Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This doesn’t feel natural

111 replies

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:30

Dropping Dd, 4 at pre school and her crying and wanting to be home with me and me making her go, when she could be at hone with me.
Why doesn’t this feel natural? Do we make our little ones part too soon from us?
Please someone remind me of the benefits of this and why I’m doing it if I don’t have to 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
berksandbeyond · 21/09/2022 07:41

You're going to have to do it at some point though aren't you? They can't live in your pocket forever. Meeting different people and working with and learning to listen to different people is what will help make your child well rounded as they grow.
Did they not attend nursery or anything? If they've never been to a childcare setting before then yes I imagine this is a shock!

TheBoxOfWhat · 21/09/2022 07:36

Ask the staff what she is like in preschool. Is she having fun? Are there photos of her playing happily? Ds used to tell me he only ever played at the sand table but preschool nursery had lots of photos of him having a ball playing in the pretend cafe, riding round on trikes, listening to a story with everyone else.

There are huge benefits to going to a preschool. I am a sahm and I sent mine for mornings at 3 years old. But I also made sure that they spent time alone with Dh from day 1 and left the room lots so they could spend time with their grandparents so it wasn't all just Mum.

MargaretThursday · 21/09/2022 07:28

I think if you watch how animals start encouraging independence as their babies get bigger and it's time to move on it is natural though.

I'm always surprised how vicious the gentle little budgies are when they want the chicks to start eating on their own rather expecting to be fed by parents.
In fact mum has just been moved out of the cage for that reason.

georgarina · 21/09/2022 07:25

I think kids are all different...mine were so ready for nursery and school, they always loved playgroups from baby age and would have been bored at home with me. But others are the opposite. I remember my cousin had bad anxiety at an older age and would refuse to go, try and run away, and her parents just forced her. She ended up developing a phobia and gave up uni after a few weeks because of it.

I think there is a degree of letting them be upset for a second and get over it, but if they are genuinely upset and not ready, don't force it.

Sixsmith · 21/09/2022 07:22

Libre2 · 20/09/2022 10:42

You don’t have to do this. There is always the option to home Ed. I do not do this but sometimes I wish I had. And yes, we send children way, way to early to school.

I home ed. I wasn't planning to. But when it got to that September, he was 4 and no way were we ready to be parted.
I love home ed, if you have the circumstances you can try it.
Remember, millions of children have sobbed on the gates of school for decades and got used to it after a while, so she will too, in time.

Bunnycat101 · 21/09/2022 07:21

Some kids do find it harder. Your child will also be of the ‘covid generation’ that is likely to find things even harder as the few years above has as well. My youngest will be the same year as yours and teachers for her activities have said this cohort is behind socially. I think nursery is vitally important to this group of children to support school readiness.

Both of mine loved and benefited from nursery - it was like a second home and they made strong friendships. I also think activities where they had to be independent helped with starting school for my eldest and will help my youngest (who finds separating harder). My 3yo will now happily go into her ballet class without me but last term couldn’t do it and cried so I had to stay and do more of a gradual retreat over weeks and weeks. She needed time to feel secure.

Losinghope9 · 21/09/2022 07:07

Nursery is flexible in how long she's there for and how may day's, some do half days. School however is not. I think it's worse to throw a child into full time school having never been away from parents and never been given the skills to learn how to make friends and navigate a school like setting.

I say this having worked in recpetion and you can tell massively those who have and haven't been to nursery. They take far longer to settle in, and generally are more tearful and don't settle for longer. Can also be harder for them to then make friend's due to this.

Just an observation, every child is individual. I also had a child who used to sob when I left him so I do know how it feels.

Allchangeonceagain · 21/09/2022 07:06

ViviPru · 20/09/2022 10:52

None of it is natural. I honestly believe that we are designed to raise children in a much more communal, tribal way, with different generations of friends and family living in close proximity sharing the task of raising children collectively. From the time children can walk they would benefit from short periods time spent nearby but independently from their parents, minded by familiar adults with other small children and older ones too. Then by the time they are 4 they would be accustomed to slightly longer periods of exploring the world with older, trusted carers, (a bit like preschool and reception) which is a healthy way to grow and learn.

But the way our society is set up with us all partitioned off from each other - through no fault or intention of our own - means we have a very often intense period before children go to pre-school or school where their experience is often limited to the immediate family at home (sure they may visit friends and family and go to toddler groups and have periods in childcare settings but it's not the same as the feral utopia of my wild imagination). No wonder it feels like a massive wrench when they are suddenly in this much less familiar, seemingly impersonal environment of pre-school and reception.

I don't know what the answer is, but ultimately I think it is in children's benefit to spend periods of time in different environments to their parents if it can be done in a caring, healthy way.

I could have written this! 100% agree. The business of having them only with us (parents) or only away from us with other people isn’t natural. There is no solution, given how society is set up. My LO is ok gking in but would rather stay with me and it feels so unnatural. I’m not going to home school as I’m too selfish (??) and would find it so hard and I’m mot sure it’s quite the answer either. Not for everyone anyway. I agree it’s just so sad for those children who find it tough. If I had a summer baby I would defer their start

EspressoPatronumm · 21/09/2022 07:05

@Staters it's incredibly bizarre that your husband has never been alone with his own child in 4.5 years..

Kitchenlight · 21/09/2022 06:58

I wanted to home school but both kids were adamant, even at four, that they wanted to go to school so I didn't. On our off days we wandered had adventures met up with some kids from the home schooling group. It was really fun for all of us.

Kitchenlight · 21/09/2022 06:51

You don't have to (if you have the option of keeping your child at home).
i eased mine in early at 3 with two days a week at nursery
then Three days a week at reception till they were five And four for the last term
worked well for us
no tears as at each stage the kids were really
ready to go

lizziesiddal79 · 21/09/2022 06:31

ViviPru · 20/09/2022 10:52

None of it is natural. I honestly believe that we are designed to raise children in a much more communal, tribal way, with different generations of friends and family living in close proximity sharing the task of raising children collectively. From the time children can walk they would benefit from short periods time spent nearby but independently from their parents, minded by familiar adults with other small children and older ones too. Then by the time they are 4 they would be accustomed to slightly longer periods of exploring the world with older, trusted carers, (a bit like preschool and reception) which is a healthy way to grow and learn.

But the way our society is set up with us all partitioned off from each other - through no fault or intention of our own - means we have a very often intense period before children go to pre-school or school where their experience is often limited to the immediate family at home (sure they may visit friends and family and go to toddler groups and have periods in childcare settings but it's not the same as the feral utopia of my wild imagination). No wonder it feels like a massive wrench when they are suddenly in this much less familiar, seemingly impersonal environment of pre-school and reception.

I don't know what the answer is, but ultimately I think it is in children's benefit to spend periods of time in different environments to their parents if it can be done in a caring, healthy way.

You have the same imaginings as I do.

Borracha · 21/09/2022 06:26

I don't agree with those saying 4 is too young. It might be for some, but not for all. Every kid is different.

I live abroad and kids here start school at 3. My middle child turned 3 at the end of June and started school in the last week of August. He is thriving - the increase in his confidence, his speech, his fine and gross motor skills has been incredible to see.

Roselilly36 · 21/09/2022 06:05

It’s awful I know, but some children take longer to settle, my DS1 suffered with separation anxiety very badly, he wanted to be with me all the time. I carried on with a local playgroup, thinking if I could get him settled there it would be easier for him going to school, the playgroup had strong links with the school so he had met the teachers for story time, used the bikes and trikes etc. Whilst he didn’t cry, he was constantly coming back to me, asking what time I was coming back to collect him etc. It’s so hard to deal with. No answers, but empathy. Flowers

amylou8 · 21/09/2022 05:54

Most of the things we do in modern life aren't 'natural'. I know it's tough but unless you're planning on having her at home for the foreseeable future she does need to get used to it. Do not make a fuss of her at drop off. Walk/carry her in, hand her to a member of staff, quick kiss and see you later, and walk away.

Wouldloveanother · 21/09/2022 05:51

My 3 year old swans in to nursery every morning like she owns the place. It’s lovely to hear her ‘news’ when she comes home, usually about which kids are in trouble for pushing/shoving and who she played with that day (she’s a bit of a tattle tale at the moment). She really enjoys telling me things Grin

The benefit is that it socialises them and teaches them to make friends. Not many pre school age kids have lots of siblings around the house like they did years ago, so it makes up for that - it teaches them how to play, how to feel happy and comfortable alongside their peers, plus gives them interesting things to do rather than just the park or CBeebies. DD does a lot of crafts, ‘baking’, outdoor play, singing, dress up etc and absolutely loves it. She comes home very proud to show off her drawings.

Home schooling etc just kicks the can down the road and keeps them in a bubble. It’ll be even harder for them to settle if they returned to school later at any point.

Happyher · 21/09/2022 05:33

Have you asked the staff what’s she’s like once you’re gone? A lot of children soon forget their mums as soon as they’re distracted by the toys. It may just be the parting that she finds difficult. And she’s getting lots of attention from you. She’s just maybe finding her way through this

Coffeetree · 21/09/2022 04:57

luxxlisbon · 20/09/2022 10:34

Children will cry whatever their age if they are only used to being around one person. If you kept her home with you for 4 years more it wouldn’t make it any easier on her.

I disagree. I started school at age 7 and I was thrilled. Higged my mum goodbye and ran into the school.

4 years old is way too soon to start school.

BlodynGwyn · 21/09/2022 04:46

Don't do it if it feels unnatural. My grandson (just born a few hours ago) is going to be home schooled and how I would have loved that myself. So much time is spent at school doing rubbish things. Now they telling them the doctor only guessed their gender when they were born!!

Ragwort · 21/09/2022 04:29

coolie my DS was the same ... went to nursery/pre-school (2 different settings) from two and a half and loved every minute of it Blush, never looked back once. He didn't 'need' to go to nursery as I was a SAHM but he really enjoyed all the activities and opportunities... I was the parent asking for extra sessions. He's always been very independent and confident about 'trying new things' ... he's 21 now and seems to have developed perfectly OK ... all DC are different. My friend's DC, same age, was the exact opposite, hated being away from mum as well ... but he's also a totally happy and confident 21 year old now.

WalrusSubmarine · 21/09/2022 04:05

We changed pre school because of a move and it’s made a massive difference. He’s so happy, relaxed and learning so much more.

It’s a shorter day which is difficult for work but seems easier on him.

Holidaying7 · 21/09/2022 03:28

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 13:45

@abovedecknotbelow Its a Pre school, no playgroup where I am (abroad) so they start the pre school at the school she will go to at 6…they don’t have to start until 6. She goes three mornings per week, although they’re already fussing that she should come all day everyday

Oh sorry missed this. It’s preschool and not school!

well if she’s not happy, just take her out. Bring her to playgroups with you. Or find her another playgroup she actually likes!

Holidaying7 · 21/09/2022 03:27

They’re too young at 4 for school. But that’s the uk for you!

If you have the confidence, OP, you could keep her out until year 1? I know some people who did that. It worked great. But they had to rely on a space becoming available in the school in year 1. (Obviously it did!)

Dunnoburt · 21/09/2022 02:54

Personally for me, pre school was an absolute waste of money and time and if I didn't have to work I'd never have put my nipper in - she was no further advanced than any other reception child because of it but at the time was constantly tired, grumpy and ill. So glad those days are gone! I don't think YABU.

NumberTheory · 21/09/2022 02:51

It may be different in your country, but research in the US shows the benefits of attending pre-school include increased reading, math and social skills in the short term and greater chance of graduating high school and college in the long term.

It may not feel natural. There’s a strong argument it isn’t. But human life isn’t natural and hasn’t been for millennia. To thrive in society in the 21st century, your DD needs skills that can’t be developed as well in a home setting (though she also needs the skills you can help her develop at home).

Swipe left for the next trending thread