Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quieter coach on train, shouldn’t it be quiet?

89 replies

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 08:40

Fairly lengthy train journeys recently, we booked the quieter coach well in advance, because we like to read or quietly look at the scenery. On the outward journey there was a man holding various face time conversations quite loudly. The woman sitting in her booked seat next to him was getting really fed up, and eventually moved. The younger guy behind us kept playing bits of music on his phone.

Coming home, the first part of the journey was bliss. We changed trains, and the two passengers behind never stopped yakking loudly. Why would anyone book a seat in a quiet coach only to be noisy? No staff around once the tickets were checked, and we are older and don’t wish to risk a confrontation. Twenty years ago my younger and healthier DH might have said something, but not now.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 12:14

Not sure the behaviour is any better in Germany - I had to tell a German guy off when travelling from Cologne to Brussels for systematically going through every ring tone on this phone. He told me the world didn't revolve around me, but he did stop doing it in the end.

DialSquare · 20/09/2022 12:14

Whilst mouse cancelling headphones might be quite handy in some situations, I obviously meant to type noise cancelling!

DialSquare · 20/09/2022 12:12

smooththecat · 20/09/2022 11:36

I know I sound about 100 years old, but people don’t know how to behave in public any more.

This. I take my mouse cancelling headphones everywhere and put white noise on my phone. I can then sit and watch the world go by without having to listen to inconsiderate arseholes playing their phones out loud or shouting at each other when having a conversation.

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 12:11

tulips27 · 20/09/2022 10:52

Instead of a quiet coach could the standard be quiet and all the noisy people can go in the "noisy coach" and Facetime and place music and Youtube on speaker to their heart's content, please?

Exactly this!

I usually find the quiet carriage is ok on commuter trains (you get the odd man who thinks the world will stop turning if he doesn't make his Very Important Call for the whole carriage to hear but it's rare). But any other time, forget it. Non-commuters see no need to even try to be quiet.

whatsup00 · 20/09/2022 12:04

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 11:42

She wasn’t loud and she wasn’t stood up. She was being a normal human being - talking, playing with her toys, reading her book etc.

She wasn’t being naughty, she just wasn’t silent. Because it’s not the silent carriage, as much as you may wish it were.

But I think the point is that you got into the quiet coach and then stated:

"DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet"

She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

Why? You know you're in a quiet carriage yet your family's preferences are put before everyone else in there? Surely if you don't teach children that sometimes you need to be quiet they just grow up to be inconsiderate adults who think their own needs trump everyone elses? It just seems really rude. Well, it doesn't just seem rude. It is rude. It's basically just saying I'll do what I want, screw everyone else. It sounds like it wouldn't fly in Germany and Japan though, where there is more respect for the public.

listsandbudgets · 20/09/2022 11:59

I've been put in the quiet coach before without choosing it. Usually when you book there's an option to be in ot bit not one NOT to be

That was fun woth 2 year-old DS. The train was crowded and everyone in the coach hated me

PuttingDownRoots · 20/09/2022 11:44

When DID it become apparently socially acceptable to listen to music/watch films etc without headphones on public transport.

No one wants to hear Peppa Pig for example... yet I've been on transport with competing episodes from different families.

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 11:42

RaRaRaspoutine · 20/09/2022 11:00

Well I have told children to be quiet and sit down before. If you won't parent then I'll do it.

She wasn’t loud and she wasn’t stood up. She was being a normal human being - talking, playing with her toys, reading her book etc.

She wasn’t being naughty, she just wasn’t silent. Because it’s not the silent carriage, as much as you may wish it were.

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 11:37

mamabear715 · 20/09/2022 08:45

I'd mention it when staff come round, but probably not directly, although I'd probably be passive-aggressive huffing & puffing quite a bit..

After our tickets were checked, never saw a member of staff! For most of us its just common courtesy. Above every pair of seats there was a sign, it was mentioned in the spiel about the train.

@tulips27 I love your suggestion of a noisy coach! 🥳

OP posts:
smooththecat · 20/09/2022 11:36

I know I sound about 100 years old, but people don’t know how to behave in public any more.

Ronbo · 20/09/2022 11:14

Read this and weep:

www.jrailpass.com/blog/japan-train-etiquette

"Eating in public or while walking is not a common practice in Japan. You should eat on trains only when taking a long-distance train"

"Never talk on your phone while on the train, unless using the designated phone area of the shinkansen. Silence and use headphones so that your media cannot be heard by others."

"While you may be accustomed to chatting with your traveling companions while using public transportation, this is not the norm in Japan. Loud chatter or other disturbance is considered rude."

User135644 · 20/09/2022 11:00

I don't think a lot of people are even capable of being quiet anymore.

RaRaRaspoutine · 20/09/2022 11:00

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 10:05

We ended up in the quiet carriage with our toddler a few months back. We didn’t book seats there, weren’t any available to book, it was just the only carriage with free seats.

We didn’t realise it was the quiet carriage until DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet.

She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

Well I have told children to be quiet and sit down before. If you won't parent then I'll do it.

Brefugee · 20/09/2022 10:56

We didn’t realise it was the quiet carriage until DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet.
She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

FFS. You're the type of person that causes stress for people who book the quiet carriage for a reason. Yes your DD may not have been disturbing anyone. But your assertion that you wouldn't have tried to stop her screaming and running down the train is typical of selfish behaviour that people are complaining about here. Quiet means quiet talking is fine. Screaming and running about not ok. "appease someone else" - lovely.

And you may not like to try that in Germany. You will be told to stand in the corridor or the gap between the trains.

RaRaRaspoutine · 20/09/2022 10:53

Yes but people are selfish and suffer from main character syndrome. The tinny music makes me want to murder the perps. Even worse are the fucking rugby oafs that have conversations about their, I don't know, erectile dysfunction or whatever at 90 fucking decibels. And people on the phone performing their conversation for the benefit of everyone, argh.

tulips27 · 20/09/2022 10:52

Instead of a quiet coach could the standard be quiet and all the noisy people can go in the "noisy coach" and Facetime and place music and Youtube on speaker to their heart's content, please?

lanthanum · 20/09/2022 10:29

We also ended up with reserved seats in a quiet carriage when we were travelling on a family railcard. As it happened, DD was asleep, so it was no problem, but I did feel that we shouldn't have been allocated to that carriage.

LIZS · 20/09/2022 10:29

ThatsNotMyMuffin · 20/09/2022 10:06

We've accidentally been booked into a quiet coach recently with two kids under 5 (had to input the ages). When we queried this with the conductor he said the quiet coach doesn't really mean anything, and is randomly assigned seats if someone doesn't choose one.

You can review the auto allocation and change them but agree ut should be more prominently flagged.

Natty13 · 20/09/2022 10:27

I get a long train journey 3 or 4 times a year and always book for the travel coach. I can count on one hand the amount of times I HAVEN'T had to ask someone to be quiet in the last 2 years.

I hate confrontation but I hate sitting there with my blood boiling and my peace ruined even more.

HopingNotCoping · 20/09/2022 10:11

I accidentally got on the quiet coach with my 3 & 5 year old a few weeks back. Guess I was too busy wrangling them & bags/stopping them causing chaos to notice the stickers until after we sat down.

As soon as I noticed, I told the children we should move and up we get, only for five year old to start asking spectacularly loudly 'But why do we have to move? What's a quiet carriage? WHY?! AM I NOT BEING QUIET MUMMY? IS THIS QUIET?? WHY DO WE HAVE TO MOVE!!!?' as I slowly manoeuvred them out. 😂

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/09/2022 10:06

Because they’re inconsiderate gits.

ThatsNotMyMuffin · 20/09/2022 10:06

We've accidentally been booked into a quiet coach recently with two kids under 5 (had to input the ages). When we queried this with the conductor he said the quiet coach doesn't really mean anything, and is randomly assigned seats if someone doesn't choose one.

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 10:05

We ended up in the quiet carriage with our toddler a few months back. We didn’t book seats there, weren’t any available to book, it was just the only carriage with free seats.

We didn’t realise it was the quiet carriage until DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet.

She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

Oblomov22 · 20/09/2022 10:00

Why on earth didn't you say something. "Please could you keep the noise down, this is the quiet coach". More fool you if you didn't.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/09/2022 09:57

I doesn’t mean silent, so I think people chatting to each other is fine - as long as not those loud, drunk conversations that people have, or people who seem to have to yell and exclaim every single thing.

Phone calls shouldn’t be happening though.