Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quieter coach on train, shouldn’t it be quiet?

89 replies

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 08:40

Fairly lengthy train journeys recently, we booked the quieter coach well in advance, because we like to read or quietly look at the scenery. On the outward journey there was a man holding various face time conversations quite loudly. The woman sitting in her booked seat next to him was getting really fed up, and eventually moved. The younger guy behind us kept playing bits of music on his phone.

Coming home, the first part of the journey was bliss. We changed trains, and the two passengers behind never stopped yakking loudly. Why would anyone book a seat in a quiet coach only to be noisy? No staff around once the tickets were checked, and we are older and don’t wish to risk a confrontation. Twenty years ago my younger and healthier DH might have said something, but not now.

OP posts:
User135644 · 20/09/2022 18:41

MadameMinimes · 20/09/2022 18:21

People should be quiet in the quiet carriage. Not totally silent but hushed voices, any talking kept to a minimum, no answering phones, definitely no shouting or playing music. To be honest I think it’s a shame that it isn’t the norm in all carriages. I think consideration for others is a good thing.

Japanese trains really are as quiet as described in that link. People are just very considerate of others and avoid doing anything that would disturb people.

Quiet carriages here are far noisier than just a normal Japanese carriage (although admittedly it was a while ago that I was last there) and from what I could see absolutely nobody answers the phone on a train there.

In a multiple carriage train there should be a designated carriage for taking phone calls and made clear on all carriages that headphones are required for listening to/watching devices.

Before mobile phones people just read books on trains. Now they have to have phone conversations.

Oysterbabe · 20/09/2022 18:31

I never book the quiet coach anymore. The noise is the same as everywhere else but I feel more angry about it.

JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 18:28

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 10:05

We ended up in the quiet carriage with our toddler a few months back. We didn’t book seats there, weren’t any available to book, it was just the only carriage with free seats.

We didn’t realise it was the quiet carriage until DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet.

She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

Yeah, she gets the wine spilled on her, and not the once only, then the quiet chat about how she’s adopted and her “mother” is off to sell her for sausages.

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 18:25

Mojoj · 20/09/2022 18:02

Quiet train means no mobiles. It doesn't mean no talking!

Not the odd word to each other but not a full blown conversation when you can go in a different carriage. The trains often have 12 carriages with 3 quiet ones, so it's not hard to find a space in one of the other 9. Sometimes they are really busy but then it's not quiet anyway.

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 18:24

Sorry to post twice - it said Just had to ask a passenger to use headphones and hence stop disturbing all the other passengers here in the ICE with her language learning app at full volume. The passenger was probably 60 years old. This annoying noise issue isn’t just something the young do!

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 18:24

Just saw this on Twitter and thought of this thread: twitter.com/jonworth/status/1572257980950913027

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 18:24

Just saw this on Twitter and thought of this thread: twitter.com/jonworth/status/1572257980950913027

MadameMinimes · 20/09/2022 18:21

People should be quiet in the quiet carriage. Not totally silent but hushed voices, any talking kept to a minimum, no answering phones, definitely no shouting or playing music. To be honest I think it’s a shame that it isn’t the norm in all carriages. I think consideration for others is a good thing.

Japanese trains really are as quiet as described in that link. People are just very considerate of others and avoid doing anything that would disturb people.

Quiet carriages here are far noisier than just a normal Japanese carriage (although admittedly it was a while ago that I was last there) and from what I could see absolutely nobody answers the phone on a train there.

Mojoj · 20/09/2022 18:02

Quiet train means no mobiles. It doesn't mean no talking!

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 17:54

carefullycourageous · 20/09/2022 16:09

This sounds bliss Smile

I do like British freedoms generally but there are far too many noisy arseholes on the trains.

Doesn’t it. I’m glad its not only me that gets fed up with lack of consideration. Headphones are the answer for next time.

OP posts:
CoffeeWithCheese · 20/09/2022 16:40

LIZS · 20/09/2022 09:41

That reminds me that of another trip recently, mid morning on a hot day, when we ran into a group on a Thameslink, probably youngish professionals who were presumably off to a festival or party, scantily dressed, loud, swigging from bottles and shots, standing as train was packed. For them the party had already started, for fellow travellers , many with children, it was very uncomfortable.

Used to be fairly normal when I commuted to the next city down for the Friday evening commuter time trains to be party-going groups working on getting shitfaced early.

The stag do dressed as Santa but with a bare chest and Tom Jones medallion who insisted on trying to conga down a standing room only crammed train was one particularly notable occasion.

I begged a car park permit and started driving.

mummyh2016 · 20/09/2022 16:26

@gatehouseoffleet struggling to see where I said we squealed and screamed? Unless there is another post mentioning a hen do of course, however I do appear to have missed it if that is the case.
We chatted however there were 10 of us so we weren't quiet. I got some laughs when I walked on with my 4ft inflatable penis though! The train was heaving though and apart from there being a sign saying quiet carriage you wouldn't have known it. The conductor told us it happened all the time.

carefullycourageous · 20/09/2022 16:09

Ronbo · 20/09/2022 11:14

Read this and weep:

www.jrailpass.com/blog/japan-train-etiquette

"Eating in public or while walking is not a common practice in Japan. You should eat on trains only when taking a long-distance train"

"Never talk on your phone while on the train, unless using the designated phone area of the shinkansen. Silence and use headphones so that your media cannot be heard by others."

"While you may be accustomed to chatting with your traveling companions while using public transportation, this is not the norm in Japan. Loud chatter or other disturbance is considered rude."

This sounds bliss Smile

I do like British freedoms generally but there are far too many noisy arseholes on the trains.

gatehouseoffleet · 20/09/2022 16:01

warmeduppizza · 20/09/2022 14:11

DH and I went to sit in a quiet carriage a while back. We quietly walked to a couple of seats and I asked him, “Shall we sit here?” This bloke across the aisle immediately stood up and shouted “No, you WON’T sit there if you’re going to be talking to each other, this is the QUIET carriage. Go somewhere else!” 🙄

I often think about saying that when noisy people get on chatting but am not cheeky enough to!

To respond to another post, even if you are on a hen do is it compulsory to scream and squeal? Could you just chat normally?

angeIica · 20/09/2022 14:56

SeaThingChild · 20/09/2022 14:15

I travel on trains a lot and I always thought the quiet carriage just meant you shouldn't use noisy electronic devices or take calls I don't think it means you can't talk and that children have to be silent. I don't sit there on purpose but trains are usually crowded and I have sat there by chance before with my kids. Wouldn't occur to me to stop them talking, it's always adults who spoil the train journeys I've been on, usually by being drunk, not kids chatting and being kids.

The trouble is that some see 'kids being kids' as letting them blast out whatever they're watching on their screens.

It doesn't bother me much, Years of commuting and the apathy, or resignation, has set in. Headphones help.

PornographicPriestess · 20/09/2022 14:17

I haven't read the full thread, so someone may already have mentioned this, but sometimes when you book a ticket you're assigned a seat on the quiet coach without asking for it. It happened to me when DC was little. A six hour trip to Scotland. We managed to find vacant seats elsewhere but that won't always be possible.

SeaThingChild · 20/09/2022 14:15

I travel on trains a lot and I always thought the quiet carriage just meant you shouldn't use noisy electronic devices or take calls I don't think it means you can't talk and that children have to be silent. I don't sit there on purpose but trains are usually crowded and I have sat there by chance before with my kids. Wouldn't occur to me to stop them talking, it's always adults who spoil the train journeys I've been on, usually by being drunk, not kids chatting and being kids.

warmeduppizza · 20/09/2022 14:11

DH and I went to sit in a quiet carriage a while back. We quietly walked to a couple of seats and I asked him, “Shall we sit here?” This bloke across the aisle immediately stood up and shouted “No, you WON’T sit there if you’re going to be talking to each other, this is the QUIET carriage. Go somewhere else!” 🙄

angeIica · 20/09/2022 13:59

It's supposed to be but it rarely is in my experience

Lcb123 · 20/09/2022 13:58

i usually book the quiet coach (do a lot of train travel), but rarely is it quiet. I have to say in a lot of trains it is really not made clear - just small stickers or signs. It should be made more obvious as I do think a lot of people don’t realise esp if they don’t travel on train much

mummyh2016 · 20/09/2022 13:23

We were put in the quiet coach on my hen do Blush my friend booked the tickets, she couldn't complete the transaction online so had to call to pay, she got chatting to the lady on the line who even asked why we were travelling. Got on the train to find this member of staff for some unknown reason had sat us in the quiet coach!

Brefugee · 20/09/2022 13:11

Not sure the behaviour is any better in Germany

it is. I travel on ICE trains a lot. More than a lot. And every time you're in a quiet carriage and someone makes a noise, another passenger will speak up. And if it doesn't stop more than one will. And then it stops.

The only time I've seen it not stop, the conductor told him to move, and the next station, since the chap then started being a bit verbally agressive and shouty, the transport police removed him. Not that it would come to this every time, but it's not beyond the bounds of belief. And for the PP who thinks her child shold be able to do what she likes: over here? you would be told in no uncertain terms that people have paid for quiet seats and to move. And it would be enforced by the conductor.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 20/09/2022 12:59

It's possible some people don't realise it's a quiet coach. I got assigned to one once and had no idea! I answered a call and the lady opposite sternly told me it was the quiet coach and I rather sheepishly ended the call and apologised. I think now I'm older I would have handled it differently (she was quite rude about it tbh, I'm sure because I was younger), but she was within her rights to inform me and expect me to step out.

As soon as one person starts making a load of noise others think it's okay to do the same as clearly it isn't observed/they don't know, it's just human nature. Always take headphones or earplugs on a public transport journey, always.

PearlWithTheGirlEarring · 20/09/2022 12:53

DialSquare · 20/09/2022 12:14

Whilst mouse cancelling headphones might be quite handy in some situations, I obviously meant to type noise cancelling!

mouse cancelling headphones

Now those could be an invention!!!

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 12:21

@whatsup00 It’s the quiet carriage, not the silent carriage.

So no, I won’t be keeping her silent.