Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air fryers…what’s the hype?

215 replies

mummy203 · 20/09/2022 14:16

am I being unreasonable thinking air fryers are hype? Or am I just not getting it yet

I’ve been bought a 4L tower one, not used yet because I’m not sure I’m going to keep it. At first I thought fab I will use instead of my oven, but all the tutorials seem to show everything cooked separately chips for 20mins, chicken for 20mins and so on. There’s not enough room to put everything in for a family meal to cook at the same time. I can’t see how this would work cooking a meal for even 2 people. If you have to put half the dinner in the oven anyway then why use the air fryer at all just put everything in the oven at the same time 🤷🏼‍♀️ What am I not getting?

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 21/09/2022 15:23

@BlackForestCake Yes you can, and you can prove the dough in it as well.

Nolongera · 21/09/2022 15:22

Lunar270 · 21/09/2022 12:33

Prior to the energy crisis, relatively few people were worried about energy consumption of appliances so naturally it wasn't a selling point. Times change and the same goes for electric blankets vs central heating.

What you're describing with your oven and loaves is exactly what makes air fryers more efficient. Faster heat up time and a smaller volume means less energy use overall.

Unfortunately you can't legislate against stupidity and if people think they can eat chips every day, it's got nothing to do with the fryer but the people using them. That doesn't detract from the basic premise that they're a good thing overall.

There will be some people who will make a reasonable return ( people who heat single things up frequently), but I would suggest the majority of people will never use one enough over the course of its life to recoup the outlay.

Modern electric ovens are far from inefficient, as my bread experiment showed.

There is no magic wand to cut electricity usage, just as there was no magic wand for eating chips everyday, they just implied it.

I think there is a lot of justification going on on this thread, people have laid out considerable sums and now they need to prove it wasn't a waste.

Can anyone show me the maths?

Always4Brenner · 21/09/2022 13:14

Haven’t read the whole thread so advice would be buy a bigger one with two drawers use lining paper (from Amazon). Hopefully moving into new home and can’t decide this route or a mini cooker with oven.

BlackForestCake · 21/09/2022 13:11

Can you bake bread in it?

BlooberryBiskits · 21/09/2022 13:05

Sisisisi · 20/09/2022 14:35

4L is very small Op.😬
Ours is 6 L for just DH and I.
Families need the dual versions unless you just want to do a single serving.
If you havent used it could you refund/ swap?

I agree, you could probably just do chips in that so I’d return it for something more suitable

Mine is 5.7l, it’s a great size for 1-2 adults or 2 adults and a child I would say, for a larger family maybe you need a 2 drawer one?

I have the vortex and I LOVE it - quicker & cheaper than an oven, love that it switches itself off so good can’t burn if you get caught up in other things

I cook everything in it - from sausages, chips, meatballs, to home baking (pies, cakes, making a small number of scones, cookies etc). Great for reheating things etc

Probably more useful for you if you sometimes prepare separate meals/eat at different times

Lunar270 · 21/09/2022 12:33

Nolongera · 21/09/2022 12:19

When the air fryer came out it was pushed as a way to have fried food with fewer calories, little mention of energy saving.

We had an expensive one at work, loads of people convinced they could eat chips every day with no consequences. That was bollocks too.

Electric cookers, especially those with hobs as well as ovens need a different input (30amp iirc?) as if everything is on at the same time it will draw much more current than a 13 amp plug can provide. Once an oven is up to temperature it hardly draws significant power.

I recently used my smart meter to measure my ovens use, baked 4 loaves of bread in 40 minutes, less than 1kwh of electricity, less than 10p a loaf for energy .

Prior to the energy crisis, relatively few people were worried about energy consumption of appliances so naturally it wasn't a selling point. Times change and the same goes for electric blankets vs central heating.

What you're describing with your oven and loaves is exactly what makes air fryers more efficient. Faster heat up time and a smaller volume means less energy use overall.

Unfortunately you can't legislate against stupidity and if people think they can eat chips every day, it's got nothing to do with the fryer but the people using them. That doesn't detract from the basic premise that they're a good thing overall.

Getoff · 21/09/2022 12:31

I think my tiny air fryer actually has a higher peak draw, at 1300 watts, than my fan oven, which I think is only about 1000 watts for the element near the fan. The reason the fan oven needs to be wired into a special circuit is in case I decide to use the the top and bottom elements and the grill and the other oven (it's a double-oven) all at the same time as the fan element.

Nevertheless I expect the air fryer to use a lot less electricity. The smaller volume means it takes two minutes rather than ten to pre-heat, and once it's reached its target temperature it will have the heating element switched off for a bigger proportion of the time. (Ovens stay at a target temperature by switching the heating element off and on, in the same way that your central heating maintains a target temperature by switching your boiler between full-blast and off.)

Sparklingbrook · 21/09/2022 12:22

I don't think the name 'air fryer' helps, it's much more than that. Makes it sound like 'whatever you'd do in the frying pan do in this'. Which has turned out no to be the case because we never fried anything anyway.

Nolongera · 21/09/2022 12:19

When the air fryer came out it was pushed as a way to have fried food with fewer calories, little mention of energy saving.

We had an expensive one at work, loads of people convinced they could eat chips every day with no consequences. That was bollocks too.

Electric cookers, especially those with hobs as well as ovens need a different input (30amp iirc?) as if everything is on at the same time it will draw much more current than a 13 amp plug can provide. Once an oven is up to temperature it hardly draws significant power.

I recently used my smart meter to measure my ovens use, baked 4 loaves of bread in 40 minutes, less than 1kwh of electricity, less than 10p a loaf for energy .

Thelnebriati · 21/09/2022 10:48

FarmGirl78 Its cheaper because its heating up a smaller area than an oven. So it reaches cooking temperature faster.
2.5kw seems high, mine is about 1400W - thats running at the highest temperature, which we've never used.

GasPanic · 21/09/2022 09:52

@FarmGirl78

It's hard to compare them on the power ratings alone. The reason being as the power rating tends to be the maximum power draw of the device at any time, rather than how much power is actually consumed per minute, which can depend on a lot of different factors (outside air temperature, what temperature you set the fryer/oven to etc).

The only real way to compare them is using a smart meter. I have an energy monitoring pass through plug that can be used to measure how much energy the air fryer uses. But the cooker is hard wired into the mains supply. This is because the cooker draws so much power it can't be used with normal 13A plug in mains sockets, and it has to be wired directly into a higher power socket (usually 30A) instead (this alone is an indication that my cooker uses a lot more power than the air fryer).

Sparklingbrook · 21/09/2022 09:45

It's one of those things that gets stuck at the back of the cupboard for decades,

Is it? All the people on here that use one daily would disagree. I have a Breville sandwich toaster that is regularly used too.

I did throw the ice cream maker in the back of the cupboard though.

Nolongera · 21/09/2022 09:28

FarmGirl78 · 21/09/2022 08:51

I don't understand how it's cheaper. My oven is 0.8kw, checked my Mum's and it's 0.9kw. My brother's ninja thing is 2.5kw. The blurb says it can reduce energy bills by 65% (I assume by cooking time) which is still more than my oven. I can't fathom how everyone is saying it's cheaper to run. Or have I just got a shit oven?

They set up a specific means of cooking something that flatters the air fryer and use that as their example.

It's one of those things that gets stuck at the back of the cupboard for decades, like a George foreman grill, a breville sandwich toaster and those abs machines that were going to give us all fantastic abs.

Then thrown out when you move house.

Lunar270 · 21/09/2022 09:01

FarmGirl78 · 21/09/2022 08:51

I don't understand how it's cheaper. My oven is 0.8kw, checked my Mum's and it's 0.9kw. My brother's ninja thing is 2.5kw. The blurb says it can reduce energy bills by 65% (I assume by cooking time) which is still more than my oven. I can't fathom how everyone is saying it's cheaper to run. Or have I just got a shit oven?

There isn't a rule saying that all air fryers are more efficient than conventional ovens. But in the main, it's likely to be true.

Due to the smaller volume, heat up time is significantly reduced as is cooking time, especially in my case where I have a range with a single large oven. The difference is 10 minutes for me (warm up). Plus the power difference is 3kW+ vs 2kW.

Sounds like the difference with you might be less but still worth comparing.

FarmGirl78 · 21/09/2022 08:51

I don't understand how it's cheaper. My oven is 0.8kw, checked my Mum's and it's 0.9kw. My brother's ninja thing is 2.5kw. The blurb says it can reduce energy bills by 65% (I assume by cooking time) which is still more than my oven. I can't fathom how everyone is saying it's cheaper to run. Or have I just got a shit oven?

NotSorry · 21/09/2022 06:25

There’s a podcast here about them - some good info if you’re undecided

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0018hjr

FingersofFish · 21/09/2022 01:29

I sold ours, friends raved about them but I could never get a full meal out of them. Even fish fingers and chips plus there didn't seem to be much time saving. I'm told they make the best roasties but I usually just do them in the oven that's on for the meat which makes more sense to me.

Chouetted · 21/09/2022 01:26

I live alone, so have had a small toaster oven for years and years (stupid name IMHO, the one thing it can't do is toast). Heating up a gigantic oven for just me was daft.

Are air fryers really that much better?

Furries · 21/09/2022 00:54

I’ve had mine a few weeks now. I got the large Ninja Dual drawer (the AF400).

Am definitely pleased that I went for one with two drawers. Whole chicken in one drawer, potatoes in the other - set temperature and time for each drawer and then synch them so that they finish cooking at the same time. About 3 mins before the end of cooking, chuck a few frozen yourkshires in with the potatoes. Veg done quickly on the hob. Roast dinner in 50 minutes.

Jacket potato done in 40 minutes vs around 1 hour 20 in the oven. Sausages in 8 minutes - was dubious but they were lovely. I’ve used my oven once for a pizza.

I find the baskets easy to clean - I don’t have a dishwasher, so they’re done by hand no problem at all.

PeloFondo · 20/09/2022 22:38

userxx · 20/09/2022 21:19

@PeloFondo How long for a part baked roll ?

Couple of minutes or so. I usually put it in, microwave the soup and it's done at the same time but I do like my soup lava temperature Grin

Ski4130 · 20/09/2022 22:10

SpinningFloppa · 20/09/2022 22:03

It’s enough for 5 of you? Don’t you have to cook things separate?

It depends on what you’re cooking really, I tend to still use the hob with a griddle pan for chicken/fish if I’m doing potatoes in the airfryer, or cook couscous/rice separately if I do meat in the airfryer.

Creameggs223 · 20/09/2022 22:07

mycatisannoying · 20/09/2022 19:40

I don't get it. Ours has been gathering dust in the cellar.

What's not to get? Food cooks quicker and is cheaper than using an oven.

SpinningFloppa · 20/09/2022 22:03

Ski4130 · 20/09/2022 22:02

We’ve got a 4ltr one, and we’re a family of 5. I haven’t switched the oven on since we got it! It does the best chicken, homemade chips, roast potatoes, cakes, toasties etc etc and it’s really easy to clean, the kids can use it. I can’t think of one negative about ours.

It’s enough for 5 of you? Don’t you have to cook things separate?

Ski4130 · 20/09/2022 22:02

We’ve got a 4ltr one, and we’re a family of 5. I haven’t switched the oven on since we got it! It does the best chicken, homemade chips, roast potatoes, cakes, toasties etc etc and it’s really easy to clean, the kids can use it. I can’t think of one negative about ours.

userxx · 20/09/2022 21:55

@Lunar270 it's been a long day! I'm following now 😏