Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Modern Britain

159 replies

theworldhas · 21/09/2022 05:46

from today’s Guardian newspaper:

”Nearly 11 million people are now behind on their bills while more than 5 million have gone without food, according to new research that reveals Britons are skipping meals “just to keep the lights on”.

The figures, based on an Opinium survey of 2,000 UK adults in August, found 5.6 million have gone without food in the past three months as a result of the cost of living crisis.

This included skipping meals, eating once a day or not eating at all on some days. Nearly 8 million people had sold a personal or household item to help cover bills.”

Shocking stuff in modern Britain. Inequality and poverty has skyrocketed the past ten years. These stats ought to be the headline and front page on every British newspaper from now until the next election.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2022 10:49

CryingAtTheDiscotheque · 22/09/2022 10:44

What "other sources" have you mentioned below?

If you scroll back you’ll see I’ve mentioned it twice already.

More or Less - a great programme which analyses headlines like this. It was brilliant during the pandemic as it got away from the heightened headlines. I’m listening again and they’ll look at stuff like this.

The media loves any emotional reaction, clicks which mean £. Anything which counters that rationally I’m all for.

autyspauty · 22/09/2022 10:49

DancingBudgie · 21/09/2022 06:52

I agree with Pufferpuffin. Each time I go into a supermarket, it's very busy with shoppers trolleys full of foodstuff.
The roads are just as busy as are the airports, so quite where these destitute people are I have no idea.

They are falling through the cracks.

Just saying that the supermarket is full doesn't mean that people aren't behind on their bills or not buying enough food for themselves.

CryingAtTheDiscotheque · 22/09/2022 10:44

MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2022 10:25

Moving on from a pp who seems to be taking it badly - if a survey is linked it’s natural people will question it. The Guardian has form for this as I found out during the pandemic - I always question now as a result and turn to other sources which I mentioned below:

It’s a useful skill anyway given the power of the media - one our dc could stand to gain so they’re not so emotionally drawn in to clickbait so easily.

What "other sources" have you mentioned below?

Rosehugger · 22/09/2022 10:42

Absolutely well put. The ignorance of some posters on this thread beggars belief

Quite. One thing I've noticed is more security tags being placed on food items, and we live in a well-off area but not without people in poverty (who are often disregarded because of being in a generally better off area). That indicates to me that theft has increased, and people stealing food indicates an increase in poverty and/or associated issues. There are also several food banks in the area and there were none, zero, fifteen years ago when we moved here.

Perfect28 · 22/09/2022 10:37

The Conservatives offer neolibralism though and how is that better?

LimitIsUp · 22/09/2022 10:32

ChristmasFluff · 21/09/2022 09:23

It's hardly rocket science to work out that the people who are in the shops are the ones who have the money (either always, or on a particular occasion) to buy stuff.

Or are the impoverished meant to wander the aisles at M&S in rags, carrying empty shopping baskets and staring longingly at thick-cut chips in goose fat, purely so that MNers can gauge the state of the nation?

Those of you who are buying food will know that the price of it has vastly increased recently. Since the poor spend a larger proportion of their income on food than the wealthy, it is probably not unreasonable to suggest that M&S shoppers will be less impacted than others.

To say this rise in prices is having no effect on poverty is wilful disregard.

Absolutely well put. The ignorance of some posters on this thread beggars belief

Perfect28 · 22/09/2022 10:31

Have some people here never come across the concept of a sample in statistics. You can likely go and read about how the sample was selected if you cared to

MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2022 10:25

Moving on from a pp who seems to be taking it badly - if a survey is linked it’s natural people will question it. The Guardian has form for this as I found out during the pandemic - I always question now as a result and turn to other sources which I mentioned below:

It’s a useful skill anyway given the power of the media - one our dc could stand to gain so they’re not so emotionally drawn in to clickbait so easily.

KeyWorker · 22/09/2022 10:24

I don’t think I fully understand how from a sample
of 2000 people they can know 5.6million people went without food. Any statisticians able to explain. Do they take the results from the 2000 then multiply each answer group by the Uk population?

Mamamia7962 · 22/09/2022 10:22

Kendodd - I read a medical article a while ago, where it stated that for the first time evidence showed that life expectancy was falling due to our unhealthy love of junk food.

I am in my 50s so when I was growing up it was very much a case of meals cooked from scratch and fish and chips was a very rare treat. Look at how many fast food places there are now, the McDonalds in my local shopping centre is always really busy, the same for KFC and all the other take away outlets

I genuinely think that there are some families who are really struggling but I think it depends on what a person's perception of poverty is. That will be different depending on the era you were brought up in.

onlythreenow · 22/09/2022 10:15

You don’t have to respond to click bait articles and headlines without thinking how did they arrive at this number. For any article you see not just the ones that align with your view.
There’s no point in getting upset with anyone who does question it. More or Less is a good programme to show how headlines can be used for emotive articles - although all they do is look at context maybe not for you.

Please stop responding to me - you are totally missing the point!!

Kendodd · 22/09/2022 09:45

Fair enough, people don't believe the survey. Perhaps they will believe the death rates then. Life expectancy was actually FALLING in the poorest communities in the UK since Tory austerity was introduced, so pre covid. Poverty has also been sited as a reason children have been taken into care recently.

Not that I expect the above to make a single bit of difference to Tory voters.

Thelnebriati · 22/09/2022 09:29

People aren't voting Labour because Momentum scare the crap out of people. They come across as an authoritarian group who are more interested in neoliberal identity politics than socialism.

LimitIsUp · 22/09/2022 09:21

Why do people keep voting conservative. It completely bamboozles me - if you want a fairer society with more equitable distribution of wealth than you vote Labour (or tactically for Lib Dems)

I vote Labour although it's in my narrow personal interests to vote Tory (husband and already pay multiple 000,000s in tax) because I remember what it's like to be financially disadvantaged. It's hard not to lose sympathy with Jo average voting tory - what are they thinking? (Are they even thinking)

walkingonsunshinekat · 22/09/2022 08:54

Benefit claimants inc those on working benefits got a 3% rise, when inflation is already over 10%, energy prices have doubled, even with Government support.

But still the cry is Poverty? what Poverty!

Funny how the Guardian is a click bait headline but a link to a Times etc isn't, i guess what is or isn't depends on your politics.

MarshaBradyo · 22/09/2022 07:08

onlythreenow · 22/09/2022 04:47

To those who don't believe it, please leave your bubbles and go to food banks, poorer towns or even ask people on MN if they are struggling rather than being blind to it all.

Those who don't believe it would rather rely on statistics and data - if they can't actually see it, it isn't happening. That's a problem in this world we live in now, people spend more time 'researching' on their computers than actually looking at how others might be living.

Again you are imagining an issue that isn’t there.

I know it’s an emotive topic but honestly give it some thought beyond people just ‘care about research’.

You don’t have to respond to click bait articles and headlines without thinking how did they arrive at this number. For any article you see not just the ones that align with your view.

There’s no point in getting upset with anyone who does question it. More or Less is a good programme to show how headlines can be used for emotive articles - although all they do is look at context maybe not for you.

garlictwist · 22/09/2022 06:22

I live in quite a deprived area. A lot of people don't work and are home all day. I see people getting Deliveroo all the time, sometimes more than once a day! I don't know how they afford it.

mellongoose · 22/09/2022 06:15

Sorry to PP but the term 'relative poverty' is utter nonsense and shouldn't be used. The term is used widely by charities, media and others for purely party political reasons. Why? Because lots of people fall into that category. I did, apparently, but never felt poor.

By definition, there will always be a hefty proportion of the population living in relative poverty.

Even if the average person person earned £1m then someone on £40k would be living in relative poverty. It is a nonsense.

It is also deceptive and dangerous because it masks the real statistics of people living in absolute poverty/deprivation.

I would like to see proper definitions of deprivation and the look at year on year stats for the last 40-50 years.

Some people are struggling, they absolutely are. But until we get a true picture, we will not know the true extent of this crisis.

onlythreenow · 22/09/2022 04:47

To those who don't believe it, please leave your bubbles and go to food banks, poorer towns or even ask people on MN if they are struggling rather than being blind to it all.

Those who don't believe it would rather rely on statistics and data - if they can't actually see it, it isn't happening. That's a problem in this world we live in now, people spend more time 'researching' on their computers than actually looking at how others might be living.

caroleanboneparte · 22/09/2022 01:16

This thread kind of explains why the tories have won the last 4 elections.

We didn't used to be such a right wing country, what went wrong?

Florenz · 21/09/2022 23:40

The Guardian just prints what their readers want to read. And Guardian readers want to read that poor people are going hungry, can't afford to pay their bills, having to sell their meagre possessions just to keep the wolf from the door.

user1484264563 · 21/09/2022 23:19

Sorry OP, these figures are utterly inaccurate and bordering on disreputable; as far as I recall from their last outing they're a second hand rehash of a survey conducted by a charity that works with the most vulnerable. To take the findings of a niche survey and extrapolate them by 10s of thousands to equal uk population is utterly unhelpful and directs attention away from those most in need.

shinynewapple22 · 21/09/2022 22:10

Lunar270 · 21/09/2022 07:55

I'm no statistician but how do they extrapolate 5.6 million from a survey of 2000?

I would assume that approximately 10% of people polled reported extreme financial difficulties - they have just multiplied that percentage out across the population as a whole . How random the 2000 people were - who knows ? I would agree that it's not a large enough number to be truly representative .

FrecklesMalone · 21/09/2022 22:06

Boxowine · 21/09/2022 21:40

Yes and the poor could also eat their children if necessary.

The poor are good at having too many children. The logical solution is surely to BBQ a few of the podgy ones.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 21/09/2022 21:55

God. The fatlogic in this thread already.