Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about my child being forced to sit next to child who harms him just because he’s a good kid

90 replies

Mollyshoe · 20/09/2022 22:28

Last year my son sat next to a very disruptive boy who would thump him all day long, thump him to demand to see answers, just generally distract him by tapping hîm and kicking his chair and also coughing and blowing in his face and pulling his hair.

I asked to have my son moved after he started to hate school because of it. This was only after nothing else worked. The school said no. Eventually they moved my son and his mood improved.

this year, year six, my son was happy to be sitting with his friend. But after a week, the disruptive boy was moved next to my son because he was misbehaving and they think my shy, well behaved son is a good influence. Maybe he is but my son is now getting thumped, harassed, tapped, kicked and blown at again.

The teachers say they don’t see it happening - because the boy does it when he can get away with it as soon as the teacher is marking, covered by ta, talking to another child!

Am I being unreasonable to ask for my son to move? I know they need resilience but not against this it’s unfair he had to sit next to disruptive kids who cause him harm and anxiety instead of his friend because he’s a good child.

he said he feels like he’s being punished and struggled to sleep tonight .

To be clear this is about this one child harming mine not a hate war against all kids who are “disruptive”to varying and uncontrollable degrees and who I understand may face understandable challenges that I sympathise with.

OP posts:
Irridescantshimmmer · 21/09/2022 08:58

That has seriously got to be a safeguarding issue. Your son, who is a good kid deserves to feel safe at school.

This is assault and its got to stop. The dissruptive kid needs one to one help or therapy of some kind too but not to the detriment of other children.

The violent kid probably feels out of his depth, or feels a bit thick.....so putting him next to a clever child is making him feel worse, hence his behaviour, so it is a very vicious cycle.

I am sure if you speak to the head teacher, get them to understand your concerns and mention safeguarding, hopefully they will step up and sort this out.

I really hope a solution happens and quickly.

CallMeLinda · 21/09/2022 08:58

Your son is being physically assaulted daily by this boy.
I'd demand he was moved, I would not be asking.

Twilightimmortal · 21/09/2022 08:20

I would say that you will not use my child to scaffold this child. This child clearly needs a LSA and that is not my child's problem. Move the child away from my son or I will move my son from the school.

oakleaffy · 21/09/2022 08:18

The cane scene in Kes was actually real.
The actors weren't told of it , and were paid extra.
Looked very painful.

oakleaffy · 21/09/2022 08:14

Sparklythings1 · 21/09/2022 07:29

I can see this one from both sides unfortunately. No child should go to school to be assaulted so no, he shouldn’t have to sit with him. However, I’m a teacher and I have just started with my new class who has a child like this in it. It seems over the years parents have repeatedly phoned in to say their child isn’t ‘allowed’ to sit next to this child. Some parents have phoned in to say their child isn’t ‘allowed’ near a few other children too so I have inherited this class I’m just getting to know and I can’t move a single child anywhere without children announcing ‘HE’S NOT ALLOWED NEAR HIM’ or ‘I’M NOT ALLOWED NEAR HER’! It’s now got to the stage if I move anyone for repeatedly talking, a parent phones in to complain. The very nature of being the teacher is that you are in control and make decisions around children’s learning, including where they sit but I feel my class is now being run by parents and the kids are aware of this. A boy came in last week and said to another boy who was clearly now unhappy with his seat ‘DID YOUR MUM NOT PHONE AND TELL HER LAST NIGHT?’. I’m on the verge of quitting for a whole list of reasons, the behaviour of children you describe being one of the main ones but parents running the class is now another. It can be difficult not to speak negatively about someone’s child when a parent phones in to complain about someone so that might be what the teachers are doing in your case but every time I get someone phoning in I just have to agree, add that rule to my long list and move them

Separate desks like in exam halls might be better?
Sounds like hell.
Discipline seems definitely have gone to pot in the last two decades.

Looking at old films like Kes, the cane seemed to work! {I jest}

Years ago, there were ''Naughty'' children, but they were very much in the minority, and a University lecturer friend who also taught GCSE at FE colleges in the past says ''You never get any trouble from students who sit in the front row, it's always those at the back''

Brefugee · 21/09/2022 08:14

can you tell him to shout loudly every time the child hits him? Then he'll be the disruptive one and the teacher can sit your DC next to a nice quiet child.

I can't believe that teachers still do this. I used to get it all the time until my dad went in and told them he'd told me to punch back and had taught me some boxing moves. (he hadn't, but i probably would have eventually punched back)

Fredthefrog · 21/09/2022 08:10

I'm a teacher. Insist your child is moved. I had a child in my class who I had sat next to about 8 kids within the first few weeks but she was aggressive and violent to each so I put her on her own table and spent a lot of time working on positive responses as she was using the violence to get attention so I made sure I gave her a lot of attention and support before she got violent and she began to improve and was able to sit with groups for certain subjects.

oakleaffy · 21/09/2022 08:02

endofthelinefinally · 20/09/2022 22:36

It is such a lazy way of dealing with the disruptive children and very cruel to the well behaved kids who get abused and assaulted all day long. My child used to come home covered in bruises because she was always put next to the naughtiest boy to "encourage him to be good".

It's so wrong to team a 'good' child with a 'Naughty' one...I remember having to sit next to the class Bully occasionally... I detested it, as I'm, sure she did.

Her slack~ lipped sneer as she was pulled from the back of the class to the front was memorable.

They probably do it as your son has nothing in common with the naughty child, so the teacher hopes your good son will have a calming effect.

It's not your son's job to be a ''Good influence'' on this horrid boy.

scrufffy · 21/09/2022 08:00

I'm so sorry this is happening to your son.

It happened to one of my DC who is now in their mid thirties.

I let it go on too long. Don't be like me.

Sparklythings1 · 21/09/2022 07:29

I can see this one from both sides unfortunately. No child should go to school to be assaulted so no, he shouldn’t have to sit with him. However, I’m a teacher and I have just started with my new class who has a child like this in it. It seems over the years parents have repeatedly phoned in to say their child isn’t ‘allowed’ to sit next to this child. Some parents have phoned in to say their child isn’t ‘allowed’ near a few other children too so I have inherited this class I’m just getting to know and I can’t move a single child anywhere without children announcing ‘HE’S NOT ALLOWED NEAR HIM’ or ‘I’M NOT ALLOWED NEAR HER’! It’s now got to the stage if I move anyone for repeatedly talking, a parent phones in to complain. The very nature of being the teacher is that you are in control and make decisions around children’s learning, including where they sit but I feel my class is now being run by parents and the kids are aware of this. A boy came in last week and said to another boy who was clearly now unhappy with his seat ‘DID YOUR MUM NOT PHONE AND TELL HER LAST NIGHT?’. I’m on the verge of quitting for a whole list of reasons, the behaviour of children you describe being one of the main ones but parents running the class is now another. It can be difficult not to speak negatively about someone’s child when a parent phones in to complain about someone so that might be what the teachers are doing in your case but every time I get someone phoning in I just have to agree, add that rule to my long list and move them

Stag82 · 21/09/2022 07:12

I would contact the school and log it as a safeguarding issue. The school have a duty of care to keep your son safe. Ask then what the propose to do to keep him safe.

follow up your conversation with an email and also have a future meeting date in place.

ittakes2 · 21/09/2022 06:58

My kids primary school was like this - even to the point where my son was expected to play with this kid at each lunch and break. I only discovered when my son started crying at night saying the kid would hit him if my son did not play what he wanted my son to play. Tell them this seating if effecting your sons mental and physical health and you need the school to protect him. And if they don’t I would escalate to head teacher or even board. Go one further and take your son into school this morning and ask to see the head teacher as your son is being bullied.

Chuckles19 · 21/09/2022 06:31

Yes, I’m a teacher. You are being reasonable asking for him to be moved. Email and I say ‘I would like him moved immediately.’
Done. No need to go into huge detail, just say for the same reasons as before.

However, with him being in year 6 now I would also suggest encouraging your child to have a little talk with the teacher at break and ask if they can move away. When he gets to secondary there will be multiple seating plans that he may not be happy with and this might help for if he has to speak to teachers then.

This other child is probably waiting for every opportunity that that teacher is not watching. E. G turning to the board for a moment, helping another student.

Iknowforsure1 · 21/09/2022 03:37

YANBU
Schools are quite powerless these days, there is no much at all they can do with persistently disruptive children. Not much help or funding. But that’s the thing, duty of care is for all the children. And the fact that the child is quiet and non disruptive doesn’t mean that their feelings have to be disregarded. No, I would absolutely not having my child be used as a “good influence “ in this case. More like abuse.

templesit · 21/09/2022 03:33

What did the school say?

I agree, you must stand up for your son.

At school I had the 'naughty' boy next to me throughout my junior years. It was because I was so quiet and good but would almost be like his 121 🙄 or mini teacher trying to get him to be quiet/ listen. This meant I struggled to focus and fell behind as a result.
No one helped me and I wish they had.

Bluesparkled · 21/09/2022 03:11

If I had a colleague sitting beside me doing those things I’d report him or her for assault and if my company had forced me to sit with them knowing it, I’d also sue them!
I don’t know why children are expected to put up with this sort of crap when we wouldn’t.
This has been my dcs problem in the past, too. Sometimes I have also been told It’s good for dc’s learning to be helping disruptive child with their work.
Unacceptable in every possible way.

NumberTheory · 21/09/2022 02:34

OP if you can deal with this without involving the police, that will probably be easiest and best (providing it actually gets dealt with). But I think you need to be much more proactive than you appear to be being here and not just leave it up to your son to protest each time.

Email the school and inform them your son is being assaulted in class by this boy. Mention this is a continuation of behaviour they dealt with in year 5 that disrupted DS’s schooling for [however long it was before they moved them] and that their letting it recur seems to be a failure of their duty of care to your son and you expect a more timely response this time. If their bullying policy seems robust enough, specifically ask them to follow it. But if it’s pretty wispy washy tell them you don’t consider it appropriate by itself and they need to immediately protect your DS from criminal assault.

Having him loudly protest isn’t a bad idea. Each time this happens he should tell the boy to stop and walk away and tell the teacher, unless he fears that will escalate the violence, in which case he needs to tell the teacher quietly when he can. But it isn’t enough. Everyday this happens he needs to tell you and you need to email the school (so there is a trail they can’t deny) stating that your son has been assaulted in school again and asking what safeguarding steps they are going to take to stop it happening. If he has bruises you need to take photos of them. If they don’t move him after the second time it happens, go to the police and report the assault, tell them you have tried to go through the school but they are putting your son in harms way. I would also keep my child off school, informing the school that he will only return when they agree a plan with you to keep him safe from assault.

This may seem like a dramatic response. But if you don’t make them act quickly your DS will lose confidence in the school and, more importantly, in you. He will stop telling you what’s happening and become much more vulnerable - just as he gets to an age when you really need good communication with him over risks and relationships. He can’t handle this on his own. He doesn’t have the autonomy to change his environment and get properly away. He risks being told of himself for defending himself and his teachers aren’t listening to him. You need to make them take it seriously and make your son’s school safe for him.

mathanxiety · 21/09/2022 02:21

YANBU

Call the HT every single day to complain and have a list of all the previous day's incidents when you call. Send an email daily too sonyou have a paper trail.

At the end of each week request a meeting with the teacher and HT. Your H should go too.

If you can email the teacher you should CC her.

Be the squeakiest wheel the school has ever seen. If you get no satisfactory response from the school, you should go to the governors.

Moving the violent student to sit beside some other quiet child is not a satisfactory answer.

Appleblum · 21/09/2022 01:57

No I wouldn't put up with this at all, your poor son. You need to approach his school again and escalate it if necessary.

I'm not sure why they are refusing to move him though. DD is always being put next to 'disruptive' kids as teachers feel that she can be a good influence on them. She mostly doesn't mind and she gets along well with most people. However she was placed next to a boy last year who was hiding her stuff and leaving rubbish on her seat. I brought this to the attention of her form teacher who immediately made the boy apologise and moved him once she verified that it was true.

Novum · 21/09/2022 00:33

Have you taken photographs of the bruises?

I think you need to insist on a move now, pointing out that your child is being bullied and injured and that this is a safeguarding issue, in addition to preventing him from learning. If they won't co-operate, ask for an urgent meeting with the head, and make it clear beforehand that the agenda items will be how they propose to keep your child safe from assault, and what they are doing to comply with their own bullying and safeguarding policies. Before you go, print off copies of those policies and any others that may be relevant and be ready with questions about how they are applying them. Ideally take someone with you to take notes, and produce and circulate your own minutes afterwards recording everything the school agrees to do and how they say they will protect your child.

Fraaahnces · 21/09/2022 00:13

my daughter had this for years. I taught her to yell out every time! “Ow! Stop kicking me, “Sean”!” , “Stop pulling my hair, “Sean”! That really hurts!!!”
*I had one particular teacher complain that her yelling out like this was disruptive, but I bought dates and times I had been previously to discuss this with her and that if she didn’t move this kid, then I would be reporting her to authorities.

Pallisers · 21/09/2022 00:03

In all honesty, I think the teacher found it easier to sit the boy away from my DD than deal with my DD's responses to the behaviours directed at her and also mine. I know that probably passed the problem on to others in the class, but I only have my DD in there as my priority and she had taken her turn.

This is the blueprint of what you need to do OP. You need to make such a fuss that it is easier for the teacher to move your child somewhere safer than make you put up with it. Yeah, maybe the problem is passed on but you have only one priority - your child. Once your child is safe, you can certainly work with the school for better policies etc but not until your child is safe mentally and physically.

They are failing that other child too - expecting a peer to sort out his behaviour.

BoviTraci · 21/09/2022 00:02

Ring your local police station
And ask to speak to the schools community copper . All schools have one . He or she will sort this for you . I did it my my son was being bullied. It did the trick as it got round like wildfire .

lannistunut · 20/09/2022 23:58

I was a teacher. This is unacceptable. I would go into school tomorrow, to reception, and say you will not bring him into class until the seating plan is changed. Take a photo of any bruises and say you will report to Ofsted if the seating plan isn't changed. The school is complicit in the physical bullying of your child. Do not doubt yourself, this is completely out of order.

France98 · 20/09/2022 23:52

I'm a teacher and this is not acceptable.