Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to move house…

55 replies

Mrsblueshoes · 20/09/2022 20:42

We live in a small 1 bed flat in London which we love. And is half an hour from work. But we have an 8 month DS. We found a small house in the town I grew up in near my mum. It means a long commute-2 hours -+ unreliable trains.
I don’t really want to move back to my old town, the idea makes me a bit depressed, although it’s fine & people love living there. I’m sure we’d make friends & settle in.
It seems to make sense to be near my mum for childcare support, although she is often very busy with her own things too so he’d have to tag along with her ..
we’ve decided we’d stay put in London in our flat until I go back to work & we know what it’ll be like. And the thought of moving feels a bit much right now.
but my mum is making me feel very selfish in this decision, that the pollution will harm our DS, that we won’t have any support & we should do what s best for him. I know she’s disappointed, but I feel awful now and so confused! Should we jump into the unknown and long (expensive) commute for the sake of our baby? Or stay with our decision to stick it out in London & the small flat a bit longer?…

OP posts:
Happyhappyday · 21/09/2022 05:03

Having no commute (DH and I both WFH) is HANDS DOWN the biggest thing that’s made our lives easier with a small child (4yo). I would do anything you can to keep commute short.

DD is 4 and sleeps roughly 7:30-6:30. I get to see her until 8am when daddy walks her to school. I pick her up at 4:30 and we have until bedtime. If I had to commute, I’d be rushing to get out the door just as she was up, so wouldn’t see her and then likely she’d have to stay at nursery until 5:30/6, rush home, dinner, bath bed. I would likely get maybe 1.5-2 hours at most with her a day, any time I commute comes directly out of the time I get to spend with her. If I was commuting and seeing her less every day, I’d also find it a lot harder to take time to do hobbies and see friends and miss out more time with her but then my quality of life would be much lower.

You can’t buy time. Don’t give 12 hours a week because your mum is making you feel guilty!!

Marchitectmummy · 21/09/2022 04:49

It doesn't sound like either are ideal and probably you will need to look to move somewhere else in the end.

Do you have a nursery lined up where you live? Not sure post covid how long the lists are but when we had ours they were extremely long in the area of London we live in. That might sway your decision making now.

In the next couple of years school will start to come into your thoughts, are there local schools of interest for your child?

Start to think about those and you may find the answer to your question in practicalities outside of what type of place you live in.

Monstermoomoo · 21/09/2022 04:37

Definitely stay put for now. My kids hate the days when their dad works a two hour train ride away as he leaves before they wake up and gets back after they're in bed. The little one cried himself to sleep last night because of it. We do it because we have to but it's so incredibly far from ideal. I'm sure your little one would benefit more from more time with you than more time with a grandparent anyway, if there has to be a choice. Also, once your little one starts school (I realise that's quite a while off!) you'd never be able to do drop offs or pick ups with that kind of commute. Again, it's fine if it's something you have to do. But if you can avoid it, I would!

PMAmostofthetime · 21/09/2022 04:01

Mrsblueshoes · 20/09/2022 22:30

Ah thank you! This makes me feel so much better! To be fair I was looking at doing 3 days a week so not a long commute everyday- probably should’ve added that! But definitely makes me feel less mad/selfish for our decision 😅

That's still 12 unnecessary hours away from DS a week.
You have made the right decision.

NumberTheory · 21/09/2022 03:14

Agree with others, 2 hour commute for you will not be good for your DS.

Can you make a two bed flat and childcare work in London? Because it’s a great place to bring up kids. So much for them to do. So many services when they’re small. Schools tend to be good. If they develop a passion then there are almost certainly top tier clubs/coaches around. And when they get to teen years it’s fantastic.

Holidaying7 · 21/09/2022 02:16

Also if you love London, why leave? I know it’s expensive and property size will be a compromise, but it can be a wonderful place to raise a child. Diversity, culture, always something going on. And schools in London outperform those out of London. Move to a 2-bed if you can afford it, when you feel you need the space, and live somewhere you love.

Holidaying7 · 21/09/2022 02:13

Two hour commute… you’d never see your baby!! So definitely don’t do that.

Aria999 · 21/09/2022 02:10

Do not do a 2 hr commute, even 3 days a week. Nightmare! You will be exhausted and not see your child on those days.

Even pre kids I had a 1 hour maximum I was willing to commute.

StripeyDeckchair · 21/09/2022 01:54

2hr commute for both of you will be horrific. You'll hardly see your baby, be permanently tired, itll cost and it won't be good for your relationship.

Hang on where you are for now and look at other places to move to - max commute 1hr.

Star81 · 21/09/2022 00:26

Even only working in office 3 days a week is 12 hours travel v 3 hours travel - that’s a whole extra day with your child a week !!

Duchess379 · 21/09/2022 00:23

4 he commute on top of your work day - firm no from me!

Coyoacan · 20/09/2022 23:46

Definitely not practical. What would you do the day you get a call at work telling you your child is sick and crying for you? City living is not that bad

StatisticallyChallenged · 20/09/2022 23:37

Nope, I'm in the "fuck that" camp. When they're little a short commute is a huge benefit- we stayed in a small place for years because my walk to work was 10 minutes which made all the difference when I went back with a 6 month old

We've moved out now, but I now work from home which is a game changer. Your time together is precious (not a working mum bash, it work FT, but when you do then you don't want to be wasting your non-work time on a train)

distracta · 20/09/2022 23:20

Don’t move!!!!

EfficientDynamics · 20/09/2022 23:17

A 2 hr commute each way will destroy you

I currently drive 25 minutes each way and that is the most I would want to do, luckily it's basically one road

Don't do it

TiaraBoo · 20/09/2022 23:14

From your posts, I’d say the best thing for your child is
-not to commute 4 hours per working day
-find proper childcare as your busy mum toting DS around doesn’t sound feasible
-don’t move somewhere you already find depressing
-tell yourself “my life, my choices” and don’t let your mum make your decisions for you

PickAChew · 20/09/2022 22:59

How could an extra 3 hours away fro your baby be better for anyone?

mondaytosunday · 20/09/2022 22:56

Your commute two hours each way means you don't see your child on those days!
It's an insane idea.

Exasperatednow · 20/09/2022 22:52

I was in your position. 1 bed flat, baby and London. Moved to be near sfamily but changed job but still with a long commute. So I moved house, had baby, changed to another big job with commute. It was incredibly stressful.

I'm happy now, many many years later but it would be impossible for us to move back due to house prices and I have often wondered what our lives would be like if we had stuck it out.

Lcb123 · 20/09/2022 22:46

I’d stay put for now and see how it is when you return to work. Could you look at somewhere in between as an option? If it means you can afford a bit more space but not such a long commute

Leeds2 · 20/09/2022 22:46

If you were to do 3 days a week, is your mum able to absolutely commit to looking after your child on those three days? Or would it be a bit hit and miss, because she has commitments ?

GabriellaMontez · 20/09/2022 22:44

Your Mum needs to butt out.

You and your partner need to decide what's best for your family.

jeaux90 · 20/09/2022 22:38

I'd wait, move out (somewhere else not your old town) for primary schools etc. also gives you time to search for a job perhaps that doesn't require a massive commute.

I lived in London when my daughter was very small and made the move out for school. It was somewhere I fell in love with an hour from family.

They liked it so much they (parents and a sister) moved to villages near by ConfusedGrin

Mrsblueshoes · 20/09/2022 22:30

Ah thank you! This makes me feel so much better! To be fair I was looking at doing 3 days a week so not a long commute everyday- probably should’ve added that! But definitely makes me feel less mad/selfish for our decision 😅

OP posts:
RachelSq · 20/09/2022 20:50

A two hour commute is four hours a day travel. That’s madness.