Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be on the deeds of the house

340 replies

Unicornetto · 20/09/2022 19:04

We aren't married but should I have my name on the deeds of the house?

Me and my partner have been together for 15 years and bought our first house 5 years ago. The house is in my partners name as I had no income at the time as we had just had a baby. I have had various part time jobs to fit in around the children over the last few years and haven't contributed to the mortgage just the food shopping and clothes etc for kids.

He has just remortgaged and I've been asked to sign the 'declaration of no interest' (I did this before) but I'm wondering if I should be on the deeds as we're not married? Is this possible if I don't pay the mortgage and I'm not on the mortgage? He said he doesn't believe in marriage, even though I do and says he's happy as we are. I'm just worried that I have no financial stability, which is due to giving up my full time job to raise our family. I asked him if its possible for me to go on the deeds and he said no as I'm not on the mortgage and gets really annoyed with me for asking. Just wondering what other unmarried couples have done in this situation?

OP posts:
NCforthis864 · 21/09/2022 23:00

She is choosing to not work/be part-time etc. Choosing to not look financially protect herself. Also, having the kids together does just simply not entitle her to be on the deeds. Again, if I was the boyfriend, my main concern would be that the children are protected if anything happens, which they would be as they would inherit the property.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 21/09/2022 22:54

@NCforthis864 but she is contributing by raising their children and working part time is part of that.

We had a discussion before children that, in an ideal world, one of us would not work in order to raise young children. That wasn't possible, but me working fewer days was possible. DH wouldn't cut me out of the home rights because I'm not earning as much as him because I'm home with our children more - what a ridiculous suggestion 🤷🏼‍♀️

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 22:43

She has got three children to him!

NCforthis864 · 21/09/2022 22:38

Minority view here but I think if you have not contributed to the mortgage, you shouldn't be on the deeds. The only way to protect yourself is equality - get a full time job, contribute to the mortgage, split childcare/food/bills. How you couldn’t have seen this earlier given you have previously signed such a declaration is beyond me. Reversing it, if my partner didn’t contribute there’s no way I would put him on my deeds. I would protect my asset completely.

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 22:31

Not easily. Lenders dont normally allow it. Someone at the start of the thread said that HSBC are more lenient but Ive never known it in applications and Ive had a lot of mortgages

Username112233 · 21/09/2022 22:26

@MrsPerfect12 yes you can

Blossomtoes · 21/09/2022 22:23

MrsPerfect12 · 21/09/2022 21:58

When a mortgage is involved you can't be on the deeds of the house without being on the mortgage.

You can.

MrsPerfect12 · 21/09/2022 21:58

When a mortgage is involved you can't be on the deeds of the house without being on the mortgage.

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 21:32

Chuckiegg · 21/09/2022 21:10

In my (dated) experience it depends. If the bank considered an adult child was contributing to the mortgage payments but not on the deeds they would insist on legal advice.
With a partner they definitely would as they would consider them to have a beneficial interest which would possibly prevent eviction in the event of default.
Barclays lost a big case when a wife signed security documents for her husband. She went to court and said she didn't understand the full implications of what she was signing. From that point all their procedures changed. This was probably 25 - 30 years ago.

www.e-lawresources.co.uk/Barclays-Bank-v-O-Brien.php

This one?

The wife co owned the house though.

In OPs case she has no financial interest at all. She might as well be a lodger, theres no evidence she has financially contributed to the property

Which I think a lot of people have not considered, there may well be a reason why she didnt want to be part owner because that also means being part debtor.

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 21:16

@MindYourBeeswax

Oh, God. You are quoting me out of context.

I’m ‘pretending’ nothing.

She is his greatest “asset”. And she must have the confidence to realise that.

Nothing wrong in saying that.

A man with a partner/spouse who can string a sentence together and benefits him, is frequently promoted more readily. The sum of parts, so to speak. That’s society for you.

I want her to be aware of her worth in expecting more. And how valuable she must see herself as.

I’m certainly not sugar coating anything. If I didn’t think it was a hole she was in, I wouldn’t have invested so much time on this thread.

It is a matter of encouraging OP.

I have stated she must see her own IFA and her own solicitor. Not his. Paying them herself.

You are lacking understanding of how you and a few others have made her feel.

Some of the responses are outright fatalistic.
OP will feel hopeless and leave it for another decade.

I don’t think you want that either, do you?

I want her to speak up and to watch him.
She will start to see how things clearly, the more she does so.

Damn right, he needs to get down to that registry office.

I have absolutely asserted this.

If he won’t, there are a few things I can think of that might help in the meantime.

Her OP may be devious, uncaring, or witnessed divorce and it has made him overly cautious. He may think she will leave if she is better off and they marry.

We can’t speculate but this will unravel as she expects to be involved in financial decisions, to hear and be involved in speaking to the same organisations and people as he is.

Please don’t underestimate how coercive partners can be.

Things are often performed by guilt tripping (“look how hard I work”), and shame (“you are an embarrassment to us all by not working enough, nobody wants to hear what you have to say, they will never let you be on the mortgage, it’s the rules, not up to me, what will they think when they hear how long you haven’t been working for” and on, you get the drift.

Arguments like this are often alternated by generous gifts to confuse the person and negative viewpoints endorsed by enmeshed older family members.

I have a supper getting cold now. Must go!

Chuckiegg · 21/09/2022 21:14

Sorry OP this probably isn't helpful. I would see a lawyer for advice.

Chuckiegg · 21/09/2022 21:10

In my (dated) experience it depends. If the bank considered an adult child was contributing to the mortgage payments but not on the deeds they would insist on legal advice.
With a partner they definitely would as they would consider them to have a beneficial interest which would possibly prevent eviction in the event of default.
Barclays lost a big case when a wife signed security documents for her husband. She went to court and said she didn't understand the full implications of what she was signing. From that point all their procedures changed. This was probably 25 - 30 years ago.

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 21:04

They dont have to 'enforce' it. Shes not forced to sign it. If she doesnt sign it then clearly it impacts on the mortgage going though. She's been advised not to sign it for that very reason.

What happens when someone remortgages with their adult children living in the property. Do all the adult children have legal advice.

Chuckiegg · 21/09/2022 21:00

My banking/legal knowledge is very dated but I would be surprised if a lender could enforce a declaration of no financial interest without insisting you received independent legal advice before doing so... any solicitor at that point would presumably point out how vulnerable your financial situation is.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 20:35

@Daringdarling
I do want to encourage the Op to take the only step she can-marriage or civil partnership. The only step that will help.
I have no doubt she is "lovely and intelligent"-it doesn't matter if she wasn't though. What matters is shaming her boyfriend into sharing his assets.

It also does no harm to point out to others who might be contemplating having children with a man who doesn't think they're good enough to marry or to share their assets with.
If a woman has no money, is a lower earner, goes part time or gives up work altogether, she must make sure that those assets are shared and the only surefire way to do that is marriage or a a civil partnership.

If the woman is well off on her own terms, has a great job and no intention of giving it up then it's a different ball game. The OP isn't in this position.

You pretending that her loveliness is impressing all his workmates and that the bank will get involved is really quite damaging and sugar coats the bloody awful hole she's in.

This is a man who not only doesn't want to share his assets he actually wants her to sign an official piece of paper declaring that she is entitled. he is covering his arse and she has left hers exposed.

He sounds like a piece of work and she has been gullible. Hopefully, he will trot down to the Registry Office but he sounds like a man with a plan and that plan is to keep the lot for himself.

Good luck OP!

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 20:27

And quite honestly the waiting times at most banks make you feel suicidal anyway.

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 20:25

HotDogKetchup · 21/09/2022 20:16

Which begs the questions why would someone phone their bank in that scenario? Totally bizarre.

At a stretch someone might ring the bank and become upset talking about their overdraft or credit card bill or cant pay their mortgage payments and during the conversation threaten suicide or say they're feeling suicide and of course there are processes to follow for staff

That is ENTIRELY different to Ms unmarried phoning up to complain that their boyfriend bought a house on his own and Ive got no pension and buy all the kids clothes dont you know. He's applied for a mortgage again on his own, what can you do for me?

The customer service bod is busily making notes that this sounds like a good customer in the making (she is female after all), better ensure she gets some junk mail through the post about new account opportunities. Oh and can I put you through to complete a quick survey about our service today?

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 20:23

@HotDogKetchup now you’re being deliberately obtuse.

The subject was why banks do indeed take notes under particular circumstances whether it be dependency or a health issue.

I have already stated banks’ motivation for doing for soft and more grave purposes.

You wouldn’t score highly on a critical appreciation exam, because you are skim reading. You are exercising hyperbole to disprove a valid point.

HotDogKetchup · 21/09/2022 20:16

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 20:07

I cant even respond any more you're on another planet, comparing it to if someone phones and they're suicidal.

Which begs the questions why would someone phone their bank in that scenario? Totally bizarre.

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 20:16

@MindYourBeeswax , you’re quoting out of context there.

I was reminding her that she is I’m sure lovely and intelligent. I don’t think you have any concept of how coercion can outweigh a person’s normally logic reasoning and self worth in life.

OP said how worthless some of these responses made her feel. I have seen yobs with crass doom laden responses on here before.

OP sounds very much like she has had a sense of hopelessness over the years. A “what’s the point?” outlook that can be due to family or spousal conditioning.

You’re derogating her self worth and her motivation, here.

She has asked for advice. That takes courage.

And yes, I do think her partner will likely have chosen her well. Men like this prefer their partners kind, lovely, intelligent enough to listen and advise based on all the years they have known them but, and this is crucial … compliant.

Often, there is fear of abandonment at the root of these circumstances, let’s help and encourage the OP, shall we please.

BadNomad · 21/09/2022 20:13

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 19:45

@BadNomad Please re-read.

I said OP would need to ask for her partner’s permission and talk together on a speaker phone.

He should be involving his partner and mother of their children in this. It’s about revealing whether this is laziness, ignorance or malicious intent.

If he doesn’t want her involved in speaking to them, well, well, well, then … his blasé view of not being particularly bothered about marriage falls off its axis and comes clanging to the floor, doesn’t it.

It will reveal that he cares an awful lot!

But why does he need to give her permission to talk to them when he can do it himself? If he wanted to put her on the mortgage and deeds he would arrange it. She doesn't need to be on a group call for that. It doesn't give her any power. It is him who needs to sort this. If he wants.

bellac11 · 21/09/2022 20:07

I cant even respond any more you're on another planet, comparing it to if someone phones and they're suicidal.

HotDogKetchup · 21/09/2022 20:07

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 20:02

OK @bellac11, let’s ask @Andypandy799 about the relevance of note keeping on financial systems in banking.

Do you realise what happens when a bank customer is sui.ci. dal , for example ?

No, you’re right they take no notes whatsoever. They don’t want a situation on their hands that the customer may have recorded but they haven’t.

Algorithms on our phones are recording everything about us. Continually.

Some of those algorithms are powered by your banking app.

It’s quaintly sexist to imagine that banks aren’t interested in the woman of the household regardless of whether she is banking with them or not. They want the woman of each household to bank with them during her lifetime and to get her onboard too.

Research statistics frequently report that the main decision maker for consumer products in the household is the woman. Banks care about her motivations.

This is deviating from my original assertion that the OP should get the bank to document her stance on withdrawing her interest in the property in their notes on the mortgage of partner.

How much detail or influence banks’ digital filing notes have, is something view of us will ever know but one thing is for sure is that it’s in their benefit to know because it is powering household consumer decision making.

OP has nothing to lose by doing so.

but OP would be confirming information they already have?

Daringdarling · 21/09/2022 20:02

OK @bellac11, let’s ask @Andypandy799 about the relevance of note keeping on financial systems in banking.

Do you realise what happens when a bank customer is sui.ci. dal , for example ?

No, you’re right they take no notes whatsoever. They don’t want a situation on their hands that the customer may have recorded but they haven’t.

Algorithms on our phones are recording everything about us. Continually.

Some of those algorithms are powered by your banking app.

It’s quaintly sexist to imagine that banks aren’t interested in the woman of the household regardless of whether she is banking with them or not. They want the woman of each household to bank with them during her lifetime and to get her onboard too.

Research statistics frequently report that the main decision maker for consumer products in the household is the woman. Banks care about her motivations.

This is deviating from my original assertion that the OP should get the bank to document her stance on withdrawing her interest in the property in their notes on the mortgage of partner.

How much detail or influence banks’ digital filing notes have, is something view of us will ever know but one thing is for sure is that it’s in their benefit to know because it is powering household consumer decision making.

OP has nothing to lose by doing so.

MindYourBeeswax · 21/09/2022 19:58

The OP cannot phone his bank any more than I can phone my neighbour's bank. She is a legal stranger to him.

Your only way out of this OP is marriage or a civil partnership.

It doesn't matter how "lovely or intelligent" you are-quoting an earlier pp-if he won't engage in a legal ceremony, you just don't count when it comes to his affairs.

For other posters, who might be contemplating three children without marriage and in a low paying job-if he thought you were so lovely and intelligent-a prize-he would want to marry you.

OP.Tell him you've won the lottery. He might rush you down to the registry office.

Swipe left for the next trending thread