Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have massively messed up our finances

216 replies

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 18:55

My fiancé and I have been saving for our wedding for a year. I earn more than him but I’ve always been a spender. Never in debt or beyond my means but I’m not a big saver. We’ve been saving our money separately and have now come to pool it all together and I’m £1500 short. I don’t know how it’s happened. I just overspent every month and hoped it would all work itself out and now it’s come to it and I just haven’t saved enough. I honestly don’t even know what I’ve spent it on, just frittered on expensive skincare and make-up and stuff.

We have enough money to make up the shortfall but it means eating into our normal savings and my fiancé will cover it, like he always does, because he’s dependable and reliable and I’m useless.

He’s upset and disappointed but being quite nice about it. He grew up with a lot of debt in his family so gets worried about people keeping secrets with money because he doesn’t want me to end up hiding things and getting depressed and desperate etc. I’m just so embarrassed. How can I make it up to him? I never used to be so reckless, just lifestyle creep once my salary started going up.

OP posts:
70billionthnamechange · 20/09/2022 20:15

@Ihaveaquestionn I know, it's all getting a bit dramatic on this one 😂😂

PantyMcPantFace · 20/09/2022 20:13

If your weakness is online treats - after having been insta-marketed at - then control that. Simpll accept online frivoulous purchases can only happen on a Thursday*. That is it.

So you want something. Fine. Pop it in the basket and wait until Thursday. Go back to the basket on Thursday....do you really want/need it? You may find a lot of them are less appealing a day or two later.

And YY to the Monzo. Work out your weekly or monthly "treat/luxury" budget and put it in a pot. Once it has gone, it had gone. Also, the sheer act of having to "withdraw" the money from the pot into your account makes you think....do I really need this?

*Other days of the week are available

carefullycourageous · 20/09/2022 20:13

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:15

@deedledeedledum sorry, I meant an account he could see and check on me on. Not an account he would put his money into.

This is not a good basis for a relationship at all. He needs to be able to trust you, not to check up on you. You need to be able to trust yourself.

IMO you need to understand why you are doing this.

I have been terrible with money - debt, over spending, frittering, 'forgetting'. I am now reformed (many years). But I had to understand why and I had to take responsibility myself.

I agree with some of the others - you sound a bad bet for marriage just now. I am not saying this to be a goady bastard - do you really want to marry (anyone or this person)? Because you are sabotaging your wedding to buy make up - that is not a great sign of commitment.

caringcarer · 20/09/2022 20:11

OP, you fiance must feel so sad that you have prioritised new make up over your wedding with him. Stop and think about how he must feel. Then make sure you don't do it again. You are getting married and will be a partnership. That means one person not doing all the spending and relying on the partner to make up shortfall.

Paulac77 · 20/09/2022 20:06

I was the same with money .. I’d get my wage, pay the bills then couldn’t really tell you where the rest went.
I now, have a note on my iPhone of my monthly outgoings and dates - I mean everything! My rent, fuel, food, gas, 1.99 on HPInk, 79p cloud data .. you name it. This also includes money to savings, then whatever is left I transfer to a monzo account - that’s my spends. When it’s gone, it’s gone 🤷‍♀️
Marking off when everything has come out keeps me aware of what’s going on in my account, and having the separate spend account keeps me within my limits.

TeacupDrama · 20/09/2022 20:06

look up HANNAH LOUISE POSTON on you tube she used to spend too much on make up etc to the extent it messed with her finances you might find her helpful it is a USA site

Ihaveaquestionn · 20/09/2022 20:05

JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 19:21

You could cancel the service, and just have a registry office service. You’d save money that way.

Or, of course, just plough on, spending more of your partner’s money and starting off married life having shown him clearly where he comes in your priorities.

Either way works I suppose.

Jesus that’s a bit harsh!

Her partner has the money and I’m assuming she will pay him back… she sounds very concerned about it and like she’s learned her lesson.

she doesn’t need to cancel the bloody service

Namenic · 20/09/2022 20:04

OP - I think people are being a bit extreme. I think you should use this to make LONG-TERM changes to your attitude to money. Would you be able to sit down with your fiancé and show him your account and go through it with him? Perhaps make it a regular thing - like every 2 weeks review your statement for what you have spent on and adjust.

Some wins might be: 1) don’t buy clothes/shoes. The clothes you have in your cupboard will probably last you quite a long time (I still have clothes from 10years ago). 2) minimal make up (I don’t wear any, but if you must, go with budget options). 3) don’t go on nights out 4) don’t buy takeaway lunches/coffees - do 1 food shop and make sandwiches and coffee in a thermos.

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 20:04

All the advice I’m reading and taking on board, I need the good and the bad. Thank you. I need this to be my wake up call.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 20/09/2022 20:03

You make it up by stop indulging yourself and save every penny to pay back your shortfall into the shared savings. Start keeping a diary of every penny you spend.

If you don't get a grip on this, your relationship is at stake. He's been poor, seen the result of big debt, and he won't want to go back there.

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 20:03

sortmylifeouseptember2023 · 20/09/2022 19:56

OP your DF loves you and you are getting married. This is a happy joyous time. It is good you have recognised that your spending needs some adjustment but please don't let it overshadow this truly happy event. In my marriage, we never separated finances but many of my friends do. Set up a standing order to pay DF back and let that be the end of it. Enjoy your big day and congratulations.

This made me cry, thank you so much ❤

OP posts:
moneymortified · 20/09/2022 20:02

TeacupDrama · 20/09/2022 19:56

you need 4 bank accounts

  1. a joint one for bills mortgage insurance utilities etc, food budget, this is just direct debits you can't use it to pay bills no cards
  2. a second account with same bank with debit cards for food car fuel transport household expenses etc
  3. savings account with a different bank you transfer into this the same day as you are paid you don't have online banking so you can't just transfer money back maybe telephoone banking or a rule that you have to wait 48 hours to transfer that wait might be long enough for the urge to splurge to pass
  4. a personal spends account again a third bank so you can't move money from accounts 1 and 2 into it, you transfer a set amount in at beginning of month you can spend it on make up or whatever but when it is gone it's gone until next payday the sum you agree with DH and he has a similar account; couples should have equal free spends even if earnings have a disparity this is the account you must buy presents for DH and your friends from
you might want to add a fifth joint savings account for holidays christmas a new car etc with the rule that neither of you can use the money without the other's agreement

at some point you will need long term savings for extra pension etc

unsubscribe from all beauty fashion influencers emails youtube tiktok etc if you need to be informed of it's existence you don't need it; you know already what you need

try a no buy 3 months to reset your habits where you buy nothing bar essentials if you run out of shampoo or foundation or tights etc you can buy a new one but not if you have an unopened one in the cupboard
if you don't sell your unused makeup make yourself use it up by not buying another one until it is finished
good luck... life style creep can make you poor

This is fantastic practical advice, thank you.

OP posts:
Choppies · 20/09/2022 20:02

If you set up a joint monzo for him to watch your spends for accountability then unlink any other cards from Apple Pay or whatever and only carry the monzo card with you - remove other card details from stored data on phone, etc. basically make it impossible to dip into savings on impulse. Put extra money in premium bonds or similar so you have to wait 3 days to access after pulling it out. You have to be really strict until you’ve broken the habits.

good luck OP!

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 20:01

@MapleSpice thank you so much for sharing and for this advice, I really appreciate it!

OP posts:
YouSirNeighMmmm · 20/09/2022 19:59

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:02

@YouSirNeighMmmm I love that phrase - good value investment in our happiness. Very little I buy is for that whereas most of what he spends his money on is. We need to work on that together.

Please interpret my words any which way that helps you, but I kind of meant you individually should be investing in your happiness, not "frittering" money away.

Ensuring you have decent skincare products on hand is a good investment. Buying a nice new pair of shoes is a good investment if your old "nice pairs" are getting worn or uncomfortable. Buying lots of skincare products that are very expensive and you don't need - not a good investment!

I think that both of you deserve to buy things for yourselves (as individuals), as well as having a responsibility to each other.

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 19:58

PhilInt · 20/09/2022 19:53

I think you need to understand why you buy these things. It sounds more emotional to me. I say this because despite this being a one off saving up occasion and you setting up systems to save you still broke those systems because you couldn't resist. What makes it a compulsion for you to buy things?

My spending changed drastically during lockdown. It coincided with a decent pay rise and then I was very anxious at the start of lockdown. Got obsessed with makeup and skincare and my hair - just became very obsessed. I also spent a lot more time on social media getting sold to by influencers.

OP posts:
Aintnosupermum · 20/09/2022 19:58

If I were you I would do Dave Ramsey with your fiancé. It’s really important you are open and honest with each other regarding how you best manage your money. Once you are married you are a team and it’s amazing what you can accomplish when you have clearly defined roles.

Its ok to spend £200 or £1500 on make up if you can afford it. Reality is you can’t afford it when you have obligations regarding your wedding and a mortgage.

Just wait until you have children. My money runs out of my account faster than Linford Christie.

ScruffGin · 20/09/2022 19:58

You need a budget! Literally... There's an app called that (YNAB for short). You keep your money in there "virtually" (it doesn't leave your back account), and you put it in digital envelopes each time you get paid for everything you need.
If there's no money in the "makeup" section, and you want to buy something you need to move it from somewhere else. Makes you think about what's really important.
I've saved so much money since starting it, it's really amazing! You can get a months free to see how you get on.

Personally I wouldn't marry you until you'd proven you could change.

LovelyChicken · 20/09/2022 19:57

How do you feel about saving money for the type of wedding you wouldn't have chosen yourself?

sortmylifeouseptember2023 · 20/09/2022 19:56

OP your DF loves you and you are getting married. This is a happy joyous time. It is good you have recognised that your spending needs some adjustment but please don't let it overshadow this truly happy event. In my marriage, we never separated finances but many of my friends do. Set up a standing order to pay DF back and let that be the end of it. Enjoy your big day and congratulations.

TeacupDrama · 20/09/2022 19:56

you need 4 bank accounts

  1. a joint one for bills mortgage insurance utilities etc, food budget, this is just direct debits you can't use it to pay bills no cards
  2. a second account with same bank with debit cards for food car fuel transport household expenses etc
  3. savings account with a different bank you transfer into this the same day as you are paid you don't have online banking so you can't just transfer money back maybe telephoone banking or a rule that you have to wait 48 hours to transfer that wait might be long enough for the urge to splurge to pass
  4. a personal spends account again a third bank so you can't move money from accounts 1 and 2 into it, you transfer a set amount in at beginning of month you can spend it on make up or whatever but when it is gone it's gone until next payday the sum you agree with DH and he has a similar account; couples should have equal free spends even if earnings have a disparity this is the account you must buy presents for DH and your friends from
you might want to add a fifth joint savings account for holidays christmas a new car etc with the rule that neither of you can use the money without the other's agreement

at some point you will need long term savings for extra pension etc

unsubscribe from all beauty fashion influencers emails youtube tiktok etc if you need to be informed of it's existence you don't need it; you know already what you need

try a no buy 3 months to reset your habits where you buy nothing bar essentials if you run out of shampoo or foundation or tights etc you can buy a new one but not if you have an unopened one in the cupboard
if you don't sell your unused makeup make yourself use it up by not buying another one until it is finished
good luck... life style creep can make you poor

MapleSpice · 20/09/2022 19:55

I just wanted to say that I've been you. I sort of still am, but I have a husband who I'm completely open with about being useless with money and he's brilliant with it.

I still don't 100% trust myself to ever be good with money, despite best intentions. I send him 95% of my salary to pay my share of the bills and then the rest goes into our savings, and then I have a reasonable amount for spending on little things and treats. It's good because he has complete visibility over both of our finances, I do too but I can't just transfer a little bit extra every time I see something and get that fleeting desire to buy it!

It's hard, but you ARE making those first steps. You can't stop here, I'll echo the other posters who've said you need to repay the £1500 to show you are committed to changing, even if it is just repaying it to the savings. You need to do this to prove you don't think he'll bail you out every time and to show you're growing from this.

On a side note - the Sali Hughes Facebook group is AMAZING for selling make up and fragrance, they're lovely and supportive in there and will be happy to offer more advice as well as relieve you of some of your beauty goodies! Wink

FruitPastilleNut · 20/09/2022 19:55

You can make it up to him by making it up to him.

Stop spending ANY non essential money and save, hard, until you can pay it back in the shortest time possible. Want a coffee? Tough. Need a haircut? Do without. Fancy a new anything? Don't buy it. Save every penny until you can give him that £1500.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 20/09/2022 19:55

Following up previous comment with a more constructive reply.
On pay day, set aside rent/mortgage, bills, debts, genuine expenses, and savings. These are the things you need to prioritise so you look at them first.
What is leftover is what you have to spend on yourself - and this is the part you are not prioritising, it's for frivolous, fun, social, non-critical. From this you can work out what you have to spend per day or per week, whatever works best for you.
Then either withdraw the cash and spend it so you can literally see the amount decreasing or keep a notebook with you where you can keep a tally of what you are spending.
Final suggestion - stick a post-it note to your debit card with writing in big red letter saying "do I really need this?!" Every time you go to pay for something you will see it.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 20/09/2022 19:55

Very little I buy is for (good value investment in our happiness) whereas most of what he spends his money on is. We need to work on that together

Ouch Sad
Considering you know he comes from a background where this would worry him, that's a pretty hurtful position to have taken

Working on things together is usually good, but in his shoes I'd be wondering how great your commitment to a shared future is ... and in yours I'd do everything I could to replace that £1500 and assure him that he doesn't have to wonder any more because you've taken full ownership of this

Swipe left for the next trending thread