Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...so what exactly is "service and duty"?

266 replies

ServiceAndDuty · 20/09/2022 10:14

After countless threads on the royal family, I feel nobody goes into full detail of what the royal family do apart from the same phrase "service and duty".

I genuinely would like to be enlightened on what this "service and duty" is, not including showing up to events and waving, watching tennis and rugby matches, opening places, having an expensive wedding sometimes etc.

I feel nobody has really answered in detail what it is.

I am open to being educated if I'm missing something.

OP posts:
walkingonsunshinekat · 20/09/2022 15:30

@Mamma80 All what you list is intangibles, esp "generates more wealth etc" 4x as many people go to french palaces than UK palaces and with no Royals, they d be more open = more visitors.

D of E yes thats a great scheme but tbh you could call it anything, so long as it had the funding, after all D of E will carrying on now he has gone.

Reassures? a great help with millions of families in poverty, must be a great comfort.

KC wont slim it down, no one votes for their own demise.

Mamma80 · 20/09/2022 14:40

Embassador for our country and the commonwealth.
Reassures the country in times of need
The most experienced impartial politician we have.
Generates more income into the country than they are paid.
Custodian on palaces and jewels (not owner)
Supresses their own choices and opinions
Restricted movement (cant go out whenever they want)
Arranges and Writes 100s of letters to people who have reached out to them to provide comfort.
Understands what the people want from the monarchy, the importance of them turning up and what they do.
Hundreds of public engagements to endorce charities for good in our society.
Ceremonial duties.

Opens parliament
Red box daily.
Councils elected officials
Charles will be his own king, but in terms of the queen she has loved a privileged life but also a restricted one. Shes carried out over 21000 engagements in her 70 years, if you worked 5 days a week that's more than 1 a day for 70 years. Dont underestimate the importance of those visits.
Indirect diplomacy (undertaken by most countries)

Charles pre covid did 521 engagements 2019.
Thats not easy and most people his age are retired.

But above all, look at the spectacle of the last 10 days, it makes me proud to be brotish, its our national identity and our Unique selling point as a country for many around the world.

Yes its wrong we have children in poverty but If you sold it all off tomorrow its a drop in the ocean and the problem lies in other places. Oil company profits ect ect. And I genuinely believe we would be worst off without the Royal family and they bring more to the table than they take. King Charles in particular has been vocal about sliming that down as they adjust and modernise.

Look also at the things they have done with the princess trust and the Duke of Edinburgh scheme.

BrownOwlknowsbest · 20/09/2022 14:36

This will give you an idea of the late Queen's daily work thecrownchronicles.co.uk/explanation/a-day-in-the-life-of-the-queen-her-daily-routine/

ideasmirrour · 20/09/2022 14:18

The other issue is that you can structure constitutional arrangements all you like; but they may come out with rather different effects in practice.

We have a monarch who is also head of an established church. Yet we have one of the most apolitical head of state roles and one of the most secular public spheres on the globe, maybe bar none.

Compare the US with an elected head of state and formal separation of powers — and yet, as the supreme court has recently shown us, far closer to being a theocracy than almost any other developed nation.

Think of it another way — why did so many commonwealth nations retain the queen as head of state? It isn’t just because of tradition, or because somehow they loved being colonised. It’s because she performed a very useful constitutional function that it would cost a lot to replicate “in-house”, as it were. You might think that in itself is probably wrong — and I would agree. But getting rid of one head of state and trying to replicate those functions in a different form is costly and difficult. And you may not end up with something you like that much at the end, either. That’s not to say you shouldn’t — but pretending that the head of state doesn’t really do anything is just silly. You can, of course, make it so that they don’t do anything. But then you have to have other people who do the job instead.

fallinover · 20/09/2022 14:17

Yes I know all that, I’m trying to understand why people think we are a better country for having a monarchy.

Logically it makes little sense but in practice it seems to work better than the alternatives.

A symbolic head of state enables pomp and patriotic feelings to be expressed with minimal political misuse.

Also I think power is usually best given to those who don't want it, a hereditary monarch fits that.

Wheelyweddingwipedout · 20/09/2022 14:13

@ServiceAndDuty havent read the whole thread so apologies if someone has already suggested this book to you - What do you do?

Clavinova · 20/09/2022 14:10

Topgub
Charles couldn't even lift a pen

He can lift a paintbrush;

2016
Prince Charles has been revealed as one of Britain’s most successful living artists after raising millions of pounds for charity by selling prints of his paintings.
Copies have been sold through the shop at his family residence, Highgrove House, and since 1997 the watercolour paintings have brought in £2million for The Prince of Wales’s Charitable Foundation.
Added to that is the estimation by an art dealer who previously handled sales of the Prince’s lithographs that they raised at least £4million.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3431159/Prince-Charles-revealed-one-Britain-s-successful-living-artists-new-figures-sold-6m-works.html

www.thenationalnews.com/arts-culture/art/2022/02/04/moroccan-landscape-features-in-first-full-exhibition-of-watercolours-by-prince-charles/

edition.cnn.com/style/article/prince-charles-paintings-watercolors/index.html

2bazookas · 20/09/2022 14:01

The searchable court circular is freely available on line

www.royal.uk/court-circular

ideasmirrour · 20/09/2022 13:44

Why do you think she would “come away with no actions”?

Is an actor not doing a job because the performance itself is the task? Or a diplomat not doing a job if s/he is chairing a meeting where other people are briefing him or her just for information? Are they not working while they are hosting a dinner where they are expected to memorise the role of every attendee and put them at ease? Isn’t that part of the job rather than some kind of “perk”?

The entire point is that head of state isn’t a role much like anything else. A diplomat is probably the closest comparison, but it’s not exactly right either. I think however that pretending it isn’t actually a job and does nothing is sneery and ignorant.

Many governance roles across all of the public and private sector might seem surplus to you, but actually performing them is still work. I’m of the mind that we should have a constitutional elected head of state myself; but I’m not foolish enough to believe this wouldn’t be a pretty onerous job — probably devolving a lot of work also to the church, the civil service, the diplomatic service and an elected second chamber in order to make it work — and the entire edifice would cost a fortune to run.

NicolaSixSix · 20/09/2022 13:40

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/09/2022 13:17

I'm very sorry to hear that, and it isn't right for a society not to support people with caring responsibilities. We have far too big a gap between rich and poor, and it should be a real mark of shame not to pay tax. However, I'm guessing this was some time ago, given he was your great-uncle. Life expectancy has gone up a lot in recent decades. I hope things would be a bit better now. Most people have some entitlement to sick pay or benefits in those circumstances.

The exact same - not able to take time off because they wouldn’t be paid for it, and end up dead during a work shift - could happen today to:

your Uber driver.
your Just Eat delivery person.
your Amazon worker.
the pub worker who is doing a shift there via an agency.
those on zero hour contracts up and down the country.
any person who is self employed, eg an accountant, or a cleaner. Someone in a different thread, who is self employed, detailed how their cancelled operation yesterday wreaked havoc with their health and business.

please also double check how much some of the companies above have paid in tax.

when it is pointed out that the UK has fewer BHs than any other european country, people are quick to mention the cost of a BH. This one was sudden (and all the problems that come with it - see above, eg cancelled operations), the cost was stratospheric, yet not only completely acceptable, apparently, people also tie themselves in knots to explain it.

like the subjects that we are, we should unquestionably bow to our betters. In 2022.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/09/2022 13:38

Mental gymnastics! Grin Well, I'm a long way past the ordinary kind, that's for sure.

Inherited wealth and privilege - look no further than David Cameron, George Osborne, Boris Johnson and a fair number of other top Tory politicians. Tony Blair didn't pull himself up by his bootstraps either.

As for where to find the wealthy bankers etc, there are plenty here on MN. I often see posts saying 'I earn a six figure salary in the City/accountancy/management consultancy/Magic Circle law firm/other unspecified "senior role" ', or their partner does, or both.

stripeyzeb · 20/09/2022 13:37

From my perspective, they're born into an inherited role they didn't ask for and opting out isn't really an option (not without huge consequences). So for me, 'duty and service' is attending endless mini ceremonies and shaking hands and talking to people and flying all over the place in the days after your mum has died, when frankly most of us would rather sit at home and cry. Service and duty is acknowledging that your life isn't your own and you can't just pop to the or out for a walk and you're probably never going to have genuine friends (other than the ones on your staff). It's accepting the role you didn't ask for and putting the country's needs ahead of your own,

And yes, it comes with enormous privilege but the price is living in a protected bubble constantly until the day you die. I'm not a royalist but I recognise particularly in the last 10 days that their ethos seems to have been 'country first, family second'. It's more than I could have done.

thesurrealist · 20/09/2022 13:30

I do enjoy the mental gymnastics of people trying to defend these people with comparisons to CEOs and the PM etc.

It's really not the same.
As anti-Tory as I am, I very much doubt that Liz Truss just turns up to a meeting and comes away with no actions.
The Royal Family have vast amounts of inherited wealth and despite the really really hard work of some people on this thread.....no one can give examples of how they actually benefit this country.
Hey ho, just about time to read my papers for the next meeting.

5128gap · 20/09/2022 13:30

Some people, for reasons I don't personally understand, have a need to consider there are people who were born to be better than them. They have a need to exalt someone to a status above the ordinary, for no other reason than their birth, then imagine that individual is caring for and guiding them. These people feel huge gratitude and appreciation for a word, a handshake, a speech at Christmas, so will consider even the most minimal contribution, smallest inconvenience or basic courtesy from someone royal a great service. So even if they explained what they mean by it, it may not meet your own definition.

JamSandle · 20/09/2022 13:29

The Queen stepped into the role and made it her own. Imo she lived and breathed the role ever since.

Her duty was probably providing future heirs, following rules and protocol and being a dependable figure.

Whether people like Royal Families or not, the Queen is quite universally admired for how she took up the mantel and represented the country on the world stage, especially in her engagements with other world leaders.

SudokuMania · 20/09/2022 13:29

The Royal family are Public Relations people.
I don't really understand what PR involves but it's counted as a real job.

NicolaSixSix · 20/09/2022 13:28

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/09/2022 13:12

The Royal Family don't have a monopoly on celebrity status and money. The Duke of Westminster is the richest person in the country, possibly after the monarch. Where's the vitriol directed at him? Plenty of people making obscene amounts of money in the City, and giving nothing back to this country. A good many of them got there through school and family connections.

because there are loads of people who haven’t earned their advantages we shouldn’t not criticise some of them?

are you sure there is no vitriol directed at bankers and the like?

2 wrongs doesn’t make a right,

etc.

Anyway, let me know where I can find them and I’ll let rip to their faces what I think of them and their unearned privilege.

Sorted

LadyKenya · 20/09/2022 13:24

Dinoteeth · 20/09/2022 11:49

There must have been times she's come out of those meetings fuming but not been able to rant it off.

Thats dedication!

No that is diplomacy.

nokidshere · 20/09/2022 13:22

I find all these royal threads bizarre. However the 'inherited wealth' gets brought up all the time. There isn't a single person on Mumsnet, or probably in the country, who would inherit a fortune and say 'no sorry I don't want it, give it to someone else'. Not one. And anyone who says they would Is a liar.

Even the wealthy who give lots away still make sure they can fund their own lifestyle first.

thesurrealist · 20/09/2022 13:22

Mamamia7962 · 20/09/2022 12:30

The Prince's Trust has helped a lot of ordinary people.

So he set up a charity.....

What doe she actually do in that charity?

LadyKenya · 20/09/2022 13:19

KimberleyClark · 20/09/2022 10:56

And how have the ordinary people of Commonwealth member states benefitted directly from it. Many members such as India and Jamaica are still hugely unequal societies.

This.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/09/2022 13:17

thesurrealist · 20/09/2022 13:12

The Queen worked until two days before her death, at 96

My great uncle died whilst at work. He was 60. He hadn't been feeling well for the last few days, but couldn't take time off sick because he wouldn't have been paid - and he and my great aunt didn't have any other income because she was a carer for their disabled adult son.

I'm very sorry to hear that, and it isn't right for a society not to support people with caring responsibilities. We have far too big a gap between rich and poor, and it should be a real mark of shame not to pay tax. However, I'm guessing this was some time ago, given he was your great-uncle. Life expectancy has gone up a lot in recent decades. I hope things would be a bit better now. Most people have some entitlement to sick pay or benefits in those circumstances.

ideasmirrour · 20/09/2022 13:17

thesurrealist · 20/09/2022 12:55

Ok, so the meetings. On average I have about 5 a day. Did Charles have to do any of the following (which my administrator and I have to do for every meeting):

Go through diaries to find a suitable date, set up a doodle poll to find a date, go back to diaries for more dates
Decide the agenda and ask people for items for that agenda
Prepare the agenda and send it out to everyone coming to the meeting along with the invitation
If face to face find a room and book it and, if necessary book coffee/tea/water
Go through the action log for the last meeting and chase people for reports/updates/presentations
make sure all actions from last meeting are completed/if not then identify why not
Write reports/updates/presentations for meeting
Arrange and have pre-meets if a briefing is needed eg if there is a conflict to resolve and an agreed approach needed
Get to meeting under own steam and on time if F2F, deal with panicked phone calls from people getting lost/stuck in traffic/train cancelled
If virtual, deal with technical issues
Chair the meeting
Contribute to meeting and take on actions
Remind people that they are on mute/delays when people are frozen on screen/can't screen share
Take minutes
Deal with the one person who always saves the really complicated and urgent issue until AOB
Clear up the room
Deal with the people who hang around at the end of the meeting chatting
Go to next meeting and making sure you've got all the paperwork needed and have had time to read it
Type up minutes and send them out
Rinse and repeat for the next time

Or does he just rock up and sit there, being waited on and then bog off at the end without even clearning his coffee cup?

Well, yes; she probably had to do a bit of that, though not all.

What do you suppose an Ambassador does, for example? It’s a role that is similarly situated somewhere between an executive and a ceremonial role — it’s both. You live “over the shop”, being available as a host as well as being an employer. A lot of what most people regard as “free” time are instead actually spent on the job or performing ceremonial duties. But you also spend a lot of time reading paperwork and minutes, being briefed on things you need to know about. When you host an event you must behave impeccably, including knowing everyone who’s coming, memorising a brief biography of them each beforehand, and being able to talk to each of them about their work. People report to you, but they also work for you, and so you manage them too.

The Queen usually was on trips to public events, often overnight or for two nights, every ten days as well as everything else.

Plus reading all the parliamentary papers each day. Can’t skip them because you do need to sign them. And even though our head of state is not formally an executive role like the POTUS, it’s not purely ceremonial either. It’s somewhere in the middle — deliberately so.

Charles — who I don’t especially like, to be honest — reportedly works for large parts of the day, skipping lunch, and including four hours of paperwork and correspondence each night.

Plus the monarch is also the head of the CofE, and has a not merely ceremonial role there. Fancy going to church at least a couple of times each week, all your life, and never skipping it unless you’re pretty gravely ill? I don’t.

As I say, I’m not a monarchist. I don’t like the cushion of inherited wealth, nor the class system; and the monarchy has a fair number of monstrously thick hangers-on siphoning up money and privilege.

But I also recognise that it is a pretty gruelling job which never goes away. I wouldn’t like to do it. I think it’s probably a racing certainty that Elizabeth was an old-fashioned workaholic, and the service and duty thing was part of that.

But she certainly didn’t have nothing to do but swan about all day; and if we got rid of the monarchy and replaced it with a different kind of Head of State model, there would be a lot of work that needed doing for the role, and it would also be extremely expensive (take a look at the expenses of the French presidency, for example).

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/09/2022 13:12

NicolaSixSix · 20/09/2022 13:08

Difference is that these other people you mention don’t get idolised, don’t get a life of immense privilege just because they were born, in a country so rich but that also allows children to go hungry

The Royal Family don't have a monopoly on celebrity status and money. The Duke of Westminster is the richest person in the country, possibly after the monarch. Where's the vitriol directed at him? Plenty of people making obscene amounts of money in the City, and giving nothing back to this country. A good many of them got there through school and family connections.

thesurrealist · 20/09/2022 13:12

The Queen worked until two days before her death, at 96

My great uncle died whilst at work. He was 60. He hadn't been feeling well for the last few days, but couldn't take time off sick because he wouldn't have been paid - and he and my great aunt didn't have any other income because she was a carer for their disabled adult son.