Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have massively messed up our finances

216 replies

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 18:55

My fiancé and I have been saving for our wedding for a year. I earn more than him but I’ve always been a spender. Never in debt or beyond my means but I’m not a big saver. We’ve been saving our money separately and have now come to pool it all together and I’m £1500 short. I don’t know how it’s happened. I just overspent every month and hoped it would all work itself out and now it’s come to it and I just haven’t saved enough. I honestly don’t even know what I’ve spent it on, just frittered on expensive skincare and make-up and stuff.

We have enough money to make up the shortfall but it means eating into our normal savings and my fiancé will cover it, like he always does, because he’s dependable and reliable and I’m useless.

He’s upset and disappointed but being quite nice about it. He grew up with a lot of debt in his family so gets worried about people keeping secrets with money because he doesn’t want me to end up hiding things and getting depressed and desperate etc. I’m just so embarrassed. How can I make it up to him? I never used to be so reckless, just lifestyle creep once my salary started going up.

OP posts:
Lcb123 · 20/09/2022 19:54

Having recently saved for a wedding- put the money in savings in payday. Have a monzo or chase card you can put a specific amount on for day to day. Don’t shop as a hobby, and unsubscribe from all emails from online shops!

PhilInt · 20/09/2022 19:53

I think you need to understand why you buy these things. It sounds more emotional to me. I say this because despite this being a one off saving up occasion and you setting up systems to save you still broke those systems because you couldn't resist. What makes it a compulsion for you to buy things?

Divebar2021 · 20/09/2022 19:52

I think it’s possible to change but you have to be quite committed about it. I used to be a person who shopped as a hobby and I consider that to be quite an embarrassing admission. I’ve had to work quite consistently to stop casual spending on nonsense - I’m not perfect but I’m a lot better. I paid attention to where my money was going to - all the usual suspects clothes, make-up, coffees out etc and I responded to those temptations individually. I unsubscribed from emails and stopped with fashion magazines. I unsubscribed from an SM influencers who used the word “haul” and concentrated on finding those involved in slow fashion / minimalist wardrobes etc. I stopped mooching around the shops just because I had time. I ventured into second hand clothes and sold some unwanted items. I consciously looked at cheaper skincare like The Ordinary or brands at Aldi /Lidl and would make myself use up a product before repurchasing. I did the same with shampoo etc. Took my lunch into work…. All the usual advice. Eventually finding my favourite product cheaper in TK Maxx became more fun than buying full price in a department store. Or finding a gem in a charity shop. But overall the aim is being happy as you are without the need for another lipstick or shoes.

NumberTheory · 20/09/2022 19:52

I think there’s a lot going on here and you could probably do with some counseling or just a bit of space with a friend who can be kind but also robustly candid with you to sort some of it out.

You have been able to save in the past. But now, with a savings goal for a wedding ahead of you, you started spending a small fortune on stuff you aren’t really getting much out of. You say “I’d transfer bits and bobs back when I wanted something and said I’d save the extra next month, and it just hasn’t all balanced out” so you must have known, deep down, each month when you were doing this that it couldn’t “balance out” because you were never doing the balancing, you were only ever taking cribs and drabs. But you kept doing it. It’s a bit of a teenage - sticking your head in the sand - approach. And the question that springs to mind for me is - what are you actually trying to avoid? You don’t need what you’re buying, you don’t even use a lot of it. So what were you getting out of buying it. And what were you getting out of jeopardizing your wedding rather than actively trying to make it happen?

Is the wedding something you don’t really want? You said it was your fiancé’s baby, but were you coerced into it? Or have you suppressed your own needs around it yourself? Was the savings plan unrealistic? Did you have as much say as your fiancé about how much and over what time frame?

The point about canceling the wedding over this isn’t that you don’t have the money to pay for it - it’s that it’s an indication that the two of you shouldn’t be increasing your legal and financial entanglement until you’ve sorted out your issues. For his sake, because if you don’t get a grip he could pay a heavy price down the line, both financially and in terms of years of worry and anxiety. And for your sake, because your behaviour screams not really being comfortable with where you’re heading in life.

Floweryflora · 20/09/2022 19:52

Oh. Cmon; unless you are about to drip feed you have additional needs. You knew you were doing it and you knew he’d make it up so you selfishly spent what you fancied and used him.

Dragonskin · 20/09/2022 19:51

i do, but then I’d transfer bits and bobs back when I wanted something and said I’d save the extra next month, and it just hasn’t all balanced out.

Well yes, obviously it will only balance out if you also have months where you save more than the norm. It sounds like you set an unrealistic goal for someone with your level of spending discipline

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/09/2022 19:50

For the time being, curb all none essential spending for three months. Use that time to give yourself a spending detox, and send 1500 his way across the months.

Once the three months is up, sit and work out what your share of the bills are, how much you want to save, and set up a direct payment out to separate places for those. Then with whats left, think about how you want to start managing it moving forward.

If you enjoy make up shopping, then start a notebook page in your phone of all the items you see you are interested in, and their price. Then once a quarter, sit and sort through your make up, see what you have, what gaps, replacements needed etc and order the things from the list you need/still want.

In other words, sleep on any purchase. For a good 90 days.

Chevyimpala67 · 20/09/2022 19:49

I find going through my statement and actually adding up all the books, coffees, treats makes me rather more reticent with my spending!

tigerbear · 20/09/2022 19:48

You can def sell unopened makeup on selling sites like Vinted (there are no selling fees, so I’d recommend it over EBay). I sell a lot of clothes on there too. You won’t make loads, but it’s better than nothing.

starpatch · 20/09/2022 19:46

I have to save up for taxes and to put money into pension at the end of the financial year (I don't do it as I go along in case I lose my job) you just need to set up a seperate account for whatever you need to contribute towards this partnership, ie a savings account, set up a standing order and that money gets paid each month straight after pay day.

Always4Brenner · 20/09/2022 19:45

I Amy have very little but not paying for smoking week etc means one day when my dark times are finished I’ll be quids on. Already saving for new home bits bed fridge etc.

JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 19:45

We worry about our children ending up like the OP. DH and I are from poor backgrounds, so always knew that we’d Ned to take proper responsibility for our finances, and that we’d need good careers to become wealthy. I’ve some cousins who were given whatever they wanted, including money long after they had left home, and it’s no surprise that they are now struggling and have never got a proper career going.

SpotlessMind88 · 20/09/2022 19:44

Hearthnhome · 20/09/2022 18:58

If I am honest, having been with someone like you, I’d he posted I would say don’t get married until you show you can change.

You earn more but he is having to make up your shortfall? Just because you thought it would work itself out.

You make it up to him by changing. When you make a commitment you stick to it. Not just ignore it until it’s too late and rely on him to fill your gaps.

Absolutely this!!
finances don't just work themselves out. You're the one that is in charge of your finances, burying your head in the sand won't change them, as you have seen. Make it up to him by changing. He shouldn't have to subsidise your lifestyle when you earn more

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:44

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 20/09/2022 19:41

Don’t want to just pile on you OP but you’re not really taking responsibility. You thought it would just make itself up somehow…but that somehow never happened and now there’s repercussions to that.

You sound like you come from quite a privileged place - both financially and your mindset. You’ve clearly never gone without, which kind of accounts for the breezy “oh I just thought it would come from somewhere” mentality.

Truly taking responsibility would be preventing having to dip into your other shared savings and find the money elsewhere.

Agree with everything you’ve said, not a pile on.

OP posts:
Daisychainsx · 20/09/2022 19:44

Stop online shopping. Take out £100 cash each pay day and that can be your treat fund, and only buy if you're in a shop and using cash. You'll think 100x more before you make these purchases than clicking buttons online.

I stopped online shopping about 4 years ago and saved a fortune. I saved so much that I've been able to stop working to allow me to have a family. I quit in February and have barely eaten into my savings. I don't buy myself make up or outfits unless I need to. I'm currently pregnant and where before I'd have gone and bought a whole new wardrobe, I've bought a couple of essentials and accepted a bag of 2nd hand maternity clothes from my sister in law, which has done the job pretty well! I don't miss any of it at all, I feel so much freer.

Nobody knows if the make up on your face cost £200 or £20. Once you cut down you'll be sickened by the amount of stuff you have and spending you did, and you'll have so much you won't need to buy another thing for years 🤣

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:43

@Crazykatie I don’t have a credit card! I know, ridiculous.

OP posts:
SeemsSoUnfair · 20/09/2022 19:43

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:31

@spiderontheceiling I’ve never been in debt. I never will be. That’s not my issue.

You are in debt. To the suppliers of your wedding, which should be the most important thing on your mind. What if you had to pay a wedding supplier that you committed to paying and your fiancé couldn't pay your part either? What would happen in the real adult world?

Terrible basis for a marriage.

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 20/09/2022 19:41

Don’t want to just pile on you OP but you’re not really taking responsibility. You thought it would just make itself up somehow…but that somehow never happened and now there’s repercussions to that.

You sound like you come from quite a privileged place - both financially and your mindset. You’ve clearly never gone without, which kind of accounts for the breezy “oh I just thought it would come from somewhere” mentality.

Truly taking responsibility would be preventing having to dip into your other shared savings and find the money elsewhere.

Crazykatie · 20/09/2022 19:41

Change you credit card for a debit card then you can only spend after you have been paid, also move any spare cash each month into a separate account so you’re not tempted.

ExtraOnions · 20/09/2022 19:39

You aren’t in debt, and can still afford the wedding …. Not really the end of the world.

I am shocking with money .. really shocking, and i’m the primary wage earner. We have seperate bank accounts, and a joint account - as soon as I get paid £1500 gets transferred into the joint account (that I don’t have access to), and all bills are covered. I also pay the “running costs” (food, furnishings etc) for the house. I spend up every month, I can’t save .. hopeless.

My husbands money all goes into savings - for both of us, he’s a saver and a planner .. he’s good at it.

It all works itself out.

SeemsSoUnfair · 20/09/2022 19:39

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:30

@SeemsSoUnfair I desperately want to get married. Not a drip feed but I originally wanted to elope for very little money, the wedding is his baby. He’s planned it. It would be even worse for him to delay at this stage, he’d never want to do that, I already suggested it.

Part of being in a equal relationship is being able to compromise so you are both satisfied. You agreed to whatever your wedding plans are.

If you are going ahead with wedding plans you are not fully committed to, or feel you have been coerced into it, or feel you have no choice....or can't be bothered saving for, then you shouldn't be getting married.

Womencanlift · 20/09/2022 19:39

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:31

@spiderontheceiling I’ve never been in debt. I never will be. That’s not my issue.

You obviously have a very comfortable safety net whether that be your own income or your family’s wealth.

However for me if I was your DP it would be more about the difference in values when it comes to money and trusting each other

What about the next big purchase? Are you still going to be loose with your spending?

I will be honest I ended a pretty serious relationship with someone who had the same outlook on money to you. Even though they were pretty secure financially so didn’t think spending was an issue, it was for me because it showed we had different priorities on what was important in our relationship

Iamclearlyamug · 20/09/2022 19:39

Can you not set up a standing order so that whatever you're meant to be saving instantly disappears on payday? If it's not there you can't spend it surely?

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 20/09/2022 19:38

How can I make it up to him?

You know exactly how to make it up to him. Curb your spending, be responsible and respectful, save hard. Pay that extra £1500 into the fund and more on top to show you can be relied on.

Bubblebubblebah · 20/09/2022 19:37

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:31

@spiderontheceiling I’ve never been in debt. I never will be. That’s not my issue.

I will be blunt, you said you will save x and didn't. Saying you eill never be in debt has no value.

It's really understandable why your DP is upset.
I think like with everything people need wakeup call. Problem is that I don't think this eill be it because DP saved the day....

Start saving in something like Moneybox on the accounts ehere you need to gove notice or have only 1 withdrawal