Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ExDH is furious I’m keeping his name… AIBU?

433 replies

NCsurname · 20/09/2022 12:58

Divorce recently finalised after being separated from exDH for some time. I received a message this morning from exDH who noticed that my married name is still present on my LinkedIn profile. I politely responded to let him know that I wont be changing my surname back to my maiden name and left it at that.

Received a barrage of abuse in response so I’m wondering, AIBU?

For context,

  1. we don’t have children, but I’m now known well professionally under my married name.
  2. the name isn’t particularly unique or uncommon, so I don’t feel it specifically links to him in any way. Also, I’ve moved away since the split so it’s not as if he’s having to see me around and be reminded of it.
  3. I found the process of changing my name after marriage to be a massive hassle and given the stress involved in the divorce itself, I’d rather not bother with the admin of name changing again.
  4. I’ve grown to like the name and it just feels like “me”. I never liked my maiden name and feel as though a nice surname is the only good thing I got from the marriage!

AIBU? I should point out that I’m now in a new relationship, my new partner is well aware of all of this and sees no issue.

OP posts:
LuckyLil · 20/09/2022 16:44

Well if it wasn't my surname originally then I probably wouldn't do it myself because I'd want a complete divorce including any association with his surname. The reasons given do make it look more like it's being done just because it's convenient for you, rather than because it's actually necessary. It's interesting how people who rant about feminism are so comfortable with the idea of hanging on to the patriarchy of having to take on a man's surname at marriage.

blisstwins · 20/09/2022 16:44

Keep the name. Absolutely ignore his email. I would be stone cold silent.

TooBigForMyBoots · 20/09/2022 16:42

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:26

No. Feminism is not about 'making any choice you want as a woman'. I asked above if you think the morality police in Iran (women) who grabbed Mahsa Amini and beat her to death for wearing her hijab wrong were making a feminist choice.

You said the reason for changing your name was to avoid a load of hassle and admin. Leaving aside the fact that this is not true - I have encountered none of those issues, and in fact on this thread the women who HAVE changed their name have said it was a hassle to do so - I asked you a very simple question.

Why, if you are not secondary to your husband, did you change your name, and not him? Or not both of you?

Is declaring women secondary to their husband a new feminist thing then?

Owlsinmybedroom · 20/09/2022 16:42

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:37

If 95% of women in the UK change their names on marriage, and about 1% of men do it, does that suggest to you that it has a basis in the inequality of the sexes, and that the system whereby women are second-class citizens owned by their fathers or husbands is still very much alive and kicking?

That's very much not my point though, as I have explained in my thread repeatedly.

My point that I objected to was the people saying its fine to choose one way of doing things if you have kids, but not if you don't, as if women with children are allowed more choices than women without children.

I haven't advocated for changing your name upon marriage, although I have explained my complex reasons for doing so. I have only advocated for childless women being afforded the same respect as women with children.

Seeing as childless men very rarely have to justify their childlessness or advocate for the same standards being applied to them as men with children (or similarly men with children don't get the same impact on their careers etc as woman with children) I'm not sure how advocating for the status of parenthood not being used to dictate different standards being applied mean I should be lectured on what is or isn't equality.

imtoooldforthiscrap · 20/09/2022 16:42

Tell him that if he doesn't want you to have the same name as him, then he's welcome to change his. Remind him you've already changed your name once because of him and you won't be doing it again because of the amount of paperwork involved!

mam0918 · 20/09/2022 16:40

I really find the vitrol from other women on topics as non-issued as this ridiculous.

How do fully grown women get angry at other women because of their name which doesnt effect them at all?

I litrally got threatened by another woman in the run up to my wedding because I said I hadn't decided if I was changing my name, not only was I told matter of factly how 'wrong' I was, told I was an awful mother and didnt deserve to be married but actually even physically threatened.

I choose to renounce my paternal name at 18, I chose to keep my maiden name, I choose to give my child their father names... but I also completely understand why other women choose to do differently.

At the end of the day NON of it makes anyone 'better' than anyone else regardless of what you choose, there is no 'right' choice its all just personal preference and to get angry that someone doesnt think exactly like you on something as minute as this is scary.

so people calling OP 'pathetic' really should stop because its certainly not the OP that is the one coming across that way.

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 16:40

@Rosehugger you've been in the Mumsnet world too long love.

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:37

Owlsinmybedroom · 20/09/2022 16:34

I've already explained on this thread that I changed my name to my husbands because my family were abusive and I didn't want to keep anything from them.

I understand taking my husbands name was old fashioned, and I understand why people would think its anti-feminist. But the reality is I took the name of someone who loved me, instead of keeping the name of someone who wanted to break me.

I could of course have come up with a totally different name for myself, and my DH could have changed to that too, and we did discuss it, and my DH would have done it if I had really wanted to. But honestly changing your name is a faff and I didn't see why both of us should have to go through that. It was a decision that was pragmatic and in no ways declares that I am lesser than him.

If 95% of women in the UK change their names on marriage, and about 1% of men do it, does that suggest to you that it has a basis in the inequality of the sexes, and that the system whereby women are second-class citizens owned by their fathers or husbands is still very much alive and kicking?

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:36

steff13 · 20/09/2022 16:34

Your argument just doesn't follow. Unless you come up with a surname that's completely unique to you, it's always a "man's name," be that your father, or your maternal grandfather, etc.

My married name has been my name for 26 years. It's very much "my own name."

So your married name is yours, but the name you were registered with at birth is your father's?

What?

My daughter was registered with my surname. How about her? Does she have 'a man's name'? If she gives that name to her daughter, will that still count as 'a man's name' in your opinion? How many generations of women will it have to pass through before any of us get to say that it's our name?

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:34

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:30

Societal norms are fine if men choose to abide by them then. But women aren't allowed to roll with the norms of their culture or society as this makes them anti-feminist. Curious definition of choice you have.

I hope that's not directed at me, as it doesn't remotely resemble anything I've said or anything I believe.

I have no more time (less in fact) for men who uphold patriarchy and sexism than I do women.

If my husband had wanted me to take his name, I would have known he wasn't the right person for me to marry. And I 100% would have known he wasn't someone I wanted to father my children.

Owlsinmybedroom · 20/09/2022 16:34

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:03

Of course not having children doesn't make you a second-class citizen.

Taking a man's name when you marry him is a declaration that you're lesser than him, though.

I've already explained on this thread that I changed my name to my husbands because my family were abusive and I didn't want to keep anything from them.

I understand taking my husbands name was old fashioned, and I understand why people would think its anti-feminist. But the reality is I took the name of someone who loved me, instead of keeping the name of someone who wanted to break me.

I could of course have come up with a totally different name for myself, and my DH could have changed to that too, and we did discuss it, and my DH would have done it if I had really wanted to. But honestly changing your name is a faff and I didn't see why both of us should have to go through that. It was a decision that was pragmatic and in no ways declares that I am lesser than him.

MacavityTheDentistsCat · 20/09/2022 16:34

I'd keep it. Aside from the reasons you have already mentioned, changing your name on divorce can not only cause confusion, but also "announces" the fact of your divorce. Some may not mind this, but others may wish to keep their private matters to themselves. I, for one, prefer to keep my private life to myself and I certainly wouldn't want my private matters known about by my business contacts. (And I somehow doubt many men go around advertising their divorce at work!)

steff13 · 20/09/2022 16:34

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:16

So women never, ever get our own names? My daughter has my surname, and yet somehow, you still categorise her as having a man's name? Is that just for all eternity? Women never get to say our names are our own?

Your argument just doesn't follow. Unless you come up with a surname that's completely unique to you, it's always a "man's name," be that your father, or your maternal grandfather, etc.

My married name has been my name for 26 years. It's very much "my own name."

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:31

FriendlyHedgehog · 20/09/2022 16:27

I've explained it three times as clearly and nicely as I can but there still seems to be something you don't understand and I can't figure out what it is. I'm going to give up now I'm afraid.

So as far as you're concerned, if my daughter keeps her name, and gives it to her daughter, and so on, forever, it will still be "a man's name" because at some point hundreds of years ago a man had that name?

So as far as you're concerned, women should carry on taking their husband's names, and giving their children their father's names only, because we never get to say that our names are our own anyway, regardless?

How convenient.

PrincessofWales · 20/09/2022 16:30

@Rosehugger generally people comment on something they know a little about or they just come across as goady?? Nothing to do with being a thread monitor but I might try that role, sounds fun!

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:30

Societal norms are fine if men choose to abide by them then. But women aren't allowed to roll with the norms of their culture or society as this makes them anti-feminist. Curious definition of choice you have.

Americano75 · 20/09/2022 16:29

I think YABU for divorcing this guy, he sounds like a real prince*.

*dick

FriendlyHedgehog · 20/09/2022 16:29

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:27

I've asked you to explain why you think a name that a woman has had since birth, that was her mother's surname, still, in your view, counts as 'a man's name'.

Which I have, but you don't like the answer. So let's end it here.

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:28

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:27

About 90% of men have a standard masculine appearance, is that a free and equal choice, or a norm imposed by society?

You're just being silly now. So I'll give up, as you obviously hoped i would, and won't ask again why it was you that changed your name, and not your husband.

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:27

FriendlyHedgehog · 20/09/2022 16:27

I've explained it three times as clearly and nicely as I can but there still seems to be something you don't understand and I can't figure out what it is. I'm going to give up now I'm afraid.

I've asked you to explain why you think a name that a woman has had since birth, that was her mother's surname, still, in your view, counts as 'a man's name'.

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:27

About 90% of men have a standard masculine appearance, is that a free and equal choice, or a norm imposed by society?

FriendlyHedgehog · 20/09/2022 16:27

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:23

Why do you think my name isn't my own? But my husband's belongs to him?

Why do you think it matters if it's shared with male ancestors?

Incidentally my name comes from the place my ancestors came from, and were driven out of, so reflects my ethnic identity and history as well. I've taken my daughter to visit the place itself. So I have absolutely no interest in destroying that link to my heritage.

I've explained it three times as clearly and nicely as I can but there still seems to be something you don't understand and I can't figure out what it is. I'm going to give up now I'm afraid.

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:27

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:25

So I have absolutely no interest in destroying that link to my heritage

DH's name comes from the same heritage as mine, so I wasn't destroying any heritage.

So he wouldn't have been either, if he had changed it to yours. Why didn't he?

BloodAndFire · 20/09/2022 16:26

Rosehugger · 20/09/2022 16:24

So why did you change your name and not him?

Keeping my name wasn't a hill I chose to die on, as it wasn't something that bothered me at all, and it was my choice. Feminism is about women having as much choice as possible, to do things which are not feminist.

No. Feminism is not about 'making any choice you want as a woman'. I asked above if you think the morality police in Iran (women) who grabbed Mahsa Amini and beat her to death for wearing her hijab wrong were making a feminist choice.

You said the reason for changing your name was to avoid a load of hassle and admin. Leaving aside the fact that this is not true - I have encountered none of those issues, and in fact on this thread the women who HAVE changed their name have said it was a hassle to do so - I asked you a very simple question.

Why, if you are not secondary to your husband, did you change your name, and not him? Or not both of you?