Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...so what exactly is "service and duty"?

266 replies

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:14

After countless threads on the royal family, I feel nobody goes into full detail of what the royal family do apart from the same phrase "service and duty".

I genuinely would like to be enlightened on what this "service and duty" is, not including showing up to events and waving, watching tennis and rugby matches, opening places, having an expensive wedding sometimes etc.

I feel nobody has really answered in detail what it is.

I am open to being educated if I'm missing something.

OP posts:
FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:44

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:41

You literally said trolling here

Yes that’s what you’re trying to get us to do isn’t it? Troll an old lady who was only buried yesterday?

You don’t mention her or even the monarchy in your OP. You just vague post and pretend not to know what words mean.

You want us to do denigrate the dead nonagenarian.

If you’d started a debate about wealth and monarchy under your own name, I’d have been with you.

Arenanewbie · 20/09/2022 10:44

OP, I think many people answered your question: Royals do meetings, speeches, opening events etc, attract attention to causes. We call it service and duty because it’s shorter and sounds nicer. Is it enough to justify their wealth and attention to them? It’s up to you to decide. I guess your thread is not about this, you just wanted to clarify the duties?

Mamamia7962 · 20/09/2022 10:44

The royal family carry out about 2,000 engagements a year, entertain around 70,000 guests, many from abroad and reply to 100,000 letters. Any letter that was written to the Queen got a reply as she said that if someone had taken the time to write to her it was only right that they should take the time to acknowledge that.

When the royals go to an engagement they have notes to read up on beforehand so they know about the organisation they are attending and can make relevant small talk. It's not just turning up shaking hands and cutting a ribbon as so many on here think.

ExHack · 20/09/2022 10:43

LadyHarmby · 20/09/2022 10:29

For example, here’s what Charles & Camilla did on 2 May 2019:

The Prince Charles, Duke of Rothesay, President, The Prince's Foundation, this morning held a Meeting at Dumfries House, Cumnock, Ayrshire.

His Royal Highness, Patron, the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh, afterwards received Mr. Simon Milne (Regius Keeper).

The Prince Charles, Duke of Rothesay, President, The Prince's Foundation, this afternoon visited Dumfries House Festival of Farming.

His Royal Highness, Royal Founding Patron, Business in the Community, later attended a Meeting at Dumfries House.

The Prince Charles, Duke of Rothesay, President, The Prince's Foundation, this evening held a Dinner for supporters at Dumfries House.

The Duchess of Cornwall, Patron, this morning visited the National Stud, Newmarket, and was received by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant of Cambridgeshire (Mrs. Julie Spence).

Her Royal Highness, Honorary Member, the Jockey Club, afterwards attended a Lunch at the Jockey Club Rooms, High Street, Newmarket, and was received by Mr. Andrew Merriam (Deputy Lieutenant of Suffolk).

And all that was of benefit to… who exactly?

akabluebell · 20/09/2022 10:42

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:40

@ExHack thank you! I don't understand why people instantly get sarcastic when a discussion is open. I just want to know what people think service and duty is and why that service and duty is still worth heredity wealth and status

The alternative is a President like Trump, but of course then it would be a political elected post, which I used to think would be better. Now I don't.

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:42

@FromageRouge anyway I won't be responding to you after this as I'm here for a discussion not an argument

OP posts:
StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 20/09/2022 10:42

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:29

@StrictlyAFemaleFemale but I'm really confused how all that is service and duty and still worth all that heredity wealth?

Teachers are not allowed to express political views to the children they teach.

We all had to follow COVID rules and have minimised funerals and weddings.

Many people attend church and remembrance events and dont see it as a "job"

The wealth and duty are 2 separate things.

The wealth as I understand it comes from the amount of land owned by the Crown. But you didn't ask about that in your op - you asked about duty.

I didn't say she was the only person to serve, so that's why you can find overlap with other professions such as teaching. Yes some people go to Church but only one is the head of it. The head cannot choose not to.

Furthermore all the other clergy and teachers and public servants get to retire. She kept going until 2 days before her death aged 96. That is extraordinary.

marcellen · 20/09/2022 10:42

averageavocado · 20/09/2022 10:19

Showing up to events, smiling, being nice to people when you would rather not be, eating food you probably dont like, when you're full but have to show willing, standing for hours while children sing the same song for the 500th time and looking interested, not nipping out to the corner shop when you feel like it, not getting hammered and photographed in weird questionable places (I'm thinking QE2 here), criticised for doing X,criticised for not doing X, criticised for thinking about doing X

Its obviously well paid, but not sure I'd actually want to do it

Love these examples - eating food you probably don't like 😂

People in this country are so sycophantic to the Royal Family it's beyond belief. Most people work hard, do service and fulfil duties...for considerably less money, privilege and usually no thanks!

Time to end monarchy!

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:41

FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:28

Go and goad someone who cares.

Trolling a dead nonagenarian who put the hours in , isn’t really to my taste. Even an immensely privileged nonagenarian.

You literally said trolling here

OP posts:
ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:40

@ExHack thank you! I don't understand why people instantly get sarcastic when a discussion is open. I just want to know what people think service and duty is and why that service and duty is still worth heredity wealth and status

OP posts:
FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:39

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:34

I find when people don't have an educated answer they go straight to "it's a troll!!". Why can't people just have a proper conversation for once and learn from each other rather than go straight into "troll" "goady"

You’re not going to get a decent discussion when you NC like that and word an OP like that.

But still nobody has called you a troll. You’re hallucinating.

HotDogKetchup · 20/09/2022 10:39

FruitPastilleNut · 20/09/2022 10:29

What I find remarkable is that I've not heard one anecdote or story about anything the Queen actually did that benefited her people. Literally not one.

You hear that she was a wonderful woman. That she served for 70 years. That she did her duty. That she was a wonder. A remarkable woman. A national treasure.

Never any specifics...just about her existence and how wonderful she was. It's quite fascinating when you tune into this fact and see it repeated on every news story, every interview of a member of the public.

I would hazard a guess that in the numerous interviews of the public yesterday, all going on about how wonderful she was...if the reporter had asked the question 'and what do you think her biggest achievement or greatest contribution was?' - most people would reply with the same guff about 70 years/great sense of humour/doing her duty/serving her Country. Never specifics.

Yes and with that it’s not difficult to see why OP isn’t clear either.

ExHack · 20/09/2022 10:38

I think people are purposely being obtuse. @FromageRouge I agree!
Is anyone capable of discussing this intelligently rather than repeating what they've heard on the media about "duty and service"?
Yes they attend a lot of meetings and openings and are very influential and attract tourists. Apart from those involved in the tourism industry, how does this improve life in Great Britain for the majority of citizens?

HotDogKetchup · 20/09/2022 10:37

FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:24

TBF she could look that up as easily as she could look up dictionary definitions.

Just a little bit suss to make change for this too.

I’m no monarchist, but even I can understand that HMQ worked hard for no (additional) personal gain. In the sane squaddies and clergy go above and beyond.

Mumsnet would be totally obsolete if we just googled everything rather than having a discussion…

walkingonsunshinekat · 20/09/2022 10:37

LadyHarmby · 20/09/2022 10:27

Sigh. Google ‘Court Circular’ and go to the website. Put in some dates and the royal of your choice and it’ll give you a list of what engagements and meetings they have. You can search retrospectively.

Yes but to what end?

What happens if this stuff didn't get done?

Does Parliament need a state opening etc etc etc

The Monarch signs off laws etc he or she may vehemently oppose, such as shutting down the 'Commons or allegedly Brexit.

K.Charles environmental speeches hasn't stopped sewage being dumped in rivers and waterways or the UK breaking international air pollution treaties.

So what if no one met the King of Saudi Arabia, has meeting him stopped his country bombing women n children in Yemen with uk made weapons?

Service and duty are just meaningless phrases bandied about by pro royalists.

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:34

I find when people don't have an educated answer they go straight to "it's a troll!!". Why can't people just have a proper conversation for once and learn from each other rather than go straight into "troll" "goady"

OP posts:
akabluebell · 20/09/2022 10:34

The head of state has weekly meetings with the PM. They are briefed daily by their staff as to what's in the red box which I think is delivered every day. Also briefed on new laws as there is a requirement for Head of State to sign off all new laws. Constitutionally it's a grey area as to whether HoS can refuse to sign off a law. It's an interesting question.

They also entertain visiting dignitaries, undertake visits to their patronages, and undertake overseas tours as required by the PM. Check the court circular, some of it's in there.

ExHack · 20/09/2022 10:34

I think the late Queen was a good example of the "ultimate celebrity" from a time when such people were not as numerous. Everyone in the world knew who she was, saw her photos in the media, knew all about her life and family… She was glamourous and wore amazing outfits. And the fact that she had some admirable qualities and spoke of the hoi polloi as "her people" made her all the more likeable.
Does it all serve any purpose apart from encouraging tourism and selling magazines? A good question. Perhaps she inspired or set an example of good behaviour in those that admired her. I don't really know.

FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:33

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:31

@FromageRouge I'm not trolling anyone and I never mention Queen Elizabeth specifically, there are other royals apart from her and what do they do?
I find just accusing someone of "trolling" after they ask a question to be telling. I'm not arguing with anyone, just interested in what this service and duty is and like I said, willing to be educated.
But I won't continue to respond to you

I didn’t say you were trolling. I said you were goading.

Why else would you NC?

Ponoka7 · 20/09/2022 10:33

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:18

@LadyHarmby but once again that's probably most of the population in the world doing things they don't want to do but have to do to make a living

But we do it because that's life, they do what they do because it's what is expected. It is like being in a cult. Do you know the schedule of the monarch? Reading all the papers, reading the previous day's parliamentary business, meeting with the PM, other dignitaries etc.
Going to world meetings, summits etc keeps the UK relevant. We aren't as great or important as we think. The royal pomp is the one thing that only we do. The royal women showcase British fashion and their individual interest, horseracing etc. The rich middle easterns among others like to be associated with our royalty. This raises the profile of holidaying, shopping, sending their children to school etc in the UK. There's a whole code of conduct from birth until death which I suppose is duty and service. Opening up Balmoral will raise the profile of that area and make money, create jobs for a lot of people.

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:33

Can I highlight, I'm not just talking about Queen Elizabeth here. What do William and Catherine do that equates to service and duty?

OP posts:
SingaporeSlinky · 20/09/2022 10:33

It doesn’t take much to Google what the Queen did. You say showing up to events and opening stuff as if it’s easy. But she apparently planted around 1,500 trees in her lifetime, had to tour hospitals, schools, charities and meet people, shake hands, pretend to be interested in them, listen to explanations of their work, make endless small talk. Hosting dignitaries, being involved in the menus and being up to speed on politics. There was the daily red box of papers. Writing letters, cards, all those 100th birthday telegrams. Opening parliament. Investitures. Speeches.

Of course it was a life of privilege and she got to enjoy her passion for horses etc but a lot of it was probably very tedious. And I’m sure a lot of planning goes on behind the scenes to make sure royal tours go well, the outfits, the literal dressing, the nods to hosts. It doesn’t just happen.

FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:33

@LadyHarmby you’ll waste hours C&Ping that stuff. OP is only here to goad. Look at the username.

The idea that “duty and service” is a royal-specific notion is so elitist and OP doesn’t seem to have noticed s/he is buying into it.

mamabear715 · 20/09/2022 10:31

Well just as a START she went through the Govt red boxes EVERY DAY. I think she had two days off per year from that.