Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quieter coach on train, shouldn’t it be quiet?

89 replies

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 08:40

Fairly lengthy train journeys recently, we booked the quieter coach well in advance, because we like to read or quietly look at the scenery. On the outward journey there was a man holding various face time conversations quite loudly. The woman sitting in her booked seat next to him was getting really fed up, and eventually moved. The younger guy behind us kept playing bits of music on his phone.

Coming home, the first part of the journey was bliss. We changed trains, and the two passengers behind never stopped yakking loudly. Why would anyone book a seat in a quiet coach only to be noisy? No staff around once the tickets were checked, and we are older and don’t wish to risk a confrontation. Twenty years ago my younger and healthier DH might have said something, but not now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brigante9 · 22/09/2022 21:34

I booked a table seat in the quiet coach, 2 blokes same table took and made work calls for 3 hours. I didn't moan because you do not know what people are like, they could have just told me to fuck off and carried on.

Now I book miles ahead in the quiet first class coach, a single seat. Much nicer, similar price.

BirdinaHedge · 22/09/2022 21:15

Thank you @Babyenroute THat's very thoughtful. A lot of passengers are not so thoughtful (commuters from Paddington to Reading at rush-hour on the train to Cornwall, I'm looking at you)

Babyenroute · 22/09/2022 07:41

Needmorelego · 20/09/2022 08:49

Yes the quiet coach should be quiet.
Although some people might just get on the train and find the first empty seat and not realise they are in the quiet coach.
But mostly it's down to behaviour that's the same on any public transport.... selfish people who just don't give a toss.

I've done this before and my friend and I were mortified when we were confronted at the end of someone's journey- we had not noticed that we were in the quiet coach and spent the whole time chatting! Still feel bad about it sometimes 😳 I aM now ultra careful to check

TigerRag · 22/09/2022 07:30

Lds1 · 22/09/2022 07:29

A member of our family is autistic and noise sensitive, we always book the quiet carriage to try get some peace of mind that it won't be too noisy.

I have the same problems. And sometimes find that the other carriages are quieter.

Lds1 · 22/09/2022 07:29

A member of our family is autistic and noise sensitive, we always book the quiet carriage to try get some peace of mind that it won't be too noisy.

JamSandle · 22/09/2022 07:24

This is one of my pet peeves. It's not just that people make noise but the noise is so obnoxious. Loud shouty conversation, phone calls on speaker. It's very inconsiderate.

balalake · 22/09/2022 07:22

The best answer in my opinion would be to replace the quiet coach with one with compartments. Reduce the chance of noise in your seat by at least two thirds.

TigerRag · 22/09/2022 07:20

YellowTreeHouse · 21/09/2022 21:49

What part is selfish?

It’s the QUIET carriage, not the SILENT carriage.

But some of us want peace when we travel. That's not selfish. But why could you have gone into another carriage if your child wants to play?

Wafflesnsniffles · 21/09/2022 22:05

I hate that so many are perfectly ok about behaving like this on trains, on buses, on the street, park benches. No one else wants to listen to the footie match you are watching on your screen, no one else is interested in your work call about Sandra who cant make it in today. And absolutely nobody wants to listen to your precious darling play a computer game or watch peppa pig. Get thee some headphones and shut up!

<rant over>

YADNBU op but sadly common courtesy isnt something as widely understood as it should be.

YellowTreeHouse · 21/09/2022 21:49

MeridasMum · 21/09/2022 16:45

Such selfish behaviour.

What part is selfish?

It’s the QUIET carriage, not the SILENT carriage.

AlwaysTheBrideNeverTheBridesmaid · 21/09/2022 17:04

girlmom21 · 21/09/2022 17:00

To those people who wear good noise-cancelling headphones, do you not get nervous about missing your stop? I get so anxious on trains if I can't hear the announcements!

No, I have the app so I can easily see what time we’re due in and just keep an eye out before that time to see which stations we’re at.

girlmom21 · 21/09/2022 17:00

To those people who wear good noise-cancelling headphones, do you not get nervous about missing your stop? I get so anxious on trains if I can't hear the announcements!

GCAcademic · 21/09/2022 16:49

I never book the quiet coach because I know the inevitable noise will just irritate me even more because it's supposed to be quiet. Instead I splashed out on expensive noise cancelling headphones. Worth every penny.

MeridasMum · 21/09/2022 16:45

YellowTreeHouse · 20/09/2022 10:05

We ended up in the quiet carriage with our toddler a few months back. We didn’t book seats there, weren’t any available to book, it was just the only carriage with free seats.

We didn’t realise it was the quiet carriage until DH went to the toilet and saw the sign but there wasn’t a chance I was going to try and keep my toddler quiet.

She wasn’t shouting and screaming or running down the train, she was well behaved, but she was chatty and wanted to play and I wouldn’t have stopped her to try and appease someone else.

Such selfish behaviour.

Itslookinggood · 21/09/2022 16:39

Share the pain.

Booked the quiet carriage in 1st to do a whole bunch of work. Opposite sat four middle aged entitled men who spent four hours loudly sharing their opinions on absolutely everything with the whole carriage.

Just that general inconsideration of it wound me up. Not even a suggestion of respecting others.

BirdinaHedge · 21/09/2022 16:26

And reflecting on this - stereotypically, we tend to think that the British are more reserved & polite, and that Americans are brash & loud.

Behaviour on trains would suggest completely the reverse!

BirdinaHedge · 21/09/2022 16:20

They really stick to those rules and guidelines too. From the moment you step in the platform there are foot prints to stop you where to stand, leaving a space for those to get off first, to quiet calm carriages with seats which can be reversed so no one needs to sit backwards, to leaving the station on the correct escalator and exits. Train travel on the Shinkansen was bliss.

I'd say the same about train travel in the USA - at least in my experiences over the years on the north east corridor route from DC to Boston, via New York. The Quiet Car is announced as a carriage where they maintain a "library level of quiet." Which means a minimum of talking, no music, no phones.

Passengers observe this behaviour, and require it of others.

Compare that with the element of scum which travels via CrossCountry. For some reason, passengers on CrossCountry trains are really awful - to an extent I don't find on other train routes (eg Great Western, Avanti, East Coat line - I do a lot of train travel).

I once had to ask a train manager to intervene because of the level of foul-mouthed abuse shouted at me for politely asking someone carrying on a long loud conversation in the Quiet Carriage to take their call to the vestibule. ie "Excuse me, this is the Quiet Coach. Could you take your call in the vestibule?"

Not long after (although I'm not claiming causality! Grin ) CrossCountry stopped having a designated Quiet Carriage. When I asked a train manager why, she said that they didn't have enough staff to deal with the people who regularly flouted the behaviour requirements in the Quiet Coach.

Abraxan · 20/09/2022 19:40

MadameMinimes · 20/09/2022 18:21

People should be quiet in the quiet carriage. Not totally silent but hushed voices, any talking kept to a minimum, no answering phones, definitely no shouting or playing music. To be honest I think it’s a shame that it isn’t the norm in all carriages. I think consideration for others is a good thing.

Japanese trains really are as quiet as described in that link. People are just very considerate of others and avoid doing anything that would disturb people.

Quiet carriages here are far noisier than just a normal Japanese carriage (although admittedly it was a while ago that I was last there) and from what I could see absolutely nobody answers the phone on a train there.

The ones we used in Japan had special areas people could go and stand in if they needed to use their phones. No one used one to speak into or listen without headphones in the carriage seats.

Abraxan · 20/09/2022 19:34

Ronbo · 20/09/2022 11:14

Read this and weep:

www.jrailpass.com/blog/japan-train-etiquette

"Eating in public or while walking is not a common practice in Japan. You should eat on trains only when taking a long-distance train"

"Never talk on your phone while on the train, unless using the designated phone area of the shinkansen. Silence and use headphones so that your media cannot be heard by others."

"While you may be accustomed to chatting with your traveling companions while using public transportation, this is not the norm in Japan. Loud chatter or other disturbance is considered rude."

They really stick to those rules and guidelines too. From the moment you step in the platform there are foot prints to stop you where to stand, leaving a space for those to get off first, to quiet calm carriages with seats which can be reversed so no one needs to sit backwards, to leaving the station on the correct escalator and exits. Train travel on the Shinkansen was bliss.

gogohmm · 20/09/2022 19:08

In theory but depending on how you booked your ticket you can't always know in advance it's the quiet coach plus those without seat reservations will grab whatever is available.

I find headphones useful

JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 19:01

Angelinflipflops · 20/09/2022 18:51

I've always though quiet carriages meant no audible electronic devices rather than people chatting

LNER say this about theirs;

”If want to catch up with work, read, or have a doze, you’re more than welcome in our quieter coach.

You’ll find our havens of peace in coach B or H (depending on the train).

If you’re in the quieter coach, please keep the noise down. Music through headphones should be kept quiet enough as to not disturb other passengers and conversations should be conducted quietly. If you do have to make or take a call, please move into the end of the coach through the doors before dialling or answering.”

Angelinflipflops · 20/09/2022 18:51

I've always though quiet carriages meant no audible electronic devices rather than people chatting

Seymour5 · 20/09/2022 18:50

Mojoj · 20/09/2022 18:02

Quiet train means no mobiles. It doesn't mean no talking!

Quiet conversations are fine. Feeling the need to share with most of the carriage really isn’t.

OP posts:
JenJones5 · 20/09/2022 18:49

We use the East Coast main line a fair amount, and only ever nowadays in first class.

It’s often not much extra, but the noise levels, behaviour, and general sense of calm is worlds apart.

INeverSawAPurpleCow · 20/09/2022 18:41

I've been on trains that had 'family carriages', I think usually in the holiday season. I've walked through them on the way to the buffet, and they're from hell. The mess, the stink of hot food, the drinks cans, the kids running up and down screaming . . . However if you don't want to have to keep your child quiet, they'd be perfect. The problem seems to be that a lot of people like the quiet carriage so long as their little darlings can make as much noise as they choose.

Swipe left for the next trending thread