crown Jewels make bigger all difference to me and I’d happily surrender all the jewels in the U.K. who’s acquisition dates to colonial times.

Because it makes bugger all difference to me, just to emphasise that again.

I do wonder though if any of the foreign aid and health care and genuine charity work provided by Britain and the British over the years is going to be offset against some reparation claims?

Lndnmummy · 24/09/2022 07:42

VladmirsPoutine · 21/09/2022 15:31

I genuinely think reparations should be a topic as big in the UK news scene as the cost of living crisis. I genuinely think this.

Me too

Sausagenbacon · 24/09/2022 07:33

For goodness sake, there isn't a poor person who isn't linked with something nefarious either.
And do tell how you would define rich. I imagine about £5000 pa better off than you.
And who would you pay it to?

Outwiththenorm · 24/09/2022 07:17

Tax the rich more. There are your reparations. There’s not a rich person alive who isn’t linked to something nefarious.

Sausagenbacon · 24/09/2022 06:45

Yes, I'm afraid they did. Looking at the list of owners, many people of lower levels in society owned slaves, or part-owned.
Not slaves in the UK, obviously.

MsPincher · 24/09/2022 04:36

Sausagenbacon · 22/09/2022 11:16

Many ordinary people owned slaves, or part owned. It's not as simple as upper and lower classes.

Not in the uK they didn’t.

MsPincher · 24/09/2022 04:34

Farmerazza · 22/09/2022 15:52

If you were not around when slavery took place and do not want hear about reparations. Why pay slavers up until 2015 - your taxes paid for this. Why didn't you complain then?

We didn’t pay slavers until 2015. See above

Swipe left for the next trending thread