Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This doesn’t feel natural

111 replies

PoorPaddington · 20/09/2022 10:30

Dropping Dd, 4 at pre school and her crying and wanting to be home with me and me making her go, when she could be at hone with me.
Why doesn’t this feel natural? Do we make our little ones part too soon from us?
Please someone remind me of the benefits of this and why I’m doing it if I don’t have to 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sherrystrull · 21/09/2022 19:04

I think helping children to build resilience is a good idea. However, all of my friends and family work so their children have been with a mixture of nursery and grandparents from a very young age so preschool was the natural next step.

EspressoPatronumm · 21/09/2022 17:35

@Ragwort it wasn't op who hasn't left her kid with her husband it's another poster called @Staters

Turndownthatthatcrap · 21/09/2022 17:28

@Ragwort The op didn’t say she hasn’t ever not left her Dd with her Dh 🤷🏻‍♀️

Ragwort · 21/09/2022 17:20

If the OP has never even left her DD with her own father ... how on earth would the DD cope if mum is rushed to hospital or worse? When my DS was younger I was determined not to be over protective... of course his own father could look after him and he got used to spending time with friends, family (no, they weren't nearby but whenever they came to visit), nursery people etc etc. So many mothers seem to want to be a martyr to their DC, it really isn't healthy to be over protective.

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 12:30

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 10:39

@GabriellaMontez

You’re basically landing in the same place aren’t you though?

You are saying that the argument for encouraging children to find some independence from their immediate families is driven by working mother guilt.

In spite of the evidence that it is actually supportive for children.

So thanks for the semi climb down.

Evidence that it is supportive for the children

Supportive of what? Which children? What childcare?

There is a huge spectrum.

If you're happy with the Evidence you have no need to feel guilty.

Still no rationale for your claim that The later you leave this the harder it gets why do you tell yourself and others that? Is it guilt ?

oxydant · 21/09/2022 11:26

Those saying 4 is too young, my son just plays all day... what actually is the issue?

He showed me his downward dog and sang a song about a bumble bee... how is a 4 year old too young for that?

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 10:39

@GabriellaMontez

You’re basically landing in the same place aren’t you though?

You are saying that the argument for encouraging children to find some independence from their immediate families is driven by working mother guilt.

In spite of the evidence that it is actually supportive for children.

So thanks for the semi climb down.

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 10:24

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 08:58

Should I feel guilty about using childcare then? I'm a lone parent so had no alternative. But presumably I should also feel guilty because, yeah.

Do you believe the only reason parents are encouraged to take their children to nursery and preschool settings is because they are "feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too"?

What's your rationale for believing this? In the face of overwhelming evidence that children do benefit from some socialisation away from the family. Or was this just a stealth dig at working mums?

I don't think you should feel guilty.

I said the claim you made The later you leave this the harder it gets is what people say when they feel guilty.

And it's a claim without any rationale.

heartbroken22 · 21/09/2022 09:29

How is she today? There are some comments on here that a bit deep. All I can say is it may take a a few days, a few weeks to settle in and thats okay. Just work at it.

neverbeenskiing · 21/09/2022 09:16

OP, I could have written your post when my eldest started pre-school. I found the tears and cries of "mummy come back!" at the gate so heartbreaking, I would be counting down the hours until I could go and pick her up. I felt so guilty I almost pulled her out. I am SO glad that I didn't!

It took her a while to adjust but once she did DD absolutely loved pre-school and would be so excited to go every day and to tell us about everything she'd done when she came home. She is 8 years old now and still talks about trips, special events and activities she remembers from pre-school! She got so much out of it.

They did a lot of work on getting the DC ready for primary school, so by the time it came to it she was such a confident little thing, it didn't bother her at all starting school. I braced myself for tears and staff having to peel her off me at the gate but it just never happened. She saw it as a big adventure but not a massive adjustment as she was so well prepared for it and already used to some of the routines and structure from pre-school. She still loves school now. It helped that she had made friends at pre-school who went up to the same primary school so she already knew a couple of familiar faces.

My youngest skipped through the gates of the same preschool on his first day without so much as a backward glance which just goes to show they're all different and it's not necessarily a reflection on the pre-school itself or how they're parented. My 8 year old loves coming with me to pick her brother up because the staff there still remember her fondly and make a big fuss of her.

Ultimately its your decision and no one else can tell you what's right for your own child. But personally I'm really glad we stuck it out and I firmly believe that if we hadn't, we'd just have been storing up problems for the start of School.

WhatIsThisPlease · 21/09/2022 09:10

My DD2 hated pre school so I very rarely sent her. We had a lovely time at home and she had no problems whatsoever settling into school.

I think she was just too young for pre school, she wasn't ready to go.

Wouldloveanother · 21/09/2022 09:09

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 08:58

Should I feel guilty about using childcare then? I'm a lone parent so had no alternative. But presumably I should also feel guilty because, yeah.

Do you believe the only reason parents are encouraged to take their children to nursery and preschool settings is because they are "feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too"?

What's your rationale for believing this? In the face of overwhelming evidence that children do benefit from some socialisation away from the family. Or was this just a stealth dig at working mums?

No guilt at all here. When everything was ‘natural’, babies would have many many siblings close to themselves in age - perhaps 18 months between them in many cases. They would also have local relatives or even relatives living with them who would pitch in. So babies and toddlers were used to busy, thriving households with plenty of little buddies to play with a numerous trusted carers. I haven’t popped out 5 kids so nursery is the next best thing.

It’s comparatively unnatural for a child to spend all their time with one other adult, just the two of them, if you think about it like that.

Aozora13 · 21/09/2022 09:01

I wonder whether it’s preschool itself she’s struggling with, or the transition part (having to leave the house and go). If she’s happy when she’s there and talks positively about it I’d be inclined to persevere and focus on supporting her through the drop off. If she doesn’t settle while she’s there I might consider taking her out or finding a different setting, if you have that option.

Mine have all been in nursery since a year old (and that feels extremely unnatural, handing over your baby) and by pre-school they really benefit from the range of activities, making friends, growing independence etc. My eldest started school just after her 4th birthday and loves it. But different personalities will find it easier/harder, and sometimes it’s about their maturity/they’ll grow into it and sometimes it’s just how it is - not everyone loves school!

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 08:58

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 08:53

The later you leave this the harder it gets.

Not true. As many of us have experienced. This is what people say when they're feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too.

Should I feel guilty about using childcare then? I'm a lone parent so had no alternative. But presumably I should also feel guilty because, yeah.

Do you believe the only reason parents are encouraged to take their children to nursery and preschool settings is because they are "feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too"?

What's your rationale for believing this? In the face of overwhelming evidence that children do benefit from some socialisation away from the family. Or was this just a stealth dig at working mums?

Wouldloveanother · 21/09/2022 08:55

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 08:53

The later you leave this the harder it gets.

Not true. As many of us have experienced. This is what people say when they're feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too.

I do wonder how much of it is the child not being ready rather than the parent themselves. Some parents on here sound distraught to be separated from their child even for a few hours, and don’t know what to do with themselves when the kid goes. I wonder if it rubs off on the child to make it all feel like a ‘bad thing’. A job would help distract them I suppose.

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 08:53

The later you leave this the harder it gets.

Not true. As many of us have experienced. This is what people say when they're feeling guilty about using childcare and want you to feel guilty too.

Wouldloveanother · 21/09/2022 08:53

ViviPru · 20/09/2022 10:52

None of it is natural. I honestly believe that we are designed to raise children in a much more communal, tribal way, with different generations of friends and family living in close proximity sharing the task of raising children collectively. From the time children can walk they would benefit from short periods time spent nearby but independently from their parents, minded by familiar adults with other small children and older ones too. Then by the time they are 4 they would be accustomed to slightly longer periods of exploring the world with older, trusted carers, (a bit like preschool and reception) which is a healthy way to grow and learn.

But the way our society is set up with us all partitioned off from each other - through no fault or intention of our own - means we have a very often intense period before children go to pre-school or school where their experience is often limited to the immediate family at home (sure they may visit friends and family and go to toddler groups and have periods in childcare settings but it's not the same as the feral utopia of my wild imagination). No wonder it feels like a massive wrench when they are suddenly in this much less familiar, seemingly impersonal environment of pre-school and reception.

I don't know what the answer is, but ultimately I think it is in children's benefit to spend periods of time in different environments to their parents if it can be done in a caring, healthy way.

I agree with this.

But societal trends just don’t support it - people are having children much later now, so the grandparents are too old to help with childcare or be very involved. We also tend to move away from where we grew up, so we lose the nearby family network.

It’s easy to see why postnatal depression is so common.

AngelinaFibres · 21/09/2022 08:36

Stickmansmum · 20/09/2022 11:47

Some kids find things harder than others. Some adults find things harder too. These are all valid feelings but it’s important for children to adjust. The ability to adjust and helping them learn to cope with new things is he greatest gift you can give your child OP.

They are safe, they have lots to do. They will see mummy later for cuddles. In the meantime, they are growing far more as people than they could being kept by your side to avoid the discomfort of adjusting.

This.
My mother still talks about taking me to school at 5. I cried because I hated it and my brother cried because he wanted to go and was too young. I would have very happily stayed at home. My father had been a teacher so everything we did at school we also had at home. What we didn't have was learning to be independent, learning to think for yourself and speak for yourself. I was NT but very, very shy. Being with other children is very important. Learning to cope with different situations is crucial. Nursery and Reception classes are set up for this.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/09/2022 08:10

Those people saying “take her out”, don’t you think you’re just delaying the inevitable point where a child starts to find its independence?

I understand some children mature faster than others so there may be a value in waiting a few more months but how can it benefit a child to keep delaying the point at which you start to learn how to rub alongside other people?

I just worry that this approach is actively encouraging children to fear life outside the family bubble, fear change and fail to learn to process difficult emotions without their parents. I don’t think it’s healthy. The later you leave this the harder it gets. I home there are a lot of home Ed enthusiasts on here but let’s be honest, this isn’t an option for most of us.

I remember the days of watching my child cry when she went off to childcare it’s heartbreaking but that doesn’t mean it isn’t the right thing to do.

Tigger85 · 21/09/2022 08:05

Ds went to nursery school just turned 3, it's only 2.5 hours per day, he cried going in but the teacher said he was happy and playing with the other children within 5 mins. By the end if the year he was crying at pick up because he wanted to stay and play. He started reception a few days after turning 4 and i was worried about how he would cope with full length days but he was fine and enjoyed going to school. He's year 1 now which he doesn't like as much because there's more sitting down and less play but he still seems to most like it. He was desperate to be around other children after the isolation of Covid lockdowns and restrictions, I wish he could have been allowed to start reception age 5 and had longer in nursery school. It definitely helped his socialisation and his ability to listen and follow rules. Your daughter will hopefully be ok after a few weeks of settling in, have a chat with her teacher if you are concerned about how upset she is going to school, hopefully once she's in class she happily plays like my ds did and its just a drop off issue.

70billionthnamechange · 21/09/2022 08:03

You don't have to, take her out. Mine didn't do pre school and loves school. Obvs they can still be the same next year but much easier to explain when you're coming back etc at 4/5 than 3

GabriellaMontez · 21/09/2022 07:57

TulipVictory · 20/09/2022 10:44

Just to say I kept mine with me, no nursery etc and they went into school just fine 😊

Same. One went in fine. One struggled a but. They're all individuals.

Have a break from nursery. Plan to do the summer term instead. She'll be a bit older and wiser. Six months is a long time.

I don't know why you're doing it if you do t have to.

Herejustforthisone · 21/09/2022 07:53

Staters · 20/09/2022 13:18

My DD started last Monday.
Now when I say she has never been away from me I mean never!! Never stayed by herself with her Dad or overnight at Nanny’s. She is almost 4 1/2.
I’ve had all of the ‘oh you’re going to struggle when she starts school’ and ‘it’s not normal to never have any you time’ blah blah. But, she was a longed for baby, after almost a decade of trying and failed IVF she is our little miracle and I wanted to keep her close as long as I could.
I am knowingly over the top with worry, bumps, grazes, temperatures - everything. I contemplated not sending her until next term when she’d be 5 but she is definitely ready for it now. I have always been encouraging about how much fun she’ll have when she finally goes and that’s she’d make lots of friends so she has been excited to start.

Luckily, she is a confident, bright little girl and on Monday she told me “you’ll be fine Mummy, Daddy is with you this week so you’re not by yourself” went in and I didn’t even get a second glance off her 😭
Then this morning when Daddy went back to work she told me I could tidy her playroom for her 🙄😂
This week will be harder than last as DH is back in work, but I aim to keep myself busy - not just reading mumsnet.

That is a level of intensity I cannot relate to.

Will you go back to work?

ChagSameachDoreen · 21/09/2022 07:51

I think it depends how she is when she's there, and what she's getting from it. My daughter cries blue murder as soon as she sees the gates to her kindergarten, but settles as soon as she sees her key worker, and is clearly getting a lot from being there.

It's harder if you're not seeing any benefits or if your daughter is upset all day.

Ducksurprise · 21/09/2022 07:45

If you don't need to work don't send them.
Most of the lauded positives are there to make working parents feel less guilty.

It will look even more crazy when you look back when they are teens. The enforced attendance at school is for two reasons, economic and to help protect the vulnerable, if you are neither then your child is being sacrificed for the greater good.