Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...so what exactly is "service and duty"?

266 replies

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:14

After countless threads on the royal family, I feel nobody goes into full detail of what the royal family do apart from the same phrase "service and duty".

I genuinely would like to be enlightened on what this "service and duty" is, not including showing up to events and waving, watching tennis and rugby matches, opening places, having an expensive wedding sometimes etc.

I feel nobody has really answered in detail what it is.

I am open to being educated if I'm missing something.

OP posts:
Namenic · 20/09/2022 11:13

I think one of the big achievements of the queen was behaving in a way most people thought was ‘acceptable’ and not saying or doing anything outrageous over a long life. She also attended long functions and met people when she might not have felt like it.

I’m sure I would have done quite a few things the public disapproved of - and if so, the press would have magnified it and I’d probably be quite upset about what social media say. I’d personally not swap my life for one of the royals.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 20/09/2022 11:13

Meetings, greetings, eating things you might not like.

Sounds very similar to the Kardashians to me.
(Perhaps less eating though)

Topgub · 20/09/2022 11:13

Such defensiveness rather than actually admitting the truth

🤣

wincarwoo · 20/09/2022 11:11

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:33

Can I highlight, I'm not just talking about Queen Elizabeth here. What do William and Catherine do that equates to service and duty?

Look it up.

Mamamia7962 · 20/09/2022 11:11

Exhack - Charles and Camilla don't carry out 2000 engagements a year, that would be impossible, that's the royals as a team.

The Queen was 'brand UK.' She played a large part in the billions that the UK made every year from tourism and also in lurury goods expo

wincarwoo · 20/09/2022 11:10

FruitPastilleNut · 20/09/2022 10:29

What I find remarkable is that I've not heard one anecdote or story about anything the Queen actually did that benefited her people. Literally not one.

You hear that she was a wonderful woman. That she served for 70 years. That she did her duty. That she was a wonder. A remarkable woman. A national treasure.

Never any specifics...just about her existence and how wonderful she was. It's quite fascinating when you tune into this fact and see it repeated on every news story, every interview of a member of the public.

I would hazard a guess that in the numerous interviews of the public yesterday, all going on about how wonderful she was...if the reporter had asked the question 'and what do you think her biggest achievement or greatest contribution was?' - most people would reply with the same guff about 70 years/great sense of humour/doing her duty/serving her Country. Never specifics.

She's a world recognised icon. She has a role in the constitution. Charities benefit from royal patronage.

Topgub · 20/09/2022 11:10

Its baffling to me that people are so desperate to believe that these people are some how special or deserving of the adoration.

I guess if they admitted the truth they'd have to face how much of an idiot you were.

mamabear715 · 20/09/2022 11:10

Best reply I've seen, @ideasmirrour
I love the monarchy so our choices are very different, but that was a very measured & well thought out post.
(Wish I'd written it!) ;-)

Dinoteeth · 20/09/2022 11:09

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:46

@Arenanewbie yes the duties as all I ever see in the media is visits, watching sports, opening etc. that I wanted clarification whether I was "missing" something in terms of "hard work"

The bits you don't see are them meeting the PM every week, never discussing what is said in those meetings. Questioning what is happening in country, what can Gov do about it.
Going though government papers every day.
International relations, meeting other heads of state, to encourage good relations and trade links.

Going to meetings with people you don't actually like, but always being nice and kind to them. Hosting visitors.

State banquets sound great lots of food, but you need to make conversation with people to make and build relationships. That's not always easy.

wincarwoo · 20/09/2022 11:08

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:21

Has anyone actually got a clear answer apart from

"What exactly are you asking?"

"Doing things there forced to do"

Many people these days HAVE to work until late 70s and even then when they retire they have a pittance of a state pension...

You need to look at the court circular. Also Google role of monarch in the British constitution.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 20/09/2022 11:08

Do you not know how to Google things OP? I guess it's a good thing you aren't our head of state.

walkingonsunshinekat · 20/09/2022 11:06

KimberleyClark · 20/09/2022 10:56

And how have the ordinary people of Commonwealth member states benefitted directly from it. Many members such as India and Jamaica are still hugely unequal societies.

The Commonwealth is just the UK's attempt at keeping an empire, hence we are still at the head of it.

As the UK and Europe face their biggest economic, if not military threat since WW2, who is India backing via sanction busting - Russia.

Says it all for the UK's soft power shit.

CulturePigeon · 20/09/2022 11:05

KimberleyClark · Today 10:58
HotDogKetchup · Today 10:54
Sorry her Uncle, but the sentiment remains that he didn’t want the job so was able to abdicate. So it’s not true that they have no choice.
He did want the job, he wanted to do it with the wife of his choice at his side. But this was impossible, so he decided he wanted Wallis more than he wanted to be king.

There's been an enormous amount of new info on the Abdication Crisis in recent years as new docs etc have come into the public domain. I suggest reading up on these - it's fascinating.

Basically, the story we've all been sold for more than half a century is not an accurate representation of the situation. Far from Wallis being the evil woman, holding on to Ed VIII (who was by all accounts, a dim, boring and needy chap - good-looking, but thick as trifle), she wanted out but ended up tied to him in some sort of myth about their devoted love.

Also, there's a lot of evidence to suggest that their Nazi sympathies were all too well-known to the RF and the govt, and frankly the govt needed an excuse to get rid. Lots of memos etc about this from the govt and royal officials about how disastrous he would have been as king.

He didn't want the job either. Totally selfish, trivial, vain and thick to do anything but dress elegantly, dance the foxtrot and sun himself on the Riviera...oh, and go and visit his mate Adolf, who was planning to set him up as a 'puppet' king when the Nazis took over Britain.

Thank goodness for George Vi!

Topgub · 20/09/2022 11:05

@FruitPastilleNut

I agree.

What have any of them actually done to improve the lives of their 'subjects'

wincarwoo · 20/09/2022 11:05

They help charities raise loads of money.

Arenanewbie · 20/09/2022 11:04

Some of them are not easy. You need to stand on heels or in a lighter clothes or walk long distances, you should look good and smile whatever you are feeling inside. And yes, you do have a lot of help but you need to put your feelings and worries aside, the scrutiny is much more worse then in other jobs. You can’t trust people as they might sell the story about your to newspapers.
I think there are always a question that you can’t put your own interests and your partner and kids first. Your outlook is always a bit different, you look at bigger picture.
Look at the late Queen, I’m sure she wanted to stay in bed that Tuesday but she was dragged out to see Boris and then Liz. At some point she maybe wanted to divorce but it wasn’t possible, there was constant worry about threats to her children. And she was judged constantly for everything. Princess Margaret couldn’t marry whom she wanted (I’m not saying that it’s a good choice but I’ve chosen my DH myself without parents involved). The same was with Charles.
I don’t think I would love this life. There a lot of plus points but they are mostly coming from being rich so being rich is good. And those who are rich but not royals enjoy their life much more imo.

Dreamstate · 20/09/2022 11:03

FruitPastilleNut · 20/09/2022 10:29

What I find remarkable is that I've not heard one anecdote or story about anything the Queen actually did that benefited her people. Literally not one.

You hear that she was a wonderful woman. That she served for 70 years. That she did her duty. That she was a wonder. A remarkable woman. A national treasure.

Never any specifics...just about her existence and how wonderful she was. It's quite fascinating when you tune into this fact and see it repeated on every news story, every interview of a member of the public.

I would hazard a guess that in the numerous interviews of the public yesterday, all going on about how wonderful she was...if the reporter had asked the question 'and what do you think her biggest achievement or greatest contribution was?' - most people would reply with the same guff about 70 years/great sense of humour/doing her duty/serving her Country. Never specifics.

Exactly what I was thinking as I watched the funeral. I know it was a state funeral but there was literally nothing, nothing about anything she has achieved in her role.

Namenic · 20/09/2022 11:03

I guess service and duty means that you have to think about more than just what you want to do even if you have the money and time to do it.

compare the royals to some rich family who have inherited wealth. They can choose what they want to wear or do and who to invite to dinner. Royals have some restrictions - some would say many restrictions. Some people say celebrities have mental health issues due to abuse on social media etc. royals have some of that.

Harry and William may or may not have wanted to walk behind their mum’s coffin and have their every moment photographed. Same with Louis and Charlotte. Royals probably didn’t like the press taking pictures of them over their teenage years or dissecting who they dated. King Charles may or may not have wanted to walk 1.5hrs through London or greet lots of dignitaries and make speeches after his mum has died (whether you think it is a useful thing or not, many people did turn out to watch etc).

I think what you are saying OP is that compared to the positives they have, the royals don’t have to do that much. The key is who you compare them to. Compare them to some of the rich list people in U.K. or compare them to the average or poor person? But then what if you compare the poor person in U.K. to someone in a war zone or developing country?

akabluebell · 20/09/2022 11:03

The comment about upholding the class system is an interesting one. I used to think like that and was very much a republican however the House of Lords have stopped some pretty stupid crap from the Commons getting into law. The fact that H of L are theoretically apolitical is a very good thing.

You only have to see what happened with Brexit to realise giving ordinary people a vote about something of which they know nothing is really not a good idea . . ..

Crikeyalmighty · 20/09/2022 11:02

As someone who lives in Windsor I am not anti monarchy. I am extremely anti the fact it seems to be used as a 'look how amazing we do pageantry etc ' and cover up the fact that there are so many issues in the UK unless you are wealthy or old with housing paid for and good pensions. I think service and duty is basically just an overarching term for the list of 'commitments' that comes with monarchy . The town wasn't full of people 'paying respects ' it was full of people having a day out , taking selfies and sat on castle walls eating chips .

NoodleSnow · 20/09/2022 11:02

I saw Charles and Camilla at a theatre once (a few years before they were married). They were clearly attempting to be as low profile as possible, sitting in circle seats with a few security staff nearby, rather than a box or anything. People gave them a round of applause as they left the circle at the interval. It’s a theatre interval - you’re either going for a drink or a wee! It looked excruciatingly uncomfortable for them to have that unwanted attention.

ideasmirrour · 20/09/2022 11:01

I’m a republican myself, but it’s a hard job — do you spend several hours a day reading parliamentary business, dictating and writing letters, signing paperwork, and being briefed on diplomatic news and the schedule for the day’s and week’s events as well as memorising the details of the main people you’ll be meeting or telephoning that day? Every day with few days off all your life?

It’s not that dissimilar to the working duties of, say, a politician or ambassador, a CEO of a charity, a head of state in any other country, or anyone who is the nominal head of business in a major state or public institution. Do you know what a CEO in business or a charity does? Or people working in the civil or diplomatic service, for example?

Disagree with constitutional monarchy all you like — there are plenty of reasons not to agree with it. But pretending that it isn’t a bloody hard job with long hours and pretty much no time off is just childish.

HotDogKetchup · 20/09/2022 11:01

KimberleyClark · 20/09/2022 10:58

He did want the job, he wanted to do it with the wife of his choice at his side. But this was impossible, so he decided he wanted Wallis more than he wanted to be king.

Yes so he was able to make that choice. He was not forced to be King against his will. There was a choice. That was my point. Harry has walked away.

Topgub · 20/09/2022 11:01

@LadyHarmby

Is that supposed to be an example of a hard day's work ?

You know Dumfries House is his house too, right?

Yeahrepublic · 20/09/2022 11:00

FromageRouge · 20/09/2022 10:18

Don’t you have a dictionary? Or are you completely unfamiliar with the culture? I don’t understand what it is you’re asking.

I agree with the OP. What exactly do they do? People talk about hardworking royals but what does that really look like?

Yes they do these huge trips that take them away from home but they're still just shaking hands and going to dinners.