Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This doesn’t feel natural

111 replies

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:30

Dropping Dd, 4 at pre school and her crying and wanting to be home with me and me making her go, when she could be at hone with me.
Why doesn’t this feel natural? Do we make our little ones part too soon from us?
Please someone remind me of the benefits of this and why I’m doing it if I don’t have to 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 13:42

@Twizbe She’s only just turned 4 in summer

@Staters V similar story here, regarding ivf etc and length of time! I’m not massively protective when she falls etc and am pretty laid back about all that, we also have a large friendship group and do lots of activities…it’s just she seems so..sad 😞but is fine when she’s out, so we’ll stick with it

OP posts:
Twizbe · 20/09/2022 13:28

It's a good preparation for school. I'm assuming she is old in her year so no option to defer her entry.

Preschool is great for preparing them for going to school.

Suzi888 · 20/09/2022 13:19

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:36

What are the benefits for her then, if she’s clearly happier being at home? It helps me to keep strong with it all to know

They make little friends, have a little independence and it preps them for school.

Staters · 20/09/2022 13:18

My DD started last Monday.
Now when I say she has never been away from me I mean never!! Never stayed by herself with her Dad or overnight at Nanny’s. She is almost 4 1/2.
I’ve had all of the ‘oh you’re going to struggle when she starts school’ and ‘it’s not normal to never have any you time’ blah blah. But, she was a longed for baby, after almost a decade of trying and failed IVF she is our little miracle and I wanted to keep her close as long as I could.
I am knowingly over the top with worry, bumps, grazes, temperatures - everything. I contemplated not sending her until next term when she’d be 5 but she is definitely ready for it now. I have always been encouraging about how much fun she’ll have when she finally goes and that’s she’d make lots of friends so she has been excited to start.

Luckily, she is a confident, bright little girl and on Monday she told me “you’ll be fine Mummy, Daddy is with you this week so you’re not by yourself” went in and I didn’t even get a second glance off her 😭
Then this morning when Daddy went back to work she told me I could tidy her playroom for her 🙄😂
This week will be harder than last as DH is back in work, but I aim to keep myself busy - not just reading mumsnet.

Smineusername · 20/09/2022 13:17

If it feels wrong keep her with you another year

Moonlightdust · 20/09/2022 12:44

My SIL who lives abroad has her youngest aged 2 and 9 months starting school full time. The child is nowhere emotionally developed and still drinks a bottle of milk. I think it’s barbaric.

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/09/2022 12:43

Keeping her home and sending her to school at 5 to an environment where the rest of her class are used to socialising and already have friendship groups will make it harder for her to find her niche, and can have long lasting detrimental effects on self esteem and ability to learn and fulfil potential

felulageller · 20/09/2022 12:31

She'll be picking up on your anxieties.

Do you talk to her about your positive experiences of school?

Does she see you going out during the day? Don't tell her you are going back to sit in the house waiting to collect her!

This generation of covid DC's are going to find it harder socialising as they had a big gap of no social contact.

Does she do clubs?

How is she socially with other DC's? Does she know any DC's at school?

A headteacher once said to me that the most important lesson for DC's preparing for school is to learn to be told 'no'. She said lots struggle to settle in as they've never been told 'no' before!!

Could it be this? Is she used to everything revolving around her?

If you really don't want to continue you are free to homeschool. That's a good option for some DC's/ parents.

Pinkpeony2 · 20/09/2022 12:14

ViviPru · 20/09/2022 10:52

None of it is natural. I honestly believe that we are designed to raise children in a much more communal, tribal way, with different generations of friends and family living in close proximity sharing the task of raising children collectively. From the time children can walk they would benefit from short periods time spent nearby but independently from their parents, minded by familiar adults with other small children and older ones too. Then by the time they are 4 they would be accustomed to slightly longer periods of exploring the world with older, trusted carers, (a bit like preschool and reception) which is a healthy way to grow and learn.

But the way our society is set up with us all partitioned off from each other - through no fault or intention of our own - means we have a very often intense period before children go to pre-school or school where their experience is often limited to the immediate family at home (sure they may visit friends and family and go to toddler groups and have periods in childcare settings but it's not the same as the feral utopia of my wild imagination). No wonder it feels like a massive wrench when they are suddenly in this much less familiar, seemingly impersonal environment of pre-school and reception.

I don't know what the answer is, but ultimately I think it is in children's benefit to spend periods of time in different environments to their parents if it can be done in a caring, healthy way.

This.
The thing is it’s just a black and white chop.
Home with Mummy all day every day (in some cases) and then chop. Off you go to strangers for the day.
Of course they are going to struggle and want to be back where they know if safe with Mum.
This is totally unnatural for humans. The care giving would be shared more earlier on and then the child would venture out slowly. Spending more and more time away from his mother until completely independent. Not just dressed and left with people he doesn’t know.
Thats the society we’ve created though. Yes you can home school but society and living costs usually don’t allow for that and so few people do it that actually mixing with a wide amount of peers is impossible. Then you are the odd ones out later in life and how does that affect lift chances once schooling is over?
Do you home school right up to working age or make that chop in secondary school which surely is going to be extremely difficult.
So as we live in this society we generally have to abide by the rules to fit in later down the line. It’s hard but mostly they do settle and then enjoy going.

RoseAndVioletSims · 20/09/2022 12:11

I personally don’t feel that kids “get used” to being dropped off by sending them when they aren’t ready. My step dd went to nursery full time from 9 months old and was never ready for school drop offs as at 5. She screamed and clung!
my other dd didn’t go to nursery at all. She went to preschool 3 mornings a week from age 3.5 but any time she didn’t want to go I didn’t force her in the door. I just took her home. I was a SAHM so was able to. I appreciate that not everyone can do this. By start of school at age 4 she was very confidentially walking in. She never felt like it was a punishment or something she was forced into and I never once had her scream or cling to me at drop off.

Burgoo · 20/09/2022 12:06

There are a few things here...

I'm curious about your attachment style with your daughter. Are you protective, cautious, anxious or in "the way" a lot? I don't mean any of that negatively BTW! Children are wonderful emotion sponges, so she will feel it if you are unsure. Children must rely on their care-givers for cues that things are going to be fine. It's why when my daughter falls over and scrapes her-self I just pick her up and we carry on. No drama, no fuss.

The reason I ask is because you sound anxious about sending her away and a little over-attached. We as parents have to let go, let them experience things and thrive. I say that because you seem to think her being at home with you (and constantly being happy) is better than her feeling discomfort, working through it, meeting new children and then learning to deal with emotions in the future.

Her telling you she misses you etc is her way of shaping you to feel guilty. It's what children (ALL children) do.

Just some ideas:

Validate the fact she misses you AND remind her that she has some other children to play with at pre-school too.

Reinforce her going to school. What incentive does she have at the moment? Anxiety, sadness? Heap on the praise when she gets home. Make cakes, paint, take her out to play football... ANYTHING that reinforces school = good thing.

At the same time, I can feel your pain. Ours is only 2 and we have this to come. Though she can't wait to get rid of us! We took her to family recently (we don't see them often) and wow! She told us to go out! Just keep reminding yourself that an unhealthy attachment increases the chances of her having MAJOR psychological issues later. Sending her to meet new people is a way of getting her used to socialising with "the tribe" - the longer you wait, the harder it will be. Unless you want to have her at home until she is 40 (and if you do, that isn't healthy).

KoalaCape · 20/09/2022 11:54

Does she know you're at home? Maybe you need to tell her you're off to a meeting, work, the gym or something so she doesn't think you're home and she's not. If she says she wants to stay home with mummy you just make it clear you won't be at home and she can't stay at home alone.

It's very clear at school which children did or didn't have time away from parents/carers before compulsory age and it will benefit her in the long run to go, plus the people leading it are professionals in child development so she will benefit in more ways than one.

TulipVictory · 20/09/2022 11:51

@PoorPaddington mine went to school at reception age (just turned 5) but didn't go to nursery/pre-school

Topgub · 20/09/2022 11:49

Are you going to keep her at home forever?

Surely you must be aware of the benefits of education and socialisation?

Clubs and hobbies?

Stickmansmum · 20/09/2022 11:47

Some kids find things harder than others. Some adults find things harder too. These are all valid feelings but it’s important for children to adjust. The ability to adjust and helping them learn to cope with new things is he greatest gift you can give your child OP.

They are safe, they have lots to do. They will see mummy later for cuddles. In the meantime, they are growing far more as people than they could being kept by your side to avoid the discomfort of adjusting.

FlipFlopFlippedyFlop · 20/09/2022 10:58

At four years old she will definitely benefit from the structure at pre school and being around kids her age. Also, she will be benefit from being out of her comfort zone and facing new challenges. Some things are very difficult to recreate at home. Another point is that next year she will have to go to school. It will be much easier for her of she ready has experience being away from you. The beginning is always hard but hopefully soon she will start to enjoy it.

From the research I have read it seems that under the age of three being at nursery may not be beneficial and on the whole kids might benefit from being at home rather than undergoing the stress of being away from their primary carer. However, after the age of three nursery is definitely of benefit.

I can relate to how you are feeling. My eldest is in year two and I still worry every day if they are comfortable and happy at school. My younger one ( one year old) has just joined nursery and screams his little head off every morning. It breaks.my heart to see him so happy and cheerful on the morning and then his little face becomes sadder and sadder till we reach nursery. Don't have a choice though..I have had to return to work so he has to go to nursery. I just hope he settles in soon.

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:57

@ComtesseDeSpair She just says she misses me, she said it to me last night before falling asleep that she was feeling sad as she’d miss me in the morning at present school 😫she just does some mornings at present.
When we ask her if it’s fun etc, she says she likes it but wants to be at home

OP posts:
PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:56

@ComtesseDeSpair I thought it would be beneficial for her to go part time so next year isn’t such a shock being away full time 🤔

OP posts:
PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:55

@TulipVictory At what age?

OP posts:
lemonyanus · 20/09/2022 10:53

Oh it is awful at the start. The second week is peak for crying at the door, once the novelty has worn off and before they settle in. What helped my son was meeting another little friend from his class outside and going in together, we also did that thing where you draw a heart on their hands and yours and they can press it when they miss you. That helped a lot.

ViviPru · 20/09/2022 10:52

None of it is natural. I honestly believe that we are designed to raise children in a much more communal, tribal way, with different generations of friends and family living in close proximity sharing the task of raising children collectively. From the time children can walk they would benefit from short periods time spent nearby but independently from their parents, minded by familiar adults with other small children and older ones too. Then by the time they are 4 they would be accustomed to slightly longer periods of exploring the world with older, trusted carers, (a bit like preschool and reception) which is a healthy way to grow and learn.

But the way our society is set up with us all partitioned off from each other - through no fault or intention of our own - means we have a very often intense period before children go to pre-school or school where their experience is often limited to the immediate family at home (sure they may visit friends and family and go to toddler groups and have periods in childcare settings but it's not the same as the feral utopia of my wild imagination). No wonder it feels like a massive wrench when they are suddenly in this much less familiar, seemingly impersonal environment of pre-school and reception.

I don't know what the answer is, but ultimately I think it is in children's benefit to spend periods of time in different environments to their parents if it can be done in a caring, healthy way.

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/09/2022 10:52

Some children are ready at a younger age than others. If she’s four and this is pre-school, and she isn’t settling, take her out and try again next year when she’s compulsory school age.

Can she explain to you why she cries? Does she just dislike being away from you and home, or is there a problem with other children or the environment?

jokingfox · 20/09/2022 10:50

Mine got to a stage where he no longer benefits from being surrounded by adults and benefits more from being with his peers. I've seen huge positive changes including behavioural changes. Mine started last January at 2.5 and still gets a little upset in the mornings but is happy as soon as I leave. I can hear him cheering his little friends and playing happily as I linger around outside the door to make sure he is fine and he is more than fine. Every child is different though with different personalities, the benefits so far has outweighed the little negatives we still experience in the mornings with my little one.

cooliebrown · 20/09/2022 10:50

both my children walked into school on the first day without a backward glance. Which was upsetting in its own way!

TulipVictory · 20/09/2022 10:44

Just to say I kept mine with me, no nursery etc and they went into school just fine 😊

Swipe left for the next trending thread