Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have massively messed up our finances

216 replies

moneymortified · 20/09/2022 18:55

My fiancé and I have been saving for our wedding for a year. I earn more than him but I’ve always been a spender. Never in debt or beyond my means but I’m not a big saver. We’ve been saving our money separately and have now come to pool it all together and I’m £1500 short. I don’t know how it’s happened. I just overspent every month and hoped it would all work itself out and now it’s come to it and I just haven’t saved enough. I honestly don’t even know what I’ve spent it on, just frittered on expensive skincare and make-up and stuff.

We have enough money to make up the shortfall but it means eating into our normal savings and my fiancé will cover it, like he always does, because he’s dependable and reliable and I’m useless.

He’s upset and disappointed but being quite nice about it. He grew up with a lot of debt in his family so gets worried about people keeping secrets with money because he doesn’t want me to end up hiding things and getting depressed and desperate etc. I’m just so embarrassed. How can I make it up to him? I never used to be so reckless, just lifestyle creep once my salary started going up.

OP posts:
RJnomore1 · 20/09/2022 20:51

Woah up a bit

youre not in debt

youre paying your half of the bills

you are saving.

what might put this into context is how much you were supposed to have towards the wedding; £1500 of £3k is very different to £1500 of £15k. But regardless there’s a fair bit of hysteria on this thread.

PicturesOfDogs · 20/09/2022 20:51

My fave is Taylor Budgets, she’s a young American single mum, her older videos were better, (only because she’s making more money now due to YouTube etc), living with parents and saving for her own place.
Life situation completely different to mine, but principles are universal and found it really inspiring

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 20/09/2022 20:49

For the future, could you set up one of the savings accounts with a 30 day withdrawal notice period? Pay your savings amount first on payday and then it’ll be so hard to withdraw the money to buy something frivolous that you probably won’t bother.

BadNomad · 20/09/2022 20:48

He doesn't need to cover it. Just take it out of the normal savings, then you can top that back up over time.

PicturesOfDogs · 20/09/2022 20:48

I’m a bit like this, When I feel like I need to rein it in, I watch those ‘cash stuffing’ videos, I find them really soothing and therapeutic, and they really inspire me to watch what I’m spending

JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 20:45

Ihaveaquestionn · 20/09/2022 20:05

Jesus that’s a bit harsh!

Her partner has the money and I’m assuming she will pay him back… she sounds very concerned about it and like she’s learned her lesson.

she doesn’t need to cancel the bloody service

No, she doesn’t as her poor partner will just plug the gap.

Annoyingkidsmusic · 20/09/2022 20:45

Joint account. Very quickly my oh stopped frittering away so much money buying coffees, lunches, etc when I started getting the notifications on my Apple Watch 😂 and going both ways, I stopped buying as much homewares etc unless I felt we really needed them.

Honestly, a joint account for transparency and accountability will massively nip it in the bud.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 20/09/2022 20:44

I don't at all think you're the bad person you think you are, based on what you've said - but why the Hell are you, an adult woman who has a decent job and is on the verge of getting married, allowing yourself to be swayed by "influencers"? This would put me off marrying anyone, even more than them having blown money on tat.

Surely you are a unique, wonderful, attractive individual? If you don't believe you are, and that spending money on some face cream that some twat of an "influencer" recommends, then working on that might in turn help you work on the money side of things.

MissConductUS · 20/09/2022 20:38

There's an old saying that "you get what you measure". Find an app that you use to record every expenditure and categorize it, including what you spend in cash. Think of it like calorie counting when dieting. If you have to take ownership of the spending by recording it, you'll think twice about how necessary it is.

I use Quicken on my laptop, but I"m sure there are plenty of smartphone apps that do the same thing.

Notsoglamanymore · 20/09/2022 20:38

I used to be very much like you are now, very blasé about finances and would just spend my money as quickly as I got it, fully in my (admittedly very small) overdraft every month and never really saved much at all, very little impulse control and no sense of delayed gratification. Then I realised that I wanted money put aside for the “what ifs” of life and that if I didn’t sort myself out I would end up being an old saddo with nothing😂 and I wanted to be able to be self sufficient and rely on myself to sort myself out so I started saving a small amount each month and over the past 10 or so years I’ve managed to save up what I think is quite a significant amount, I now save way more than I spend every month and saving has become the buzz for me, I love to see it building up. One big thing that helped me is to log onto my online banking app every single night without fail, that way you stay face to face with the reality of how much you have and how much you are spending, I then round off the amount in my current account every time I spend on my card and transfer the difference to my savings every single time I use it, even if it’s just pennies, it adds up. But as far as things go with buying stuff, I wait a few days when I want something, if I still want it after a few days or a week or I NEED it, I’ll buy it, most stuff I’ve forgotten about by the time a day or two passes so figure I couldn’t have wanted or needed it that much in the first place.

ScurryfungeMaster · 20/09/2022 20:37

The best way to make amends is to change your behaviour. Could you set a budget for yourself? So bills and then X amount for savings go out of your account first, that way you can reach your saving goals and then whatever is left over you can spend on whatever you want.

I used to be a massive spender, constantly ordering stuff online that I didn't need like clothes that never got worn. I'm the complete opposite now and always try to save as much as possible.

GetThatHelmetOn · 20/09/2022 20:35

How you make it up? Pay him back the £1500, that would make you look dependable and hopefully teach you a lesson. Just set a standing order for £200-300 a month until you pay the debt off.

Boxowine · 20/09/2022 20:34

OP, what do you plan on cutting out of your wedding to make up for the shortfall? Your dress? Can you do secondhand shoes or give up hair and makeup? Maybe the photographer?

No547 · 20/09/2022 20:32

How you can make it up to him.....pay back the £1,500. Treat it like an outside debt, agree an amount per month and set up a DD for this.
How to move forward - full financial transparency. Perhaps a joint account for all money except a small stipend per month for personal spending. That way you're not tempted to overspend and he can track money in/out of the account.
Either way, I would place marriage on hold until this is sorted.

Ihaveaquestionn · 20/09/2022 20:32

70billionthnamechange · 20/09/2022 20:15

@Ihaveaquestionn I know, it's all getting a bit dramatic on this one 😂😂

I know! The hysterical mumsnet brigade

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 20/09/2022 20:32

This book may help
Your money or your life

This book looks at the mindset of consumerism (amongst other things). You buy stuff to reward yourself for working hard and you work hard so you can buy stuff to reward yourself etc...

I am a great believer in intentional spending. Work out what really matters to you and spend your money on that.

To give you some practical examples:

  • I don't spend a lot on clothes because they don't make a great difference to my happiness, but I have spent stupid amounts taking my family to sporting events.
  • I have a second-hand phone on a pay as you go sim because it does what I need it to do but I chose to spend a lot of money sending my DC to private school.

I don't regret any of that spending because it was intentional and matched my goals.

Another example, one of my goals is to have the choice whether or not I work to retirement age and so I have prioritised savings and investments over a bigger house or car. I appreciate this is a luxury choice to be able to make and not everyone can save for retirement.

Ask yourself the following:

  1. Can you remember what you spent the money on?
  2. Has it made your life better in the longer term?
  3. Did the spending match your aims, goals and desires?
  4. Was there any "because I deserve it" spending?

Maybe you didn't need some of what you bought, and you would be better focussing on the things that make your life better (and that can include a fun evening with your friends drinking stupidly priced cocktails occasionally)

BettyB0Op · 20/09/2022 20:30

Get on vinted. Sell off anything you don’t want or need, show him you’re willing to make sacrifices!

Puffalicious · 20/09/2022 20:26

OP, I'm so glad you're taking on board all this excellent advice. Martin Lewis weekly email is great- sign up for it.

If you go on to have children you'll be permanently skint for the first while, so it's good to get into good habits now (I'd be a millionaire if I didn't need to buy food for DH and 3 hungry, huge, rugby-playing boys!).

Jaade · 20/09/2022 20:21

Seems like a nothing issue.

you’re not in debt and keep up with all your bill payments and you’ve just had to pull money out of a joint savings account as you haven’t saved as much as you had targeted?

some of these comments making out youre a bad person or suggesting they would not go ahead with the wedding if they were your partner are ridiculous 😅

Changingtides1234 · 20/09/2022 20:20

I wouldn’t usually comment and so many people have so mine will probably be lost.
I am exactly like you. The higher earner. I came from a poor family, so when I finally got money I spent it, fast. I was awful.

I did exactly what you did but worse 5000 I spent. On what?! Who knows.

anyways I upset my now husband (yes he still married me)
so I said this;
im rubbish and will continue to be rubbish at saving until it becomes my new normal. So when I got paid I put everything I could into his savings pot. Now some will completely disagree with this, that means they have a lot of power and could run off with your savings. But I’d been with hun 7 years and is too lazy to run anywhere so I trusted him. That’s how we saved for our wedding.

anyways it did become my new normal and eventually I stopped sending money. In fact I had a little one and managed to save for a house!

you will get there. If you trust your man, show him you’re aware of your mistake and perhaps send him the money on paydays until you’re married.

Noteverybodylives · 20/09/2022 20:19

I’d seriously be reconsidering the marriage after this.

Not only are you silly with money but I’d also be thinking that you must not want to get married to do this.

Obviously apologise but words are cheap and actions are way more important- you need to remove things from the wedding, go without any luxuries to save up quicker and return anything you have brought recently and don’t need.

You need to show him that he means much more to you than material possessions.

carefullycourageous · 20/09/2022 20:18

Lavender2021 · 20/09/2022 20:17

A guy I know at work who isn't great with money so it all gets paid to his wife then he gets his spending money! But it is a little bit like being treated like a child but works for them and he has no money worries.
His wife is the main earner.

This is like controlling the symptoms, without curing the disease though, it will work but it isn't a real solution as no trust can build up.

Lavender2021 · 20/09/2022 20:17

A guy I know at work who isn't great with money so it all gets paid to his wife then he gets his spending money! But it is a little bit like being treated like a child but works for them and he has no money worries.
His wife is the main earner.

TimeAtTheBar · 20/09/2022 20:16

I feel like I’m reading a different thread.

He wants a big wedding. How much? If you’re short by £1500 is that 50%, 10% or 5%?

Was there any compromise? Big weddings are SUCH a waste of money and if I was having to massively curb my spending every month to afford it I wouldn’t be happy.

You haven’t gone into debt. You’ve just not achieved a savings goal. You’re obviously saving a lot as there is another pot to dip into.

This is such a non issue for me.

PinkArt · 20/09/2022 20:15

How do you make it up to him? You show him this is the last time this ever happens. And you keep showing him that.
You need to treat the spending like the addiction it sounds like. Before you think about spending any money on anything think, do I need this, will I use this but mainly is owning this more important that showing my fiancé that I have got a handle on this.
I'm a shopper, I get it. If I like something I'll buy it. But I'm a saver too, especially for something important to me, like the wedding presumably is to you both. Keep sight of the really important stuff so it doesn't feel like you're missing anything when you're actually gaining.