Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be on the deeds of the house

340 replies

Unicornetto · 20/09/2022 19:04

We aren't married but should I have my name on the deeds of the house?

Me and my partner have been together for 15 years and bought our first house 5 years ago. The house is in my partners name as I had no income at the time as we had just had a baby. I have had various part time jobs to fit in around the children over the last few years and haven't contributed to the mortgage just the food shopping and clothes etc for kids.

He has just remortgaged and I've been asked to sign the 'declaration of no interest' (I did this before) but I'm wondering if I should be on the deeds as we're not married? Is this possible if I don't pay the mortgage and I'm not on the mortgage? He said he doesn't believe in marriage, even though I do and says he's happy as we are. I'm just worried that I have no financial stability, which is due to giving up my full time job to raise our family. I asked him if its possible for me to go on the deeds and he said no as I'm not on the mortgage and gets really annoyed with me for asking. Just wondering what other unmarried couples have done in this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HotDogKetchup · 07/10/2022 21:10

Isn’t it sad to have to acknowledge, that in life there will always be some people who gain pleasure from keeping their foot firmly on the head of women asking for much needed help? And the authority and vehemence with which they insist they are right! Never ceases to surprise me.

Or woman who understand that under English common law, a bank owes a duty of confidentiality to its customer, and it is an implied term of the contract between the bank and its customer that the bank will keep the customer’s information confidential.

The discussion that OP alleges took place was unlawful and should not have occurred.

Daringdarling · 07/10/2022 19:00

@Unicornetto I remember this one!
I’m really glad that you made the attempt to speak up and that it paid off!

Well done. Keep us updated when it happens because I’m sure it will be inspiring to others in your position.

Look back over the history of this thread, at a few posters on here telling you that there was no point, it wasn’t possible, etc.

I was insulted when I said to call and speak up about your situation, that it was in the bank’s interest to be made aware of your compromised situation and I was told that I was “living in fantasy land”!!

Moral of this is to ignore the doomsayers!

Isn’t it sad to have to acknowledge, that in life there will always be some people who gain pleasure from keeping their foot firmly on the head of women asking for much needed help? And the authority and vehemence with which they insist they are right! Never ceases to surprise me.

Andypandy799 · 04/10/2022 20:04

@Unicornetto

Glad everything worked out for you both

Unicornetto · 04/10/2022 18:40

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 18:08

But he should be bothered OP.

He should be bothered that people entrusted to manage what is likely the biggest financial investment of his life are now speaking to third parties about that investment when they have no legal right to that information.

Any right thinking person would be massively concerned about that. You know you're you. So does he. But anyone could have called up and had the conversation you had with them.

They've breached his data and violated any code of conduct for the industry.

If that doesn't concern either of you then that's very worrying.

Yes he was concerned but hasnt done anything about it. All of the above that you have explained we are already aware of.
We are 'right thinking' people..
This happened a couple of weeks ago now, if he doesn't want to pursue making a complaint I can't force him.

OP posts:
rageapplied · 04/10/2022 18:34

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 18:08

But he should be bothered OP.

He should be bothered that people entrusted to manage what is likely the biggest financial investment of his life are now speaking to third parties about that investment when they have no legal right to that information.

Any right thinking person would be massively concerned about that. You know you're you. So does he. But anyone could have called up and had the conversation you had with them.

They've breached his data and violated any code of conduct for the industry.

If that doesn't concern either of you then that's very worrying.

I agree with this. It's a massive breach and really needs reported to the ico.

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 18:08

But he should be bothered OP.

He should be bothered that people entrusted to manage what is likely the biggest financial investment of his life are now speaking to third parties about that investment when they have no legal right to that information.

Any right thinking person would be massively concerned about that. You know you're you. So does he. But anyone could have called up and had the conversation you had with them.

They've breached his data and violated any code of conduct for the industry.

If that doesn't concern either of you then that's very worrying.

Unicornetto · 04/10/2022 18:04

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 17:18

I'm not sure I would trust advice from someone who has discussed with you the specific details of any financial arrangement you are not legally attached to, to be honest.

It's not permitted as it's a data breach and violates all privacy clauses.

So it either didn't happen or your partner needs to be making a formal complaint about how they've handled his data, private financial and legal matters.

I'm not saying he should have an issue with you wanting to do any of this.

He should have a HUGE issue with them speaking to someone unnamed on his agreements about those agreements.

Well it did happen, why on earth would I make it up! He doesn't seem really bothered!

OP posts:
HotDogKetchup · 04/10/2022 17:30

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 17:18

I'm not sure I would trust advice from someone who has discussed with you the specific details of any financial arrangement you are not legally attached to, to be honest.

It's not permitted as it's a data breach and violates all privacy clauses.

So it either didn't happen or your partner needs to be making a formal complaint about how they've handled his data, private financial and legal matters.

I'm not saying he should have an issue with you wanting to do any of this.

He should have a HUGE issue with them speaking to someone unnamed on his agreements about those agreements.

Yes also seems totally bizarre that they would look to alter the application based on a conversation with someone who isn’t their client.

wellhelloitsme · 04/10/2022 17:18

I'm not sure I would trust advice from someone who has discussed with you the specific details of any financial arrangement you are not legally attached to, to be honest.

It's not permitted as it's a data breach and violates all privacy clauses.

So it either didn't happen or your partner needs to be making a formal complaint about how they've handled his data, private financial and legal matters.

I'm not saying he should have an issue with you wanting to do any of this.

He should have a HUGE issue with them speaking to someone unnamed on his agreements about those agreements.

Unicornetto · 04/10/2022 15:03

Ramsbottom · 30/09/2022 17:07

It would probably benefit me with feeling fulfilled bit it wouldn't benefit the kids and their happiness is my priority

why wouldn’t it benefit the kids? Good childcare can be very beneficial to kids, from learning independence to socialisation on.

but I’m very surprised the mortgage advisor spoke to you about his mortgage. That’s a total data breach and is not permitted.

It would just be breakfast club and after school club, I don't think they would get much out of it to be honest and would cost £330 per week! I have used childcare in the past before they went to school, yes it is beneficial. But you have to weigh up whether the cost is worth it. Working 25 hours a week and not paying childcare makes sense until they can let themselves in after school!

OP posts:
Unicornetto · 04/10/2022 14:57

I was totally shocked that the mortgage adviser would speak to me too. The initial conversation I was just asking the question if me going on the application without my earnings being taken into consideration was a possibility. I left my email address with the admin lady. I then had an email from MA later that day saying yes this is possible and asking me for my bank statements payslips I'd etc and asked me to phone back for a phone appt. Maybe it was because it was mybsame email address from 5 years prior when we made the 1st application? Anyway I phoned up and MA answered and she said we can fill in application now, gave her all my details and she couldn't get through to the building society to confirm a couple of things so I left it with her. Next day she emailed both of us to say we would have to go through the application process again if though its an edit and would mean new hard credit searches etc and due to my age they would have had to reduce the number of years on the mortgage making payments higher. As this was a bit risky due to the rates going up and my partner already had a fairly good rate secured we didn't got ahead with a new application add me on. The building society have confirmed that I can apply to be added onto the deeds though when its all gone through.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 30/09/2022 18:41

Whats the happy ending?

Has OP been back?

I agree that I dont understand how she managed to talk to the mortgage advisor about confidential issues

FinallyHere · 30/09/2022 18:38

It sounds like a great happy ending. So please to hear that it was just ignorance rather than malice keeping you from the joint ownership.

I know it is possible for a partners income to be disregarded for the purposes of mortgage if one partner's income is sufficient. We did that most recent remortgage

I'm very surprised that a 'stranger' could have that conversation with the mortgage company. How t st if you get through the usual ID checks ?

Ramsbottom · 30/09/2022 17:37

Yes I don’t get it either, she would loose her job over that. You just can’t discuss someone else’s mortgage, their payments and being added to it, without his permission, that’s batshit, only the person going after the mortgage can do that.

and the whole he can do an equity transfer, he’s not agreed to that.

wellhelloitsme · 30/09/2022 17:13

This afternoon I had a telephone appointment with the mortgage company that my partner is remortgaging with (I told him that I would be phoning them this morning to see if I could be added on he said no point blah blah but I said I'mdoing it anyway). The lady I spoke to was the same lady I met 5 years ago when I couldn't go on the mortgage as I affected the affordability. Now I'm earning, I'm not a dependant and so she calculated that me going on the mortgage without taking my earnings into account (as he can afford it without me) makes no difference to the monthly payments of the mortgage offer. As the mortgage is at offer stage, she's going to speak to the lender to make sure I can be added on. If its too late he can do transfer of equity after its gone through for a small fee.

How on earth was OP able to discuss her partner's mortgage and even request lenders being spoken to re the mortgage, without her partner's permission?

Is that not a data breach / massively against policy to share information about a mortgage with an party entirely uninvolved on paper?

Ramsbottom · 30/09/2022 17:07

It would probably benefit me with feeling fulfilled bit it wouldn't benefit the kids and their happiness is my priority

why wouldn’t it benefit the kids? Good childcare can be very beneficial to kids, from learning independence to socialisation on.

but I’m very surprised the mortgage advisor spoke to you about his mortgage. That’s a total data breach and is not permitted.

Andypandy799 · 30/09/2022 11:54

@Unicornetto well done I’ll keep my fingers crossed the mortgage offer can be changed. At least you took the fist step and as for all those who blamed your dp for doing this deliberately shame on them

NCforthis864 · 22/09/2022 18:58

Do you trust him to do the transfer of equity after, and what percentage of equity? Watch it’s not a Joint Borrower Sole Proprietor Mortgage which essentially means there are two borrowers but only one owner.

HotDogKetchup · 22/09/2022 18:50

Technonan · 22/09/2022 18:43

You need to get some good legal advice, now. You have no protection and you have no independent income. Don't sign the declaration of no interest. Why is he asking you to do this, unless he wants to be in a position to end the relationship and give you nothing?

Legally, he can do this. Your contributions - giving up your career, having children with him, bringing the children up and, I suspect, a lot of housekeeping and general support sadly count for close to nothing, legally.

To he honest, I wouldn't want to stay with a man who acted like this, but that is your decision. What is important is that you get some legal rights over property that you have a strong moral right to. Good luck.

I don’t know - but have experienced brokers sayings there’s “no point” adding someone without an income to the mortgage. I suspect they don’t understand the implications of that and are just looking at the mortgage application in isolation.

OP’s OH might have followed their advice and not realised the implications for OP.

Technonan · 22/09/2022 18:43

You need to get some good legal advice, now. You have no protection and you have no independent income. Don't sign the declaration of no interest. Why is he asking you to do this, unless he wants to be in a position to end the relationship and give you nothing?

Legally, he can do this. Your contributions - giving up your career, having children with him, bringing the children up and, I suspect, a lot of housekeeping and general support sadly count for close to nothing, legally.

To he honest, I wouldn't want to stay with a man who acted like this, but that is your decision. What is important is that you get some legal rights over property that you have a strong moral right to. Good luck.

HotDogKetchup · 22/09/2022 18:37

If OP gets some financial security there’s less onus on her to work FT. Enjoying your childrens childhood, in the way you most want to, is worthwhile too.

Daringdarling · 22/09/2022 18:30

@Theprimeofmissmulroney Yes, it’s outrageous for the higher earning parent to expect the significantly lower earning parent to pay for all the childcare.

Talk about ensnaring mothers.

I think some volunteer to accept this imbalance because they feel it gives them better legal rights over their children.

Reality is that so many mothers are already limited to badly paid, part time /zero hours jobs, as it is.

Theprimeofmissmulroney · 22/09/2022 18:19

Just responding to your thought about whether to work full time or not. I would suggest it would be better to work full time. Every year you miss ft work, you're losing pension. I work ft and childcare bill just comes out of our joint account. It doesn't come just out of my wages. You need to take that approach.

Testina · 22/09/2022 18:02

Hymnulop · 22/09/2022 17:49

No a T of E does not effect the fixed rate. That's why it's called a t of e and not a remortgage.

Is that for me, @Hymnulop ?
You can’t just do a transfer of equity without the permission of the lender, because you’re reducing the security they have based your mortgage on, and added a complication of another owner.

The lender may well request a re-mortgage.
I didn’t say that would affect the fixed rate offered, I said that if they have a fixed rate with a repayment charge, the repayment charge could be an issue. That’s because if they re-mortgage, they may trigger the repayment charge. The fixed rate could go up to, just because at the moment rates are increasing and the one he is mid-application on may no longer be available.

I think OP needs to be very careful before relying on a mortgage broker who says a transfer of equity is simple.

Especially because it’s the same mortgage broker that gave her duff advice 5 years ago 🤷🏻‍♀️ I say duff advice… duff advice in terms of protecting herself. But that’s not what a mortgage broker is there to do. Which again is why I wouldn’t rely on a mortgage broker being an expert on a transfer of equity. Just like during my divorce, my solicitor didn’t try to give me advice on mortgage applications.

Daringdarling · 22/09/2022 17:57

Bloody well done for calling and having a voice in all this, Unicornetto !!!

This is the beginning of a shift in discovering for yourself what can be done to secure your financial future.

I would speak to a solicitor about this before doing committing to do anything else but please do so quickly.

If your partner is out a lot during the day, this is no problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread